Notoman
Aug 18, 2009
Writing Feedback / Spanish Language proficiency [15]
I agree that the practicality of a second language is tied to the locale. Spanish is very useful in the United States, but I imagine that French would be handy if you lived in the northeastern states that are closer to Quebec. As Sean pointed out, French is much more practical for Canadians. It would be very useful in Africa as well.
We were vacationing in Quebec last week. My mom is proficient in Spanish and was able to read about 90% of the French (all of the signage and many of the publications are exclusively in French), but understanding the spoken language was a *totally* different story. There is a lot of overlap between the French and the Spanish so I think that emphasizing your proficiency in French would be important. They are both Romance languages ... not (necessarily) in the woo-your-lover way--Romance in this case refers to Rome. Your experience in French is documented by taking four years in college ... or maybe your semantics are a little tricky ... when you say that you weren't able to minor in languages, it leads me to believe that you might have only been planning to take those courses and then didn't follow through.
I have to admit, when you talk about the other languages--Chinese, Indonesian, and Sudanese (as in the Sudanese dialect of Arabic??), I find myself skeptical. Part of my skepticism could be that you don't substantiate how you became fluent in Chinese and Indonesian or how you are able to understand Arabic. There is certain expectation that comes along with the word fluent. Furthermore, Taiwanese isn't considered a dialect--Min is the dialect they speak in Taiwan--and using Sudanese instead of Arabic leads me to believe that you are bluffing. English, French, Chinese, and Arabic are all very different languages ... if you are applying to med school, I assume that you are fairly young. Too young, perhaps, to have lived in all of these other countries and gained proficiency in the languages. I know that you have a limited number of characters, but if you want to be believed, you may have to provide some backing or scale down your claims of being fluent.
I agree that the practicality of a second language is tied to the locale. Spanish is very useful in the United States, but I imagine that French would be handy if you lived in the northeastern states that are closer to Quebec. As Sean pointed out, French is much more practical for Canadians. It would be very useful in Africa as well.
We were vacationing in Quebec last week. My mom is proficient in Spanish and was able to read about 90% of the French (all of the signage and many of the publications are exclusively in French), but understanding the spoken language was a *totally* different story. There is a lot of overlap between the French and the Spanish so I think that emphasizing your proficiency in French would be important. They are both Romance languages ... not (necessarily) in the woo-your-lover way--Romance in this case refers to Rome. Your experience in French is documented by taking four years in college ... or maybe your semantics are a little tricky ... when you say that you weren't able to minor in languages, it leads me to believe that you might have only been planning to take those courses and then didn't follow through.
I have to admit, when you talk about the other languages--Chinese, Indonesian, and Sudanese (as in the Sudanese dialect of Arabic??), I find myself skeptical. Part of my skepticism could be that you don't substantiate how you became fluent in Chinese and Indonesian or how you are able to understand Arabic. There is certain expectation that comes along with the word fluent. Furthermore, Taiwanese isn't considered a dialect--Min is the dialect they speak in Taiwan--and using Sudanese instead of Arabic leads me to believe that you are bluffing. English, French, Chinese, and Arabic are all very different languages ... if you are applying to med school, I assume that you are fairly young. Too young, perhaps, to have lived in all of these other countries and gained proficiency in the languages. I know that you have a limited number of characters, but if you want to be believed, you may have to provide some backing or scale down your claims of being fluent.