Unanswered [1]
  

Home / Writing Feedback   % width   Posts: 5


IELTS task 2 Reading Ebooks vs watching TV and playing computer



serbinax 7 / 18  
Feb 18, 2020   #1
Some people believe that reading stories from e book better than watching TV or playing computer games for children.

To what extent do you agree or disagree?



Opinions are divided on whether reading an electronic book is a more valuable source of information than watching TV or playing computer games for children. Although nowadays television and computer games provide plenty of educational material for younger generation, I believe that reading an e book holds more advantages.

As opposed to television and computer games, reading is an activity which makes the children implement their own imagination and creativity rather than watching something that has been created for them. Furthermore, reading invokes the kids' curiosity when they encounter unfamiliar vocabulary in the text and helps them acquire knowledge about their native language when they learn the word's etymology, pronunciation and spelling.

Another reason, why e book is better than TV or games, is that reading helps children develop such skills as concentration and attention. Like any other skill, reading requires practice, and in order to fully understand the contents of the book, kids need to give their full attention to the text. It also teaches children how to predict and anticipate the development of the plot, thus building such an important skill as projecting their own future.

On the other hand, the knowledge disseminated by vivid pictures on the screen is easier to absorb by children, but the excess of colorful pictures and moving objects can distract the kids, especially the young ones, from other important tasks. Playing computer games can also be very addicting, as a result of which children fail to do well at school. Spending too much time in front of the screen can lead to developing health problems, such as shortsightedness, bad posture, etc. Therefore, reading is better for both health and effectiveness.

As a conclusion, it can be reiterated that reading an e book is a better way of learning for children than watching TV or playing computer games, as it is a more effective and healthier way to acquire new knowledge.

sou78 3 / 3  
Feb 18, 2020   #2
The prompt is if you agree or disagree. When you used (On the other hand), it seemed to me like you did a comparison between ebooks and watchig TV, and this is a completely different prompt.
Devaii 2 / 6  
Feb 18, 2020   #3
Though you were saying that ebooks were better, your tone was kinda passive. You also contradicted yourself in some parts, especially when you talked about screens are bad for eyes. Whether they're playing video games or reading an ebook, the kids will still be exposed to a screen. Also, adding a counterclaim would definitely strengthen your argument!
Holt  Educational Consultant - / 15460  
Feb 19, 2020   #4
Your response to the prompt created as prompt deviation. That means, you are not discussing the prompt based on the question asked. To make it clear, let me show you where the mistakes lie in the presentation:

OP: To what extent do you agree or disagree?
YR: I believe that reading an e book holds more advantages.


As you can see, the response should have been a measured representation of your agreement to the given statement. It was not supposed to be and advantage/disadvantage response. An example of a more appropriate response is:

I strongly agree that reading ebooks...

Due to that deviation in your response, the TA will be marked as tangential and with an inappropriate response format. It will not achieve a passing mark. Your GRA score will also suffer due to the run-on sentences in every paragraph. You failed to appropriately use complex and simple sentences in the presentation. This affected the coherence of your discussion and created an non-cohesive paragraph presentation in the process. Therefore, the essay will not achieve a passing score.
OP serbinax 7 / 18  
Feb 19, 2020   #5
@Holt
Thank you so much for your feedback, I think I can see where my mistakes are.


Home / Writing Feedback / IELTS task 2 Reading Ebooks vs watching TV and playing computer
ⓘ Need Writing or Editing Help?
Fill out one of these forms for professional help:

Best Writing Service:
CustomPapers form ◳

Graduate Writing / Editing:
GraduateWriter form ◳

Excellence in Editing:
Rose Editing ◳

AI-Paper Rewriting:
Robot Rewrite ◳