Unanswered [6] | Urgent [0]
  

Posts by birdcages
Joined: Dec 31, 2011
Last Post: Jan 1, 2012
Threads: 2
Posts: 11  
From: United States of America

Displayed posts: 13
sort: Oldest first   Latest first  | 
birdcages   
Dec 31, 2011
Undergraduate / 'memories of Chinatown' - CommonApp - Changing my culture/society through art [5]

In which I spend my New Year's Eve frantically revising my personal essay, hahaha.
Anyway, I'd really like help regarding the overall tone and message of it - my writing style's always been... pretty much exactly the opposite of good-essay-writing, but I didn't realize how much so until now!


I don't know much Chinese now, aside from slang and the odd broken sentence, but I miss it, the quiet slur of words and strong syllables. Sometimes I hear it on the streets from foreign businessmen who make it their jobs to learn every language under the sun, but the words are clipped, impersonal, and without any of the rich accent that I've come to associate with elaborate handmade paper lanterns and elegant ceramic vases.

But all the beauty and art does little to disguise the details I started noticing when I grew older, things that are subtle but speak volumes of how the culture treats women. Soon, they're all I can think of: memories of Chinatown, of my mother piling rice into her husband's and children's bowls at the dinner table before scraping the leftovers into her own bowl; of the press of a parent's palm, firm, to the base of his daughter's neck, reminding her to stay quiet when a man speaks.

I move to Queens, New York. It's noise and grit and color, a jumble of honking cars and rusty fire escapes and asphalt. The women who live there reflect that; they are unapologetic and provocative and so unlike the good Chinese girls I've been told to to take after. They fascinate me, and there's something about the unbarred effrontery that is infectious. It makes me restless and reckless, louder and ready to snap at every throwaway misogynistic remark from my Chinese tutor. It's as if I can compensate for the meekness of my aunts and sister and mother, and the hypocrisy of it all doesn't hit me until-

-one day, when I'm taking the 7 train to Manhattan and looking mindlessly out the smudged windows at 5Pointz, a broken-down warehouse completely covered in graffiti. It's a display I see biweekly, but a black-and-purple square catches my eye: a hijab-wearing woman, emblazoned with the words "LIBYAN WOMEN HAVE GUNS."

A week later, I make the trip to the 200,000-square-foot space and the art is brilliant up-close: a heavily-tattooed woman snarling at a leering man, a depiction of Lady Liberty crushing a man and turning him to gold, and pieces on the sides of dumpsters that speak of violence and poverty and racism. It's in-your-face and obscene and absolutely mad, everything I love about Queens, and it bowls me over. These people are passionate and angry and doing something about it. They're throwing their names up on walls and demanding to be heard. They're scrawling profanities and political statements on tidy corporate buildings. They're using art, something they're clearly in love with, in its most basic form - as a way of mass communication and self-expression - to change things that they desperately want to love: their communities, weighed down with sexism; their world, led by men who refuse to change it; their friends and families, who are too silent.

I pick up a paintbrush.

I think about Chinese culture, how it's about art and boldness and strength, too- dragon performances on New Year's, all stomping feet and power, and the ballad of Hua Mulan, who loved her family and fought for them under the guise of a man.

I think about what I love about art, what I want to change and what I want to do, and the world looks brand-new and terrifying from here. I think about being angry and bitter and demanding my culture and society to change, and I think about being angry and passionate, about using art to change them myself.

My main complaints have been that it's too esoteric, all over the place / not to-the-point, and that my point isn't very clear. Suggestions?

Thanks in advance - happy New Year's Eve, all!

birdcages   
Dec 31, 2011
Undergraduate / Yale supp. essay- "'A woman's perfume tells more about her than her handwriting'" [10]

I really like it - it's creative and a light read that does show a lot of your personality.

I'm not a fan of the third paragraph, actually. It sounds awkward and fragmented, imo. Maybe change it to -
Are you a Chanel Chance Eau Tendre? Sephora describes it as a spring flowery fragrance with bright hints of grapefruit and quince, "intoxicatingly innocent." Or maybe you see yourself as a Viktor and Rolf Eau Mega, a warm sweet fruity perfume with hints of pear and basil that make it "glamorous, chic and sophisticated," according to Nordstrom. Perhaps you are a Miss Dior Cherie, one of my favorite scents? It's "chic and youthful," Ulta says, describing its modern luxurious blend of mandarin, caramel popcorn, patchouli, and musk.

But I agree with the poster above me - describing yourself as glamorous and chic sounds a little shallow (although I actually love Victor and Rolf Eau Mega! haha)

I like the thing about Wiki - like Yale said, they're interested in things that your CommonApp doesn't show, and I think it's good that you show that you like to dig for information.

Help me with my personal statement, please? :)
birdcages   
Dec 31, 2011
Undergraduate / 'the local community garden' - CommonApp Extracurricular Activity [6]

I agree with stars93 - I think it'd be leagues better if you either deleted or cut down on this bit:

On the first day, there were seven people at the garden plot who had all "willingly" volunteered to help out. I had a miserable time slaving over vegetables and dirt for three hours that day. However, as the garden grew, the effort of the other five volunteers slowly diminished into nothingness and so, I was forced to take on a greater responsibility.

To be honest, it makes you seem like a bit of a whiner, and the fact that you said you were 'forced' to take on a greater responsibility does not come off well. & If you reduced that part, you'd have plenty of room to talk about what you gained from it!

That said, the last few lines are very good - you sound genuinely happy with the experience.

I'd love it if you took a look at my CommonApp essay :)
birdcages   
Jan 1, 2012
Undergraduate / I have a Mohawk---commonapp essay for upenn, princeton, amherst, rochester [14]

I agree with the first poster - the second conclusion is leagues better, imo. Also, I'm not really a fan of the paragraph before your conclusion - it feels a little after-school-special to me. Like, 'too happy' of an ending? I mean, if that's what happened, that's wonderful for you & I'm certainly not telling you to lie, but the way you wrote it makes it seem like a complete 180. I think you can write it in a way that's a little more subtle.

Otherwise, I think it's a great essay! You can really hear your 'voice' & personality come through.

Take a look at my CommonApp essay? :)
birdcages   
Jan 1, 2012
Undergraduate / 'The President of the Hip-Hop Club' - CommonApp Extracurricular - Newspaper [9]

Please briefly elaborate on one of your extracurricular activities or work experiences in the space below (1000 character maximum):

The President of the Hip-Hop Club, a tall teenager, shuts off the speakers, and I shake his hand. "Thanks for interviewing with me," I say. "Can you tell me a little about your club?"

The boy grins. "A lot of people just see us as kids making too much noise, and that's what hip-hop started out as: folks who didn't have money but made sure they were heard. It's important that message and culture are spread, so we appreciate the publicity."

"It's my pleasure," I laugh, scribbling down the quote. I've been the editor of my school's newspaper for two years, and this is why I'm absolutely in love with it.

Every editorial and feature story that we publish is a way for students to put up messages that they think should be seen. Society changes and the world is kept human by people who make themselves heard, and I hadn't understood their need for a platform to do so until I joined The Patriot. That realization is what gave way to my passion for art and my desire to communicate through it.

Too abstract? I had another draft where I talked about my duties & the time I spent on the newspaper, but it felt really dry and just like I was listing facts that they could see on my extracurricular activities list anyway, so I tried a different approach.

Thanks in advance!

birdcages   
Jan 1, 2012
Undergraduate / 'India, a world eight thousand miles away' - My World - MIT Essay [5]

I think you have a really nice springboard here. I can definitely see the point you're trying to make, but it's a little choppy - maybe work on your transitions? I know you're trying to contrast the worlds you came from, but you can do that without making the transition from paragraph to paragraph so jumpy. I mean, at the end, it's obvious what all your other paragraphs were leading up to - following your own passions - but before I read the last few sentences, I wasn't sure what point you were trying to make, so I'd suggest connecting them.

The grammar's great, but I'd also suggest connecting some of the shorter sentences - it just makes for smoother reading.
birdcages   
Jan 1, 2012
Undergraduate / 'Mexican culture' - Yale/ Harvard supplement [15]

Thank you for your help on my essay!

I've always loved the quote you're using, by the way, haha. Anyway - I think you put a lot of sentences/phrases in that are unnecessary and distract from the point you're trying to make. For example, you certainly don't need to talk about your uncle getting drunk, and the bit with your aunt on the phone seems to serve no purpose other than heartstring-plucking. Also, while your last sentence is a good message / speaks a lot about you, it's not the main point of the essay. You can certainly keep it in there, but I'd write more about how your grandfather's death "helped you define one of your values or changed how you approach the world" - it would help your essay answer the prompt more, I think.
birdcages   
Jan 1, 2012
Undergraduate / 'The President of the Hip-Hop Club' - CommonApp Extracurricular - Newspaper [9]

Thanks for all the help! Finished helping the first three posters w/ their essays & getting to work on yours now, Calvin!

Version 2: (It's about 30 chars over limit - this character limit is going to be the death of me. Anyway, comments/suggestions?)

The tall teenager shuts off the speakers and shakes my hand. "Thanks for interviewing with me," I say. "Can you tell me a little about The Hip-Hop Club?"

The boy grins. "Sure- we make noise. That's what hip-hop started out as: folks who didn't have money but made sure they were heard. It's important that message and culture are spread, so we appreciate the publicity."

"It's my pleasure," I laugh, scribbling down the quote. I've been the editor of my school's newspaper for two years, and this is why I'm absolutely in love with it.

Every editorial and feature story that we publish is a way for students to put up messages that they think should be seen. Society changes and humanity is kept intact by people who make themselves heard, and I hadn't understood their need for a platform to do so until I joined the newspaper. It was then, leafing through a stack of articles, that I knew I wanted a way to spread my own messages; that realization is what gave way to my passion for art and my desire to communicate through it.
birdcages   
Jan 1, 2012
Undergraduate / 'doctor's hands perform miracles' - Stony Brook Med Supplement [3]

This is a really good take on the prompt - it reads well, is original, and speaks a lot about you.

I do like the first paragraph a lot, but I'm not a fan of the first and last lines of it. The first sentence doesn't really do anything for the paragraph, imo. "The portrait in front of me, glossy and [insert adjective here LOL] truly pictures how I will look as a doctor." is what I would change the first line to if I were writing this, but I clearly have a much different style, so take from that what you will! I don't like the last sentence of the first paragraph at all - I love the idea of dropping the portrait into an x-ray machine, but the sentence itself sounds awkward and weakens an otherwise strong intro.
birdcages   
Jan 1, 2012
Undergraduate / 'The President of the Hip-Hop Club' - CommonApp Extracurricular - Newspaper [9]

Yue - Omg, 997 characters, haha. Thank you so much! Ah, I wanted to keep the boy's response about the hip-hop club because I feel like it kind of ties in with my message? They're spreading their message, the importance & significance of urban culture, and even though it's through song and dance, things that are commonly seen as the opposite of the normal form of communication (text), it's just as strong, and I think that's true about art, too. CLEARLY, I DO NOT HAVE THE SPACE TO PUT ALL OF THIS LOL.

Reading yours over now :)
birdcages   
Jan 1, 2012
Undergraduate / We are so small but yet so powerful. Common App essay! [16]

"The girl, Xinxin, was one of my mom's former patients." <-- suggestion on how to change that sentence, haha.
Also, imo, it flows nicely - not too choppy/sudden at all.

Anyway, I agree with Nicole - I think you should talk more about yourself. I don't think it'd be too hard to shorten the paragraph about Xinxin while keeping it just as powerful; definitely keep the bit about her parents thanking your mother. Let me know if you need any help doing so!

I really like it, by the way - it's really sincere & speaks a lot about you.
birdcages   
Jan 1, 2012
Undergraduate / 'memories of Chinatown' - CommonApp - Changing my culture/society through art [5]

Ah, thanks very much! I was actually trying to communicate that I used to be really angry and hostile/bitter in my feminist views, but I now realize that's not the point - it's about trying change the things I see as sexist by doing things that will impact my culture/society positively, not just being angry and doing nothing. Thanks for letting me know that's not how it came out - will def. try to fix that!

Quick question - I'm still getting complaints from my friends about how it's 'all over the place' that is, first it's about Chinese culture, then it's about feminism, then it's about art. My point is to tie all of them together by stating my goal to change society (the point of including Chinese culture was to show how sexism taints things that I desperately want to love) to not be as prejudiced/unfair towards certain people through art. Since I'm getting told that it's not coming across well, should I just delete the first paragraph about Chinese culture?
birdcages   
Jan 1, 2012
Undergraduate / 'Surfing and water' - Common App: Extracurricular Essay [5]

I sat silently on the foam ledge, intoxicated by the thick chlorine in the air and surrounded only by my own thoughts despite the large crowd. I was on the verge of losing consciousness when I asked myself: "Why am I doing this?" It was the 2011 National Flow Tour Championships, the biggest stage of the sport. Even if I were to become the champion, who would care other than my close friends and followers of the sport? People will still look at me like I'm from another planet when I tell them I surf in Missouri. Even the harshest critics would still consider my passion a joke. Imo, you need a better transition between these two sentences. I know, the 1000 char limit is the worst, haha. You can cut down on chars by shortening/deleting one of the sentences before this? 'Even the harshest critics would still consider my passion a joke.' <-- this adds to your point, but it's not that necessary, and you're trying to make every word count. Despite all of the opposition I had found it inside myself to continue. I surf for my own enjoyment, not for other people's opinions. Nothing can replace the wonderful feeling of the water gliding beneath my feet. One day, when Flowboarding is just as popular as football, I will be able to look into the camera and tell my mother that I love her on national television. This is why I surf.

Also, I think it'd strengthen your essay a lot if you put in one or two lines about what else surfing has done for you - what you've gotten from it, how it's strengthened your character. ... Clearly, I am a pot calling the kettle black since I've completely failed to do that on my own essay, LOL. But good luck! :)
Need Writing or Editing Help?
Fill out one of these forms:

Graduate Writing / Editing:
GraduateWriter form ◳

Best Essay Service:
CustomPapers form ◳

Excellence in Editing:
Rose Editing ◳

AI-Paper Rewriting:
Robot Rewrite ◳

Academic AI Writer:
Custom AI Writer ◳