amyfu215
Nov 28, 2010
Undergraduate / "My Morning Jacket and my voice" (Essays for USC) [6]
Thanks for editing my essay! I wasn't sure how nit-picky to be in my critique, but i hope this helps! :)
"poetry and literature are"
Instead of they, use "it overwhelms"
Maybe for the first essay, get into your personal experience earlier on. The first part is a tad common, but you do a good job of transitioning on into the second, more specific paragraph.
The whole first essay is very cohesive and thorough. It is slightly typical as you said, but a solid essay overall.
For your second essay, I am looking at the new corrections you made.
Maybe include a bit of an explanation of "I'm Amazed"? There's not quite a connection between the first line where you mention the song you performed, and later when you talk about the artist. The judges might not be familiar with the song. Or it could just be me.
Maybe make this flow a bit more, these two sentences sound a bit choppy. Change the beginnings?
Good use of solid evidence and details about the artist. I really liked your transition of ideas, and I think that your edits made your essay better and more positive sounding. I agree, I think you should use your second essay.
Thanks for editing my essay! I wasn't sure how nit-picky to be in my critique, but i hope this helps! :)
poetry and literature is.
"poetry and literature are"
Most poetry is well-crafted; they overwhelm the reader with imagery,
Instead of they, use "it overwhelms"
Maybe for the first essay, get into your personal experience earlier on. The first part is a tad common, but you do a good job of transitioning on into the second, more specific paragraph.
The whole first essay is very cohesive and thorough. It is slightly typical as you said, but a solid essay overall.
For your second essay, I am looking at the new corrections you made.
which is why I decided to perform "I'm Amazed"
Maybe include a bit of an explanation of "I'm Amazed"? There's not quite a connection between the first line where you mention the song you performed, and later when you talk about the artist. The judges might not be familiar with the song. Or it could just be me.
The advent of technology and AutoTune software has removed authenticity in music. The music industry is transforming into an industry of vanity, where more effort is poured into promoting the artist's image and securing a place on the Billboard Top 100 than into writing and composing the music.
Maybe make this flow a bit more, these two sentences sound a bit choppy. Change the beginnings?
Good use of solid evidence and details about the artist. I really liked your transition of ideas, and I think that your edits made your essay better and more positive sounding. I agree, I think you should use your second essay.