There are 3 major problems with the restated prompt. The first problem, is that it alters the public opinion idea by using the wrong reference point:
long been a controversial debate
. There is neither a reference to a controversy, debate, or long term discussion. The topic basis alteration can only result in deductions.
The second problem, is that the reference to
school-aged children
is made in the discussion. This is an incorrect age range reference as the mention in the original relates to teenagers or young adults. School-age children will never be asked to perform community service.
Finally, the writer jumped directly opinion basis in the last part. Totally skipping the complete keyword response to the question provided. He should have firmly disagreed before laying out the reason why.
The first reasoning paragraph is totally unrelated to his opinion as previously stated. This paragraph should not have been presented since this is a single opinion essay. The writer presented 2 valid supporting opinions in the next paragraph which should have been properly expanded over 2 paragraphs instead. Instead, he will lose points for 2 reasons:
1. The writer gave an unrelated opinion discussion
2. The writer has an under explained related opinion in the essay
While the sentence structure and word usage will have limited deductions applied, the main scoring areas will receive score reducing deductions.