ironhand
Aug 10, 2014
Undergraduate / "From East to West" - Common App event/experience Essay [5]
Hi. Alas, English is not my first language, so I will try to comment from the position of pure logic:
1) The part that describes your feelings before and during the move is a bit too long. The question was about accoplishment/event, so, IMHO, it would be better to tell more about YOUR actions and positive changes in your character (this part is slightly vague).
2) The essay is too much self-critical. "Spoiled, timid girl" really sounds unwell. I had similar problem in the MIT essay "What attribute of your personality are you most proud of?"
3) The main problem: original question was about transition from childhood to adulthood. Your essay tells about changes, caused by move, but it would be better to add more about that part where you describe your accomplishments.
Sorry if it was too harsh. I think the essay is good by itself, but it needs certain editing.
Hi. Alas, English is not my first language, so I will try to comment from the position of pure logic:
1) The part that describes your feelings before and during the move is a bit too long. The question was about accoplishment/event, so, IMHO, it would be better to tell more about YOUR actions and positive changes in your character (this part is slightly vague).
2) The essay is too much self-critical. "Spoiled, timid girl" really sounds unwell. I had similar problem in the MIT essay "What attribute of your personality are you most proud of?"
3) The main problem: original question was about transition from childhood to adulthood. Your essay tells about changes, caused by move, but it would be better to add more about that part where you describe your accomplishments.
Sorry if it was too harsh. I think the essay is good by itself, but it needs certain editing.