Unanswered [6] | Urgent [0]
  

Posts by zkinx6
Joined: Oct 14, 2012
Last Post: Nov 27, 2012
Threads: 2
Posts: 5  

Displayed posts: 7
sort: Latest first   Oldest first  | 
zkinx6   
Nov 27, 2012
Essays / (Union Army) First year college student not understanding thesis statements [2]

Don't use rhetorical questions in an intro, it makes the argument seem weak. In a thesis you want to take a stance that leaves the reader no doubt what you are arguing. Now your second sentence is the only one that seems to take a stance on the topic you are writing on. To make a stronger introduction, restate the questions as statements, ex. But could it be said that the Confederate troops were superior to the Union troops despite their defeat? changes to " However, the confederate army certainly gave it all they had. Where the confederate troops lacked in numbers, they made up for in cunning skill." -Something like that, just worded how you feel is best. Now it is still difficult to decipher what your topic is and what you are arguing exactly. Some advice, plan out your essay by first deciding what your stance is on the issue. And even before that make sure you know what the question is. Analyze your prompt, it likely says something about analyzing and discussing the merits of the confederate army. Rewrite the prompt as a question like "What strengths and weaknesses did the confederacy and what circumstances would be necessarily for them to overcome their weaknesses?".

Now i have no idea what your actual prompt is sorry if that example does not help. Next answer the question and take a clear stance. Research your topic and find evidence to support BOTH sides of the argument, focusing on your side still. Now you can develop claims from the pieces of evidence from your research (always use sources, it builds credibility into your writing). Now make 2 or 3 claims ex, The confederate army consisted of men far more prepared for the brutality and harsh living conditions associated with. war. (your evidence or warrant would point out from a credible source that the men were better conditioned to those kind of conditions for whatever reason).

Finally, the point i was getting to, your 2 or three claims are basically your thesis statement in its most condensed form. Of course you don't write them out fully, you did a good job of this " Confederates were superior because they were previously prepared for harsh living conditions, and also had better leadership.". Just make sure this one sentence effectively answers the question (also 3 points are better than 2). lastly, the question at the end of your introduction needs to be made into a statement. Maybe work it into a claim. That is all for now. Google CSI or CWI (claim support/warrant impact). It is a template for writing effective argumentation in essays and debate. Best of luck.
zkinx6   
Nov 26, 2012
Undergraduate / Raising Scores at What Cost: UT essay B - Review [4]

PLEASE PLEASE leave comments and critique, I have limited time before i have to submit this. Deadline is DEC 1st for UT. Thank you.
This is about the ill effects high stakes standardized tests have had on my education and the education of my generation.

Prompt: Choose an issue of importance to you - the issue could be personal, school related, local, political, or international in scope - and write an essay in which you explain the significance of that issue to yourself, your family, your community, or your generation.

Mine and countless other student's experiences in public school have been centered around learning to make decisions when given a problem designed to have exactly one correct solution. Over the past decade standardized testing has risen exponentially thanks to the No Child Left Behind Act and it's successor Race To The Top. The laws mandate that test results be used as a measure of accountability to rate the success of public schools. Federal funds are then distributed based on those ratings with high performing schools getting increases and low performing schools being penalized with cuts. The battle for federal funding results in a strong focus on state standards at the cost of a broad curriculum and a well rounded education. In my home state, Texas, I took the high-stakes Texas Assessment of Knowledge and Skills (TAKS) every year from the third through the eleventh grade. Raising standards is a good thing, however as a student who has participated in the system of high-stakes testing, it is clear that while the system is slowly succeeding in raising scores, it is failing to prepare my generation for their own future and the future of society.

In my sophomore year pre-calculus class, following a first semester of trigonometry, the second semester comprised a lengthy and unengaging review of rudimentary algebra. For four months, I worked superficial problems on worksheets almost every class day. These depth-less problems were given to my class as preparation for the TAKS. This pattern of learning new material the first semester and reviewing for the TAKS the second semester happened in at least one class every year. In English we would read passages from old TAKS tests to practice short answer response questions and discuss strategies for test taking. The teachers did not seem to want it this way, however it was just the way things worked.

With my education revolving around an increasingly narrowing curriculum focused on a high-stakes test, I began thinking about what skills and values were not on the test. Creativity, discovery, curiosity, integrity, and critical thinking are just a few of the skills and values that the test does not measure, but that are important to a meaningful and prosperous future. Instilling these traits into students goes hand in hand with the academic goals of education, yet today there is no time for them in the test centered curriculum. There is hardly any time left to discuss current events, complex real world issues, or take a look at the people making a difference in the community and the world. There is little time at all for complex higher level thinking.

My school experiences were largely based on the idea that there is one correct solution to every problem. My generation has had this idea drilled into them since the third grade. As a society we must recognize this is not how to effectively educate future generations to prepare them to face the uncertain futures ahead of them. Our education system must move in the total opposite direction of standardization, starting with politicians and bureaucrats realizing that they can't simply make an education system based in the era of the Industrial Revolution work in the 21st century. In reality there is almost always more than one correct solution to any given problem. Doing away with excessive standardization and embracing the diversity of every generation is something I will always advocate for. For now by simply raising awareness, in the future by voting and voicing my opinions to those I elect to represent my community, my state, and my country.
zkinx6   
Nov 26, 2012
Undergraduate / Texas A&M App. Essay; 'A Dad is a man who is there for his children' [2]

I like your introduction, it frames the essay well. One suggestion for clarification.
"It's a shame that I haven't been able to fully appreciate my dad until my teenage years. He took my mom and older brother in 19 years ago and hasn't taken a second at his decision. For any man to take in two kids that aren't his and treat them as his own is nothing short of amazing."

Replace with "has never looked back"

Overall it is good and engaging. Good job.
zkinx6   
Oct 14, 2012
Undergraduate / 'magnificent grandeur of music' - Short essay from Common app. [8]

I really like your description of the feelings you have performing, as others have pointed out, you certainly have passion. One thing that I would do, I think it would benefit you write in terms of a progression of how music affects you and has helped you grow as an individual. From what admissions officers have told me, they are looking for statements that reflect your personality and how experiences have effected and shaped who you are today. Just how i would approach it. Possibly find a way to creatively add your achievements in music into the short essay. Anyway, you have a great style and i wish you the best of luck in your scholarly and musical endeavors. Cheers
zkinx6   
Oct 14, 2012
Undergraduate / College Essay A: Adam Savage impacted my life [4]

I'd appreciate feedback on errors, revising, and anything else i can do to improve my essay A. Thanks.

Prompt: Write an essay in which you tell us about someone who has made an impact in your life and explain how and why this person is important to you.

Looking for a needle in a haystack? Good luck. This well known idiom describes a very difficult if not impossible search. Almost a decade ago, on the television show Mythbusters, co-hosts Adam Savage and Jamie Heineman took up the challenge of using modern technology to render the "needle in the haystack' adage meaningless. Each of the hosts constructed a machine they hoped would sift through hay, pulling out the hidden needles along the way. In the show, Savage demonstrated a cyclic progression of ingenuity, open mindedness, and failure as a mode of exploration, going on to win the competition in just over 6 hours. Adam Savage and his role on Mythbusters propelled my interests towards science and inspired me with the same inclinations I had towards analytical thinking and problem solving.

It was Wednesday at 8pm. I had been waiting for this all week. It had become a tradition of mine. I tuned to the Discovery Channel and prepared for a solid hour of "myth-busting mayhem". At a young age I was already naturally inclined towards analytical thinking and problem solving, although I called it being inventive. I watched Mythbusters every week and noticed something. Adam Savage seemed to have the same inclinations. He took apart a problem like finding a needle in a haystack and looked at it one step at a time, never being afraid to make mistakes and start over until the problem was solved. It's a sentiment that only seems to grow more true as I grow older. He taught me to never give up, and instead to problem solve, and learn from my mistakes. I related strongly to these ideas and took them to heart. Everyday brings a new set of challenges in my work, my studies, and my personal life that I now greet with determination and aptitude.

Savage propelled my interest in science every episode and helped to put me on the path I am today. When asked about when his interest in science began, he answered "I have always had a penchant for taking things apart. It started as a way to look for cool things to build with, but if you take enough things apart, you start to understand how they work and how to put them back together." This curiosity of his influenced me in more ways than I could imagine. It led me to the exploration of my own mind and how to problem solve. Growing up, his role encouraged me to take things apart and make new things with them. This discovery, of learning how things work, and enjoyment of the process meant so much. I was interested in many things at that point. If you were to ask me what I wanted to be when I grew up, I wouldn't have an answer. Then Adam Savage helped me realize how much I liked science and problem solving. This realization is exactly why I have chosen to pursue a degree in the engineering today.

For a time, figuring out what I was most intrigued by was like finding a needle in a haystack. Adam Savage proved that it was not impossible, it just takes a little time. I related to Adam Savage, and his influence on my childhood became more profound than I ever thought it would. He pointed me in the right direction, and I found the needle in the haystack.
Need Writing or Editing Help?
Fill out one of these forms:

Graduate Writing / Editing:
GraduateWriter form ◳

Best Essay Service:
CustomPapers form ◳

Excellence in Editing:
Rose Editing ◳

AI-Paper Rewriting:
Robot Rewrite ◳

Academic AI Writer:
Custom AI Writer ◳