mSaKooL 4 / 3 Apr 23, 2007 #1Hey there. I was wondering if someone can edit/review these poems for me please!FoxholeZigzag like the Nile.Garbage in a small bin.Secure by the parados,but only by the rear.Surrounded by ketchup.Geography of the Trenches.Lines.Front and support.Attacked by the paper balls and fortress built. <- (is that a good metaphor for: "bombarding and barraging?")Reserve.Watching, waiting, and entertained by the overflowing tea-pots.Rest.Enjoying the luxurious gravel like a soccer ball on turf.Life in the Trenches.Weapons.Pencil and staples.domination.Odor and sight like dead ats on a sunny hot day,chlorine gas neutralized. <- (does the dead rats work w/ the chlorine gas?)Maxine and Vickers,adequate.Lee and Ross,not so much.Warfare in the Trenches.Casualties.Sanitary conditions poor.Reek of the rotting sandbags, rotting corpses, lingering odor poison gas.Chatting; pyrexia or trench fever.Machine guns,slaughter.Left in no man's land...Death in the Trenches.The Bloodshed began.For that one, my teacher said I needed more figuarative language and 5-sense detail. I just need someone to edit/review it and see if it's okay (like the metaphors and everything) and then I'll try to add more. Thank you.2nd poem:SandSand;I held it,brown granny granular.Danced in my hand.Butterfly;Yellow sunlightBrown cinnamon bun.Danced in my hand.I open my hand...My palm with long brown linesI kind of don't know how to end it. I just stop there after my palm. Any help would be appreciated. Thank-you.3rd poem/haiku:With large and big buns,The meat was tender and fresh.McDonald's Big Mac.For the haiku, I kind of don't know how to add 5-sense detail and figurative language as it's limited to a number of syllables.Any help on either of the poems would be greatly appreciated. Thank-you very much.
EF_Team2 1 / 1,708 Apr 23, 2007 #2Greetings!I'll be happy to give you my impressions. Please understand, though, that I don't know much about how to write poetry; I can only tell you what occurs to me about it as I read. :-))Attacked by the paper balls and fortress built. <- (is that a good metaphor for: "bombarding and barraging?") - This struck me as not quite right because it seemed as though what came after "paper balls" should be something similar, to balance it. "...the paper balls and [adjective] [noun]." Sorry I can't give you an example, but I don't know enough about what you were trying to say. To me, it doesn't equate to "bombarding and barraging."I love the over-flowing teapots! :-)I think the dead rats are fine :-) Just be sure to put an "r" on the word; it seems to have fallen off. ;-))Sanitary conditions poor - This struck me as a little too predictable. My first thought was, "Sanitary conditions--not" but you might want something a bit more sensory-rich, like "crush the lungs."Consider changing the last line to "The bloodshed begins" to keep your tenses the same.In the next poem, I'll confess, I don't "get" the "granny" bit. Is this a reference to a grandmother? Why? Could you have meant "grainy"? I like the line, "My palm with long brown lines"; my first thought was to add something like "...cups the world/" and then make some kind of metaphor about sweat and oceans...For the Big Mac haiku, I think I'd go with fewer connecting words that don't add to the imagery. For example:Sesame seeds crunchMeat oozing tangy sauceMcDonald's Big Mac.I hope this helps some!Thanks,Sarah, EssayForum.com