sarabarnes0123
Sep 24, 2019
Scholarship / "Why history?" Biographical Essay for QB National College Match [3]
@karleev843
This is such a brave and vulnerable essay. I love the theme throughout, however, the tone of it is pretty somber the whole way through. Try to find a way to twist these circumstances in which you've grown up into a positive. I know you said you learned from their mistakes, so try and include more examples of you overcoming obstacles as such. Be wary not to focus too much on other people. When you do, include how it affected you or made you feel, rather than just saying what happened to them (show, don't tell). For the paragraph on the cousin, I wouldn't say your mental health never fully recovered. As much as I am aware mental health is an ongoing battle, admissions officers want to know what you will contribute on campus, and negative mental health probably wouldn't appeal to them. Instead, try and focus on, again, how you overcame these challenges after some self-introspection. I would also love an elaboration on why you enjoy history. I see how you connected it with your own past, but maybe add some more examples of your intellectual curiosity rather than using it as a means of survival.
Some quick grammar things, don't put punctuation after quotes if you already have punctuation inside ("Why history?") and put commas inside the quotes ("Those who cannot remember the past are condemned to repeat it,"). I'd also not start with "Let's start with the beginning," instead just simply start.
Hope this helps!
@karleev843
This is such a brave and vulnerable essay. I love the theme throughout, however, the tone of it is pretty somber the whole way through. Try to find a way to twist these circumstances in which you've grown up into a positive. I know you said you learned from their mistakes, so try and include more examples of you overcoming obstacles as such. Be wary not to focus too much on other people. When you do, include how it affected you or made you feel, rather than just saying what happened to them (show, don't tell). For the paragraph on the cousin, I wouldn't say your mental health never fully recovered. As much as I am aware mental health is an ongoing battle, admissions officers want to know what you will contribute on campus, and negative mental health probably wouldn't appeal to them. Instead, try and focus on, again, how you overcame these challenges after some self-introspection. I would also love an elaboration on why you enjoy history. I see how you connected it with your own past, but maybe add some more examples of your intellectual curiosity rather than using it as a means of survival.
Some quick grammar things, don't put punctuation after quotes if you already have punctuation inside ("Why history?") and put commas inside the quotes ("Those who cannot remember the past are condemned to repeat it,"). I'd also not start with "Let's start with the beginning," instead just simply start.
Hope this helps!