Unanswered [5] | Urgent [0]
  

Posts by theTalkingRice
Joined: Oct 2, 2010
Last Post: Jan 6, 2011
Threads: 5
Posts: 17  

From: United States of America

Displayed posts: 22
sort: Latest first   Oldest first  | 
theTalkingRice   
Jan 6, 2011
Undergraduate / "a positive gut-feeling" - Why Notre Dame? (TOO LONG) [2]

The only thing I would actually advise you to change is the first sentence. It kind of makes it seem that you're talking down on Notre Dame, even though you're saying that your friends and acquaintances were the ones who "grimaced" at ND while you disregarded their opinions. It could be taken as a little rude, depending on how angry your admissions officer is normally :P

Everything else is pretty good imo. You're over the word limit, so if you can find anything that you think you could get rid of, you should probably do it, but if you love everything, leave it because I don't think any college would actually reject you for being like 100 words over. Although I'm in the same boat as you, never applied to college before, so maybe I'm wrong :p
theTalkingRice   
Oct 28, 2010
Undergraduate / Blank Canvas - COMMON APP EXTRACURRICULAR ACTIVITY [11]

a lot of people tend to interpret the prompt completely literally, and think they literally have to describe what they do in concrete terms, but your way of describing its effects on you personally does more than just say WHAT you do, which in the end is what admissions officers want. as i said before, they care more about WHO you are, not what you do
theTalkingRice   
Oct 27, 2010
Undergraduate / Blank Canvas - COMMON APP EXTRACURRICULAR ACTIVITY [11]

actually the anecdote at the beginning is really quite relevant to the topic. remember that the admissions officers really just want to get to know you as a person, so you don't have to force yourself to answer every single nuance of the prompt. as long as you're describing something you do that affects you emotionally, then i think you're pretty much golden. And your essay does that exceptionally well
theTalkingRice   
Oct 24, 2010
Undergraduate / "I am human" - Common App supplement [5]

Everyone belongs to many different communities and/or groups defined by (among other things) shared geography, religion, ethnicity, income, cuisine, interest, race, ideology, or intellectual heritage. Choose one of the communities to which you belong, and describe that community and your place within it. (Approximately 250 words)

It used to bother me that no one could tell that I was Chinese. "Are you Japanese? Korean?" they would ask, but they never seemed to get around to what I imagined was the most obvious choice. It's ethnic pride, I told myself as I berated my friends for not knowing my cultural background.

It later occurred to me that my fierce Chinese pride was rather overbearing. I resolved to widen my mental boundaries. "Asian pride!" was my new motto. The way I saw it, most people couldn't even tell the difference between the Asian races anyway. So at school, I associated myself with peers of Korean and Japanese and, of course, Chinese descent. As I perused the news, I found myself drawn to anything that sounded particularly oriental.

One day as I was explaining to a friend the wonders of being Asian, he asked me, "Ok. So what part of being born in Asia makes you so amazing?" I opened my mouth to answer - and then closed it because I had no answer. And I began to think. What exactly defines race and nationality anyway? Some imaginary lines drawn on a map? Hardly something to brag about. After all, people are essentially the same no matter where they live, aren't they? And so I began to expand my boundaries once more, until, finally, I came to a conclusion that I could be proud of.

So, yes, I am Chinese, and yes, I am Asian. But I am also human. And look - there's a planet full of people just like me.

I'm actually pretty proud of this. Blasted it out in 15 minutes, and it's not even that bad. Please crit and advise :D
theTalkingRice   
Oct 24, 2010
Undergraduate / "I question the world" - BROWN supplement - "what don't you know"? [3]

Yeah your essay makes my brain reel too. I had to read it twice to get it :x I like your writing style; it's like a trippy run through your mind. What do they call that? Flow of consciousness? Something like that, but not really. I guess it's like you're psychoanalyzing yourself, which I found interesting to witness.

One point though, I feel like in the end you kind of answered your own question. You say you limit yourself, which kind of suggests that you're leaning towards your slightly close-minded cubicle self, and away from your globally-minded, but kind of powerless lab self. Although technically this isn't an answer at all, so I might be raving.

Although now I'm reading your entire essay again and I'm not too sure I understood it completely anymore :P I don't think I have the mental capability to write on this level haha
theTalkingRice   
Oct 24, 2010
Undergraduate / "My intellectual curiosity, Doorbells" - Personal Statement [6]

geez, imo this is almost perfect. I don't think I'm a good enough writer to do anything except express how stylistically monumental your writing is. The only thing that I noticed was some spelling/mechanics errors in the first paragraph.

"whether" not "weather" when talking about your nanny
"Superman" not "superman"

but really other than that, your essay is terrific :x
theTalkingRice   
Oct 24, 2010
Undergraduate / "my first solo trip to China; I didn't care" - Common App [3]

Evaluate a significant experience, achievement, risk you have taken, or ethical dilemma you have faced and its impact on you.

Last summer I took my first solo trip to China. Most summers I would return with my parents to visit the relatives they had left behind over twenty years ago, but this year I had signed up to teach English to prospective foreign exchange students at the local university. To be honest, I wasn't all that thrilled; the way I saw it, the four weeks I'd spend at the university were infringing on precious time away from my parents' overbearing attentions, but I didn't really have anything else to do. And so I showed up on the first day, unenthusiastic and anxious for the last day to roll around. And on the last day, I showed up with my entire life turned upside down.

I don't really like this all that much either...I've come to realize that i don't do well with long essays haha...I like to get my point across in short, emphatic statements, so getting this many words was a challenge. That said, i'm actually about 60 words over the recommended 500, so maybe it's not that much of a problem after all >< in any case, i don't like this essay lol.

advice is appreciated, thanks

theTalkingRice   
Oct 24, 2010
Undergraduate / "on my fear of museums" - Topic of Choice. Advice how to start? [3]

I think the best advice i could give is just to write it how you would say it. That's the best way to get your voice across, which is really all the admissions people want. They don't care too much about how well you can put sentences together, it's about how well you can convey yourself or an idea. It's actually a good thing that you don't know how to tackle your topic because that means it's probably something that not many people have written about, which I would assume the admissions people will appreciate. It probably gets boring reading essays about the same topics every day :P
theTalkingRice   
Oct 24, 2010
Undergraduate / "Soccer field" - Williams 'an environment that is particularly signifiant to you' [15]

I love the style of this essay. Can't really explain it, but I love your first three sentences describing the field. Contrary to what another poster said, I don't think you actually have to emphasize the fact that you are LITERALLY looking at this through a window, because then you'd really only have one thing to write about - the view outside your window. I'm pretty sure it just means the "window" of memory or something like that. Anyway, I feel like sticking so strictly to the prompt would detract a bit from the flow of your essay, but it's your call :P

Stylistically though, I think it's perfect. Good work
theTalkingRice   
Oct 17, 2010
Undergraduate / "I am an anticarcinogen" - MIT undergrad [14]

thanks again for all the comments!

i added some stuff to aid the flow, but the main idea is still the same. I also tried to cushion a bit of the stuff in the third paragraph so my personality doesnt seem so bitingly in your face when i describe some things. I suppose you'll probably see what i mean.

better? worse? Comments are appreciated :D
theTalkingRice   
Oct 17, 2010
Undergraduate / "I am an anticarcinogen" - MIT undergrad [14]

well i wasn't really saying that I can't handle serious situations at all; I just don't do it in the traditional sense, with "oh, i'm so sorry!!" etc etc. Just seems fake to me. I did go on to say that I handle them BY being humorous
theTalkingRice   
Oct 16, 2010
Undergraduate / "I am an anticarcinogen" - MIT undergrad [14]

Thanks for the advice/compliments :p

but what you're saying is that your first impression was kind of a bad one? Because the admissions people probably only have time to read it once or twice, and I don't want it to sound good only after reading it a couple more times. Is there anything in particular that you didn't really like on your first readthrough that I could change? I'm trying not to make myself sound too much like an unemotional jerk but it's hard haha. Thanks
theTalkingRice   
Oct 16, 2010
Undergraduate / "I am an anticarcinogen" - MIT undergrad [14]

What attribute of your personality are you most proud of, and how has it impacted your life so far? This could be your creativity, effective leadership, sense of humor, integrity, or anything else you'd like to tell us about. (*) (200-250 words)

I am an anticarcinogen. What? you say, You prevent cancer? How can that be? Simple arithmetic - laughter is said to reduce the severity of cancers; I make people laugh. Two plus two; I prevent cancer.

Clever metaphors aside, it's safe to say that I am almost literally defined by the words "sarcastic humor." Our English class did a sarcasm unit last year and when the teacher asked if anyone could define sarcasm, everyone pointed at me. I spout cynical observations like a fountain; my brain is a virtual goldmine of the stuff. Imagine political cartoons, but personified.

I suppose this is partly a side effect of my inability to handle emotion-intensive situations; at least, not in the traditional sense. As soon as a point is reached where sincere human compassion is required to continue a conversation, I throw in sarcasm to divert the topic. That's not to say I'm incapable of expressing sympathy; I just refuse to belittle the emotions disclosed to me in such confidence by offering awkward half-condolences. And in all honesty, would anyone really believe them? Instead, sarcastic humor is my own way of conveying concern, of communicating the compassion I cannot effectively describe in words. I try to make people laugh, because it is the best thing I can do for them. I express my own belief that people shouldn't be so tense, so concerned with details all the time. Enjoy life. Laugh. And that, I suppose, is more heartfelt than anything else I could ever articulate. So I guess even though there's no cure to cancer, I'm probably the next best thing there is.

I won't lie, I kind of hate this essay. I'm really bad at writing essays about myself so this was a real challenge. The first paragraph and a half I thought was especially bad. But i was trying to SHOW my personality instead of writing about it, which is why this is written pretty informally, since that's just the kind of person I am.

also, I know there should be quotes in the first paragraph, but I decided to go without them for stylistic reasons. It just seems to flow better without. And it matches the general tone of the piece that I'm going for. :/

Advice is appreciated, thanks :D
theTalkingRice   
Oct 16, 2010
Undergraduate / (volunteering at the library) - Common App - Activities Essay [9]

I really like your first 2 sentences, but I don't think they transition very well into the statement that says "I have been volunteering at the library..." I think they should actually be moved into the middle of your essay, somewhere between talking about the tasks you carry out and your passion when interacting with the kids. You might have to change a little bit so they don't seem like they were copypasted, but I feel like the two sentences fit better there. Although it's your essay, so it's your call :D

btw, in the sentence "I have been volunteering at the library ever since I was old enough to" you should probably add something to the end, like "I have been volunteering at the library ever since I was old enough to do so." Just because you shouldn't end with a preposition :3 sorry for being a grammar nazi haha
theTalkingRice   
Oct 11, 2010
Undergraduate / Sneaker Collecting Common App [6]

wow I love this essay. I wish I had something this unique to talk about haha. The only thing I didn't really like was how you started the second paragraph with "Hello, my name is..." It seems a little, ionno, forced? And it's definitely unnecessary because the admissions officers are going to have your name right there. I feel like if you just start with "I am addicted to sneakers," it not only emphasizes the statement more, but it also directly transitions from the previous paragraph.
theTalkingRice   
Oct 10, 2010
Undergraduate / "Challenge of my first day as a software programmer with no programming background" [5]

Thanks! currently working on adding some stuff to the conclusion, but I was wondering if anyone thought that this essay wasn't all that personal? I had some friends read it over and they thought that there wasn't enough personality in it. Should I add some quotes or something to make it a little more anecdotal?

Any advice would be great, thanks.
theTalkingRice   
Oct 7, 2010
Undergraduate / "Challenge of my first day as a software programmer with no programming background" [5]

so i wrote this one pretty fast as well.

Tell us about the most significant challenge you've faced or something important that didn't go according to plan. How did you manage the situation?(*) (200-250 words)

I showed up to work on my first day as a software programmer with no programming background. I had been hired at a Michigan-based insurance agency for my general familiarity with computers, but of programming, I knew nothing. My supervisor, an awkward young man who handled all the tech work for the entire agency, was to teach me to write script and perform any necessary programming tasks. But, due to his crushing workload, I was simply given an assignment and told to inform him when it was finished. There was no instruction.

I soon realized that my supervisor would be of no help; I would have to rely on myself. For the next week, I observed finished projects, trying to understand how they worked. I made small changes, to see what each function controlled. What I did not understand, I Googled and found explanations for in programming forums. Slowly I began to learn. I completed my first assignments and received others. The previously unintelligible code began to take on the semblance of a language, something familiar and natural.

Now, months later, I have carried out virtually every programming task in the office, everything from writing help files for insurance score software to bridging scores between insurance companies and customers. My supervisor still offers no aid, but I look back and realize that maybe I didn't need his help to begin with; that I have never needed anything other than my own willingness to learn, and perhaps a good search engine.

any opinions, suggestions, anything would be appreciated :D
i kind of hate the conclusion, but i've always been terrible at those. anyone think they can help me with that? thanks in advance
theTalkingRice   
Oct 2, 2010
Undergraduate / Henry Ford's lesson- COMMON APP ESSAY [3]

yeah i think you make too many mentions of Ford as well. you almost seem as if you're critically analyzing the quote itself, instead of integrating the quote into an essay that reflects you. In the first paragraph, don't actually say "This is what Henry Ford means, etc etc." Just say what you think it means, without mentioning Ford at all, and work your way into the action. Or better yet, don't even say what it means to you, and try and define it in your actions throughout the essay. Or you could state it at the end as a kind of epiphany kind of thing. Anyway, try not to mention Ford too often, or it sounds like you're writing an analytical essay lol.

to be rather brutally honest, i don't really like the topic of this essay. you do show some growth and development, but you write about having self-confidence in a kind of roundabout way that seems more hesitant than anything else. Some advice for you would be to cut a lot of the really flowery, circuitous sentences into shorter, more brief statements. Those always tend to emphasize your words a little more and make you sound more sure of what you're saying. But hell, you're writing about self-confidence, do it however you think you can make it work lol. This has lots of potential, and I'm not trying to bash your writing at all. Keep at it :D
theTalkingRice   
Oct 2, 2010
Undergraduate / "the suburbs of Detroit" - MIT undergrad - Describe the world you come from [4]

hmm, I revised the last two paragraphs very quickly in about 15 minutes just to get some feedback on whether or not i'm going in the right directions. I guess I'll just copy-paste the whole thing in here cuz it's a little easier that way.

again, any feedback would be appreciated. i'm about 4 words over, but i'm not too worried about it
theTalkingRice   
Oct 2, 2010
Undergraduate / common app essay - math is an art form [2]

wow this is really impressive haha. reading this makes me not want to start my own common app essay because I feel like it won't even come close.

there really isn't any stylistic issues that i can help you with; you've basically got that covered
but there are some redundant word choices that you have that can lower your word count a little bit

"While my classmates next to me draw cotangent curves on graph paper and redraw them for every shift their equations require, I close my eyes for a moment and draw them in my head."

you can get rid of the "next to me" since (1) you can basically assume they're pretty close to you if you can see them drawing graphs and (2) it isn't really all that important to your main idea anyway

"Though this means I take a longer time to solve each problem, it is my way of ensuring I truly understand each concept I'm learning. And as math has become an artistic outlet for me, my fear of the subject has matured into an unexpectedly warm fascination for it . "

those words are a little redundant

there's a lot of little stuff that can be taken out to make your words less...circuitous i guess? This way you sound a little more direct and by extension a little more confident and decisive. I just pointed out some of the more obvious ones for you.

But really, your essay is extremely well written; it doesn't really need all that much work. I'm just nitpicking because i don't think a comment that says "it's perfect!" would be all that helpful
theTalkingRice   
Oct 2, 2010
Undergraduate / "the suburbs of Detroit" - MIT undergrad - Describe the world you come from [4]

Describe the world you come from; for example, your family, clubs, school, community, city, or town. How has that world shaped your dreams and aspirations?(*) (200-250 words)

I live in a small, virtually unknown city in the suburbs of Detroit. Due to the proximity to the Automotive Capital of the World, nearly every family has someone working in the auto industry. The streets are quiet and the residents so law-abiding that the police department is essentially unemployed. Welcome to the City of Troy, Population: 81,000.

Don't get me wrong, I'm not saying that it's a bad place to live; we still laugh and enjoy life. It's just that Troy is so upsettingly generic. Every family owns at least two cars. Everyone lives in a house that looks just like the one next to it. If you drive down the street, the sidewalks are always empty - no one walks. Everyone is content with their lives, content with their successes and never seeking more.

"Study engineering, just like your father!" my mom says. But what if I don't want to just follow a mold given to me? Maybe it's because I hate how unassuming life in this city is, but I want to get out into the world and make my name known. I chafe at the self-imposed restrictions we place on ourselves. I yearn to prove myself to be more than just another Troy kid, content to live my life in anonymity. I choose to pursue engineering because I want to, because I believe I can do some good in the world with the knowledge, not because someone else wishes it. My mistakes will be my own - but so will my success.

This is really as close as i can get to the truth and still be interesting. It seems a little depressing to me, but i'd appreciate any feedback at all. Thanks
Do You Need
Academic Writing
or Editing Help?
Fill in one of the forms below to get professional help with your assignments:

Graduate Writing / Editing:
GraduateWriter form ◳

Best Essay Service:
CustomPapers form ◳

Excellence in Editing:
Rose Editing ◳

AI-Paper Rewriting:
Robot Rewrite ◳