Unanswered [2] | Urgent [0]
  

Home / Undergraduate   % width   Posts: 9


Common App Essay Topic #1: A "Walker" to Remember



dayae21 2 / 9  
Dec 6, 2009   #1
PLEASE HELP! XD
I've just completed a rough rought draftfor Common App Essay topic #1, which is...
Evaluate a significant experience, achievement, risk you have taken, or ethical dilemma you have faced and its impact on you.

I'd very much appreciate a hard, critical look at my essay and any constructive advice on how I could make my essay better, make it more concise, or even whether my essay fits this topic!

Thank you so much for your time!!!

The day I joined my school newspaper staff, an editor handed me my first story assignment and coolly told me to prepare to interview a widow of our Sunny Hills High School's former cross country coach. One year had passed since her husband was killed in a car accident, but a story idea had just come up when it was discovered that the mysterious $4,000 check that had appeared in the cross country team's mail a few months ago had been donated by this very lady I was to talk to, Ms. Pat Walker. While I did have some curiosity to find out more about the story, I was seized with dread as I dialed her phone number, knowing that her husband's death had something to do with the donation. What if she bursts into tears talking about her husband? The worry plagued my mind going into the interview.

Although Ms. Walker never did cry in the end, in retrospect I feel that the interview was all the more memorable because she did not cry. Ms. Walker told me of many things during our phone interview. She told me about her "unusual request" to the judge to allow the defendant's court fee to be donated to our cross country team in her husband's honor-which is where the $4,000 came from. But above all, she told me of her husband's great passion for running. "My husband, he was a runner all his life. In his entire life, he ran marathons and long distance, and was very, very devoted." She proudly recounted how her husband, Mr. Wayne Walker, coached the Sunny Hills cross country team for 10 years, guiding the team to three league titles. Though he retired as a coach in 1999, he still returned every year to help with the school's cross country invitational events. "Through lifelong donations to Sunny Hills cross country, I hope to keep alive Coach Wayne Walker's memory," she said. "He inspired and motivated all runners with his passion for running and his belief that all runners needed to test the limits of their endurance and to believe they could always cross that finish line." Her words carried so much conviction in her husband's beliefs, and I felt that at least in spirit, Mr. Walker was still alive with her.

Thoughts and emotions I developed from the one-week interview may be rather subtle, but I'm certain I would not have gained its manifold lessons anywhere else. Emerging out of a naïve sense of pity for the widow, I came to experience a new spectrum of feeling of respect and admiration for her endurance through a very tragic event. While confronting the cold wall of fate with a certain level of acceptance, Ms. Walker went on to apply a greater determination to make a difference in the lives around her through an act of giving, which I see as an ultimate triumph of human spirit over life's unexpected challenges. While Ms. Walker's willpower touched me for sure, however, the person that captivated my heart the most was Mr. Walker himself, whose passion absolutely transcended death and stunned me with its "ripple effects". That his wife has made it her life-long work to donate time and money to runners in his remembrance, that the school has renamed two invitationals in tribute to his career, and that a group of young runners continue to be inspired to follow his same passion through the wife's life-long support... All these people that have been moved by one man's eternal dedication meant to me the most meaningful culmination of pouring one's soul into one passion in life.

"Enthusiasm moves the world," James Balfour once wrote. Certainly Mr. Walker's enthusiasm moved several worlds around him, including my own. Only now, I envision when that time should come in my own life. With what passion and what burning zeal would I someday impact the lives around me? What defining fervor will the world remember me for after I have left this earth? What will I care about and love so much so that, at least in that field of study, work, or interest, I will strive for the best and will be happy to devote my entire life serving the world? I take it as my noble duty and my life-long goal to seek answers to these questions.

yahyakhan 1 / 4  
Dec 6, 2009   #2
you have written a pretty good essay with a unique personal example and plenty of details to back it up but i think a few things should be altered.

first of all i think its a little too long, you might consider editing it. also it gets a little tedious in the middle; by the second paragraph the reader realizes what the essay is about and might lose interest. i think you should shorten it, delete an irrelevant paragraph if possible, keep a little suspense and tie it all in the last para/conclusion.

otherwise its a great essay
OP dayae21 2 / 9  
Dec 6, 2009   #3
Thank you for your comments! :)
Yeah, I totally agree with you that my essay kinda "drags" in the first few paragraphs...
I'm working on tightening them up.
Do you think I should get rid of my first paragraph about my childhood hobby and get right to the point about meeting Mrs. Walker?
OP dayae21 2 / 9  
Dec 6, 2009   #4
Can anyone give me more suggestions on how to improve my essay?
Logical_Fella_C - / 31  
Dec 7, 2009   #5
Avoiding redundancies will help you tighten up your essay.

For instance,

--which involved exploring a part of someone else's life and straining to share the story with others through my article--

this part should be taken out. Since you wrote about this in the previous paragraph quite extensively, I don't think you need an extra explanation for your "fateful encounter with Mrs. Walker."

self-discovering

self-driven

self-giving

I don't know if it's just me... but anyway, I found it repetitive that you used three adjectives that start with "self-" in one paragraph.

The one week I spent interviewing her and writing the article were personally the most self-discovering and eye-opening experiences.

Here, you can remove "personally."

I think what yahyakhan meant by

delete an irrelevant paragraph if possible

is that a lot of the things you talk about in the third and the fourth paragraph overlap.

Stylistically speaking, you rely too heavily on adjectives and adverbs when you describe people or events. Good use of action verbs will not only reduce the "dragging" problem, but also strengthen the impact of the messages you are trying to deliver.

Oh, and your conclusion could be improved by talking about what specific activities you would like to engage in instead making a rather generic remark like this:

So no longer indulging in the selfish hoarding of items, skills, and achievements for myself, I hope to more open up my heart and ability in contributing to enrich, help, and serve the lives around me.

Overall, I do think that you write quite well and that you chose a great topic to write about.
Good luck!
yahyakhan 1 / 4  
Dec 7, 2009   #6
deleting stuff that a person writes oneself is extremely hard and dont take my advice badly but i feel that the first two paragraphs are mostly irrelevant; it would be much better if you started with some sort of interesting hook for the reader and then carried on with the rest of the essay. your idea is unique, you write well so everythings in your favor; just make some improvements
dbsqudtlr 4 / 22  
Dec 7, 2009   #7
I love how you start the essay. by the way, I have a similar experience of having collected those things as a child :)
But I feel like you should definitely try your best to shorten your essay to around 600 words...
Maybe it would be a good idea to just stick to the point better and be more straightforward.
Try to take out the details that you think is not so necessary as the others.

I know it's really hard, but you don't want the admissions people just skipping a part of your essay just because it's too long!
OP dayae21 2 / 9  
Dec 8, 2009   #8
Logical_Fella_C: Thank you so much for your detailed advice XD. After reading your comments, I can see what a big difference it will make to replace the adjectives/adverbs with strong, concise verbs and more expresssive nouns. Also, I'll keep in mind to be specific about how I hope to contribute to the people around me. I greatly appreciate your help!

yahyakhan & dbsqudtlr: Thank you for your compliments & encouragement, and thanks for reminding me that admissions committees do look for concise & straight-to-the-point writing. I'll definitely try my best to shorten my essay in the next few days.

(by the way, dbsqudtlr, are you Korean? X) 'cause I am and I used to collect those things when I was living in Korea until 6th grade.. haha)

Anyways, THANK YOU SO MUCH everyone!!!
OP dayae21 2 / 9  
Dec 26, 2009   #9
This is my new draft! Please take a look at it and I would greatly appreciate any constructive advice/suggestions! Also, please let me know what words/phrases I could remove to tighten up the essay. THANK YOU!


Home / Undergraduate / Common App Essay Topic #1: A "Walker" to Remember
Need Writing or Editing Help?
Fill out one of these forms:

Graduate Writing / Editing:
GraduateWriter form ◳

Best Essay Service:
CustomPapers form ◳

Excellence in Editing:
Rose Editing ◳

AI-Paper Rewriting:
Robot Rewrite ◳

Academic AI Writer:
Custom AI Writer ◳