Unanswered [1]
  

Home / Undergraduate   % width   Posts: 7


Common App Essay—Grandfather's watch



vamin007 1 / -  
Oct 17, 2024   #1
Hi I am just looking for feedback on my common app essay. I have had other people look at but I would like a variety of perspectives.

A small, sleek metal frame: cool to the touch, reflecting any light that beams toward it. The dial, layered with monochrome components; a black face, textured like bubblewrap; 12 thin metal bars; 48 smaller white strips, each marking the small increments of the hour; three hands, each one synchronously tracking time's endless flow. The back: "SEIKO"; "WATER RESISTANT"; "ST STEEL BACK"; "JAPAN A"; scratches scarred the text. This relic, passed down to me after my grandfather's passing, holds a 50-year-old legacy. As I admired its intricate beauty, I couldn't help but wonder: How much is it worth?

It was fake.

My heart was disappointed, yet I wondered why my grandfather had a fake watch. Was he scammed into paying hundreds for the watch? Did he buy the watch just because it looked nice? Was he aware that it was fake? My mother told me he was sent it as a graduation gift from his brother, yet I never saw him wear it.

Why didn't he wear the watch when he died? Why did my mother not remember the piece until it was discovered in his closet? Why didn't we put it in his coffin before he was cremated? The watch had been with him throughout his entire life, yet it wasn't with him when his time ended.

My grandfather was a massive fan of fashion, in every photo he took he had the watch on. I couldn't blame him, it was a good watch. The watch traveled with him for at least 40 years. Keeping track of every single moment in his life.

I saw photos of him wearing the watch. He was with college friends, employees, his wife, and daughters. The watch walked with him through his graduation, sat on his wrist during his interviews, and was pointless when he spent time with family because he would lose track of time.

When I discovered the watch, its battery was dead, reminding us that his time had ended. I replaced the battery, letting it tick and track a new lifetime.

I rarely wore the watch daily, scared I would damage or dirty it. I would only wear it to important events: interviews, exams, celebrations, family reunions, and the SAT. I even wore it on my first date-which took place in a movie theater. The cool touch of the watch kept my body from getting hot, his spirit reminded me that I wasn't alone. All of the moments I wore the watch, I shared them with him. Yet I have only lived a fifth of my entire life.

As I look into the future, as the second hand continues to tick, my grandfather will be there. Graduations, interviews, my wedding: my grandfather will be watching me. Each glance at the watch will continue to remind me of the resilience and patience he and I embody throughout our lives. In recent years, I feel that I have become more like him-hungry for knowledge, reading books and magazines just to learn about the world I live in. As I step into the next chapter of my life, whether it is navigating college or pursuing a career, I will carry the values that my grandfather had- hard work, humility, and persistence. I do not only seek academic and career growth but personal growth too. I do not want to only achieve personal success but also carry forward my grandfather's legacy and principles, sharing them with others along my journey.

But, everyone runs out of time.

When the time is right, my child will inherit the family jewel. It will not just be a shiny accessory, but a keeper of wisdom, values, and memories. My grandfather and I will be with whoever harnesses the watch. Whenever they cross the stage during graduation, we-I-will be with them.

The morals and principles of my grandfather were carried through the watch and passed to me; the morals and principles of me will be carried through the watch and passed to my child; the morals and principles of my child will be carried through the watch and passed to my grandchild. The watch holds more than just time-it holds a legacy.

Holt  Educational Consultant - / 15460  
Oct 18, 2024   #2
I have to tell you that I cannot review this for validity in terms of responding to the common app prompt. You did not give the writing guide topic that you were supposed to be explaining about using this narrative so my comments will be general and focused on what I know regarding the point of view of the reviewers.

The essay focuses too much on the watch and your grandfather. It barely focuses on you and the actual experience that the watch relates to in terms of your development or point of view as a person or new owner of the watch. For that reason, I believe that the reviewer will not be interested in pursuing the content of this essay beyond the first paragraph. You lost his interest totally by the second paragraph where you failed to refocus the essay on yourself. The essay is all about your grandfather instead of you. Being deceased and not the applicant for admission, he should not have factored so heavily in this presentation.
molnardebora 1 / 3  
Nov 1, 2024   #3
Hello! The essay should focus more on you. While it's nice to talk about your grandfather, after reading it for a while, I wonder when the section about you will begin.Good luck on your essay!!
milan123 2 / 5  
Nov 2, 2024   #4
your essay has a poetic tone that is right for your objective. You have maintained a natural flow with a perfect blend of poetery.
essaycheck24 3 / 4  
Nov 3, 2024   #5
You should focus more on youself, especially on your personal growth. Good Luck!
gigi_aa 3 / 6  
Nov 3, 2024   #6
I love the way you write. It's fun and enjoyable. however, I agree with the other commenters that your essay focuses more on the watch rather than on you. Be economical with your descriptions. You only have 650 words, so spend more time conveying your relationship to the watch rather than the watch itself.
woodg 4 / 8  
Nov 3, 2024   #7
@vamin007
It is definitely engaging. That said, I agree with the other commenters: your essay should focus primarily on you. With only 650 words, consider trimming down the descriptions and dedicating more space to exploring your connection with the watch.


Home / Undergraduate / Common App Essay—Grandfather's watch
ⓘ Need Writing or Editing Help?
Fill out one of these forms for professional help:

Best Writing Service:
CustomPapers form ◳

Graduate Writing / Editing:
GraduateWriter form ◳

Excellence in Editing:
Rose Editing ◳

AI-Paper Rewriting:
Robot Rewrite ◳