"I'm normal in some ways" - Stanford supplement: letter to roommate

Hi! This is my first thread, but be as critical as you can; I give you permission to be brutal with your feedback. Here's the prompt:

Virtually all of Stanford's undergraduates live on campus. What would you want your future roommate to know about you? Tell us something about you that will help your future roommate -- and us -- know you better. (250 words minimum)

And here's my essay:
Dear Future Roommate,

It's common knowledge that every dorm room contains a normal roommate and a weird roommate, and if you don't have a weird roommate, then you are the weird roommate. However, you'll have nothing to worry about, because I will probably be the weird roommate.

I'll seem perfectly normal at first; I'll be shy, friendly, and I'll smile a lot. Don't worry; the shyness will disappear shortly after we meet. When this happens, I'll still be friendly and smile a lot, but please don't be alarmed when I pull out a ukulele and start to sing, "All the world seems in tune on a spring afternoon as we're poisoning pigeons in the park." I don't really want to murder innocent pigeons, and I do sing normal songs, too (although most of them tend to be just as quirky as Tom Lehrer's "Pigeons In The Park"). And don't be alarmed when I start to come up with terrible puns about 185 random objects walking into bars. Some of my jokes aren't so terrible, and thinking of jokes is thoroughly entertaining. My closet is in rainbow order, I like to point out Mini Coopers when I see them, and I love to crunch numbers in a world where math is the runt of the academic subject litter.

I like to think I'm normal in some ways, though. While the ukulele and jokes are important, my family and friends transcend everything else in my life. When I can, I like to snowboard and play soccer. I thoroughly enjoy art and music, as well as the occasional rock concert. I think that's enough for us to become good friends, Future Roommate.

Hope to see you soon!

Best wishes,
Rachel

Your essay is definitely cute and interesting :), but I have a small warning. Lots of stanford essays have been written in the "letter" format, and for some reason, lots of people mention the exact same things you do - the "shyness at first" then out pops a wacky personality. You don't need to start over, but I do think that in order to make the essay stronger, you need add a focus on one specific thing, perhaps one anecdote or story.

Just my two cents, some people may disagree. I wish you best of luck!

Thanks so much! I had no idea so many people were shy and wacky... but, yeah, thanks. I'll take that into account. =)

I like your essay... perhaps add more quirky details; intersperse them throughout your essay using specific references. Perhaps you might also want to make the first part more short and concise: btw, VARY YOUR WORD CHOICE. Although it's a letter to your roommate, I still feel as if you should use some carefully chosen vocabulary... thesaurus.com

Every dorm room contains a normal roommate and a weird roommate. If you don't have a strange companion, then you are "the weird one". However dearest roommate, don't worry--because I will probably be the weird roommate.

At first, I'll seem perfectly normal at first. I'll be a little shy, friendly, and I'll smile a lot. But the shyness will disappear shortly after we meet. When this happens, I'll still be friendly and smile a lot, but please don't be alarmed when I pull out a ukulele and start to sing, "All the world seems in tune on a spring afternoon as we're poisoning pigeons in the park." I don't really want to murder innocent pigeons, and I do sing normal songs, too (opposed to Tom Lehrer's "Pigeons In The Park"). And don't be alarmed when I come up with terrible jokes about 185 random objects walking into bars. Some of my wordplay isn't so terrible, and thinking of jokes is thoroughly entertaining. My closet is in rainbow order, I like to point out Mini Coopers when I see them, and I love to crunch numbers in a world where math is the not-so-popular runt of the academic litter.

I like to think I'm normal in some ways, though. While my ukulele, jokes, and academics are important, my family and friends transcend everything else in my life. When I can, I like to snowboard and play soccer. I thoroughly enjoy art and music, as well as the occasional rock concert. I hope that's enough for us to become good friends, Future Roommate.