cantabile
Dec 31, 2013
Undergraduate / COLUMBIA SUPP ESSAY. Hearts and Not Family [2]
"advice"- advise
"art"- "artistic" (?)
Overall, the first essay is very well written. I really liked the repetition used with the heart thumps and the multiple examples that you used. However, (and I'm guilty of this too) maybe it's a bit too much repetition? I'm not entirely sure whether it's too much as I have the same tendency and it reads well to me, but I've heard that there's a line between effective repetition and superfluous redundancy. Regardless, I feel that the essay captures your ambition to attend Columbia.
(one last thing... I don't think the "are you?" part of the ending is really necessary as this is directed towards admissions officers)
The second essay is, again, very artistically written. If the unique structure and flow of it does not catch their eyes, I'm sure the contrast that you provide with the two mottos will. Just to address one issue:
The last sentence of the first paragraph is quite long and it took me more-than-average brain power to follow it. The admissions people will probably be too tired from reading applications to expend that power, so try to make it shorter or break it down into separate sentences.
I really liked your essays, and I'm quite sure that the admissions officers will like them too! They're unique, engaging, and show that you're a very well rounded person.
Best of luck in your application and studies!
"advice"- advise
"art"- "artistic" (?)
Overall, the first essay is very well written. I really liked the repetition used with the heart thumps and the multiple examples that you used. However, (and I'm guilty of this too) maybe it's a bit too much repetition? I'm not entirely sure whether it's too much as I have the same tendency and it reads well to me, but I've heard that there's a line between effective repetition and superfluous redundancy. Regardless, I feel that the essay captures your ambition to attend Columbia.
(one last thing... I don't think the "are you?" part of the ending is really necessary as this is directed towards admissions officers)
The second essay is, again, very artistically written. If the unique structure and flow of it does not catch their eyes, I'm sure the contrast that you provide with the two mottos will. Just to address one issue:
The last sentence of the first paragraph is quite long and it took me more-than-average brain power to follow it. The admissions people will probably be too tired from reading applications to expend that power, so try to make it shorter or break it down into separate sentences.
I really liked your essays, and I'm quite sure that the admissions officers will like them too! They're unique, engaging, and show that you're a very well rounded person.
Best of luck in your application and studies!