Unanswered [5] | Urgent [0]
  

Posts by twilista
Joined: Dec 5, 2011
Last Post: Dec 18, 2011
Threads: 3
Posts: 13  
From: USA

Displayed posts: 16
sort: Oldest first   Latest first  | 
twilista   
Dec 5, 2011
Undergraduate / 'Come. I want to show you a story - My Athena' - Common App Standard [6]

Will someone please give me constructive criticism on my essay? It'd be a great help!

The prompt of this is about a person who influenced your life.

"Little one, lại đây. Come. I want to show you a story," My uncle said one day as I clambered out of my small boat. Uncle was a man of little words, so it was peculiar for him to ask me to sit with him. Slightly wary, I gave him a quick bow of respect and proceeded to fold up my legs, tentatively awaiting for whatever he had to say.

His story was about Triệu Thị Trinh, a female warrior in 3rd century AD. At a young age, she had a fiery spirit and contagious passion that women had always been discouraged from in the asian culture. She broke boundaries and embraced her rebellious nature as she planned a revolt against the Wu Kingdom simply because she was able to acknowledge her potential. When her "wild" actions were questioned, she merely stated these famous words that would be immortalized in numerous history books: "I only want to ride the wind and walk the waves, slay the big whales of the Eastern sea, clean up frontiers and save people from drowning. Why should I imitate others, bow my head, stoop over and be a slave? Why resign myself?"

After that day, her words etched themselves into my mind. I remember myself sitting on the cold, concrete floor of my grandparent's old home in Vietnam, sifting through the yellowed pages of my grandfather's school notes while my cousins were busy perfecting their phở bắc recipes. I remember experiencing the grand splendor of the ancient Nguyen Dynasty palaces while the others shopped through the congested markets for fabric to craft into perfectly tailored pants. I remember how my thirst for knowledge and success puzzled my Aunts and cousins since "young girls were supposed to focus on taking care of their families, not stuffing their noses into books". Most of all, I remember pushing the boundaries and limitations of the potential I knew I had, just as Trinh had done. I didn't want a white-picket fence at the end of a cul-de-sac to help me culture my domestic skills. I wanted to pursue a route that would satiate my desire for knowledge and open up opportunities that would lead me anywhere but the confinements of a housewife's home.

I embrace the fact that I have deviated myself from the expectations of my culture by indulging in my intellectual studies. Society's unspoken rules are merely obstacles that I know I can overcome in order to achieve my highest potential. Although I may not be a female warrior fighting against a kingdom, I know I am a first generation student that is dedicated to her passion for knowledge and success, despite the great expectations of society.
twilista   
Dec 5, 2011
Undergraduate / 'heading for Egypt' + 'working at 7-Eleven' - significant risk [3]

The first one definitely sheds a lot more light about who you are, although I do think it needs to be cut down on size. You really want to get to the core of your story, the main point that you want to get across to the admissions officers. If you waste your words on meaningless details, however, admissions officers will be more likely to reject you. Remember, keep it short and concise! These kinds of essays tend to be the ones that admissions officers love, especially since they have more impact. The second one I felt was too much of a generic topic and doesn't really shed light on who you are. Yes, you are a person of good morals, but so are many other students that apply. What sets you apart? What makes you different? Those are the questions you need to ask yourself.
twilista   
Dec 5, 2011
Undergraduate / Common App to Kenyon Vassar and Wesleyan - my relationship with my mom [4]

This has the potential to be a very powerful piece. I think that you should focus the essay more about how your mom's relationship has made you grow and how this growth affects the decisions you make in life. Yes, the emotions are definitely being stirred in this piece, but focus more on who YOU are not who your mother stopped you from being.

At one point in the essay, you questioned who you were. Tell the admissions officer who exactly that is now.
twilista   
Dec 11, 2011
Undergraduate / 'Seeing the World Through Sand' - Common App Short Extracurricular Essay [7]

Will someone please help me with my common app short essay (it's the one where you elaborate on your extracurriculars)? I'm having an extremely difficult time with it, especially since it's 1000 characters max. I don't know if this essay fully conveys who I am and how sand animation has improved me. Your help would be much appreciated!

I tell stories. Not in the conventional way, however. Not with spoken words or written sentences. No, I tell my stories through sand.
Sand animation has allowed me to experience the world through different perspectives. Each time I sit at my light board and begin to draw, I live vicariously through my characters. I've been a 1920's flapper whose greed eventually tears her apart at the seams, a 5-year-old Korean boy whose war torn country took away everything he ever had, and even a concierge clerk who's met people from all walks of the earth, but has never ventured further than her New York City apartment. As I transition from each scene to the next, my characters teach me how it feels to lose, desire, and have. They teach me how to take different perspectives from the same problem and find a solution from what I've learned. They teach me how to make bonds with individuals and how to connect with strangers. But most of all, they teach me how to create and use what they taught me to show to others.
twilista   
Dec 11, 2011
Undergraduate / 'Persian-American' + 'The sneaker game' - Tufts is my dream school [4]

I think that the first one is very good and you should definitely submit it! The second, however, needs a lot of work. I feel as though you're wasting a lot of the space with the first paragraph and you only really answer the prompt with your last sentence. You don't exactly tell the reader how your personality changed/evolved nor do you tell the reader how devaluing aesthetics changes your personal outlook. Yes, you may not care about your "kicks" anymore, but did your Buddhist principles change the way you view the world? Did it make you realize that the world was too wrapped up in aesthetics and should therefore live a life that's based solely on the journey itself? Should all materials be done away with so that you can experience the true meaning of why we're here? Ask yourself questions like these, and you'll be able to write a great essay.
twilista   
Dec 11, 2011
Undergraduate / 'old African folklore' - UPenn optional essay [8]

This was a very good essay. I like how you compared yourself to the tree. One thing that I am wondering, however, is how do the African folklore and tree relate to of your background/talents/identity? While the story may guide your day-to-day experiences, is it actually a part of your background or identity?
twilista   
Dec 11, 2011
Undergraduate / "Fervor and Fire" - Stanford Supplement essays [3]

On the first essay, I think you can definitely cut a whole chunk of the beginning off. It's not really necessary, and you should be focusing more on how the main part of the experience has been important to you.

I personally think the second essay is fine! As for the third essay, I'd say that the only advice I have for you is to make sure you definitely keep it personal and make sure that the admissions officers gets to know as much of you as he/she can!
twilista   
Dec 11, 2011
Undergraduate / Dicrimination with haircuts-rochester supplement [2]

Although you technically did answer what they asked you, don't forget about the beginning of the prompt! They state the University's motto and continual improvement for a reason. Did the fact that you resolved this issue and stood up for yourself help you to continue to improve as a person? If so, how?
twilista   
Dec 11, 2011
Undergraduate / 'history is a perforce' - Cornell Essay [5]

This essay is very well written! I think you did a great job of relating how you will utilize Cornell to pursue your interests. I truly think that you have hit every part of the prompt and provided specific examples to show your passion for history. I also happen to love the beginning part of your essay! It really does show me how history excites you (I happen to love history myself so I was able to identify with it). Great job!
twilista   
Dec 18, 2011
Undergraduate / 'Blue, Gold, and FTR Spectrometers' - Why Notre Dame [5]

Hi everyone! It'd be fantastic if you could help me revise this essay. It's the standard "Why Notre Dame" essay and is supposed to be a max of 1500 characters so I don't have much room to experiment. I feel as though my essay isn't personal or creative, but yet again I know these are the kind of essays where they want to see what you'd contribute/do in the college's community.

It's the blue and gold that's splattered on the cheering faces of Notre Dame students as they wear "The Shirt" to the football games. It's the extensive alumni network and the trees the sweep the edges of the breathtaking grotto. It's reasons like these that further intensify my desire to attend Notre Dame.

As an aspiring doctor and prospective biology major, those aren't the only reasons why I want to attend Notre Dame. At Notre Dame, I know I can pursue my ambitions. It's constantly progressing as a school and making the necessary adjustments in order to revolutionize the way its students will administer their research in the modern age. It has facilities, such as Jordan Hall, where I'd be able to conduct my studies in a setting that mirrors the setting of an experienced researcher's laboratory. It's one of the only places where I could use a FTIR to determine molecular bonds in a compound and then have the privilege to head over to Nieuwland Hall to use the NMR Spectrometers to study the same compound at an atomic level. Notre Dame offers endless possibilities, possibilities that will help me thrive as a student and possibilities that can't be found anywhere else.
twilista   
Dec 18, 2011
Undergraduate / My passion in politics - Common App essay [3]

I'm not much of an editor, but I can definitely give you advice on your content. I thought it was very good and very well written. The only critique that I have is I think the first paragraph can definitely go or at least be shortened dramatically. I know you were trying to hook the reader in with imagery, but you want to waste as little space as possible. You can definitely shorten that paragraph to two lines in order to focus on the main point of your essay.
twilista   
Dec 18, 2011
Undergraduate / 'The more united the members' - What does community mean to you? [3]

I had ignored the tooth ache since the cavity was in the smallest of my molars.(I'd change this sentence. It sounds awkward when reading it.

"I have a whole thirty teeth to do the eating. What's the rush?' I kept consoling myself. <---I'd change consoling. It doesn't sound like it belongs.

This ended last week when even onemy meals had become impossible due to the excruciating pain. <--- Specify "this". It'd make it easier to read.

However much bigger and healthier the other thirty were, their shared task, chewing, had become unattainable due to this minute tooth. <--- Again, an issue with the word choice. You want to pick words that flow with the essay, not ones that may impress the reader.

The teeth form an entity of their own in which each individual is equally valuable. They easily work together despite their various structures because they have a structure that holds them together: the gum. Otherwise, they cannot keep together, and as a result lose a sense of purpose. The closer they are, the better they work and the more beautiful a person's smile. I like this analogy. In all honesty, I think you should focus more on this part of the essay. When you add this part, however, it makes the beginning seem somewhat irrelevant.

To me, a community is like teeth. It is a group of people who feel each other's pain and carry each other's burdens. One's community is that which gives one a sense of belonging. These people share the same dream, needs, and to some extent, fears. They not only contain and withstand each other's weaknesses but also compliment each other's strengths. A community is an entity of its own in which the members are interdependent. The more united the members, the more successful a community is. The part that I highlighted in red needs to be changed. It sounds awkward. I'd also add something at the end about teeth, just so you can tie everything together.

hope I helped! good luck on your college endeavors :)
twilista   
Dec 18, 2011
Writing Feedback / GOVERNMENT SHOULD FOCUSMORE ON PREVENTIVE HEALTH [3]

Never start an essay by saying "I would definitely say agree with this statement". You want to hook the reader, not directly answer the question as though you're engaging in a conversation with someone. There are also numerous grammar and spelling mistakes that can easily be fixed with spell check. In all honesty, I'd definitely read this over in order to catch all the mistakes since the mistakes should be easy to catch by anyone. The sentences aren't coherent and it's really hard to understand what you're trying to convey. Also, the prompt is a very debatable statement, and your facts/statements aren't strong enough to support your thesis. Yes, an education campaign would help and educate the "illetrate", but I feel as though it's not a strong enough point to make. Tell the reader WHY the government should focus more on preventive health, not what they could do. It's very important to understand what the prompt is asking.

hope i helped and please don't think I was being too harsh! :)
Need Writing or Editing Help?
Fill out one of these forms:

Graduate Writing / Editing:
GraduateWriter form ◳

Best Essay Service:
CustomPapers form ◳

Excellence in Editing:
Rose Editing ◳

AI-Paper Rewriting:
Robot Rewrite ◳

Academic AI Writer:
Custom AI Writer ◳