Unanswered [1] | Urgent [0]
  

Posts by cybertron
Joined: Sep 20, 2009
Last Post: Dec 26, 2009
Threads: 2
Posts: 18  
From: USA

Displayed posts: 20
sort: Oldest first   Latest first  | 
cybertron   
Sep 20, 2009
Undergraduate / "My first time" - Common App Essay (significant experience) [7]

I like this piece. You show how something unique to you, gymnastics, has had a specific impact on you as a person.

But I do think that you could improve on the impact part of this prompt. You spend about 3 paragraphs talking about gymnastics in general-- make this more concise. Instead of spending about 2 paragraphs on the impact, take more time and really delve into it. Give more details on how gymnastics has helped create you, as a person.

Good job, though! This is a great start.
cybertron   
Sep 20, 2009
Undergraduate / "Living within natural and cultural limits" - Stanford- Intellectual Vitality Essay [21]

Hi guys,
I just recently discovered this forum and I'm so glad that there's something out there like this to help with editing.

This is the intellectual vitality essay for Stanford:

Stanford students are widely known to possess a sense of intellectual vitality. Tell us about an idea or experience you have that you find intellectually engaging.

In today's modern world, where news is instantaneous, communication is possible with the press of a button, and technology allows us to go where no one has gone before-boundaries take on a whole new realm. Where do human limitations end?

In our thirst for independence, we have tried to define freedom as escape from all limits-but just like complete freedom is a mere aspiration, limitlessness is the human fantasy.

This fantasy perhaps rose from the Industrial Revolution era, when resources were exploited, and now, we are slowly facing the exhaustion of the "limitlessness" of resources. With this mindset, society is slowly becoming embarrassed of anything which doesn't flaunt progress, technology-limitlessness. A simple game of tennis doesn't satisfy our need for exercise anymore; we require sensor technology and a virtual court.

The humanities have been preaching the concept of limits. Greek mythology has been teaching us for ages that with the rise of Oedipus, there is a fall of Icarus. Mary Shelley's Frankenstein, a warning against the modern man during the Industrial Revolution, underscores the Promethean myth in which the quest to surpass limits, only leads to self destruction.

What intrigues me about human culture is that we are so focused on succeeding, that we forget about the intangible limits which stop us. As paradoxical as it may be, I believe we are inherently a romantic society, governed by no precincts, yet we lead rational lives. We attempt to live limitlessly, we attempt to achieve limitlessly, and we attempt to sustain limitlessly, but are we really oblivious to the limits we face, or are we just acting ignorant?

The constraint upon us is not the condemnation it may seem. As humans, or earthly creatures, we are innately capable of living not only within natural limits but also within cultural limits. We are only recently realizing the impending threat of limits in the form of global warming and downward economic trends.

There is in no way that we can bring back the trees we've cut down, or sew up the hole in the ozone layer. What we can do, is realize our limits (1800 characters), and do the best we can with them.

-----
Although my essay talks about my interest in sociology and modern human culture, my future goal is actually to attend med school. Would it be smarter to write an essay which links to my future goals, even though I also have a great interest for the humanities?

----

PLEASE EDIT THIS. RIP THE ESSAY APART. I feel that it is a tad ambiguous at times, and I'm not sure if I'm properly answering the prompt.

Any comments are greatly appreciated!

Thank you so much!
cybertron   
Sep 20, 2009
Undergraduate / "Living within natural and cultural limits" - Stanford- Intellectual Vitality Essay [21]

Thanks! I will work on combining the paragraphs (I was actually thinking about that while writing this essay so I'm glad you pointed it out).

Is there anything else that needs to be worked on? Does the essay convey an "intellectually engaging" idea that I have?

(I'm sort of confused about the prompt so I did the best I could to respond to it)
cybertron   
Sep 20, 2009
Undergraduate / "Bump in the road" - unexpected, tragic [14]

Wow. This experience must have been traumatizing.

I think that this is a good start, but you can definitely expand on how you felt. The most probable reason that the prompt questions a "bump in the road" is because the admin officers want to know how you deal with setbacks. You can do a much better job explaining that.

But so far, so good.
cybertron   
Sep 20, 2009
Undergraduate / Pole-vaulting - my UF undergrad application essay [5]

This is a good essay. You answer the prompt well, but I do think that you can write a bit more about how this experience will help you contribute to the UF community. You spend about 1-2 sentences doing that. Maybe expand that to a paragraph.

Overall, good essay. I really like it.
cybertron   
Sep 20, 2009
Undergraduate / "Living within natural and cultural limits" - Stanford- Intellectual Vitality Essay [21]

I've made very minor changes; mainly regarding the paragraph size and grammar.
PLEASE EDIT. THANK YOU!

-- Revised --

In today's modern world, where news is instantaneous, communication is possible with the press of a button, and technology allows us to go where no one has gone before-boundaries take on a whole new realm. Where do human limitations end? In our thirst for independence, we have tried to define freedom as escape from all limits-but just like complete freedom is a mere aspiration, limitlessness is the human fantasy.

...
cybertron   
Sep 20, 2009
Undergraduate / My SCARS and my MISTAKES; Common App [34]

It's a good essay but kind of grotesque for me and maybe the admin officers. It's unique how you compare you're high school journey (or life journey?) to scars, but scars have a somewhat negative connotation. Focus on making this essay more positive. Show have scars have changed you for the better.

The essay is also somewhat abstract. I know this is the topic of your choice, but you should narrow it down a little more.

Overall, good start. Make your essay more positive, so you come across as a more positive person. And cut down on the graphic-ness of the scars, even though they serve as good descriptions.
cybertron   
Sep 20, 2009
Undergraduate / My SCARS and my MISTAKES; Common App [34]

Hmmm. Not necessarily. Maybe you can explicitly state your medical condition and talk about how you turned your medical condition (weakness) into something positive (a strength). It could still be a very strong essay.

On the other hand, if you really don't feel satisfied, there's no harm in writing another one.

Good luck!
cybertron   
Sep 21, 2009
Undergraduate / "Living within natural and cultural limits" - Stanford- Intellectual Vitality Essay [21]

1. Haha. Yes, I thought that too while writing it but I didn't think it would be that conspicuous. I will change that.

2. Yeah. Does this sound better:
This fantasy perhaps rose from the Industrial Revolution era, when resources were exploited and now, we are slowly facing the exhaustion, rather, limitations of these resources.

3. should I delete the word "in"?

4. Hmmm. I don't think I deleted the sentence in the re edited version. I'll try to incorporate the idea more into the essay, but then again-- 1800 character limit.

5. Thank you. I really appreciate your feedback. :D
cybertron   
Sep 21, 2009
Undergraduate / "Living within natural and cultural limits" - Stanford- Intellectual Vitality Essay [21]

Sorry, I misread your #2.

2...society is slowly becoming embarrassed of anything which doesn't flaunt progress, technology- or limitlessness.
--is the dash really necessary?

Hmmm. I'm not quite sure. The intent of that was to indicate a pause, because the key theme/word here is limitlessness. Maybe having the -- after "or" will have more of an effect, or perhaps I should just delete the -- altogether.

Let me know what you think.
cybertron   
Sep 21, 2009
Undergraduate / "Living within natural and cultural limits" - Stanford- Intellectual Vitality Essay [21]

Thank you for your comments.

Whoa, Nelly. This is a pretty long opening sentence.

I understand what you mean, but that's why I used the -- to show that the sentence is coming to a halt, and that the punch line, if you will, is "boundaries take on a whole new realm".

What if I changed the "where" to "in which"; then would I be able to keep the list, and still have that effect, or would it be too cluttered?
cybertron   
Sep 22, 2009
Undergraduate / "Living within natural and cultural limits" - Stanford- Intellectual Vitality Essay [21]

What intrigues me about human culture is that we are so focused on succeeding, that we forget about the intangible limits which stop us. As paradoxical as it may be, I believe we are inherently a romantic society, governed by no precincts, yet we lead rational lives. We attempt to live limitlessly, we attempt to achieve limitlessly, and we attempt to sustain limitlessly, but are we really oblivious to the limits we face, or are we just feigning ignorance?

This paragraph kind of touches upon what I find engaging. Should I expand on it more? I just... don't know what else to cut out, since mine is practically 1800 characters already.

Overall, I want the adcoms to know that I'm interested socio-dynamics and how modern culture thinks and functions. I have my own little theories, and this is just something I found insightful.

Does the prompt want me to specifically state what I find engaging, and why? Everything that I wrote about in this essay engages me...the overall concept.

Does anyone else have comments on this prompt, and how to approach it in general?

Thank you so much! I'll work on getting another draft up as soon as I can.
cybertron   
Sep 23, 2009
Undergraduate / "The Luger" - Stanford Common Application essay! [10]

This is a good essay but I have a couple concerns.

1. You spend a lot of time describing the gun, and your experience with the gun, but I don't seem to learn a lot about you as a person through this essay. You do spend a paragraph talking about how you want to become a weapon designer, but I think you should delve into that a little more. What does your love for the Luger/design of it reveal about you? I think if you can nail that, you'd have a pretty solid essay.

2. Although this is a unique and interesting essay, I'm not too sure how colleges would react, knowing that you enjoy designing guns/weapons.

Once again, you should focus more on YOU rather than the gun.

Overall, good essay. You have a couple grammar essays (tenses), but otherwise I like the topic and the unique approach.
cybertron   
Dec 25, 2009
Undergraduate / biology, physics, and engineering, JHU- why this major, why JHU essay [5]

Johns Hopkins offers 50 majors across the schools of Arts and Sciences and Engineering. On this supplement, we ask you to identify one or two that you might like to pursue here. Why did you choose the way you did? If you are undecided, why didn't you choose? (If any past courses or academic experiences influenced your decision, you may include them in your essay.)

---------------------------------------------------------------------- ---------

I was a naive researcher, unaware of the intricacies involved in molecular biology, underestimating the smartness of the bacteria, the DNA, the methods-I thought I could outrun it with the research and studying I'd done. I carefully micropipetted the solution into the vial, hoping that everything would go smoothly. With that in mind, I began the (bacterial) transformation.

It had been over an hour, and waiting was quite an excruciating activity (such is the life of a researcher). The three week effort had boiled down to this moment in time-please Mr. PCR machine, don't fail me. It bothered me that I had to depend on this machine to produce the climactic outcome of the experiment, but I remained optimistic in hopes that the results would be to my liking. The process was finally complete. My fingers were trembling and my mind was bartering with itself about what to do if the procedure failed, but I walked over nervously to the PCR machine. After confirming my results with the brilliant (hues of) gel electrophoresis, I knew the transformation was successful. I was elated and terrified at the same time. This small step invited in new possibilities, greater knowledge, more risks-all contributing to a greater transformation, my transformation.

Fast forward two years. I am still in the lab, this time with the tobacco mosaic virus, carefully engineering a plant's immune system to make it stronger. I'm no longer the inexperienced researcher was. I went from scratching my head at each abstract idea to delving in the language of research, recounting my results to my biology teacher, my friends, or my parents. The lab is my niche and without even thinking twice, my world is now measured with conversions, micropipette tips, agarose gel, and bacterial colonies. I welcome it with open arms, embracing the challenge to assimilate into this newfound world, where even mistakes contribute to a greater finding.

The prospect of bioengineering, being able to manipulate these microbiological beings, fascinates me. I hope to catalyze my growth as a researcher, a scientist, and a person at Johns Hopkins University under the department of Biomedical Engineering. Although my ultimate goal is to become a physician, I think it's essential that I have the engineering expertise to analyze and solve problems in biology and medicine, providing an overall enhancement of health care. I've chosen this path to medicine because I want to be of service to people and to partake in the excitement of working with living systems. In high school, I attempted to expand my horizons by completing a research project each year from the realms of plant biology to the environmental sciences. Nothing amazes me more than our human capability to find cures and alleviate pain through the art of bioengineering.

Johns Hopkins' interdisciplinary approach to education is what makes us so compatible. I want to engage with the world on an educational level and experience learning beyond the classroom setting. The broad undergraduate research opportunities at Johns Hopkins also appeal to my love for research. I hope that some day I will be able to contribute to research at this top university to be a part of the integration of biology, physics, and engineering in order to revolutionize the biosciences. Johns Hopkins is a forum of intellectual spirit, allowing for self discovery. I want to exercise my imagination, engage myself at the frontiers of knowledge and go beyond norms-- something which only Johns Hopkins can fulfill. Contributing to this institute of education would be an honor, and representing it would be a privilege.

---------------------------------------------------------------------- -------

Please shred this essay. I appreciate all the help I can get. Thank you to all those who took the time to read this and/or comment.
cybertron   
Dec 26, 2009
Undergraduate / biology, physics, and engineering, JHU- why this major, why JHU essay [5]

Thank you for the feedback. I've made the changes you noted. I felt like I did have a story of some sort in the essay, explaining my transformation as a researcher through my experiences in a lab. Did that not come across correctly?

What else can I do to improve the overall message? Also, does the essay answer the prompt sufficiently?
cybertron   
Dec 26, 2009
Undergraduate / biology, physics, and engineering, JHU- why this major, why JHU essay [5]

Thank you for your advice iRunShow. I know what you mean when you say that I should make the "past tense" more explicit in the beginning paragraphs. I tried to do that, but it sounded awkward. I use past tense in the first two paragraphs as opposed to the third one. In addition, I say "fast forward two years..."

Is that good enough to let the reader know that the first half was in the past?
Need Writing or Editing Help?
Fill out one of these forms:

Graduate Writing / Editing:
GraduateWriter form ◳

Best Essay Service:
CustomPapers form ◳

Excellence in Editing:
Rose Editing ◳

AI-Paper Rewriting:
Robot Rewrite ◳

Academic AI Writer:
Custom AI Writer ◳