Unanswered [10] | Urgent [0]
  

Home / Undergraduate   % width Posts: 14


True belief, The salvation of a cynic - Common app;topic of your choice


anally 1 / 15  
Dec 6, 2012   #1
Hi! I have two versions for the commonapp main essay. V1 has already been submitted for Early applications, but i have a very strong feeling that I'm doomed for it, because it sounds like an antichrist or something. So, V2 is the adapted version, but still, i have a bad feeling and am eager to adapt/rewrite it. I'm an international student, so please point out my erred grammars. I know it's a lot to ask to read sooooo many words. So MUCH THANKS!!!! Please be as harsh as possible. Thanks again!

V1
The salvation of a cynic

"Hang her", ejaculated the cardinal, "for a cynic shall not be saved." Fear haunting me, I could feel sweats tap-dancing on my forehead, and the ever-so-bright sunlight illuminating my brown pupils. But no light, no warmth seemed to offer an ounce of solace to me, a faithless cynic: an unbeliever.

That's the nightmare I usually wake up from. Preferring believing in nothing to blindly following some religion, I thought truth would stand on my side by being skeptical to every theory, and judging things as objectively as possible. However, lacking a firm belief almost led me to be a nihilist---it was like the noose hanging around my neck.

Fortunately, my father knew me better. He encouraged me to embrace a reasonable belief. He told stories of my grandparents, the "soldiers" who fought valiantly in wars and struggled through the hardest time in the early days. Even on the brink of ruin, they believed life will be better and held fast to it.

"That's the charm of true belief. At some point, you'll believe in something."

True belief, what magical words! I didn't fully understand it until one day in the independent research I did last year. My true belief stroked right to my heart in a millisecond like a chemical reaction.

I studied system dynamics, using Conway's game of life as the medium. According to Conway's theory, cells propagate under influence of its defined neighborhood with a fixed set of rules. My task was to compile a concise dictionary for all the detectable patterns of propagation, stationary or oscillating, and to explore the possible utilities of cellular automatons in different fields.

The cells started off as some random dots on the computer screen, constituting a disturbingly disorderly jumble, at which anyone would frown. However, after thousands of generations, the seemingly unpleasant chaos was transformed into esthetical patterns. The whole process was like a holy parturition, with order being the child and chaos being the mother. The most exciting moment was when I beheld "order" surfacing from chaos. Patterns exist in even the most disorderly pandemonium! Stable structures like block and beehive, oscillators like beacon and blinker, and more complex structures like spaceships and guns were all waiting behind the curtain: the 70*70 grid I constructed for them, longing to surface. What else could I do but love them and appreciate them for their beauty and certainty?

I've become a fervent believer of existence of universal laws, the order, or, TRUTH. I believe that behind every "uncertainty" lies some unshakable "certainty", that if I don't know velocity of electron, I must be graced with the position of it.

The scene in my dream popped into my head again. Looking at the gallows, I could still feel the texture of the crude straws around my neck. But this time, I am free. I'd never felt so relieved, with every inch of my body stretching for warmth and sunlight.

I guess as a cynic, I am saved.

V2
I'm born in a family of believers.
My grandparents, soldiers who fought valiantly in the Anti-Japanese War, were adamantly convicted in the rise of a new China. My father, a doctor who deals with doses and chemicals every day, is a believer of science. My mother, diagnosed with optic trophy at the age of 22 and never got her original 5.0-eyesight back after the craniotomy, puts her faith in God to draw His strength.

Unlike my devoted families, I remained an atheist for almost 17 years, because I preferred believing in nothing at all to blindly following some religion. I thought truth would stand on my side by being skeptical to every theory, and judging things as objectively as possible.

But I underestimated the word "belief". It's the fountain of energy that doesn't include hazards of global warming of radioactivity. And I didn't fully understand it until one day in the independent research I did last year. My true belief stroked right to my heart in a millisecond like a chemical reaction.

I studied system dynamics, using Conway's game of life as the medium. According to Conway's theory, cells propagate under influence of its defined neighborhood with a fixed set of rules. My task was to compile a concise dictionary for all the detectable patterns of propagation, stationary or oscillating, and to explore the possible utilities of cellular automatons in different fields.

The cells started off as some random dots on the computer screen, constituting a disturbingly disorderly jumble, at which anyone would frown. However, after thousands of generations, the seemingly unpleasant chaos was transformed into esthetical patterns. The whole process was like a holy parturition, with order being the child and chaos being the mother. The most exciting moment was when I beheld "order" surfacing from chaos. Patterns exist in even the most disorderly pandemonium! Stable structures like block and beehive, oscillators like beacon and blinker, and more complex structures like spaceships and guns were all waiting behind the curtain: the 70*70 grid I constructed for them, longing to surface. What else could I do but love them and appreciate them for their beauty and certainty?

I've become a fervent believer of existence of universal laws, the order, or, TRUTH. I believe that behind every "uncertainty" lies some unshakable "certainty", that if I don't know velocity of electron, I must be graced with the position of it.

Like the disorderly cells presented in Conway's Game of Life, many things in our life are presented in a state of chaos because low entropy is the nature's way of ruling. But while I'm writing a program, I have the order in my mind. And with that order, no matter how complicated the problem is, whether it is finding all the prime numbers within 10000, or enabling a model rocket to lift off, I know I can get the result I want. The algorithms are my "order"-- they are where my faith lay. That's one of my many reasons for my love of computer engineering.

And the same rule applies to robotics. As the main programmer and the leader of my VEX robotics team, I have to solve more practical problems than just dots on screen with my computer programming skills. The problems in need of solutions can vary from a nonfunctioning "limit" (a kind of sensor), to the whole robot going rogue. Deep in my belief that there's always order underneath those real-life chaos, I manage to solve the problems with terse algorithms, the order that I believe in.

Originally, I thought beliefs were for the infirm ones who would wallow in the mud of misery, waiting for salvations from others' conceptions and expecting to draw strengths from a community, or for the indolent ones who were not industrious enough to explore their own life philosophies. But now I have my own belief, my faith in Truth. I will happily serve Truth my whole life and dedicate what little strength I have to the course of science.
Didgeridoo - / 306 191  
Dec 6, 2012   #2
Your beliefs aren't necessarily the problem, but your essays do sound a little close-minded.

As a Christian strong in my faith, I found the emphasis on science being fact and the implication that religion cannot be fact a little offensive.

Also, faith is believing in what is not grounded in fact, so your faith in "Truth" sounds a bit contradictory.

Other than that, I don't see any glaring grammatical errors, and you have a very descriptive style of writing.
OP anally 1 / 15  
Dec 6, 2012   #3
Thanks so much for your feedback. I really needed that!
OP anally 1 / 15  
Dec 6, 2012   #4
And Sorry if i offended you. As to the logic fallacy you pointed out, I looked up in google and this is what i find----"Some critics of faith have argued that faith is opposed to reason. In contrast, some advocates of faith argue that the proper domain of faith concerns questions which cannot be settled by evidence." I guess i really was stupid and pretentious to talk about belief before i really learn about it. I watched "I, Pet Goat II" this morning. And apart from its political allusions, I really find religions beautiful, truly astoundingly beautiful. I guess i'll learn more before making a stupid comment then. Sorry, and thank you again.
linting2012 10 / 78 18  
Dec 7, 2012   #5
Hi Anally (funny name)

Your essay was amazing. Though I believe that the V1 is much better than V2. Here are my reasons

1. The first essay flowed better and you sounded more passionate
2. The anecdote of you father is essential, however you only point it out in V1

If I were you I would just modify a little bit of V1 to make it less offensive. So instead of saying a "cynic" use "skeptic", also drop the mother and child metaphor.

Besides that having faith in something is different in believing blindly in something, that you got it right. Take for example having faith in religion and God means that you trust in god and you have evidences (though not concrete) that enables you to trust in God. However believing blindly in God means that you simply believe in God and never question its validity. This is very well explained in your essay. Everyone has their own believe and I don't think any admission officers can penalize you for your believe (though that might be different if you apply to a Jesuit college). However you do sound a little close minded, perhaps tell us why you think having faith in religion is believing blindly?

Good Luck, a very promising essay (I am a Christian too but anyone can have their own opinion, plus Christianity is full of holes, even I start to waver. Take for example the Exodus mentioned in the bible is proven by historians to never had happened in the way described in the Bible, and Jesus may had never existed.)
OP anally 1 / 15  
Dec 8, 2012   #6
Thanks a lot for your reply! And man... Just when i thought no one was gonna notice that ID... I didn't understand that word's meaning until tooooo late...I wonder if there's any way to change that....Anyways...

I do realize that I'm close minded after finding out that many scientists have religions too(Stephan Hawkings), and that every mason has to be a theist...So i know I'm in no place to debate about religion. Maybe I'll focus the article on my view of beief intead of using some really offensive words? As to why I think having faith in religion is believing blindly, well, I was brought up in a country that (even now) believe in the power of revolutions, and of people. And also, one of my aunts chant Mantra in a language no one knows EVERY single morning, and that sounds kind of like brain washing to me....

Any way, i guess i'll read more about it before making any more narrow-minded judgments...
Thanks for your feedback! Really appreciate it.
ivyleague 3 / 7 1  
Dec 8, 2012   #7
Not too sure about how your essay as a whole will come across, but the opening sentence in your second version is a lot more attention grabbing than your original. It's simple, but powerful.
OP anally 1 / 15  
Dec 9, 2012   #8
Thank you.
linting2012 10 / 78 18  
Dec 9, 2012   #9
You know this is what you can mention

Perhaps like this. One day your pastor say something really stupid (Like for example all atheist or satanist and they like to kill people, or like he completely misinterpreted the meaning of "God's Particle" and start talking many stupid things) and all the church goers accept this without questioning the validity of his reasoning. This incident makes you realize that to believe blindly is bad etc.

Hope this help
OP anally 1 / 15  
Dec 11, 2012   #10
That certainly is interesting. Thanks a lot!
teddyliu 1 / 2  
Dec 25, 2012   #11
V1 is more interesting. Just put some says into a gentler way.
dreamer8 2 / 5  
Dec 25, 2012   #12
You are a natural writer, the language is very eloquent!

just change "Preferring believing"
to
"Preferring to believe"
in the beginning.
Bighall 3 / 18 1  
Dec 30, 2012   #13
Do not use cynic. This word is inappropriate here.
OP anally 1 / 15  
Dec 30, 2012   #14
Thanks!


Home / Undergraduate / True belief, The salvation of a cynic - Common app;topic of your choice
Writing
Editing Help?
Fill in one of the forms below to get professional help with your assignments:

Graduate Writing / Editing:
GraduateWriter form ◳

Best Essay Service:
CustomPapers form ◳

Excellence in Editing:
Rose Editing ◳

AI-Paper Rewriting:
Robot Rewrite ◳