it caused all the board to hate me and become extremely agitated. The essay is supposed to be about why you should be accepted into Honor Society.
Oh, no! That's terrible! I'm sorry to hear that.
In this world of ours, there exist extremely odd phenomena. One such phenomenon is that the words...
Capitalize Latin.
...metaphorically equivalent to a Jesus like Tetris game.---Wow, a Jesus-like Tetris game? If you explain how a Tetris game can be like Jesus in the sentence that follows this one, I think it will be a great little piece of writing!
We both have thoroughly enlightened the minds of our younger more impressionable peers. ---No wonder they hate you! This sounds pompous. :-/
Oh, I know why. "Peer" implies equal. You should use the word "juniors" or some other word that indicates that they are younger than you.
Use a hyphen in this situation:
Besides churning out test-acing pupils, I also, much like a mythical god-like Catcher in the Rye watch over the ...---Ha ha, so you write with a very sophisticated style and in a few sentences say you are godlike and that you enlighten the minds of others.
I think that ending is clever. I think you are destined to be a misunderstood artist. For now, give the essay an unmistakable theme, and
make it humble. Couple all self-aggrandizement with a few words that indicate that your reason fro accomplishing so much comes from your vision of the future, which includes this school. Write about accomplishments you made in order to achieve what is really important -- your vision of the future. Put the focus on the vision that you and the reader can share.
And use simple sentences so people are not intimidate by you! :-)