Unanswered [2]
  

Home / Book Reports   % width   Posts: 3


A Thousand Splendid Sun literary Analysis



crash_report 1 / 2  
Sep 27, 2009   #1
Plese review my paper before I hand it in tomorrow. I didn't want to trust my judgment after three cups of coffee and less than average hours of sleep

Intructions: To formulate a well-written thesis on a novel and support the idea with three supporting topic sentences.

Amidst the escalating conflicts of the Middle East, the fates of two Afghani women intertwine as they are forced into a loveless marriage and must endure the hardships with only hope to live for in a hopeless society. In Khaled Hosseini's A Thousand Splendid Suns, the tragic theme of oppressed hope is explored as the lives of Miriam and Laila pan out from childhood to death. Through the many obstacles that are thrown at these women, the hopes that they hold onto are constantly shattered. Hope for acceptance, love, and a better life are among many things that the women of Afghanistan hope in the backdrop of war and danger.

The main character, Miriam, has been through much more than children her age and one of those experiences is the anticipation for acceptance. At a young age, Miriam is recognized as an illegitimate child of Nana and Jalil. Her mother referrers to her as a harami, and Jalil's wives look upon her with cold stares of disdain. Jalil, with his idealistic world, was the only person that Miriam feels loved her and could accept her. Therefore, when she asks Jalil to bring her to the cinema and watch Pinoccichio, and to develop relationship outside the kolboa, Jalil reluctantly accepts. Alas, he doesn't take her to the cinema in fear of his wives and the social structures that frown upon it. Ultimately, Miriam's hopes to be accepted by her father are dashed, forcing her to realize the truth of the situation. Not only did her father not accept her, but Miriam felt that her husband, Rasheed, had not truly accepted her as his wife later on in the novel. After the 'honeymoon stage' of Miriam and Rasheed's marriage, Miriam has a miscarriage during pregnancy. Thus, Miriam feels that the earlier hope for acceptance is being crushed once again.

Despite the marriage arrangements of Afghani culture, many women aniticpate for a nuptial filled with love. Nana is like many women, and hope that Jalil convinces his wives to marry her and support Miriam. Nonetheless, Nana did not receive the marriage she wanted with Jalil. Nana was not the only one to suffer through the hardship of a shattered hope of love, but Laila also experiences it. Before leaving Kabul for Pakistan, Tariq, yells to Laila that he will come back for her, filling her with hope of a marriage of love. However, she is forced to sacrifice that hope when she marries Rasheed, the husband of Mariam, in order to sustain a proper upbringing for her child that she had with Tariq. However, her hope is completely shattered when an unknown man comes to the house and to tell Laila that Tariq has been killed by a bomb, leaving Laila distraught and hopeless.

The hope for a better life is always regarded throughout the novel. Earlier in the novel, Hakim, Laila's father, urges the family to leave the terrible and dangerous streets of Afghanistan. The hope to leave and start a new life is crushed by the bomb that kills Laila's mother and father, leaving her alone. In another instance, after the two women form a kinship, Laila tells Miriam of her plan to escape into Pakistan. In which, they go to the bus station and pay a man to play the role of the women's cousin. However, the man betrays the women and tells the guards of the women's escape. In turn, the women and children are cart to the police station where they are to be questioned. Ironically, the women try to escape a life of hardship only to return to that very same life with more abuse and contempt.

The book, A Thousand Splendid Suns, is riddled with oppressed hope of the women and children to the people of Afghanistan and the unstable politics that is occurring at that time. This tragic novel is a great depiction of expectations and rejections.

Notoman 20 / 414  
Sep 28, 2009   #2
Very well written! I liked this book. It was one of the better assigned-reading books I have had. There are a few things that could be smoothed a tad. Here are some thoughts:

they are forced into a loveless marriage

Yes, the women are married to the same man. At the same time even. Coming from a western mindset, the women being forced into a loveless marriage makes it sound like they are marrying each other. I think you need to clarify here. You could say that they are forced into a loveless polygamous marriage, they are forced into loveless marriages, or some other construction that doesn't make it sound like they are in a same-sex union.

In Khaled Hosseini's A Thousand Splendid Suns, the tragic theme of oppressed hope is explored as the lives of Miriam and Laila pan out from childhood to death. Through the many obstacles that are thrown at these women, the hopes that they hold onto are constantly shattered.

This construction isn't wrong, but I thought I would point it out because it is my English teacher's biggest pet peeve. He can't stand it when students use a "to be" verb and then a past participle (and "ed" verb). Hopefully, you have an English teacher that is a little more reasonable. Hosseini explores the tragic theme ... The many obstacles thrown at these women shatters the hopes ...

Hope for acceptance, love, and a better life are among many things that the women of Afghanistan hope in the backdrop of war and danger.

Because this isn't an essay on the women of Afghanistan, but the lives of the Afghan women in the novel, I'd change the wording to reflect what the reader can expect in the paragraphs to come. I feel like there is a preposition missing. "Hope in" and "in the backdrop of war" blends together and I don't know where to mentally put the "in" when I am reading it.

Ack! I just looked at the time. I have got to get my own homework done and get to bed. Here are a couple more quick thoughts though:

Miriam has a miscarriage during pregnancy

Miscarriage and pregnancy are redundant because you can't have a miscarriage if you are not pregnant (unless it is a miscarriage of justice, but I digress). Punch up those verbs a bit by rewriting it something like this: Miriam suffers a miscarriage.

Nana is like many women, and hope that Jalil convinces his wives to marry her and support Miriam.

Again, it sounds like the wives will be the ones marrying Nana. "Hope" belongs with Nana--Nana hopes.

The book, A Thousand Splendid Suns, is riddled with oppressed hope of the women and children to the people of Afghanistan and the unstable politics that is occurring at that time.

Because you haven't developed the oppression of the children or the other people in the body of the essay, I wouldn't bring it up in the conclusion. "The unstable politics that is occurring at that time" is awkward. I'd simplify it to "the unstable politics of the time."
OP crash_report 1 / 2  
Sep 28, 2009   #3
Thank you for the in sight. It is greatly appreciated. I have missed the many mistakes that you have pointed out and that could be a grade-saver.

Fingers crossed for a good grade.


Home / Book Reports / A Thousand Splendid Sun literary Analysis
ⓘ Need Writing or Editing Help?
Fill out one of these forms for professional help:

Best Writing Service:
CustomPapers form ◳

Graduate Writing / Editing:
GraduateWriter form ◳

Excellence in Editing:
Rose Editing ◳

AI-Paper Rewriting:
Robot Rewrite ◳