Unanswered [2]
  

Home / Writing Feedback   % width   Posts: 5


"Memom, how did you draw this?" Topic of Choice Essay -- opinions and critiques



MichelleHob 1 / -  
Aug 19, 2009   #1
I just threw away an essay and on a whim wrote this -- it is my personality but I am not sure how it will impress as a college admission essay? All opinions are welcomed. Thank you.

"Memom, how did you draw this?" I ask my grandmother in my tiny ten year old voice. She just smiles lovingly towards me and replies, "It's not that good -- just a sketch." But I know she's just being modest as I stare down at my far from perfect flower drawing and her accurate drawing of my face. Each line and curve seems to flow together perfectly, creating a special memory in my head. She calls me by my nickname, "Nina, see that looks just as good, maybe even better, than my drawing!" I take the compliment and grin boldly as I shade in each flower with blues and purples and greens. "You know what," Memom says sweetly, adding the finishing touches to her masterpiece, "We should paint the sunset together one day." I nod and imagine how beautiful it'll look.

After drawing for fun with Memom, taking a few art classes here and there, and being required to take an art class at school, I soon came to realize my interest in art was beginning to fade. During this time, I began to take part in recreation level basketball and cello. Don't get me wrong, playing cello was a lot of fun and each time I played I loved seeing how proud and happy my family was, hearing the relaxing pluck and hum of the strings beneath my worn fingertips. And I loved the adrenaline rush of playing my hardest in a basketball game hearing "Go, Nina!" by my biggest fan, Mom. Soon I realized cello no longer interested me and I was becoming too old to participate in recreation basketball. I should have known the need for a sharp pencil and a crisp white sheet of paper would end up in front of me once again.

Fashion magazines lay sprawled out, covering most of my bedroom floor. I sit baffled at where to begin and then finally make the grab for a Vogue magazine. The artsy and expensive brand name photographs scream at me and take over my head with thoughts: What makes you think you can actually draw this? You'll never be able to draw the shadows and delicateness of her face. I shake my head and diminish the negative voice. Carefully, I rip out a page with a stunning Ralph Lauren model posing with her hands tucked into her orange shorts' pockets. The pointy pencil tip sketches the roundness of her face and the outline of her petite figure. Frustration boils in my brain as I notice how large I drew the head. My eraser fixes the blemishes of my art work. I let the pencil redo my previous mistakes as I try my best to keep my wobbly left hand steady. Hours pass by and I'm still hovered over my work of art. My aggravation subsides, making me feel even more proud of the work I've almost completed. Each stroke of the pencil causes excitement to rise within me, knowing each step will be easier and easier. As soon as I finish sketching the model's gold brown hair, I can breathe again. The overall sketch is finished. I break out my colored pencils and begin shading in. I'm about ready to call it quits and finish it another day but motivation beings to take over and I can't stop. Finally, my hard work is done and I can't help but smile. Sure it doesn't look exactly like the photograph but what do I care? I feel as if I've climbed and conquered a huge mountain. The smile still glued on my face reminds me how passionate I am about drawing and brings me back to when I used to draw with Memom. Maybe we can go paint the sunset soon.

username621 3 / 15  
Aug 19, 2009   #2
I really like how you connect the introduction and the conclusion with the same reference to Memom. Also, the descriptions you give of the Vogue and how you once again feel interested in art is intriguing. I think you should fix the third paragraph- it's a bit unclear and I think you can be more efficient in what you mean.

Good work!
Llamapoop123 7 / 433  
Aug 19, 2009   #3
Your writing is good but your essay leaves me slightly confused.

I think that your essay is trying to tell me that you overcame the high standards you set for yourself in art. Your essay tells me that you are dedicated. It could also tell me that you lose interest in things easily. Do you enjoy drawing? Or do you just enjoy the thrill of accomplishment?

If this essay is meant to show your determination I don't see why you mention basketball and cello in the middle. How did you lose interest in art? How did you start to like art once again? Did you take up art again to challenge yourself with drawing the model? I thought you had lost interest in art. So why would you feel obligated to draw it? Did you take up art again because you lost interest in cello and basketball?
EF_Simone 2 / 1974  
Aug 19, 2009   #4
in my tiny ten year old voice.

This is too self-consciously precious. Also, ten year olds tend to be loud.
EF_Sean 6 / 3459  
Aug 19, 2009   #5
As others have pointed out, you point isn't really clear here. You decided that you were interested in art even though you aren't really very good at it? At least, that's what your essay says. I don't think its what you mean it to say, though. Decide what message you want your writing to convey, and revise it with that in mind. The details themselves are good, so you probably won't have to change that much once you've settled on a new approach.


Home / Writing Feedback / "Memom, how did you draw this?" Topic of Choice Essay -- opinions and critiques
ⓘ Need Writing or Editing Help?
Fill out one of these forms for professional help:

Best Writing Service:
CustomPapers form ◳

Graduate Writing / Editing:
GraduateWriter form ◳

Excellence in Editing:
Rose Editing ◳

AI-Paper Rewriting:
Robot Rewrite ◳