reapernanashi
Feb 1, 2017
Writing Feedback / PTE: Over a billion adults legally smoke tobacco. The long term health costs are high - for smokers [8]
Hi. I'm not sure about your word limit, but if you don't have one, I think you could develop your essay a bit more.
At the moment, you just have paragraphs detailing how the government can legislate. However, the question asks whether the government has a role in legislating, which really asks two questions: can the government legislate & should the government legislate? I think your argument would be a bit more nuanced if you tackled both perspectives.
Discuss the role of the government with regards to the health of its constituents. Talk about the idea of public vs. private space, and what rights citizens are entitled to in each area. Talk about how smoking/tobacco use is currently framed; is it a choice or an addiction? Wether its the former or the latter, what is the responsibility of the government in addressing the issue? For example, if its a choice, who makes the choice and who is affected by it? the smoker chooses to smoke, but the people he comes in contact with face the repercussions of his smoking through second/third hand smoke, even though they didn't sign up for it. How can the government deal with that conception of choice, that extends beyond the smoker? etc, etc.
Hi. I'm not sure about your word limit, but if you don't have one, I think you could develop your essay a bit more.
At the moment, you just have paragraphs detailing how the government can legislate. However, the question asks whether the government has a role in legislating, which really asks two questions: can the government legislate & should the government legislate? I think your argument would be a bit more nuanced if you tackled both perspectives.
Discuss the role of the government with regards to the health of its constituents. Talk about the idea of public vs. private space, and what rights citizens are entitled to in each area. Talk about how smoking/tobacco use is currently framed; is it a choice or an addiction? Wether its the former or the latter, what is the responsibility of the government in addressing the issue? For example, if its a choice, who makes the choice and who is affected by it? the smoker chooses to smoke, but the people he comes in contact with face the repercussions of his smoking through second/third hand smoke, even though they didn't sign up for it. How can the government deal with that conception of choice, that extends beyond the smoker? etc, etc.