talanchi
Dec 13, 2009
Undergraduate / "I have grown up on two continents" - Common App Personal Essay on Diversity [5]
Wow, took me a second to get over your critique! Thanks for your reply though, it's really helpful to see someone else's reaction to your essay.
I was actually thinking about taking this sentence out; not because I think it is pretentious but because I just don't think it makes a whole lot of sense. I do think that anyone's life is a catalogue, in a sense, it's just made up of different sections with different labels.
I think it's the main 'perspective' that I'm trying to get across (quite unsuccessfully at the moment, needs rewording!).
I didn't think of it as a 'touch' but thanks! :)
Actually, someone else told me not to use 'insofar' I'm quite curious...is it an awkward expression?
You're right, I'm having issues with the whole third paragraph at the moment..
Well that (somehow, in my muddled brain) leads on as an example of the 'judging' but I guess now it's going out the window with the other issue.
Hm, I think you misunderstood me here. Rather than talking about how I overcame cultural clashes (actually never mentioned that) or 'merged identities', I was using that as an example of how you can misunderstand someone if you judge them on single impressions rather than as a whole. The point is not that I have multiple identities but that, through my experience, I have learnt not to be superficial in judging others. Does that make better sense?
This statement is quite general and I think that it applies to everyone, not just to me - isn't everyone the product of all their experiences and isn't that what makes them, them? What does overcoming 'the cultural barrier' have to do with personal identity?
I hope I'm not hinting that; rather, I'm trying to explain how I have come to embrace/respect diversity through my own experiences...I think you'll find that I'm not really saying "immigration = diversity". Although I made it clear that I'm an immigrant, I was trying to focus more on the
. I don't think that "immigration = diversity" either, for argument's sake there are plenty of non-integrated immigrants who are the opposite of diverse.
I do agree with you and I think that you would have realised that, had you bothered read the essay. Note the ending:
So in a nutshell, I'm saying what you're saying. While I think that living in lots of countries helps to nurture a "diverse" mind, anyone can develop a "diverse perspective" - which is exactly what I want to contribute.
I'm truly sorry if my response comes across as over defensive at times, please know that it's partly just trying to defend my own work to myself:) I know that it's far from perfect and I'm grateful for your help in improving it! (And I'd be even more grateful if I could get more advice from more people!)
this essay won't help you much
Wow, took me a second to get over your critique! Thanks for your reply though, it's really helpful to see someone else's reaction to your essay.
talanchi:
my life is a living catalogue
somewhat pretentious
my life is a living catalogue
somewhat pretentious
I was actually thinking about taking this sentence out; not because I think it is pretentious but because I just don't think it makes a whole lot of sense. I do think that anyone's life is a catalogue, in a sense, it's just made up of different sections with different labels.
talanchi:
Essentially, I was able to get a view from the inside of the different "classes" and "cultures", allowing me to see more than just one side of a conflict.
so I take this as your broad perspective?
Essentially, I was able to get a view from the inside of the different "classes" and "cultures", allowing me to see more than just one side of a conflict.
so I take this as your broad perspective?
I think it's the main 'perspective' that I'm trying to get across (quite unsuccessfully at the moment, needs rewording!).
talanchi:
learnt
nice british touch
learnt
nice british touch
I didn't think of it as a 'touch' but thanks! :)
talanchi:
Insofar
second time you use it, watch out
Insofar
second time you use it, watch out
Actually, someone else told me not to use 'insofar' I'm quite curious...is it an awkward expression?
talanchi:
I try to view everything as a means towards an end rather than an end in itself.
what does this have to do with judging?
I try to view everything as a means towards an end rather than an end in itself.
what does this have to do with judging?
You're right, I'm having issues with the whole third paragraph at the moment..
talanchi:
For instance, if someone would like to gain an accurate idea of who I am, it would be nonsensical to try to do so by analyzing single points in my life
too brutal of a change of subject, some transition?
For instance, if someone would like to gain an accurate idea of who I am, it would be nonsensical to try to do so by analyzing single points in my life
too brutal of a change of subject, some transition?
Well that (somehow, in my muddled brain) leads on as an example of the 'judging' but I guess now it's going out the window with the other issue.
talanchi:
four different individuals rather than of just one.
mm...
how you did merge those identities? are you 4 in 1? unless you clarify, the admin will won't know if you overcame the cultural clashes
four different individuals rather than of just one.
mm...
how you did merge those identities? are you 4 in 1? unless you clarify, the admin will won't know if you overcame the cultural clashes
Hm, I think you misunderstood me here. Rather than talking about how I overcame cultural clashes (actually never mentioned that) or 'merged identities', I was using that as an example of how you can misunderstand someone if you judge them on single impressions rather than as a whole. The point is not that I have multiple identities but that, through my experience, I have learnt not to be superficial in judging others. Does that make better sense?
talanchi:
but I am what the aggregate of my experiences has made me to be.
how? it's not easy to overcome the cultural barrier...
but I am what the aggregate of my experiences has made me to be.
how? it's not easy to overcome the cultural barrier...
This statement is quite general and I think that it applies to everyone, not just to me - isn't everyone the product of all their experiences and isn't that what makes them, them? What does overcoming 'the cultural barrier' have to do with personal identity?
talanchi:
- I believe that diversity can only be beneficial when it is understood and respected.
by saying this, you hint that your essay explain what diversity is...and i don't think that immigration = diversity
- I believe that diversity can only be beneficial when it is understood and respected.
by saying this, you hint that your essay explain what diversity is...and i don't think that immigration = diversity
I hope I'm not hinting that; rather, I'm trying to explain how I have come to embrace/respect diversity through my own experiences...I think you'll find that I'm not really saying "immigration = diversity". Although I made it clear that I'm an immigrant, I was trying to focus more on the
view from the inside of the different "classes" and "cultures"
. I don't think that "immigration = diversity" either, for argument's sake there are plenty of non-integrated immigrants who are the opposite of diverse.
realize that diversity isn't simply having immigrated to many places.
I do agree with you and I think that you would have realised that, had you bothered read the essay. Note the ending:
I hope to contribute to the diversity in a college community not only by bringing my own diversity or life experiences but, more importantly, by bringing my perspective borne out of those
So in a nutshell, I'm saying what you're saying. While I think that living in lots of countries helps to nurture a "diverse" mind, anyone can develop a "diverse perspective" - which is exactly what I want to contribute.
I'm truly sorry if my response comes across as over defensive at times, please know that it's partly just trying to defend my own work to myself:) I know that it's far from perfect and I'm grateful for your help in improving it! (And I'd be even more grateful if I could get more advice from more people!)