Unanswered [1] | Urgent [0]
  

Posts by toonistic
Name: Hrishi
Joined: Dec 24, 2013
Last Post: Dec 29, 2013
Threads: 1
Posts: 8  
From: India
School: ACS (Independent)

Displayed posts: 9
sort: Oldest first   Latest first  | 
toonistic   
Dec 24, 2013
Undergraduate / Common App Essay Prompt 5 - jumping the puddle [6]

Prompt 5: Discuss an accomplishment or event, formal or informal, that marked your transition from childhood to adulthood within your culture, community, or family.

I couldn't believe my senses - I was at an airport, with actual airplanes in it. I had won a scholarship from the Singapore government for a 4 year high school diploma, and there were nine of us from all over the country. I could not help but feel like a kid; almost all the others were a year (or two) older than me! I can still hear my 14-year old self think: These are my batchmates? Dear lord, some of them even have mustaches. Maybe if I jump high enough I can touch one of their Easter Island heads. Why are the stairs so tall? Oh look, they're moving.

To this day being in that Airport makes me feel completely Lilliputian. I remember entering the towering metal tube, wondering what was inside it. I had been breezy and untroubled so far, lost in the joys of discovery; yet as the airplane taxied onto the runway, it hit me: This wasn't a summer camp. I wasn't going to be home for a long time.

Home for me was a small farming village in South India. Everyone knew me and I knew everybody. I'd never thought about leaving before - I had no reason; No one ever left unless they had a very good reason. Yet I was packing one day and gone the next, the whole village seeing me off at the Railway Station. They had high hopes for me; they had never seen the outside world as I was about to.

I had come from a small world, and it felt humbling and strangely overwhelming to be introduced to the real one.

Nothing in my life had prepared me for this, but as I looked down and saw nothing but blue, I knew something had changed. I was shy but unafraid. Shy of the world where I knew not a single person beyond his name, yet unafraid of the high expectations I felt on the shoulders of the small group of children that sat around me. My world was bigger, but I knew I owed it to the men and women back home to use the knowledge my scholarship, my foray into another world would provide, use it to help my country and through it, all others.

Stepping off the plane, there was a bittersweet moment when I knew I had crossed a line. I was now a global citizen, and it was a phrase that did not distinguish between boys and men. Suddenly there was a lot to do. The school I was going to would open up unexplored vistas, show me faces unseen, miles untraveled. I could do it all. My first day of school despite being the youngest in my class, I couldn't help but feel like a man among boys. I had travelled three thousand miles to get there, and my journey as an adult had just begun.

I still wonder about the road not taken, about what I might have become had I not been rushed into adulthood as I was. Perhaps I wasn't. Perhaps there is no single moment of transition from childhood to adulthood, perhaps they aren't entirely distinct. All I can say for sure is that I began that day in India, feeling like a kid hanging on his mother's saree. Lying on my bed that night in my room in Singapore, I knew I was not a kid anymore.

Children wait their whole lives to be adults, and adults wish their whole lives to be children again. There comes a point in all our lives when we simply stop wondering about adults and their bohemian ways and realize that we've become one of them. Not all of us can pin it to a single moment, but mine was in the seats of an airbus-A320 taking off into the night with a 14 year old who was the first in his family to ever cross the ocean.

---

I realise the structure is somewhat unorthodox, but I can't seem to distance myself from the material and look at it objectively. Any comments, however harsh, are welcome. Please let me know what you think, and if you could also suggest an alternate way of putting things, that'd be awesome. Thanks a bunch!
toonistic   
Dec 24, 2013
Undergraduate / When you dream, anything is possible; Perfectly content. [2]

I think it should be better for you to follow the paragraph structure, or perhaps start doing so from the second paragraph. It could give a stronger separation between the fantasy and reality part of your essay.

Also, you should more clearly state what or where it is that you feel most comfortable. It might help to restate the question sort of, because its only at the end that the reader gets the 'ah' moment - 'he's talking about dreaming! Wait is he really talking about how much he loves sleep in his college essay?' - Not great. Remember not everyone's equally smart.
toonistic   
Dec 24, 2013
Undergraduate / Indian-American/Dr. K's class - Diversity and "Why Caltech?" [2]

Being brutally honest? You're too honest.
"Caltech is the sole university where all students are consistently held to exacting standards in all their academic pursuits" and "I think I could easily emerge, unscathed and untested, from an easy four years at an average university." seem arrogant and may be considered as pandering by the faculty of Caltech not all of whom are entirely from Caltech. There are other premier institutions in the country and the reader may just wonder if you haven't written the same for all the universities you're applying to. You may be appreciated by a reader of your thinking, one respecting complete frankness, but you run the risk of most others considering you brash and outspoken.

A better approach would be to be respectful to all universities (even those you consider 'average') while expressing that you believe Caltech to be the best. Also, while it may be too mainstream, any reference to courses or faculty specific to Caltech will improve your essay. Simple litmus test? Change all the occurrances of 'Caltech' to another university and see if your essay makes sense. If if does completely, you're too generic.

Oh and hey from another Malayali trying to make it to Caltech! Take a look at my essay, I welcome any suggestions you might have.
toonistic   
Dec 25, 2013
Undergraduate / Common App Essay Prompt 5 - jumping the puddle [6]

sarthakjain
I was trying to express that I felt like a grown-up among my friends now that I had transitioned into an adult (figuratively).
I'll try and revise it.
Any other problems you found with the essay? Grammatical or otherwise?
toonistic   
Dec 26, 2013
Undergraduate / I could watch my SpongeBob! - Central to Identity [7]

It's a pretty good essay centered on a simple concept anyone can identify with - good work! However, now that you're done composing perhaps you can focus a bit more on the language. Try using varied sentence structures throughout, and ditch the semicolons unless you think they help that particular sentence. It makes for easier reading to have shorter, better sentences. Also you could try to use a bit more 'flowery' language - not too much, but a little bit should be helpful.
toonistic   
Dec 26, 2013
Undergraduate / Iraq - Common App Personal Essay - Reflect on a time you challenge a belief or idea... [2]

"Where are you from?" "Seven." "How old are you?" "Iraq." (Just clarifying, you're interchanging the two answers for comedic relief right? Even so it might be slightly better to move the pair with 'Iraq' in it to the very beginning. It helps to catch the attention of the reader as early as possible, and in your case it can be done without substantial changes) I was hunched down on the floor of a cramped, decrepit, two-room apartment in the housing projects, endeavoring to converse with two Arabic-speaking boys who had recently been granted political asylum in the United States. Their father, who arrived in the United States two years prior and gained proficiency in English shortly thereafter, looked on with a smile. (You could lose a few words in the preceding sentence, if you really needed to. eg.'Their father, a two-year old Immigrant...') One never would have guessed that he was ('had been' would be better, to give a sense of relative time) forced by militants to abandon two thriving businesses in Iraq and was now struggling to provide for his family on a part-time, minimum wage income. "Ig-gayyaat ahsan min ir-rayhhaat," he declared. "What is coming is better than what is gone." (Just an idea, perhaps you could reveal the meaning of the proverb only at the end; might be an interesting wraparound ending that makes the reader come back to the top...)

The father's Old World wisdom was remarkably prescient; within six months of meeting his boys, I had them speaking conversational, albeit broken English. ('With me') Serving as their tour guide, the father and his boys explored the Amish countryside, an amusement park, and a local zoo. The mother, a hijab-clad woman who had(Once again, relative time) never failed to welcome me into her home with a kind "asalaamu alaikum" and a hot cup of coffee, was noticeably absent from our far-flung adventures. While her family thrived, the soft-spoken, hazel-eyed woman suffered in silence.

Several years prior, Jamaat Ansar al-Sunna guerrillas used the threat of execution to force her family to leave Iraq. By the time I was introduced to her at a tutoring program for immigrants, she was disillusioned and depressed, having spent the past two years in refugee camps across the Middle East. She felt that although learning the American language would allow her to communicate with her doctors and ensure her safety in the event of an emergency, it would be the final nail in the coffin of her former life. Her indignant refusal to learn the American language and become accustomed to the area were manifestations of her futile belief that her husband would soon "come to his senses" and allow the family to return to their native land.

The inner-humanity in me prompted me to challenge the mother's belief that life in "Amreeka" entailed letting go of Iraq. To quote Mother Teresa, "Love is not patronizing and charity isn't about pity. It is just about love."

My first target was the family's taste buds, which had been seriously deprived of Iraq's decadent fare (if their cereal-and-soda diet served as any indication). Their response was nothing short of hysterical when I arrived at their apartment bearing gifts of fresh Kanafeh and Kleicha, Mesopotamian treats that I purchased from an international food market. For the mother's birthday, I arranged for a local Imam's wife to prepare the family an exquisite Middle-Eastern meal consisting of hummus and lamb Kebabs. Their gratitude was marked by ear-to-ear smiles that transcended any cultural and linguistic barriers that existed between us.

From then on, I reminded the family that in the United States, Iraq was never far away. In the following weeks, I delivered old Arabic CDs from Amazon, Iraq's new flag, and coffee beans from Baghdad to their home. I then accompanied the family to two cultural festivals - one Arab, one Greek - to show them that the United States' greatest? strength is its plurality of cultures. Equipped with the belief that being American and Iraqi are perfectly compatible, the mother finally agreed to learn English. She mastered vocabulary with the same vitality and spirit that I saw in her boys many months prior.

My experiences with the family have left me with much more than a plethora of Arabic words and phrases hammered into my head. I've learned that the smallest doses of kindness and thoughtfulness can bring the greatest spells of fear and insecurity to an end. It is with this knowledge that the aforementioned adage, a remnant of a noble culture relayed to me, truly comes to life: What is coming is better than what is gone!

Extremely well written essay, good topic. I'd say you're already there, but no reason to stop polishing right?
Oh and take a look at mine too, deadline's almost here!
toonistic   
Dec 27, 2013
Undergraduate / Girls shouldn't play soccer! - Incident or time when you experienced failure [2]

"Girls shouldn't play soccer, they'll get too muscular and look like guys!"

Playing with the boys is intimidating. But I've been doing it since I was a scrawny nine year-old, and I was (always?) pretty good at it. I needed to play soccer like I needed to breathe. Even though the boys were getting bigger than me, I had no qualms trying out for the boy's (boys) team as a fourteen year-old.

It started with a simple enough exercise on the field: tryouts for the best club in Doha - the dusty capital of Qatar. The tryouts were on a Thursday afternoon in mid-October. The sun was at its peak and it was blistering. Stepping onto the field felt like walking into a steamy oven. Unlike the rest of the barren city, the field was lush and green like an oasis in the sand. The coaches were huddled together on the sidelines and I assertively approached (approached assertively) .

But stepping on the field to play, I started getting butterflies in my stomach. Not the type you get when you're playing a big game. This was outright anxiety (the preceding sentences might work better as two sentences, not three. connect either to the next - easier reading) . These guys were big. They had the muscles of professional players with tree stumps (trunks) for legs. Their movements were exact and severe, like drills in the army. My heart started beating faster and so intensely('so hard and so fast' would provide better symmetry) I could almost hear it. Every player on the field had a red jersey on. And there I was, in a plain white t-shirt. My confidence was shot. I, for the first time, felt small and self-conscious on the soccer field. And I was reminded of what my dad said: I, being a girl, shouldn't play soccer.
(The usage of 'I, ..., ...' isn't really a common one. Seems awkward, perhaps you could try revising. It might just be cleaner to say 'For the first time, I felt small...')

The ball that had been my friend for so long was now foreign, (;) I couldn't control it. It wasn't curving or bending the way it was supposed to. Drills only lasted fifteen minutes, but each one was excruciating. I finally excused myself, ran to the bathroom and began to sob. It was my lowest moment. My sense of self came from the soccer field and knowing that I could do anything that the guys could do. At that moment I lost it, and I stopped playing.

When I came back to the States as a sophomore in high school, I was too scared to try out for varsity. I was sure I wouldn't make it. I spent the year watching the team play, wishing I were on the field. I was angry but wasn't sure why. It was easier to blame the world than to take responsibility. Still, I knew the fear of failure couldn't feel worse than sitting on the sidelines. And being angry wasn't going to get me back on the field. It slowly and painfully dawned on me that I had it all wrong. It was me who had allowed (let?) other people to shake my confidence. That realization helped me understand the difference between confidence and bravado. My dad's words made me question myself, but they also made me truly confident. I can (could) accept his views as his alone without losing my sense of purpose. As for soccer, I'm back on the field again. But this time, it feels different. It's no longer about impressing coaches or other players. For me, it's about the love of the game.

Well written essay, except for a few typos. However I have to say that the topic of girls playing sports has been done to death. I can enjoy your essay, but for an admissions officer on his 2134th, it might seem too plain. My suggestion would be to add something different, something new. Perhaps it was the way your dad said it, perhaps it an account of a teammate. But it has to be something new.

Also, the structuring might need some work. In a transformation essay, you're better off with the transformation happening closer to the middle. That way you have more space to talk about the new you and the lessons you learnt, which is what they're really looking for. The journey you've had is important, but not as important as the you that they're admitting.

Oh and take a look at mine, let me know what you think. Deadlines are almost here!
toonistic   
Dec 27, 2013
Undergraduate / Common App Essay Prompt 5 - jumping the puddle [6]

Thanks a bunch man, now I'm at exactly 649 words. You're a lifesaver.
Anytime you need me to take a look at an essay or something, let me know.

Did anything else catch your eye tho? As unpleasant or 'could be better'?
Need Writing or Editing Help?
Fill out one of these forms:

Graduate Writing / Editing:
GraduateWriter form ◳

Best Essay Service:
CustomPapers form ◳

Excellence in Editing:
Rose Editing ◳

AI-Paper Rewriting:
Robot Rewrite ◳

Academic AI Writer:
Custom AI Writer ◳