uchihakula
Sep 16, 2011
Undergraduate / Application Essay: About to die of embarrassment because it's so stinky... [2]
I hope you have not sent your essay because even though it is not very helpful for your application, there is plenty of space for improvements:
1) The essay seems too focused on your friend rather than you (2.5 out of 3 paragraphs). Try to reverse the proportion, i.e describe how the death of your friend affect you for the majority of the essay.
2) Frankly, the 1st paragraph would fit better into a story than an essay as it sounds like a forced attempt to show rather than tell (which I know you may have heard from countless books on essay that it is a good thing to do). Remember, you only have so many words to use, and show off your literary/poetic sense to talk about someone else is not space-efficient.
3) In your defense, however, your 2nd paragraph moves seamlessly and elegantly from showing (the funeral scene) to telling (about how the loss affect you). If I were you, I would make change to the 2nd para. and make it my 1st paragraph, and with a twist make the 1st to be the last paragraph - sorta like in media res. A suggestion for this twist would be like so (just some raw ideas): his death inadvertently brings revelation to your mind or he might have not been wise in doing so but he left a legacy worthy of more than any wise words (don't try to sound like preaching). Ex: "...his lifeless body, lying there amid the sobbing of his family, was more forceful than any orator standing on the podium talking about the meaning of life..."
For this emotional kind of essay, I would suggest that you ask for your female relative (they are better than female teachers) to comment on the content. The writing can be proof-read by anyone. Good luck
I hope you have not sent your essay because even though it is not very helpful for your application, there is plenty of space for improvements:
1) The essay seems too focused on your friend rather than you (2.5 out of 3 paragraphs). Try to reverse the proportion, i.e describe how the death of your friend affect you for the majority of the essay.
2) Frankly, the 1st paragraph would fit better into a story than an essay as it sounds like a forced attempt to show rather than tell (which I know you may have heard from countless books on essay that it is a good thing to do). Remember, you only have so many words to use, and show off your literary/poetic sense to talk about someone else is not space-efficient.
3) In your defense, however, your 2nd paragraph moves seamlessly and elegantly from showing (the funeral scene) to telling (about how the loss affect you). If I were you, I would make change to the 2nd para. and make it my 1st paragraph, and with a twist make the 1st to be the last paragraph - sorta like in media res. A suggestion for this twist would be like so (just some raw ideas): his death inadvertently brings revelation to your mind or he might have not been wise in doing so but he left a legacy worthy of more than any wise words (don't try to sound like preaching). Ex: "...his lifeless body, lying there amid the sobbing of his family, was more forceful than any orator standing on the podium talking about the meaning of life..."
For this emotional kind of essay, I would suggest that you ask for your female relative (they are better than female teachers) to comment on the content. The writing can be proof-read by anyone. Good luck