netlev
Dec 1, 2015
Undergraduate / 'lucky to be introduced to computers' - UC Prompt 1 - Transfer Essay and Prompt 2 - Computer Science [8]
I have already finished my application but I need to make this clear and give you an advice about constructive criticism
In the essay, when my father is mentioned it establishes two important points. The first, is the one you caught on, it gives a glimpse of the background I was raised in, but the second one is just as important. It explains why I spent time in a library as much as I did.
A teenager spending almost every day of his life in a library isn't exactly common, thus making its explanation important. That also has to be done in the fewest lines possible. Notice how that is done in a sentence that flows from talking about my relationship with him, to the turn-point where I started to work on my own future by myself. You can notice my father was never mentioned after that because his appearance in the essay is just to explain those two things, and also to explain the birth of the strong perseverance that happens to be the theme of the essay. There's no blaming nor ill-thoughts about him (or anyone nor my situation) on the essay at all. In fact, from the essay it can be seen that I use all of this negativity thrown at me as fuel to drive me forward. Using negative things in a positive way is also something done in that essay (the teacher part, for instance).
I thank you for your criticism, and I've made some changes in the essay to make some points more clear/straightforward, but it's important when criticizing to not jump on pre-conceived notions and try to ask yourself why the person writing wrote what he did and try to build on that. If you're not sure about the point being made, then ask. You can help him build over that point by either changing words, or rewording so the meaning can flow better and make sure it's coming through to the reader.
It's not an easy essay to work on from the internet, which makes me even more thankful that you even attempted to do so. You also helped me make some points more clear in my correction, which I'm also very thankful for. I hope you can use what I wrote in a constructive way so you can help other students in their essays Keep up the good work :).
I have already finished my application but I need to make this clear and give you an advice about constructive criticism
In the essay, when my father is mentioned it establishes two important points. The first, is the one you caught on, it gives a glimpse of the background I was raised in, but the second one is just as important. It explains why I spent time in a library as much as I did.
A teenager spending almost every day of his life in a library isn't exactly common, thus making its explanation important. That also has to be done in the fewest lines possible. Notice how that is done in a sentence that flows from talking about my relationship with him, to the turn-point where I started to work on my own future by myself. You can notice my father was never mentioned after that because his appearance in the essay is just to explain those two things, and also to explain the birth of the strong perseverance that happens to be the theme of the essay. There's no blaming nor ill-thoughts about him (or anyone nor my situation) on the essay at all. In fact, from the essay it can be seen that I use all of this negativity thrown at me as fuel to drive me forward. Using negative things in a positive way is also something done in that essay (the teacher part, for instance).
I thank you for your criticism, and I've made some changes in the essay to make some points more clear/straightforward, but it's important when criticizing to not jump on pre-conceived notions and try to ask yourself why the person writing wrote what he did and try to build on that. If you're not sure about the point being made, then ask. You can help him build over that point by either changing words, or rewording so the meaning can flow better and make sure it's coming through to the reader.
It's not an easy essay to work on from the internet, which makes me even more thankful that you even attempted to do so. You also helped me make some points more clear in my correction, which I'm also very thankful for. I hope you can use what I wrote in a constructive way so you can help other students in their essays Keep up the good work :).