Unanswered [2] | Urgent [0]
  

Home / Undergraduate   % width   Posts: 3


"the Viet Cong soldiers" - stanford- intellectually engaging... help on editing!



jennjenn 1 / -  
Oct 10, 2010   #1
hey everyone,

okay so a few information about me. in my high school, i'm used to writing with descriptive language in my essays. however the college application essays come with characters limit and tough prompts so my first try may sound bland or an overkill. anyway, feel free to to be a tough critic!

and thanks in advance!!

prompt #1: Stanford students are widely known to possess a sense of intellectual vitality. Tell us about an idea or an experience you have had that you find intellectually engaging.

my essay:

I close my eyes and simply thought that I will get out of this gloomy place soon. Already, I was feeling tired and sweaty. The burning pain in my knees strengthened within each step. My hands were screaming in agony as I rummage my way along the sharp rocks. Dust filled the air, threatening to suffocate me. Ahead was just plain black. A small light flickered yet my consciousness could not detect it. Soon, a huge meaty hand reached out of the darkness and swiftly lifted me out from below. Blinking at the incandescent light, I looked up to the man who had brought the end to my misery. I was never able to ascertain how long I was underground. A mere ten minutes, yet it felt an eternity before I could expect daylight. Within a moment, my knees gave way and I was on the ground. Slowly, I drifted away from the living.

I opened my eyes and here I am. Staring at the computer screen, my fingers were itching to continue on typing. I sighed, relax into my chair and simply recount my experience. In retrospective, my journey through the Cu Chi tunnel, one of the famous underground passageways, was nerve racking. I was young when my parents bought me there so I couldn't understand why the Viet Cong soldiers would make their homes deep into the Earth. But now I do, because somehow my situation is similar to theirs. They fought for their homeland while they had flimsy weapons as I am fighting for my education while I have profound hearing loss. Despite their disadvantage, the Viet Cong soldiers kept their determination. In simple words, this experience taught me of what kind of attitude I should have when fighting for my future; putting my heart and soul into the battle that awaits me in college.

zengrz - / 89  
Oct 11, 2010   #2
Hi.

The opening imagery is well written, descriptive and sophisticated in language. However, like the impression I get from many other descriptions I have read, I feel that it is a little bit exaggerated and unclear. Also, it takes up too much space, which can be more well spent writing about the "intellectual challenge" that you have faced. The analogy between Viet Cong and you is interesting, but in what way are you challenged? I think the essay can be much clearer if you are able to point out the challenge and work on it, instead of describing the recount.

In retrospective

I think "in retrospect" would be enough.

G L~
EF_Kevin 8 / 13053  
Oct 14, 2010   #3
Past verb tense:
closed
rummaged

Soon, a huge meaty hand reached out of the darkness and swiftly lifted me out from below. Blinking at the incandescent light, I looked up to the man who had brought the end to my misery. ---- excellent!!! Very good writing

I was never able to ascertain how long I had been underground.

I opened my eyes and here I am.

I really like this sentence, but in order to keep the tense consistent with the rest of the essay, make it past tense:
I opened my eyes and there I was.

:-)


Home / Undergraduate / "the Viet Cong soldiers" - stanford- intellectually engaging... help on editing!
Do You Need
Academic Writing
or Editing Help?
Need professional help with your assignments? Fill out one of these forms:

Graduate Writing / Editing:
GraduateWriter form ◳

Best Essay Service:
CustomPapers form ◳

Excellence in Editing:
Rose Editing ◳

AI-Paper Rewriting:
Robot Rewrite ◳