Unanswered [13] | Urgent [0]
  

Home / Writing Feedback   % width Posts: 10


Archimedes; "Eureka!" essay


FreedomMoto 1 / 5  
Apr 30, 2009   #1
"Eureka!" famously bellowed by Archimedes running naked, dripping with bath water, after discovering the solution to Hierons' crown dispute. "I have discovered" the derived meaning from the Greek word, Heureka. Hieron, King of Syracuse, received a golden crown and suspected that the gold smith had placed silver in the core of the crown. Looking for reason, Hieron asked Archimedes to prove that the golden crown wasn't pure. What Archimedes discovered is now called the Archimedes' Principle. Different densities of material of the same weight displace different amounts of water. Using a scale to measure a slot of gold the same weight as the crown, Archimedes placed both objects in water attached to a scale and discovered which item displaced more water. Since the densities of the object was less than the solid gold nugget, silver having a density of 10.5 g/ml and gold 19.32 g/ml, the greater water displacement of the more denser item was displayed by the lifting of the crown. Thus proving his principle, Hieron discovered his crown was impure.

Although his birthing place is debatable, most scholars would argue Archimedes was born in Syracuse, a Greek colony in Sicily, around 287 BCE. A son of the astronomer, Phidias, related to King Hieron, birthed a son Gelon, and later died at the hands of the Roman army Archimedes lived an accomplished life. Many stories surround his death, but none more impressive. It is said that Archimedes was working on three dimensional shapes, a favorite past-time, unknowing of the Roman invasion a lone soldier walked into Archimedes study and commanded Archimedes to surrender. With the reluctance of Archimedes to surrender, being too busy playing with shapes, the soldier unaware of who he was and the commands to just capture Archimedes released his sword from his side and impaled Archimedes. Archimedes died 212 BCE. Not much of Archimedes is known about his social life, but his engineering, mathematics, and contributions to science are legendary.

Work of Archimedes is still being discovered today. With the recently discovered palimpsest, scientists have been able to decode the writings of Archimedes using complex imagining and lighting techniques. The Archimedes manuscript, along with four other books, was scraped of its writings in order to make a prayer book, or Euchologion. This has made this book elusive to for those who have searched for it. The discovery of the Archimedes Palimpsest has shed new light regarding Archimedes historical contributions, mainly in the descriptions of his theories on the Equilibrium of Planes, Spiral Lines, Measurement of the Circle, Sphere and Cylinder, the Floating Bodies, the Methods of Mechanical Theorem, and the Stomation. The latter three having no written accounts of how Archimedes discovered or solved them until the finding of the Archimedes palimpsest by a billionaire antique collector. Like many achievements, like the Crown problem, Archimedes was far ahead of his time.

The Archimedes Screw is a pump that allows for vertical water transport. A large part of Archimedes creativity arose as part of the needs of his colony Syracuse. King Hieron commissioned Archimedes to create a monstrous vessel. This vessel, the Syracusia, purposively "was capable of carrying 600 people and included garden decorations, a gymnasium and a temple dedicated to the goddess Aphrodite among its facilities." (Wikipedia) The Archimedes screw was developed as a bilge pump. Usually with most ships of antiquity the sealing capabilities were less than perfect. Also, with long sea journeys storms would cause water to bellow into the cabin of the vessels. The Archimedes Screw used a spiral like screw inside of a hollow rode that would turn. This turning would then carry water in whatever destination needed. Evidence of Archimedes' Screw has be used, in concept, to develop a better functioning artificial heart that instead of mimicking the exact movement of blood thru the heart, the screw would connect directly to the Aorta and Vene Cava and past by the lungs for oxygenation in a constant motion rather that pumping blood through four cambers and passing through pulmonary veins and arteries.

Another phrase associated to Archimedes, "Give me a place to stand, and I will move the earth," came after his indulgence in to levers and pulleys. Archimedes is notoriously known for his pulleys and levers. Pappus of Alexandria witnessed the birth of a man that could move mountains. Using a complex structure of pulleys and levers Archimedes attached one end to the bow of a boat and the other to a single gear. By himself, he was able to turn this gear and move the monstrous boat. While he did not invent the lever, Archimedes wrote about the basic principle involved in pulley systems. On that day, the king declared that all words of Archimedes would be infallible. With confidence by his side, he became an icon.

Along with engineering, mathematics was another area in a long list of Archimedes great achievement. His prediction of Pi was the closest of antiquity. He used equal polygons inscribed and ascribed in and around a circle. Starting with a triangle on the inside and outside, he gradually added more sides, by a multiple of two. He was able to measure the distance around the circle, mathematically, by measuring the distance of a single side of the polygon, ascribed and inscribed, and multiplying the length of one side by how many sides the polygon had. His final polygon used ninety-six sides. Then he used this length and figured out how many diameters would fit on that distance. His number, 3.1406, was the closest to Pi in the classical age. The idea of summation rose again with the findings of the area of complex shapes. Because of this idea, Archimedes is known as the Father of Integral Calculus, which is largely based on summations.

It is said that if Archimedes Palimpsest was never lost are world today would be very different. Flying cars, the Mars landing, anything. With his greatest achievements lost our advancement came at a price, 300 years, but still his legacy lives on. A man founded on the principles of science, mathematics, and inquisition. Whether his contributions are useful to you or not, his ideas shaped the world and its view of mathematics. For a man running naked down the corridors of Sicily yelling Eureka, his accomplishments sure did move the world.

How's this for a introduction?
EF_Kevin 8 / 13,321 129  
Apr 30, 2009   #2
How long will this be when it is finished? For the intro paragraph, I think you should add another sentence after this:

...now called the Archimedes' Principle. (add a sentence that tells something about what will be said in the essay.)

Then start the next paragraph:
Archimedes' Principle explains something important about...(finish the topic sentence for para #2) Different densities of material of...

Let the first paragraph introduce the esay as a whole, and then in para #2 you can start to give the explanation.
OP FreedomMoto 1 / 5  
Apr 30, 2009   #3
Thats what I wanted to set up. A quick outline of a day in his life, followed by a more indepth summary of his life. Like I wrote, "Born in..." that was going to be my thesis of how he lived and what he accomplished. Does that work well? Example, the second paragraph explaining what was he known for. He was a mathematition, an engineer, ect... Then later in the essay explain what I felt were the high points.
Rajiv 55 / 400  
May 1, 2009   #4
Different densities of material of the same weight displace different amounts of water. Using a scale to measure a slot of gold the same weight as the crown, Archimedes placed both objects in water attached to the scale and discovered which item displaced more water. Since the densities of the object was less than the solid gold nugget, silver having a density of 10.5 g/ml and gold 19.32 g/ml, the greater water displacement of the more denser item was displayed by the lifting of the crown.

Use this instead of the above, it appears as more accurate -

Columbia Encyclopedia entry:
Archimedes' principle, principle that states that a body immersed in a fluid is buoyed up by a force equal to the weight of the displaced fluid. The principle applies to both floating and submerged bodies and to all fluids, i.e., liquids and gases.
EF_Sean 6 / 3,491  
May 1, 2009   #5
The distinction between density and weight is important though -- if you only mention weight, it will be impossible to explain his experiment.

As for the effectiveness of your existing paragraph as an intro, a famous historical anecdote is always good at catching the readers' interest, so if you aren't being held to a very strict word count, I see no reason why you shouldn't include it. I assume that it will tie into your thesis, which will be easier to judge once you post the next paragraph.
EF_Sean 6 / 3,491  
May 4, 2009   #6
Your anecdote about his death seems out of place. Usually, this sort of essay would go in chronological order of his achievements, then end with his death. It's sort of natural in what is essentially a biographical piece. You might want to move things around a bit and see if that sounds better.

Also, I thought his quote was "Give me a lever long enough, a fulcrum strong enough and I'll move the world." I know wikipedia gives the version you use, and for all I know it could be right, but I'd double check in a more reliable source, just to be safe.
EF_Kevin 8 / 13,321 129  
May 4, 2009   #7
I wrote, "Born in..." that was going to be my thesis of how he lived and what he accomplished.

I'm not sure what you mean... the thesis is supposed to be the main idea of the essay, and the main idea should be something more than a simple assertion that he accomplished great things. If you give your own slant on the meaning of his life, you can make the essay unique among essays!

Looking at your new draft, I think you should not bother about that Archimedes principle in the first paragraph. the first para should have that GREAT attention-grabbing opening, for sure, but then end the first para after giving your own slant, your own theme. End the first para before getting into all the info. Use the first para as the foundation of it all. Make your assertion about him. Then, in the body paragraphs, you can show off by not only presenting the info but by presenting it in a way that supports your assertion.

You can be very creative with your assertion that you use to give your essay flavor.
SairaTasartir 5 / 37  
May 4, 2009   #8
I'm not sure how true this is, but I heard that Archimedes actually swatted the soldier's foot for standing on his diagram, and the arrogant soldier ran him through for it. I also heard that the soldier was executed for it, and a grave was erected for Archimedes by the Romans. I think I read about this particular fact in a book called "Archimedes and the Door to Science" when I was younger. (Good book; I recommend it for your essay-- easy reading, but solid facts and easy explanations-- check your library)

The paragraph about the Archimedes screw and the ship should be separated into it's topics. If I'm reading it correctly, these are two different inventions? So you should explain them separately. They seem to be a bit garbled-- mixed together-- so it is a bit confusing.

I agree and disagree (I think...) with Kevin! Yes, introduce your topic-- not bothering with his principle just yet-- but I don't think you should get rid of it altogether! It is a very good example of the genius of the man.

Archimedes is fascinating! Good choice of topic.
OP FreedomMoto 1 / 5  
May 4, 2009   #9
Thank for your insight. I'll be sure to correct them, and I repost the essay.
EF_Sean 6 / 3,491  
May 5, 2009   #10
Hmmm . . . what exactly were the assignment instructions? If you are just writing a biographical piece, you don't really need a thesis much beyond "He did a lot of great stuff." If you are supposed to be writing an analytical, argumentative, or persuasive piece, though, then Kevin is right -- you'll need something a bit stronger.


Home / Writing Feedback / Archimedes; "Eureka!" essay
Writing
Editing Help?
Fill in one of the forms below to get professional help with your assignments:

Graduate Writing / Editing:
GraduateWriter form ◳

Best Essay Service:
CustomPapers form ◳

Excellence in Editing:
Rose Editing ◳

AI-Paper Rewriting:
Robot Rewrite ◳