Unanswered [2]
  

Home / Undergraduate   % width   Posts: 11


'Indian students / China-Singapore' UMichigan, diversity and how you can contribute



Baiwanyu 5 / 12  
Dec 31, 2008   #1
Share an experience through which you have gained respect for intellectual, social, or cultural differences. Comment on how your personal experience and achievements would contribute to the diversity of the University of Michigan.

I have 2 essays, please tell me which is better. Thank you.

1
Although many Indian students lived around us, we seldom interacted with each other. Their eccentric family traditions seemed alien to Chinese.
To our surprise, on Racial Harmony Day in Sigapore, the ten Indian girls in our class all dressed in Cheongsams, Chinese traditional costumes. They came to greet us and expressed their admirations to Chinese culture.

They passed us sarongs(Indian costumes) and said " You may try ours, perhaps you will turn to like Indian cultures too."
Their deed warmed our hearts tremendouly. Looked at us in the mirror: sarongs, huge gold Jewelries and the red dot on each forehead ï we were just like Indians except for our lighter complexions. Suddenly I realised that the world could be so colourful with so many different costumes and it could be so happy to embrace others' culture. The icy division between our two groups was broken.

Coming from China, I had a hard time fitting in initially. However, the more I explored about Singapore's multicultural society, the more I valued diversity. In Michigan, there will be students with different roots and different thoughts, and I would like to spearhead programs to promote interaction between us. By sharing my experiences in Singapore and my upbringing in China, I will show them that the lack of communication and consideration is the main reason for stereotypes and misunderstandings among different groups. Then I will encourage students to join other cultures' society to promote the exchange of ideas and histories. Students' perceptions and relationships will change, as a result of a new understanding of each other

~~For essay 1,the last para,do you think I digress from the real question?
The question is not really asking how you would promote diversity, but how you would contribute to it. It's asking: what makes you different. I am really worried about this. Thank you!~~

2
At the age of 15, I left my hometown in China to study in Singapore. I was naturally drawn to and made friends with other Chinese students at the school because we shared the same language and culture.

One day, we were sitting in a canteen eating a pork dish when a group of Malay students stood up and began verbally attacking us; they were offended by us eating pork. We were shocked, and retaliated by arguing with them. It was an argument we could not seem to resolve, so we took our case to the school office. There, our mentor explained to us that the Malay students were Muslims, and that eating pork was forbidden in their faith. It seemed bizarre to us, as we had no understanding of Islam. But once we had heard the history behind it, we began to understand and respect their commitment to their faith. The quarrel actually led to a lasting friendship between our two groups, and we continued to learn about each other's cultures throughout our time in Singapore.

What can I contribute to diversity? I am Chinese. I grew up in an environment that is very different from most of the world. I am keen to hold onto my own culture, but equally excited to embrace others. We all think differently depending on our roots and life experiences; I look forward to being challenged intellectually, and challenging others in return. Diversity is something to be lauded, and since that experience in Singapore, I have been and will continue to be proactive in promoting diversity in whatever way I can: be it by just making friends, by participating in cultural events, or by challenging ideas.

heartdews - / 3  
Dec 31, 2008   #2
i like the second one better :)
EF_Kevin 8 / 13052  
Jan 1, 2009   #3
I also like the second one better, but that's possibly because the first essay contains many grammatical errors. Both essays are well set up and written, clear and interesting.

Good luck in school!!

:)
OP Baiwanyu 5 / 12  
Jan 1, 2009   #4
Thank you. I am confused about the question "how your personal experience and achievements would contribute to the diversity", I cannot distinguish contribute and promote. Is the question asking me what makes I different? I have a new version of the last para:

As years went by, I slowly neutralized to fit into Singapore's society. I had two different cultures that I called my own: I grew up in China which is very different from most of the world. While in Singapore, I learnt the uniqueness of Malay and Indian customs and traditions which an ordinary kid in China will never have. I am keen to hold onto my own culture, but equally excited to embrace others. We all think differently depending on our roots and life experiences; I look forward to being challenged intellectually, and challenging others in return. In college, I will continue to be proactive in promoting diversity in whatever way I can: be it by just making friends, by participating in cultural events, or by exchanging different perspectives.

Please see whether this is better. Or do you think I answer the quesion? Thank you
dev_niraj - / 1  
Jan 18, 2009   #5
nice but a little loose here and there. btw baiwanyu i think you mean saree and not sarong. A saree is the dress which is draped around and is the traditional dress of india while a sarong is worn around a bikini which is definitely not India's cultural dress. Just thought it would help you. I am from India myself and know about them.
onindo 5 / 20  
Jan 19, 2009   #6
I dunno... i liked the first one better. It seems more real.

The second one- although it does not speak condescendingly of muslims, it does give a bad impression about them. I am a muslim myself and I have never apprehended anyone for eating pork in front of me hehe.

But hey I'm not saying the second essay is bad. You can do one thing. You can take the conclusion from the second essay and stick it to the first one.

Just my opinion :)
OP Baiwanyu 5 / 12  
Jan 19, 2009   #7
Thank you everyone!
Hi, onindo, I am sorry if my essay offends you. But it is real, I just exaggerate it a bit so that the impact may be more significant. It sounds unreal, is it? You mean Muslims will never request us to stop eating pork? This incident happened when we came to Singapore at 15 years old. Both groups were young and we could not speak English. Hence we could not communicate well. Do you think if I add this information inside my essay you may feel better? Or you simply feel that my story was unreal? Thank you, I really value your true opinion:)
onindo 5 / 20  
Jan 19, 2009   #8
Baiwanyu

haha your essay never offended me. I know my kind and I know that they tend to go overboard with their beliefs sometimes. What I meant to say about your essay is that the exaggeration seemed obvious. The language in the first essay was way more mellifluous, not taking into the account the small mistakes that is, and that is why I preferred it.

p.s- I like pork. I am a heathen ;)
peteyflow 1 / 2  
Jan 19, 2009   #9
Yeah I have to agree, first one is a lot better. But, I always wonder if admission really read our essays.
kids_jessy 8 / 34  
Jan 19, 2009   #10
peteyflow: Essays are considerably one of the most important components in the university applications, other than our courses and grades. In fact, sometimes admission officers don't really take note of those recommendations much since they know that the content will definitely be something nice about the applicant...

As for the essays, I agree with onindo that the first essay seems better and you can combine the last paragraph of your second essay as your conclusion :)

All the best..
thatshot550 2 / 3  
Jan 29, 2009   #11
i know what you mean with the confusion on the question. i had the same problem when i wrote my shortanswer for this question too.

but anyway i think both of your conclusions answer that part of the question.. but the revised conclusion from the second essay is my favorite. it really ties your essay together.


Home / Undergraduate / 'Indian students / China-Singapore' UMichigan, diversity and how you can contribute
ⓘ Need Writing or Editing Help?
Fill out one of these forms for professional help:

Best Writing Service:
CustomPapers form ◳

Graduate Writing / Editing:
GraduateWriter form ◳

Excellence in Editing:
Rose Editing ◳

AI-Paper Rewriting:
Robot Rewrite ◳