Unanswered [12] | Urgent [0]
  

Posts by srandhawa
Joined: Oct 28, 2009
Last Post: Jun 7, 2010
Threads: 10
Posts: 157  

From: United States of America

Displayed posts: 167 / page 2 of 5
sort: Latest first   Oldest first  | 
srandhawa   
Jan 4, 2010
Undergraduate / Why Brown - poetic, maybe too much? [4]

im not a big fan of how your first essay begins, because i wear brown, and your whole idea of freedom in neuroscience and meeeting diverse people is vague(i know its hard to get to any specifics with such a small limit but i just think you take away from your essay with listing all these things back to back, and i'd argue alot of these really arent relevant, but still, all in all the first one is a good essay, better than most brown will get on that topic, if i were you i'd focus more on the leon cooper, tower and albania ideas but what you do is fine if you choose to keep it as it is.

as for the second one, your biology idea is cliched, everybody talks about the possibilites of biology and curiosity, theres no way of fully getting around this, but you can at least try to make it less direct and evident, the way you focus your ideas is just too much like most in biology and really wont make your essay stand out, although it is well written.

Anyway, could you take a look at mine if you get a chacne

thanks alot, good luck
srandhawa   
Jan 1, 2010
Undergraduate / 'I had been overwhelmed' - LAB EXPERIENCES AND TRANQUILITY [4]

interesting, i had gotten good reviews from this at last, i really felt like i had made this more clear, my english teacher who is a really harsh grader like this and thought it made sense. Thanks alot, the essay is abstract, that is the theme, the ideas i am using are abstract, and i guess thats where the interpretations come in and thats probably where you got lost. dont think im indirectly criticizing you when i say my english teacher liked it, im not, it just shows how diff people have diff interpreations of things. its too late to make any serious revisions, it is what it is, this is my writing style and it is hard to change it, it will fall to extremes, some will love it, some will hate it, but its taking a chance and i need to take a chance considering how big of a reach some of these schools i am applying to are. Thanks alot, good luck any other comments espec to my brown essay greatly appreciated, i will glady return the favor to read yours.

please anybody, i havent gotten much of anything except for one person who didnt answer whether or not my second essay answered hte prompt and the deadlines fastly approaching, thanks alot
srandhawa   
Dec 31, 2009
Undergraduate / Brown Supplement Essay---Intellectual Experience. Failure is the new Success. [9]

heres the problem i found, this is very good although unfortunately essays dont mean nearly as much as people think even at liberal arts type colleges like brown, the conclusion was too generic, catalyze my own growth, failure the new success, it feels like you just rushed it which i can see since the word limit was being reached, but its like you just overlooked your dissapointing results, your failure, which i can see is trying to support your positive attitude, but still, your failure is the new success was too broad, not enough in the essay to support it, sounded like jargon almost, and while your a great story teller, the idea of your essay is basically you were able to gain despite your failures, but theres nothing to show those failures and how you learned off the failures. You just talk about your memorable experiences in the lab, in a way you never show how you gained from the experience in terms of failure, you just show how you gained from the lab experience and how it became obsessed from you. I'm playing a little devil's advocate here and I could be completely wrong so dont take this last thing to seriously but maybe the ad coms were not that thrilled w/ the idea of you being very concerned, almost obsessed over your results, because you say that failure was the new succss later, i dont know, if there was something that ad coms didnt like in your essay, that would be my best success.

Anyway, overall nice job w/ the essay dont take what i said as critcism, alot of it is speculation, remember lots of kids get in who were previously deferred, i would actually be really interested in what you thought about my common app essay because we write about practically the same topic but we have kind of diff interpreations. See what you think, thanks alot, good luck

more importantly if your only going to look at one , if you get a chance could you take at my brown supplement to see if it answers the questoin
srandhawa   
Dec 31, 2009
Undergraduate / Yale Supplement - the Pitbull's grin [22]

I was just about to read this before you said that:) Anyway, this is solid, conclusion is solid, actually from what i hear the deadline is not till Jan 3rd for Yale. The post mark deadline if your sending your app by paper is today, but the common app online isn't until the 3rd from what I hear. But I could be wrong, im not applying to yale, just what my friend told me. Anyway, if you get a chance, could you read mine. Thanks alot, if theres any other essay of yours you want me to read, link it to me. thanks alot, good luck.
srandhawa   
Dec 31, 2009
Undergraduate / BROWN WHAT DON"T YOU KNOW:Not Sure Whether I Should Keep Going or Scratch Idea [4]

this is interesting, but the prompt here is what dont you know, i feel like your trying to force the idea of the unknown while the theme of this essay is really the known, what you know about the kids, their names, their characterstics and such. I dont know if you should scratch this, as a whole the idea is solid, but your going to have to reshape the focus so that this essay is about the unknown in your future kids, and those characteristiics. Know what im getting at? good luck, if you get a chance, please read my brown supp essays right above yours and decide which one i should submit, thanks alot
srandhawa   
Dec 31, 2009
Undergraduate / How can you answer the what you can contribute to upenn supplement [16]

thanks alot here Zahra, here is my updated version of hte upenn essay, any comments(will be turning in by the end of today)greatly appreciated. Anybody know if a jan 1 deadline means you can turn it jan 1, or by jan 1? Thanks alot, btw when upenn says dont exceed one page, does that mean single space, because thats what it is for CMU and my essay while long doesnt exceed 1 pg in MLA format. Is 640 words way too much? Thanks alot good luck
srandhawa   
Dec 30, 2009
Undergraduate / 'I had been overwhelmed' - LAB EXPERIENCES AND TRANQUILITY [4]

I feel like this essay is pretty diff than the common app thread from before, and since i might be using a diff common app essay, i decided to create a new thread for this(Hope the moderators arent upset by this). Anyway, three things to watch. 1 Does this make sense 2. Does it create an impact 3. Anyway to shorten it*779 words too much?). Any comments greatly appreciated. Thanks alot, good luck everyone.

I had been overwhelmed. The awe from seeing the gashing veins, the yellowish pale and soft tissue complexes of the kidney I was researching were surreal. Those ripples of focus and composure from my mind had disappeared as I froze from the sheer magnitude of the situation.

But I grew so much in two and a half years. Now, as I did lab work attempting to inhibit the growth of BK Virus through various drugs, the lens through which I saw things was clearer. Firstly, I grasped the workings of ATP-ase domain and the nature of the drugs attempting to destroy them. I was no longer oblivious to the subtleties of DNA. I was engrossed in my subject. The initial ripples were replaced by waves propagating from my mind. Finally, I was no longer overpowered by results. I had a voice. Everything didn't hinge on a t-value, slope or correlation from the centrifuge. I felt a sense of power come from the empirical nature of my work: I could seek answers and had the capability to find them. I was capable of governing science's tools, those pipettes and centrifuges, to find answers to my questions. Even when my results weren't what I wanted, I was building off each one of them. I was finding relationships between different results. This is what professors talked about with achieving science at its true "zenith". Of course I was not tweaking with quantum physics type material, but I was becoming something far greater than I ever had. I was curious. I was a scientist.

Abject disappointment soon set in. When I truly analyzed the results, seeking the subtleties in relationships, I became consumed by this BK virus. What relationships? The more I looked, the more I realized I had created them. All those variables in the experiment, how much was too much dilution factor or how many cycles on the centrifuge was too many, dominated me. I had ignored the power of the tools of science, the pipettes, and even the variables. Those tools had manipulated me; my arrogance had let me think otherwise. The more I thought and looked for answers, the more the blank glare of nothing stared at me. I had been paralyzed.

The aftermath was stark. The next month lacked a fire. My work lacked cohesiveness. It wasn't apathy, rather a total shock that reverberated throughout me. I felt hopelessness.

However, I stuck to form; I was too engrossed to just leave my subject. I still stayed in the lab for hours analyzing through every set of data, those t-values and residuals didn't go anywhere. I was fazed, but I adapted enough to keep on going. Those curious eyes still stared intensely at those symmetric arches and imperfect linear regressions. I was like a shy four year old staring at the Leaning Tower of Pisa, I couldn't stop, I realized the peculiarity, but kept coming back for more.

As the weeks piled on, a latent force started to guide me: tranquility. It was gradual, but the calm that came from my empirical work soon took over. It can't be fully translated. However, in this state, I wasn't seeking relationships between different forms of science; I was just at ease. For the first time I accepted the power of science's tools when I restarted the PCR experiments. I had allowed myself to be paralyzed by the unknown in the results. I knew nothing; I feared nothing. For the first time, I felt something pure, an appeasement from knowing that being oblivious to the subtleties of the experiment was acceptable. Even though I now acknowledged myself in a position of knowing much less, I was much more aggressive. There was no pressure; I no longer had to protect myself from failure by obsessively seeking specific results that would support my hypothesis. I was free of my own responsibilities, I could be unleashed.

Finally, my experiments started to change and making sense. All those variables, such as how much is too much, were no longer a problem. I was getting somewhere. My results were becoming tangible and could lead to publication. I was making sense of those results; they were each functioning at their own independent level. They weren't cohesive, but that was the source of their power. I didn't need any relationships or subtleties; I only needed sciences tools to do what they do, control. There had been nothing wrong with that control. Keeping the unknown and its ability to paralyze my thought process alive, accepting it, has been my proudest accomplishment. The unknown revealed more than anything from the known ever had: the calming voice was all I ever needed.
srandhawa   
Dec 30, 2009
Undergraduate / Northwestern Supplement Seeking the Relationships Between the Outerworld Help [17]

Thanks Jagpal, i agree w/ totally on the intro, its just that for hte chem part, i was done w/ the beauty idea and i had to give something specific to the school in terms of academics, and chem was a good area, i will try tying that intro stanza into the conlcusion and get rid of that cheezy ending line. I will take a look at yours, just give me a little time, thanks alot, good luck.

btw, the beauty is just kind of something i sensed, it is hard to describe any more than i did because it is vague and kidn of something in mind, theres nothing abstract like to help describe or quantify it, sorry, but it was just that sense i got, hope that helps if you were interested.
srandhawa   
Dec 30, 2009
Undergraduate / Biology Major- Johns Hopkins Supplement [4]

what a great intro, really, one of the best ones ive read the past couple of wks, but while i see your a really creative writer, i dont think this whole idea of bio says nothing more than the obvious. Think about how many kids apply to J-Hop for bio and how many say the same kinds of things you do, basically the infinite possibilites and everything? Hows that going to make you stand out, your intro does, and whenever you use a creative voice, you do, but this whole theme on bio isnt really unique. Also your ending is just too generic, try to mention one specific great thing about J-Hop that you couldnt say about any other school, it might take up a little more space, but thast ok, your essay isnt too long anyway, sorry to be harsh, this isnt a bad essay, its just one that i feel you can use your creativity and your experiences in bio to create something more profound. Good luck, If you get a chance could you check out my essays. Thanks alot
srandhawa   
Dec 30, 2009
Undergraduate / How can you answer the what you can contribute to upenn supplement [16]

thanks zaharas93, i thought i would never get an answer on that? My question also is though if i dont do plme or engineering, is there still a biology program at brown, w/o the medical focus at PLME which is also ridulously hard to get into. Thanks alot, and what do you put if your not doing PLME or engineering on your application, there doesnt seem to be any room for it on that, because i dont want to those collge essays if my PRIMARY interest is not engineering. Thoughts? Any comments on the UPENN Essay espec. how to shorten it and to see if it makes any impact greatly appreciated? Thanks alot, good luck
srandhawa   
Dec 29, 2009
Undergraduate / How can you answer the what you can contribute to upenn supplement [16]

thanks alot, tkk1 that editing really really helped, thanks alot, really

anyway, i revamped my upenn essay a little to try to fit to the suggestions but its still long like 725 words any other ways we can shorten it? thanks alot, if you want me to return the favor and read your essay, just cut and copy it here, dont send me a link because there some thing wrong w/ my computer, thanks, good luck

I had found nothing to quell my fears about my two fears of college: the inadequate research opportunities and the loss of cultural strings. I would still go to college excited, but with a certain fear, what was preventing me from suffering from these same things? What was preventing the inevitable?

It hit me so quickly; the impact was profound, immediately I realized research at the University of Pennsylvania would be very unique. The presence of associate directors who give such personalized attention in the Center for undergraduate Research and Fellowships almost assures me the chance to create my own opportunities for research and resources. I will have a voice and not be like so many others stuck in such limited research positions. Ultimately, I can create my own gain from my research freshmen year, as oppose to only seeing the nuances years later and letting numerous elusive opportunities slip. Through this I can advocate the benefits of my situation; I can help create a community interested in research through which we can all achieve something greater that carries far after our time. This is the purpose of research, to extend its essence. And it's through the experiences in the lab that we can emphasize the need for chemistry and provide an alternate perspective to classmates. The student to student interaction of these ideas is an invaluable power. While we can only truly begin to realize these ideas, together we can create an environment of openness where we create our own development and identity, Science can bewilder us but never overwhelm us. I can be part of the community. We will have our own problems, but I can be part of an answer.

But even if I could see shades of promise in my future; my eyes were still staring at the problem right in front of me; the degrading effects of college on culture and heritage. I had seen numerous friends from my gurdwara (temple) lack vigor with their passion towards their culture after returning from college. I needed a refuge from this revolutionary effect.

The Asian American Studies Program is more than a refuge; it is the ink of a new creation and revolution within its members. I have heard of much travail, opportunities and numerous on campus interactive activities from the program. Finally, I had found what I wanted from college; the chance to express our identity that has been a part of us for 18 years. Furthermore, the ability to study literature greatly enhances these diverse experiences. Religious hymns and other holy texts play such a prominent role in Sikhism that I am particularly enamored by the opportunity to see the texts in other Asian cultures. I will strive to emphasize the role of literature and relate their importance in all Asian cultures. Furthermore, relaying my zeal established through eight years of tabla (Indian drum) playing and nine years of advocating and comprehending Sikh History in the Sikh Youth Symposium can also strengthen this organization at its very foundation. I cherish the chance to potentially be part of those performances through which hopefully I can further establish the prominence of the Sikh culture to this the group. This group has only been around for 13 years, it is still in the ominous phase of its development and unity and a tremendous chance presents itself to establish Sikhism on a wider scale in the organization and greater community for future generations. That shall be the challenge I most adhere to.

My future is still gnaws at me, but finally, I feel a sense of security. My faith, my development, my future, lie in the hands of a school that has created such great impact, opportunities and a vibrant community at every step of the way. The execrable feeling of fearing the inevitable can die by the day.
srandhawa   
Dec 29, 2009
Undergraduate / Northwestern Supplement Seeking the Relationships Between the Outerworld Help [17]

thanks gynn92, appreciate it, the only problem is your link is giving my computer serious problems, even when i go around it and try to click on your name and click on your essay, some kind of virus comes up, could you just copy and paste it on to this thread. Thanks alot

Anyway, any other thoughts, espec. w/ the opening and closing, is the closing too artificial, if it doesnt sound genuine its the type of thing that can really bring an essay down in an adcoms mind and the deadline is 2 days away, any thoughts greatly appreciated, ill return the favor, try copying your essay onto this thread though because there might be something w/ my computer.

Thanks alot good luck
srandhawa   
Dec 29, 2009
Undergraduate / UPenn Supplement: The Dreaded Page 217/300 [6]

this is actually what it means truely optional, hundreds of kids get in every yr w/o writing this essay. Its optional because kids try forcing essays that they have no buisness writing every yr, and most of these stories people tell dont really do anything to enhance their application, there just stories, and adcoms dont know what to do w/o them, what it tells them about the applicant, there not bad stories, but they dont really make the applicant look any better, they dont highlight any accomplishments, they dont really do anything that would increase their chances at getting into college. I'd say try to write, espec. something that woudl highlight one of your charactersitics or accomplishments, but if your at the point where you are IndoodPossible, then yeah, dont write anything, your essay just kinda rehashes the point that the school has in making it optional, often times there just isnt anything really beneficial to write about.

Just my two cents, i dont wanna sound like a know it all but i remember talking to my counselor about this who knows alot about admissions, and thats what he told me, by forcing yourself to write, if it does come out bad or if it comes out as dull and uninformative, you actually hurt your application and the risk reward ratio there is not worth it. if your serious about keeping that essay and i have no idea if you are or if your just screwing around, i wouldnt, one thing you never wanna do is insult the prompt, its like insulting the school, its not original like it might seem to you to them, so no reason to add that kind of controversy to yourself, but whatever, good luck, everybody and i mean EVERYBODY is applying to penn this yr:)
srandhawa   
Dec 28, 2009
Undergraduate / How can you answer the what you can contribute to upenn supplement [16]

thanks alot, both you guys both made alot of sense, my question is by focusing so much on answering hte question of what i can contribute( i know you have to do this) it just kind of seems to make my essay clique esque, im talking about how i can form groups and an identity, but isnt that what a million people are going to say? My initial question was whats a good way to answer what can you contribute, and i feel like all answers kind of say the same kind of thing, its just so hard to be unique w/ what you can contribute, and i feel like by deleting all the stuff about why penn is good for me, i delete my passion for why i want to go to upenn. Don't get me wrong, you guys are absolutely right about me cutting some of hte stuff down you highlighted and i def. will, but it just seems like if i do too much, then they dont really see why i want to go to penn, they dont see what about penn im interested in, know what i mean? But yes, i def will cross some things out, it just seems like the what you can contribute is so clique esche and is going to be so much like everybody else, and i dont know a way around it. Thoughts?
srandhawa   
Dec 28, 2009
Undergraduate / "Nerd, outgoing, with a strong Filipino accent" - Stanford: Roommate prompt [5]

first off a general question, if the deadline is jan. 1st can you turn it in on jan 1st, i know this is a dumb question, but i could use the extra 24 hrs, and i dont want to be cramming college essays on new years eve:)

Anyway, I do feel your pain, not getting anybody to read your essays, thats been the case for me the past two days:)

I dont know if you need to explain taiglish, kind of takes away from the awe and meaning of the word, the surprise, the connotation when you take the life out of it a little by explaining it. Your trying to answer the question to directly w/ phrases like that is one reason why i am this, or lastly ..., or that is why there..., dont do that, just explain it naturally, trust your audience a little to fill in the gaps so to say. I think you have to make your essay more cohesive, your kind of isolating your idea about singing, kuya and speaking, part of it is the diction above but i would try tying all three of those ideas together maybe in a thesis, try relating them in someway, it will strengthen the focus of your essay tremendously. I like the question you pose at the beginning and the last line, build around those and keep those ideas you have in the middle but make them more co-exist and build a little off them and i think you have something.

Good luck, if you get a chance could you read mine, espec the upenn one, the first one if your going to read one, thanks alot.
srandhawa   
Dec 28, 2009
Undergraduate / Music and International Business communities at Penn - [6]

i just realized you handed this in, so i'll hold off on the feedback to improve this:)

I have read this essay before when it was less edited, and it is solid, there was an idea or two i think we agreed to disagree on but all in all it was a solid all around essay. No you are not screwed by that repetition, colleges see all kinds of mistakes in essays, you'd be surprised, happens all the time, def wont help your application but it wont hurt you as much as you think. Anyway, if you get a chance could you take a look at my essays, espec. the first one the penn one, im asking you because you give really good feedback, i trust what you have to say. Not just trying to suck up:) Thanks alot
srandhawa   
Dec 28, 2009
Undergraduate / Upenn- Page 217 Middle-aged teenager [5]

its a solid story, your a solid story teller, heres the problem, what are adcoms suppose to get out of it? I know you reflect a little on your role in the family, but think about it this way, how does that and this whole essay enhance your application? They'll already know how good a writer you are through your other essays, how is this enhancing your application? Your problem is the same as so many of these autobiographies, they tell good stories, but the adcom does not know what to make of it, as a result, these kind of stories unless so poignant and well written rarely have much influence on a decision. The best way to enhance an application through this would be to highlight a personality trait or an accomplishment of significance. Since i dont think you can do the latter, i think your best bet is to focus on a single characteristic that you think you can really shine through your story that will make you look better and make you the applicant look better. Ultimately, there comes a point where you have to look past the writing part of it, colleges will tell you you can write about any essay topic, but thats misleading, in a reflective essay, you gotta go for something that highlights something about you, and im not talking about like how you finally passed your drivers license test. You know what I am getting at? Your writing is fine, but you really have to ask yourself hte question what am i portraying about myself and how am i helping my application? I know thats not how we usually do things and thats not neessarily the way to go to get your best writing, but now that you have some writing, look for something that highlights you and while this story is vivid and well told, i think you would be much much much better highlighting something about you more specifically like a character trait. Then you will have enhanced your application through the autobiography because i dont necessairly agree w/ you that this isnt a mandatory essay, part of the reason penn emphasizes the optional aspect of the essay is because they get so many essays every yr that just tell a random story, dont tell much about the person, and dont really enhance the application.

Good luck, i dont want to sound harsh, just want to get you thinking differently because thats the kind of thinking you'll need to win the college admission game and i didnt mean to sound like i was giving you some kind of lecture, this is just what i have picked up on a years worth of college researching and admission type of stuff. If you get a chance, could you check out my essays, espec the penn one, i know you already looked at hte northwestern one but i forgot to include the second half of hte essay, but only if you get a chance, i dont want to force you to read both. Thanks alot, im asking you because you give good feedback.
srandhawa   
Dec 28, 2009
Undergraduate / Brown- why essay (an awesome place to hang out) [7]

i like your idea about abandoning the open cirriculum, i did also, but i think for an 1000 character essay where every word matters, you could make it more powerful, really be selective of your word choices and phrases, because each one matters more for a shorter one obviously.

I think you have a decent idea, but you make it cliche esque w/ your quote every man for himself. that autmomatically turns the reader off and autmomatically hints this might be cliche esque even if its not. The idea of not learning through books only has also been repeated so often, focus on one or two things like research, an internship or the women leadership council and talk about that, and your first line w/ in addition to the open cirriculm is unecessary, if you want to refer to this later in the essay, you can try, but its really just a weak way to start the essay and weakens its focus. Good luck, sorry if this is harsh, but brown is the type of school where interest and visiting does actually matter, these kind of essays even though they are short, matter for Brown, alot of schools they dont, but not at brown.
srandhawa   
Dec 28, 2009
Undergraduate / How can you answer the what you can contribute to upenn supplement [16]

bump... i know there are lots of essays and everybodys busy but the deadline is really coming fast and any comments, anything you have, would be greatly appreciated, i'll gladly return the favor and look at anybody elses.
srandhawa   
Dec 28, 2009
Undergraduate / Northwestern Supplement Seeking the Relationships Between the Outerworld Help [17]

Hey so I edited my northwestern supp a little, its still 715 words, anything you can do to edit it and take words out unecessary would be great. Three things 1. Does the beauty idea seem powerful and relevant. 2. IS there a passion for attending the school 3. Does the ending, the last two lines especially sound really cheesy and should I cut them out? Any comments greatly appreciated, the deadline is coming really soon so I really hope to get some responses, if you could check out my Penn Thread that would be fab. Thanks alot, good luck everyone
srandhawa   
Dec 28, 2009
Undergraduate / Brown Short Answer (Anticipated Degree and Academic Interest) [3]

for such a short essay, i dont know if a movie is a great idea, that prob is a genuine reason for wanting to do it, but you have to go into depth about the movie and how it influenced how and changed your views and you dont have enough space to do that, but its kind of hard for me to tell you what to change, i feel like you could give a little more powerful description of the essay and make it a bit more vivid.

btw what school are you applying to in brown, are you doing PLME or engineering? If not, what do you mark on the application because i am really confused, im looking at bio, but i dont want to do PLME, so i dont know what to mark and whether there are any addiotional essays. DO you know if i apply for engineering that i have to go to that school and do engineering if i end up getting in like it is in most schools, or can you still go to other schools within brown? Thanks alot
srandhawa   
Dec 28, 2009
Undergraduate / How can you answer the what you can contribute to upenn supplement [16]

thanks alot wanderer, any have any suggestions for what else is superfluous and what i can take out, im kinda stuck, i want to keep in the first idea about chemistry and def. the idea about research and the asian group, but i dont know where to go in taking stuff out? Any thoughts, i'll def return the favor and read yours back, thanks alot
srandhawa   
Dec 28, 2009
Undergraduate / idiosyncrasies or peculiarities about ourselves, UChicago essay [23]

i dont see why there has to be hesitation with the beginning of hte uchicago essay, through my research it seems...., no reason to make that passive, especially not at the beginning.

Anyway, rather than say there are over 400 organizations that i would benefit from, how about listing one or two and then going into however much depth you can w/ the word limit, espec relating to your ideas of tutoring in the last para? The last three lines seem vague, talking chicago as a general place, and then saying you'd benefit from all those characteristics, again, i think your better served to talk about one or two and make that the theme of your essay.

Also, you seem to be speculating w/ the effects of tutoring and how they will fit in w/ u chicago, again that opening para where you say the impression i got was thiss... can be improved by just talking more specifics about one or two things about u chicago. If you want to include a line somewhere in the essay about all the characteristics you metnioned at the end of the essay thats fine, but that seems to be the theme of your essay, and your theme does change a little from your tutoring experience to music, i would at least tie a thesis at the beginning relating the two and how they relate to u.chicago, seems a bit too random and it seems like you dont develop the ideas to their fullest potential.

Also those generalizations like at hte beginning of the last para, i believe that ec activties... which you do in the first para also w/ alot of your opinions arent the best idea, dont just directly say i believe or i think this is important, show it, dont tell. I felt like you did a bit too much of that in the opening para.

anyway, good luck, you obviously can write, the key is to get more specific and personal like in the first essay( i think you try getting personal w/ the tutoring ideas but there are just too many generalizations there), if you get a chance could you check mine.

i know there are two, if your going to read one, the upenn one would get higher priority and be the one to read, thanks alot
srandhawa   
Dec 28, 2009
Undergraduate / "responsibilities and opportunities" - Why Brown? [8]

you say the same things everybody says about brown, its a free school, it allows you to what you want, you even acknowledge this in your essay, i have heard repeatedly that brown is what you make of it, think about how many thousands of people are going to say this. I realize the essay has to be really short, im applying to brown also, but even though the writing is solid, this is going to be like thousands of other why brown essays they will get, try to think of somethign unique that applies to you that makes brown such a good fit for you, not some broad idea of oh i have freedom to shape my own education, that doesnt really say much of anything. Good luck, sorry if this is harsh, but there are so many things about brown, talking about the liberal ways and the ability to shape your own education is the easy way out.

If you get a chance could you take a look at my penn essay and help me find ways to shorten it

btw, i like the intro, although the last one you listed was a little confusing/awkwardish, dont know if you really need it.

one other thing, do you know how applying w/ brown works, if im interested in bio but dont want to apply to PLME, is there still like a college of arts and sciences to apply to. Or, if i apply for engineering, does that mean i have to go to that school if i get in as oppose to getting to go to any other school, like a college of arts and science, like it is for most other schools? Or is it like a sep. application like PLME, you can get into brown but not into PLME? Its confusing, nowhere on the application does it say where your applying, it only says mark here if your applying to this special program, know what i mean? If I just want to apply to like a arts and sciences school, do i have to mark anything, is there any extra essay for that like there is for engineering, PLME and a couple others? Thanks alot
srandhawa   
Dec 28, 2009
Undergraduate / "MY OWN CURIOUS CASE " Feedbacks on my admission essay... [13]

I swear i already read this one and gave some comments, but i dont see my name, so oh well:)

Anyway, i dont like the word breathe in the first couple of lines, awkward, im sure if you really think about it then it would make sense, but an adcom wont do that. There just seems to be a better word for that, and i know your trying to establish a certain connotation w/ breathe, but i dont think you get the effect your looking for.

While you are a solid writer, i think you could come up w/ some more colorful/vivid/impactful/insert whatever word you want, phrases like I started to inspect it like a doctor dont really get a reader to think, theres nothing special to them like there needs to be if there going to be in your essay, and there are other ex's of this in your essay.

The whole idea of god is a bit risky, i know your not trying to get philosophical, but you run the risk, even though you dont talk about god for the rest of the essay the reader is prone to think that there is some greater symbolic meaning you might be getting at and thats something you want to stray away from. You can come up w/ another phrase for this other than god.

My biggest comment: This essay ends waaaay to abruptly and i dont think just adding another line or two is good enough, really when you talk about a reverse clock like this, what the reader will take from it and ultiamtely how an adcom will judge you is how you reflect on this and how it affected you, because it really varies soo much from person to person and that really is where the significance of the story lies. Your conclusions do leave something to be desired, your last line is waaay to easy, things may move in reverse but we move forward, thats the obvious ending and the other obvious ending you have is we dont give up easily. Go beyond that, you have a solid essay, a solid story, but then you just leave the reader w/ nothing, it ends so abruptly that nothing can really be made by it and in the end the significance of the story loses meaning. I know this is easier said than done but come up w/ a unique ending, something more powerful, something that will get the reader to think because i could have easily guessed your conclusion. I feel like if you make some of your story descriptions more vivid or whatever and leave the reader w/ something to think about and go deeper into your reflection, you'll have something goood. Good luck

Could you take a look at mine if you get a chance, i know i sent you two but the second one, the penn one is priority so if you only read one, thats the one to read. Thanks alot.
srandhawa   
Dec 27, 2009
Undergraduate / Freedom of speech, alternative energy, northwestern supplement essay - why NU? [4]

i think your playing w/ fire a little bit in the last para, best to avoid topics like this full of controversy, even though you portray the school in a good light, not a good idea, and those last few lines relating the situation to an ideal of northwestern are far to vague anyway. The same vague idea applies to the energy discussion, dont talk about solutions to the energy crisis like you do in the last sentence, be realistic, your not going to solve the energy crisis, instead, if your going to talk about the energy crisis and its focus in northwestern, talk more about your passion towards it, how it developed, and include more about northwesterns energy club or whatever group they ahve concerned with it, dont talk about the issue, talk about how the energy issue affects you. Also, get more to the point w/ quality over quantity, have a stronger intro, i like the idea of smaller classes in the essay, but you have to be more assertive and try to avoid the obvious answers about class size, most people do function better in smaller classes, try to same something unique about how smaller classes affect you for the positive.

Good luck thanks for looking at mine, if you get a chance could you see my newer one(which i meant to be mine all along just forgot to attach the second half of it lol). Thanks alot, maybe we'll see each other next yr( although theres no way im getting into northwestern:)).
srandhawa   
Dec 27, 2009
Undergraduate / Northwestern Supplement Seeking the Relationships Between the Outerworld Help [17]

thanks alot wow, i completely forgot to show the second part of the essay:) Wow, enough said, anyway heres the second part, im really sorry for making you read that abreviated part that probably didnt make any sense. Tell me what you feel here, any comments greatly appreciated i will take a look at yours now seatlelite, thanks alot
srandhawa   
Dec 27, 2009
Undergraduate / COMMON APP ESSAY FOR DARTMOUTH, UPENN, NORTHWESTERN AND OTHER SCHOOLS [37]

thanks, did you get a chance to take a look at my updated essay, it was on the bottom, i edited stuff out like the light to make it clearer, i know things can get really complicated w/ such a long thread, thanks alot, good luck, we do seem like similar kinds of writers in a lot of ways, i should probably take some of the advice i gave you:)

btw, anybody know if im allowed to start a new thread on this same essay topic because it is getting really big and people are continuing to confuse my original essay w/ the updated one, i dont want to get in trouble w/ the essayforum moderators for breaking the rules and get suspended so close to the deadline when i need this website now more than ever. Thanks
srandhawa   
Dec 27, 2009
Undergraduate / How can you answer the what you can contribute to upenn supplement [16]

I have finished up my upenn supplement rough draft, and you can see the problem about contribution i have highlighted two main concerns 1. It is waaaaaay too long 995 words, what can i do to shorten it. 2. Does it show a passion towards penn and do the intro and conclusion relate to the rest of the essay and create some sort of impact on you. Thanks alot appreciate any feedback, send me your link and i'll gladly look your essay over and return hte favor.
srandhawa   
Dec 27, 2009
Undergraduate / Northwestern Supplement Seeking the Relationships Between the Outerworld Help [17]

bump.... i am stuck, i dont know how to change this or what to emphasize or if i should even go w/ the beauty thing, and if i change that, i woudl have to change hte focus and thesis of my essay to some extent. Any thoughts, i'll def. read anybodys essay if you send me the link returning the favor. Thanks alot
srandhawa   
Dec 27, 2009
Undergraduate / How can you answer the what you can contribute to upenn supplement [16]

thanks, but that was my question, how can i ask the question what an i going to contribute? I was born and live in america, im just saying some people use diversity as something that they can contribute, others use that they have a passion toward something that they can contribute, others think they can help create or be part of a community and enhance it, this all just seems so clique esque, so many people write about this and almost all these answers are superficial, i was wondering if there is a unique approach to this, if anybody has any ideas or anything along those lines, as of right now i talk about how i can contribute to their Asian American club and how I can help create a community amongst kids within science, but that just seems so superficial and an idea that will probably be repeated over and over again. Know what I mean? IS there something that goes beyond the basics in terms of contributions? thanks alot, good luck
srandhawa   
Dec 27, 2009
Undergraduate / "WHY" - engineering department, NORTHWESTERN SUPPLEMENT [6]

this is an interesting approach, but i dont know how well it works, its not bad, and you'll get some attention for the approach, but this essay kind of fades after a solid start. Your essay is the kind i feel that need specific programs or things you like about the school, northwestern has lots of clubs, organizations etc, mention some, mention some that go w/ your passions toward engineering. Your first line, I don't like it, might just be personal preference but it comes across as awkward, forced, not the spontaneous orignial type of work your looking for. Also, even though i think the intro is the best part, it feels forced, you specifically go like, now what about the aftertaste, what about this and that, it doesn't come across naturally which if your going to try to use a creative idea, it needs to. That whole second para of I wills isn't a good idea either, talk about what you've already seen, there will be many applicants who've already visisted, who've already made contacts, who've already seen clubs in northwestern, your i will isnt as good as those who already have something w/ the university. Even if you havent visited, do some research on the organizations within the club and talk about that, what you like. If your going to talk about your post undergrad experience and how northwestern will influence it, give something more than those empty statements like northwestern will help me realize this and that. For ex, in mine i said that there emphasis on chemistry for med which most undergrad schools dont do and there emphasis on reserach will pay huge dividends in teh future. Give something more specific. The last two lines are also really awkward, cheesy esque.

I know this is alot of what seems like negative feedback, but clearly you are creative, your willing to try something new, i think if you focus around something and dont try so hard to relate to your wine theme which doesnt come across as natural, you will allow your true skills to shine through and your essay will be much stronger.

Good luck I'm applying to nw and like every other school you are i think:)
srandhawa   
Dec 27, 2009
Undergraduate / How can you answer the what you can contribute to upenn supplement [16]

the upenn supplement asks for what can you contribute to the school. What's a good answer? Lots of people say i can contribute my diversity, my passion towards something, what i've learned from a certain experience like the need for everybody to have an equal opportunity or something like that, it all seems so cliche esque. I'm trying to avoid that, but right now my ideas are just like those same ones above. Any thoughts, anybody come up w/ any kind of interesting ideas for as to how they can contribute to the school. Thanks alot. good luck
srandhawa   
Dec 27, 2009
Undergraduate / Cornell - The environment blurs into a sight of indistinguishable colors and shapes [10]

i'm sorry if i can across as harsh, you have some serious skills as a writer, you really do, and i feel like i can relate to you because i also have a tendency to write these empty statements that seem to convey a lot but dont reveal anything, they sound so good on paper, but adcoms hate them because they just sound like your trying to hard to come across as impressive. While i agree w/ spak417 that you shouldnt lengthen it w/o a purpose, i think in your case you would benefit from adding, or at least experimenting w/ it, because when you take out alot of those empty statements your going to find your going to have to write alot to make up for them to come up w/ a true theme and focus, thats why the more i look at it the more its kind of hard for me to tell you what your theme should be, i say revise those empty statements and add to this essay and see how it goes, good luck

could you take a look at my common app essay, i know you saw my northwestern one already thanks alot, i'll def read your revised one if you want me to

btw, make sure you read the revised on at the end of page 1, the one thats like 800 words. thanks alot
srandhawa   
Dec 27, 2009
Undergraduate / Northwestern Supplement Seeking the Relationships Between the Outerworld Help [17]

im having trouble figuring out what to do w/ the whole first para, is it needed, or is it not, because i do talk alot about the lab ex. and all that good stuff in my common app so i dont want to overemphasize it here also? Also, how should i talk more about academics, it seems like i have some stuff but if i portray it in a more academic way woudl that work? Thanks alot
srandhawa   
Dec 27, 2009
Undergraduate / Northwestern Supplement Seeking the Relationships Between the Outerworld Help [17]

thanks tkk1, the only problem is my commmon app was about my lab experience, how mcuh can i really write about it? I dont want that coming across as the only thing about me, it is important, but there are other things. I just don't want to have another essay focused on how my lab experiences changed me, know what i mean? I see your point about focusing more on the academics, would it just work if i give a diff perspective to those programs, maybe make them sound like things that would help me academically instead of socially? Is the helping me in the future idea good, i wanted to keep it, it was something that stuck out about NW? thanks any comments greatly appreciated.
srandhawa   
Dec 27, 2009
Undergraduate / Northwestern Supplement Seeking the Relationships Between the Outerworld Help [17]

Hey. so here is my northwestern supplement. I am a little worried it doesnt make sense. The ending is a little similar to my J-Hop one, but only one or two lines. You may have to at least just skim my common app essay to understand the beginning of this one, but i doubt it. Anyway, three main concerns. 1. Length, 769 words, how can i shorten it. 2. Is it too abstract and flowery, does it make sense. 3. Does it show a passion towards northwestern

I was stunned. The natural beauty, the awe, the vividness of the surroundings, the spontaneous magnification in the focus in my eyes from what I had seen looking out of a dorm window in Northwestern was surreal. Never could I ever imagine such a view from a college dorm, especially in a region known for its dreary, blusterous winters. Even October could be unforgiving. But that gaze into elegance allowed me the rare chance to dwell on what I am so often oblivious to. For the first time in my life, I didn't see external beauty as superficial. I had spent my whole life disparaging natural beauty; even my trips to the Canadian Rockies had been lackluster. I had begun to slowly accept nature, but never did I think it would create an inner revolution within me. Something, maybe the idea of having that beauty always a window blind away, changed me. However, appreciating these external appearances is still new to me. Establishing a deeper, profound understanding of them is one of my own personal challenges, one of my ways of indulging my own curiosity which Northwestern provides a rare outlet for. Maybe there is nothing more to find, maybe nature's beauty is a simple purity. Maybe even the awe of that beauty ceases as quickly as it formed. But to stop now? Not after opening that window, that window of possibilities.

However, beauty itself was not enough; I needed a known, and something I could relate to. The networks on the individual level were precisely what I sought. This is the known I could come back to. This is the force that will always guide me. The University Career Services immediately struck as a powerful resource. This is hardly one of those common strange, out of touch places which the student can't relate to, rather the tremendous faculty assistance along with the diverse opportunities in class courses available at Weinberg College of Arts and Sciences make Northwestern the rare institution where I can create my own education.

However, the student supported organizations are most exciting. The Biology Students Association provides all kinds of opportunities to relay my passions toward the subject with fellow students and together create opportunities that can extend far beyond our time at Northwestern and for future classes. But it's the Premedical Society that really will help me focus my interests toward medicine, as broad as they are, by allowing me to start my understanding of medical school at the age of 19 as oppose to 23. This opportunity to get a feel for the nature of medicine is further enhanced in the chemistry council, where a unique perspective of organic chemistry and rare chances to do chemical research to complement my biological research lie. The enamoring opportunities to attend prestigious lectures will only add an extra dimension to my studies. The chemistry aspect in medicine is so overlooked when discussing the nuances of biology, but Northwestern is a place where the chemical aspect of medicine will not overwhelm me. The great opportunities to do research, even if I decide to pursue other biological sciences, ensures that I can further enhance my understanding of empirical science from freshmen year, allowing for a much greater comprehensive understanding with far more opportunities. Regardless of what I choose, I won't be in the majority looking at chemistry as the "dirty work" en route to more glamorous work in biology. Chemistry will be the outlet to a greater biology. Once again, I can create my own education.

That window provides me a sense of hope with the unknown of beauty lurking in the shadows of the campus. The chance to see how this enhances all aspects of my life gives Northwestern such unique and unfathomable potential. But it's the stability provided by Northwestern that makes me so secure. This is what satisfies me: I can look out that window knowing I can create my own voice in education at Northwestern.

Writing
Editing Help?
Fill in one of the forms below to get professional help with your assignments:

Graduate Writing / Editing:
GraduateWriter form ◳

Best Essay Service:
CustomPapers form ◳

Excellence in Editing:
Rose Editing ◳

AI-Paper Rewriting:
Robot Rewrite ◳