Unanswered [5] | Urgent [0]
  

Posts by Mick
Joined: Dec 29, 2010
Last Post: Jan 5, 2011
Threads: 3
Posts: 13  
From: United States

Displayed posts: 16
sort: Oldest first   Latest first  | 
Mick   
Dec 29, 2010
Undergraduate / "discussions about anything from Plato to quantum physics" - Columbia Supplement [6]

Well, I'll tell you that this beats my supplement. All I talked about was how great Columbia was, but not so much why I deserved to go there. Guess that's why I didn't get in.

So this is pretty good; it's personal, but it also shows that you have knowledge of Columbia's curriculum. Perhaps you could scratch the Asian community part to avoid creating any unpleasant stereotypes and just talk about how that was just your family's attitude. If you're trying to sneak in your ethnic background into the essay, I don't think it matters too much since that's already in the CommonApp. But if your ethnicity means that much to you, perhaps you could include it in a way that doesn't create a stereotype. All in all though, I'll give it a 4/5.
Mick   
Dec 30, 2010
Undergraduate / Technically undecided + the "universe" in university + paternal grandfather NYU short [4]

Please tell us what led you to select both your anticipated academic area(s) of study and the NYU school / college / program or the Abu Dhabi campus. What interests you most about your intended discipline? Mention any extracurricular or non-school-related activities or experiences that demonstrate your interest.

Though I'm technically undecided, I can see myself exploring Linguistics, Journalism, and International Relations, among others, at NYU. My forte lies in the humanities: As a member of the school newspaper and the school's literary magazine, I discovered a knack for artfully conveying ideas through the tip of my pen. I love culture, as I'm a Pakistani-American and a part of the World Language Honor Society. NYU would be the perfect place for me to accentuate my understanding of the world.

NYU is 'In and of the City' and 'In and of the World.' What does the concept of a global network university mean to you? How do you think studying in New York City, Abu Dhabi, or one of NYU's global sites would change you as a person and equip you to build cross-cultural relationships at NYU and beyond?

A university would be an oxymoron if it limited itself to one area. NYU most definitely emphasizes the "universe" in university. Above all, that's what I look for in a university. How can a school be taken seriously if it's not open to all types of people? New York City alone is cultural, but nothing can match the web of learning which NYU has built all over the globe. If I were to attend NYU, I would promptly seize the opportunity to study abroad and be a part of a truly universal university.

If you had the opportunity to bring any person -- past or present, fictional or nonfictional -- to a place that is special to you (your hometown or country, a favorite location, etc), who would you bring and why? Tell us what you would share with that person.

My paternal grandfather died in Peshawar, Pakistan the year I was born. All I know of him comes from stories and a small picture. If I could show him New York City, Times Square, and how far the world has come, that the grandson of a small village man can make something of himself in America, I'm sure that would've meant a great deal to him. I'd let him know how much his son (my father) sacrificed to make me what I am, and I hope he'd be proud of where I have reached and where I am going.

Comments on any of these would be greatly appreciated!
Mick   
Dec 30, 2010
Undergraduate / NASA spacesuit Cornell Engineering Supplemental [15]

This is definitely a good idea for your essay, and if your essay doesn't turn out marvelous, I suspect that you'll still get in based on your other merits. A few critiques about the writing. It seems like you're doing more "telling" than "showing". Create a story. You did that well in the first two paragraphs, but in the last two you focus a bit more on something that you might just put on a resume. Try to incorporate NASA's interest with you more in the story. However, I still think that just the fact that NASA was interested with you will give you a lot of help. Good luck!
Mick   
Dec 30, 2010
Undergraduate / UPenn - "What do you see yourself exploring?" Supplemental Essay [6]

You definitely know your stuff about UPenn, and from what I hear that's the main thing this kind of essay is looking for. They want to know how interested you are in their school, and you showed that pretty well. Nice job!

I think a slight rearrangement of the first paragraph would do some good. I understand you're trying to set the essay up with a small anecdote, but it seems a bit too colloquial. It's good to be conversational to a point, but try to do it in a more captivating way.
Mick   
Dec 30, 2010
Undergraduate / THE RAPPING ICONOCLAST: BROWN SUPPLEMENT (INTELLECTUAL EXPERIENCE) [9]

The Rapping Iconoclast

Yips and yells, ruckus and racket; noise surged through the ring of teenagers standing outside the school. Garbed in heavy hoods and doubtful countenances, they formed an audience around the quiet Pakistani boy. A "Shh!" quelled the tumult. No one knew what to expect. I, the Pakistani boy, the "quiet smart kid", stood center stage for everyone to see. I cleared my throat and said "Drop the beat". Someone near me clasped a fist to their mouth and began to beatbox. My head bobbed, my feet tapped. I allowed myself to flow through the beat like a raft down a river. I spit a fire so heated, lit up the entire street, electrified the beat. I refused to accept defeat, refused to be let torn. I transformed from something diffident to a completely different storm.

Freestyle rapping isn't something I ever expected to do. Raised in a traditional Muslim American family, the art of rap was hardly a concern of my parents. However, I had grown up in a neighborhood where the sounds of characteristically "black" music radiated from the street gravel. I began rapping at age eleven, memorizing lyrics in the shower and before I went to sleep. Rap became a ritualistic pastime. Before I knew it, I began "spitting rhymes" without any preparation. I was an oddity, a paradox: the scrawny bookworm who spoke little but rapped a lot. I became an unlikely bridge between two groups. In meek study groups I was one person, and amongst the tough crew I was another. I wield the art of rap in a different hand than most do. Rap is a branch of poetry, a medium through which I can release aggression and stress without raising a fist. I refrain from using profanity, but the tough spirit which accompanies the culture remains in my lyrics. Rap relates to my passion for crafting words and stories. It is an instrument through which I try to understand those I'm different from. It is a tool on which I can sharpen my mind, train myself to focus and think quicker. To me, rap is a birthmark, a scar, a scintillating banner of individuality I hold above society. The banner reads "I am a Muslim, I am an American, and I am more."

My affinity for hip-hop is a hobby, yes, but I've come to appreciate my strange knack for wordplay primarily because it does not suit me. I proudly choose to debunk the caricatures which define some members of our society. Diversity is my weapon of choice when it comes to shattering stereotypes. Rap doesn't have to be typified by greed, drugs and disrespect toward women. It can provide for insightful social commentary, if given the chance. To use words to destroy the barriers which clutter our society, that is why I continue to rap: to fit in and to stick out, to understand while changing understanding. One word rings loud and clear through the beat my heart bumps to: Iconoclast.

I'd really like a critique of this: structural, grammatical, topical, etc. I also have a few questions I need answered:

- Do you think the essay answers the prompt?
- Does the essay need a title?
- When I send the actual document, does the prompt need to be IN the actual document?
- The word limit is 500 words, and I'm just under that by two words. Any ideas on how to cut down?

I think I took a risk with this essay and would really like a critique. Thank you!
Mick   
Dec 31, 2010
Undergraduate / "Happiness is relative, truth is absolute, randomness is awkward" - Rice Perspective [6]

"Ashish, I enjoy eating the Indian food that my mom cooks, I like drawing, painting, and taking photos. I write poems when I am stressed and I enjoy that too . I love to debate and biology is my favorite subj-" Maybe add in something you like that is unique to you? A lot of people like to draw and take photos and like biology. Is there a special talent or interest that you have that no one else you know has?

"Well, Ashish" He - err - I replied, slightly annoyed that I interrupted myself- If you're trying to make this humorous, you can leave it the way it is. But I think the whole talking to yourself thing works fine without you acknowledging that you're doing it lol.

I like the whole talking to yourself idea. I don't think it's been done before. It seems a bit long in some areas. The one paragraph where you talk about what you're proud of just seems to be a resume in paragraph form. Try to add stuff that is special to you that you couldn't put on a resume or a college application. Personality is the purpose of a college essay. Otherwise, I like the idea. Good Luck!

Anyone care to read my Brown Supplement??
Mick   
Jan 3, 2011
Undergraduate / "PAST AND FUTURE" - CORNELL CAS SUPPLEMENT [3]

I need to send this out asap, but it's 40 words above the 500 limit. Any ideas on cutting down??

Cornell College of Arts and Sciences Supplement:

Past. Future. The former haunts us with its solidity, the latter taunts us with its ambiguity. They are immortal twins of time, playing tug of war with the troubled middle child, the Present. It's constantly moving forward, yet constantly running away from us. What seems to be a nebulous future can become an adamant past in just a few moments. I used to lay for hours and hours in a state of pensiveness in my bed, trying my best to rearrange the past in my dreams. I had hesitated from opening my mouth and saying something that would later embarrass me. Michael Jackson had hired a different doctor to help him prepare for his tour. The terrorists boarding American Airlines Flight 11 and United Airlines Flight 175 just missed their flight. Each night I slumbered with the satisfaction that the past might be different when I woke up, and each day I'd awake to find it was just the same. I was so preoccupied with the past I had imagined in my head that I neglected the present, and my perception of reality was in turmoil. What I didn't want to believe had never happened, and what I wanted to happen I believed in.

Criticism is appreciated, but I really need to know how to cut it down. Thanks!
Mick   
Jan 3, 2011
Undergraduate / "Life full of hardships to make me mature" - Hawaii Pacific Personal Statement [5]

The tumor that was thought to of< have been removed had grown back even stronger than before, strong enough that she couldn't fight back.

I believed she was there and would help me to keep moving on. T

I was seriously depressed till the age of ten and by this time I was already in a new place. < You sort of already said this in the previous paragraph.

I met new friends who changed my life more than ever, friends who I was able to express myself tooto , friends who would listen to me.

I am a content man with many interests in life and eager to explore the world. Walter Bagehot, a famous British Analyst, once said, "The pleasure in life is doing what people say you cannot do". It's a code I will always live by and one I try and show others.... [STUCK HERE as well I don't know what else to add any suggestions?]

* I guess you can talk about how your experience makes you good for the school you're applying to. That would be a good way to tie everything up.

Does anyone care to take a look at my Cornell Supplement???
Mick   
Jan 3, 2011
Undergraduate / "PAST AND FUTURE" - CORNELL CAS SUPPLEMENT [3]

I was so preoccupied with the past I had created that I neglected the present, and my perception of reality was in turmoil. If I didn't want to believe it, it never happened, and if I wanted it to happen, I believed it.

... the terrorists boarding American Airlines Flight 11 and United Airlines Flight 175 just missed their flight. Each night I slumbered hoping the past might be different when ...

... that I neglected the present. My perception of reality was in turmoil. If I didn't want to believe it, it never happened. If I wanted it to happen, I believed it.

Then, I picked up a book called Watchmen, written by Alan Moore. At first it looked like a glorified bif-bam comic book for adults, but I found a timeless philosophy hiding under the inking of the character Dr. Manhattan. "There is no future," said the doctor, "There is no past. Time is simultaneous, an intricately structured jewel that humans insist on viewing one edge at a time, when the whole design is visible in every facet." A revelation was heralded to me through those words: The past is unattainable. We cannot write its book, only read it and learn from it. After the fact, it is nothing but a reference point from which we paint the portrait of the future. All I have the power to do is continue moving forward and make sure the future has fewer blemishes than the past. I plan to make no mistakes. At Cornell I can have fun incubating my creativity, but also be comfortable knowing my education can help me make a difference in the world. Majors such as English, Linguistics and Government offer me the chance to accentuate my talent with words and language and wield them as instruments to unite the people of the world. If I want something, I must seize the opportunity before it passes, and the opportunities at Cornell's College of Arts and Sciences appeal most to me.

Dr. Manhattan had the power to see the future; I have the privilege to make it. What Cornell can do for me is provide me with the materials to solidify my desires: to use my way with words to become the best writer I can be. All I can hope to do is embed my writing with a spark of inspiration, like the sort I found in Watchmen. "The whole design is visible in every facet". To see this whole design- the world's design, that's what calls me to Cornell. The past is behind me, and Cornell is the future.

This is the fully revised version, down to 498 words. Any comments, because I'm about to send this out..
Mick   
Jan 3, 2011
Undergraduate / "I heard about anthropology" - Cornell supplement essay [2]

And that is exactly what I saw in anthropology; diversity rather than repetitiveness

I find this academic field an option to gain as much knowledge, wouldn't the word opportunity go better then option?

Good stuff though, and you share similar sentiments to me. In fact, I'm also applying to Cornell College of Arts and Sciences. Can you read my essay (linked below) ??
Mick   
Jan 5, 2011
Scholarship / "Growing up math" - Gates Millennum - Subject you had difficulty in [7]

Is this supposed to be one paragraph? If not, may I suggest you try to separate it into at least two?
Otherwise not bad. I have one question: how many essays are required for the Gates scholarship, and do they all have to be around this length??

Also, could you look at my Cornell Supplement (It's already been sent in, but I'd like an opinion on it).
Mick   
Jan 5, 2011
Scholarship / "A leader must have courage, credibility, and innovation" [6]

There are those mean meant to follow, to do what their told, and live safely.

Sort of seems wrong to say some people were made to follow.

Good organization, but seems a little stiff. Try to make it a bit more personal, maybe? What leadership means to you, your experience with it, stuff like that.
Need Writing or Editing Help?
Fill out one of these forms:

Graduate Writing / Editing:
GraduateWriter form ◳

Best Essay Service:
CustomPapers form ◳

Excellence in Editing:
Rose Editing ◳

AI-Paper Rewriting:
Robot Rewrite ◳

Academic AI Writer:
Custom AI Writer ◳