Unanswered [10] | Urgent [0]
  

Posts by mmcnulty25
Joined: Sep 11, 2012
Last Post: Sep 20, 2012
Threads: 2
Posts: 4  

From: United States of America

Displayed posts: 6
sort: Latest first   Oldest first  | 
mmcnulty25   
Sep 20, 2012
Undergraduate / UChicago essay #1, "desire for particular type of learning" - prestige, name? [4]

Thanks for the reply. I really appreciate the feedback.

Which sections did you find it repetitive and see idea-jumping?

And yeah, I felt the same way after reading it but was still a little on the fence about it. Thanks for pushing me off! Do you feel it'd be an improvement to keep:

"I consider myself to be an ambitious person, and as such, I have several major goals in terms of my education: to attend a great college, to go get into graduate school, and to get an education that will not only prepare me for an interesting and fulfilling job but also help satisfy my never-ending desire for learning in all areas of study. What do all of these have in common? The University of Chicago can help me reach each of them."

and
"So why do I want to go to Chicago? For the prestige? For the name? No, and no. What I truly want from the University of Chicago is the learning, community, and future I know it has to offer."

And remove the rest of the questions while keeping the indicative portions of the section and adding sentence variety to make it less choppy?

Again, thanks for the help.
I'll be sure to return the favor soon!
mmcnulty25   
Sep 20, 2012
Undergraduate / 'I got my AP score' - UChicago nemesis essay, creative narrative email [4]

Thank you for your feedback. It seems like a letter because it is a letter. This was a thank you email to my English teacher for helping me do so well on my AP test. There was never any confusion on the score. That was just to base the story off of.

I was looking for criticism on the content of the story within the email and also ideas for incorporating the email into a cohesive essay.

Thanks!
mmcnulty25   
Sep 11, 2012
Undergraduate / 'I got my AP score' - UChicago nemesis essay, creative narrative email [4]

ESSAY OPTION 1.
"A man cannot be too careful in the choice of his enemies." ïOscar Wilde.

Othello and Iago. Dorothy and the Wicked Witch. Autobots and Decepticons. History and art are full of heroes and their enemies. Tell us about the relationship between you and your arch-nemesis (either real or imagined).


Below is a thank-you email I sent to my English teacher over the summer after I got my AP score. It progressed from a simple thank you to a full on short story as a result of summer boredom, but my teacher gave me the idea to incorporate it into an essay somehow and I thought that this one from UChicago was perfect. Any ideas for rewording or additions to make it fit the prompt a little better? I would also appreciate any feedback and criticism on what I have right now.

One idea I had was adding an introduction that made it kind of like an epic story from a bard or something? I thought that might add to the quirky and weird humor already demonstrated in the email. Thoughts?

Mrs. Lehman, I arrived home today to discover that my AP test results had arrived in the mail. With eager eyes and a spring in my step, I bounded upstairs to my bedroom. Though nervous, I had harbored high hopes since that fateful May morning, for I believed I had been taught by the best. Sweat saturated with aching anticipation, my shaking hands tear open the letter. Almost of its own accord, a small gasp escapes my lips. Do my eyes decieve me? Dare I believe what I see? Quickly, my disbelief turns to anger, my anger to hatred! Who is to blame? Who is responsible? I curse to the heavens for all to hear; I curse the name Nancy Lehman. Crashing to my knees, I throw my head back and howl -- an unnatural, unworldly howl. No! No! No! Too late, I realize what is happening to me. My senses sharpen. My finger grow to form huge claws. My hair twists and curls until my body is covered in a thick coat. I let out another howl as my werewolf transformation completes.

With a snarl, I remember how it all began. It was a cold winter night -- one of the coldest of the year. I had just finished my daily seven hours of studying at the library for AP English. But I was not bitter; in fact, I was the opposite. I knew that my hard work would pay off, and I would triumph come May. Everything changed when I took those fated first steps toward my car. Over to my left, I heard a low, menacing growl. In a whirlwhind of claws, teeth, and snow, I found myself on my back in a puddle of bloody slush. Pinning me to the ground was a giant wolf, its fangs gleaming in the moonlight and hot breath in my face. And just as fast as it came, it was gone. Clutching my bleeding chest, I sat up with a groan. Then everything went black.

The next morning, I woke to find myself naked and shivering in a nearby neighborhood with no recollection of the previous night's events. However, I was not without clues. All around me were the shredded remains of what look like roughly 42 people, and the taste of flesh and blood still fresh on my tongue. Fortunately, that morning was a garbage pickup day, and I easily disposed of all evidence of my bloody feast. Several unsuspecting Minooka residents were convicted of murder later that week, but I arrived at school that day with not one person aware of my dark secret. For several hours, guilt gnawed at my insides. But then I remembered why it was all worth it -- I was going to do well on the AP test. I threw myself into my studies and suppressed my guilt along with my secret and the bloody urges that accompanied it. That was my first and only episode -- until now.

With every muscle I struggle; I fight against the all consuming blackness. But a devilish thought enters my head, and I allow the transformation to take over me. As I concede to the darkness, I focus on a single thought: GET LEHMAN. With a jolt, I wake up.

"Did I get her?" I wonder aloud. Looking around, I realize with horror that I did not. My feral instincts were too strong, my urges too great. Littered around me are the small corpses of babies and puppies, most of them with teeth marks and chunks of skin missing. Tears streaming down my cheeks, I cry into the open air, "Curse you, Nancy Lehman! I ate all these babies and puppies, and it's all your fault!" Letting out a loud sob, I sink to the ground, contemplating all I had been through in the name of AP English.

"A 5 out of 10," I mumble to myself, "How could they give me a 50%?" Wait a minute... My face brightens as I remember that the AP test is scored out of 5, not 10. "Cool beans!" I exclaim. With a smile on my face, I get to my feet and skip off into the sunset whistling "Yankee Doodle."

Thanks for everything!
Mike McNulty
mmcnulty25   
Sep 11, 2012
Undergraduate / 'Poor Papaw' - Common App essay. Important Person topic [4]

All in all, I found this to be a great essay. It demonstrates your own work experience, answers the prompt, shows your commitment to helping others, hints at your intended area of study and why you want to study that, and shows your commitment to your family and the ones close to you. Colleges look for all of those.

There were several parts that seemed incomplete or confusing:

He flew to me to make sure that I was safe, even though it.
This sentence just trails off without finishing the thought.

so he wanted to spend it with people he loved and help not only his son, but encourage me in my first job.
Consider rewording this to make your intentions more clear. The part that throws me off is "and help not only his son." If you mean that he is helping your dad by driving with you, then simply add that in. You want to be as precise as possible without being too verbose. And a side not: the conjunctions "not only" and "but also" should be used together. You use "not only" and "but".
mmcnulty25   
Sep 11, 2012
Undergraduate / UT Austin SOP - experience of moving from a private school to a public school [3]

You made a great point in your question: that you do not want to make it sound like an excuse. Keep in mind, though, that that is exactly what you are doing. You walk a fine line and because of that need to be very aware of the diction that you use.

The thread is called "need help for an opener" so I am assuming that you know exactly what you want to talk about in the body of the essay. For the intro, you could cite examples in which standardized methods of evaluation, like GPA and class rank, can often be misleading. If you've ever talked about BMI in phys ed, you've probably heard the famous fact that Shaq is considered to be morbidly obese, despite being a world-class athlete, because of his high weight : height ratio. I'm sure that if you brainstormed, you could come up with some similar examples. I feel that such an intro would be a unique way to introduce the topic and show some outside research on your end as well as creatively relating to your personal circumstances.
mmcnulty25   
Sep 11, 2012
Undergraduate / UChicago essay #1, "desire for particular type of learning" - prestige, name? [4]

UChicago Supplement Essay #1
How does the University of Chicago, as you know it now, satisfy your desire for a particular type of learning, community, and future? Please address with some specificity your own wishes and how they relate to UChicago. Please respond by writing a paragraph or two.

My entire life, I have had a thirst for knowledge, a desire to learn. While other pre-schoolers drew pictures, I wrote out numbers. While other kids learned the alphabet, I was already reading. By seven, I could do more advanced math that than most fifth graders. In eighth grade, I took math at the high school. Through all of high school, I have taken every AP, honors, and college-level class available. Now as a senior, I have run out of math classes to take and will be taking Calculus II online. Even after seventeen years, I am as parched as ever. As one of the most prestigious and rigorous universities in the country, I know without a doubt that the University of Chicago is exactly what I need. Though my thirst will never be quenched, my hope is that Chicago can wet my whistle -- just a little bit. In my life-long quest for educational enlightenment, I wish not only to draw from the well of the classroom but also immerse myself in the reservoir of knowledge that is the student body. There is is some learning that can only be done through discussion and debate between peers -- just as "iron sharpens iron; scholar, the scholar" (William Drummond). Right now, my mind is nothing more than a hammer -- powerful yet blunt. At Chicago, I hope to sharpen it to a sword able to gracefully cut and slash through even the most difficult of obstacles that life has to throw my way. And in my sharpening, I hope to spar with some of the sharpest swords that America has to offer.

I consider myself to be an ambitious person, and as such, I have several major goals in terms of my education: to attend a great college, to go get into graduate school, and to get an education that will not only prepare me for an interesting and fulfilling job but also help satisfy my never-ending desire for learning in all areas of study. What do all of these have in common? The University of Chicago can help me reach each of them. So I want to attend a great college? The University of Chicago is consistently recognized as one of the best colleges in the country. So I was to get into graduate school? The liberal arts curriculum at Chicago is great preparation for any graduate program. So I want to get an education that will not only prepare me for an interesting and fulfilling job but also help satisfy my never-ending desire for learning in all areas of study? The "Chicago Trained Mind" is exactly what employers in any field are looking for, and the Chicago curriculum allows for students to study extensively and thoughtfully in just about every area imaginable. So why do I want to go to Chicago? For the prestige? For the name? No, and no. What I truly want from the University of Chicago is the learning, community, and future I know it has to offer.

I just want to thank everybody in advance for your thoughts and criticisms!
Do You Need
Academic Writing
or Editing Help?
Fill in one of the forms below to get professional help with your assignments:

Graduate Writing / Editing:
GraduateWriter form ◳

Best Essay Service:
CustomPapers form ◳

Excellence in Editing:
Rose Editing ◳

AI-Paper Rewriting:
Robot Rewrite ◳