Unanswered [2]
  

Posts by EF_Simone
Name: Writer
Joined: May 19, 2009
Last Post: Oct 4, 2009
Threads: 2
Posts: 1974  
From: USA

Displayed posts: 1976 / page 33 of 50
sort: Latest first   Oldest first  | 
EF_Simone   
Jul 18, 2009
Undergraduate / "We the People" - Undergrad Admissions Essay for Ivies? Critique =) [29]

A quick note: Look up the meaning of surreal. Is that really what you mean? I suspect that, like many people, you mean "unreal" but are saying "surreal" because it sounds cooler. But doing so flags you as somebody who doesn't know what the word really means -- not a good impression to make in an admissions essay.
EF_Simone   
Jul 17, 2009
Book Reports / The Fountainhead (Written for an Essay Contest) [8]

Noto, I'd not have thought you to be an Ayn Rand fan.

I'm not sure how to critique this essay. If you're submitting in for the contest, you've got to write as though you embrace the philosophy in the book and refrain from critiquing it in the way you might if you were writing for another purpose.

It does seem to me that, to win such a contest, you need to say something other than what is usually said about the book while at the same time keeping in mind the fact that the judges probably will be looking for essays that conform to Rand's philosophy.
EF_Simone   
Jul 17, 2009
Essays / "The opportunity to teach something you know" - GED Prep Class Essay help [5]

Or, you could follow up the thesis sentence that Sean provided not by saying why you want to teach that but by actually teaching your reader. Indeed, your instructor may be wanted to see informative, rather than persuasive, writing for this assignment.

What are three key things people need to know to take better photos? Devote a paragraph to each of those, say something in the introduction and conclusion about the joys and benefits of photography, and you're set.
EF_Simone   
Jul 17, 2009
Undergraduate / 'in disbelief and shock after our win' - University of Florida essay [24]

hey i fixed all the gramatical errors that SEAN showed me

A couple more:

"Everybody contributed ideas and, after what seemed like a century of trial and error, we finally had a good idea on how we were going to build our robot."

"This is the type of behavior I will bring to University of Florida, an analytic mind that will push itself further by studying and trying my best in everything I apply myself."

As I have pointed out before, an analytic mind is not a type of behavior. This mismatch between the introductory clause and the subject of the sentence is a grammatical error.
EF_Simone   
Jul 17, 2009
Undergraduate / Discipline, resolution, perfection. - Common App 150 word essay [9]

I disagree with Sean. The opening is the strongest part of the essay. Do make the rest of the essay fit with it but do not repeat do not cut the part that will make you stand out from the crowd... perpendicular flute, silence floating down: wonderful, memorable images.

Grammar: Notice how the intro is all in present tense, which give it a sense of immediately, but then shifts to the past tense for the last line (It was time...).
EF_Simone   
Jul 17, 2009
Writing Feedback / CBEST: The Age of Invention [6]

Again, if you are younger than fifty, say "I have a different lifestyle than I would have had fifty years ago." If you are older than fifty and describing an actual rather than hypothetical change, say "I have a different lifestyle now than fifty years ago."
EF_Simone   
Jul 17, 2009
Undergraduate / Satisfactions from activities as a physician - Columbia University Secondary [35]

. One day, it seems likely that Americans, Australians, and Brits will all end up speaking different languages, as the Englishes spoken in each will have diverged so much that they are no longer compatible.

Actually, I read somewhere -- where? -- that as the number of speakers of English as a second language eclipses the number of speakers of English as a first language, linguists are predicting the evolution of a global lingua franca quite different than the English spoken in any of those countries. American English, for its part, is evolving differently due to the heavy influence of, first, Black English as a primary dialect spoken by a significant chunk of the population. The next wave of change will probably come from the high proportion of U.S. residents who have Spanish -- a romance language very different from the Germanic Enlish -- as their first language. I'm curious to see where it will go.
EF_Simone   
Jul 17, 2009
Undergraduate / Stuck on UC prompt, there is nothing really exciting in my life.. [15]

Sean is right: Simply follow the instructions. They didn't ask if there is anything exciting in your life. They asked how your environment has shaped you. Show them that you have sufficient insight and observational ability to answer that question.
EF_Simone   
Jul 17, 2009
Writing Feedback / A concise narrative about an important event - UF Architecture college essay! [17]

You do need a conclusion. But, even more, you need to follow the directions and make the essay concise. That means both narrowing the information you include to only the most relevant and writing sentences and paragraphs that go directly and vividly to the point, without any verbal flab.

If you want the rainbow, you have to put up with the rain. This is the simple lesson I have learned upon the tearing of my ACL last summer.

From the age of eight, gymnastics was my world. I was a committed, determined, and competitive gymnast. I did not have much of a life outside of gymnastics yet I continued to excel in school although it was not my main focus . My goal ever since I first started, was competingfrom the start was to compete on the women's gymnastics team at the University of Florida.

I'll let one of our experts on concise writing -- Liebe? Noto? -- give you more specific tips.
EF_Simone   
Jul 17, 2009
Book Reports / Argumentative essay on 1984 - Outline [40]

Oceania is not a communist society so you need to revise that point before you proceed or your whole essay will be based on a falsehood.

Right. Orwell meant 1984 to be a (serious) spoof of totalitarianism. At the time, the USSR was practicing totalitarianism under the guise of communism, so that is why many people mistake the book as a critique of communism.
EF_Simone   
Jul 17, 2009
Undergraduate / "Combining sports and grades" - UT important issue essay [3]

As Sean said, it's "could have" not "could of."

Where does this common error come from?

could have = could've

"could've" sounds like "could of"

But, again, it is "could have -- "could of" makes no sense and marks the writer as poorly skilled.
EF_Simone   
Jul 17, 2009
Undergraduate / Capital Punishment (the death penalty) Essay. Should be allowed or not? [11]

using criminals as a resource would be better for society than merely killing them or locking them up.

...if only (at least in the United States) there weren't a documented history of replacing slavery with imprisonment, especially in the southern states. Anybody who is interested in this topic can Google "prison-industrial complex" Along with share cropping and other forms of debt servitude, chain gangs replaced slavery post-emancipation as a means of continuing to get free labor from bound people, especially people of African descent.
EF_Simone   
Jul 17, 2009
Undergraduate / Medical Secondary [26]

Beautiful! Your hard work on revisions payed off. This is short, sweet, and to the point.
EF_Simone   
Jul 17, 2009
Writing Feedback / Credit cards's advantages [8]

Credit cards are not exactly new. Therefore your first two sentences are not quite right.

I notice that you are not spacing after your punctuation marks. This makes your essay very difficult to read, as your sentences all run together. Correct that problem and post again for more feedback.
EF_Simone   
Jul 17, 2009
Writing Feedback / Advertisements affects on consumer goods - ielts preparing [15]

"The story delivers a desired call to drink that soft drink that people tend to drink when the weather is too hot."

It all depends on what he means.

"That..." is what's known as a restrictive clause, because the information following the "that" restricts the meaning of the word modified in a manner essential to the meaning of the sentence.

"Which..." is what's known as an unrestrictive clause, because the information following the "which" provides extra information rather than limiting the meaning of the word modified.

So, If Orlando was referring to a specific soft drink that people tend to drink when the weather is too hot, "that" is correct. However, if Orlando meant that people tend to drink soft drinks in general when it's too hot, he should have written:

"a call to drink that soft drink, which people tend to do when the weather is too hot."

Note the comma before "which" -- in general, you will only use "which" clauses after a comma. If you don't need a comma, you probably want "that." If you do need a comma, you probably want "which"
EF_Simone   
Jul 17, 2009
Writing Feedback / The generation gap + Prevention vs Cure - help with these topics [6]

I'm confused: Are these two separate questions?

For the first, I think about the research that indicates that changes in public opinion on first race and more recently sexual orientation have come from what social scientists call "cohort replacement" rather than through people changing their minds. It's not that nobody ever changes their mind, just that each new generation has had significantly more open attitudes than the previous and this, rather than individuals changing their minds, has led to recent revolutions of opinion on matters such as gay marriage.

As for prevention versus cure, perhaps you could challenge the "versus" -- why not both?
EF_Simone   
Jul 17, 2009
Undergraduate / "Want to be a doctor" - Penn State, personal statement [26]

Hmmm... I do think that the GED can help rather than hurt you, but perhaps not in response to this question... unless the reason for your GED is related to economic circumstance, in which you can argue that this has helped you to see why more people of your economic class need to be allowed into the privileged class of physicians.

I'm thinking, though, for this question, that you're best off sticking to a story that has direct relevance to wanting to be a doctor. This might or might not come from your volunteer experiences. Think hard: Why do you want to be a doctor? It's real feelings, rather than contrived stories, that jump off the page.
EF_Simone   
Jul 17, 2009
Undergraduate / "My grandparents" - UCF Undergrad essay [6]

I really like the details in the vivid first paragraph, which will be even more powerful if you tighten up the sentences, removing excess words and phrases.

The last paragraph is comparatively vague and, consequently, dull. What, specifically, do you see yourself doing that might begin to live up to your grandmother's legacy?
EF_Simone   
Jul 17, 2009
Book Reports / Key to get re-submitted! Anicent World History Paper [31]

In between reading the book and writing a draft, look back over any notes you took while reading the book. Identify the main thesis of the book and the main arguments used to support that thesis. Do you agree or disagree with the thesis of the book? Was it adequately supported by evidence? Was reading the book a worthwhile experience? Should more people read it? Answering these questions will get you started.
EF_Simone   
Jul 16, 2009
Book Reports / Argumentative essay on 1984 - Outline [40]

Perhaps you could widen the thesis, including rewriting history as one of many different ways Big Brother controls what proles know and, therefore, what they are able to think.
EF_Simone   
Jul 16, 2009
Undergraduate / Satisfactions from activities as a physician - Columbia University Secondary [35]

Americans have always preferred to rewrite their dictionary from time to time rather than to educate their citizens in the use of English.

Ditto Australians. Ditto, in regard to Portuguese, Brazil. Languages change. Even in Britain, English has changed. (Need evidence? Read Shakespeare.) Languages are nothing but social constructs -- collectively agreed upon rules -- in the first place. They naturally change over time and are especially changeable when a group of speakers moves to new circumstances.
EF_Simone   
Jul 16, 2009
Graduate / Law School Admission Essay with Special Circumstances [2]

I'm what they like to call a statistic, not in homes, but in schools.

The term "a statistic" usually refers to somebody who is a high-school dropout or a drug addict or a victim of violence. Starting in this way leads the reader to believe that something very different than what you write is coming.

Two teachers abused me in high school.

Again, this is misleading. It seems you were treated unfairly. "Abuse" tends to be reserved for sexual or physical abuse. Unless you are saying that teachers who sexually or physically abused you were then allowed to decide whether or not you would graduate, choose a different word.

The only other way that I can conceive wording this introduction to a description of unfair treatment as you have -- "abuse" "statistic" -- is if the unfair treatment was an expression of some form of bias. It can't be race or gender, since your twin sister was treated better. Sexual orientation, perhaps? If you faced persecution on that account, had to leave school to avoid it, and were still oppressed by unequal graduation requirements, that would be worth stating explicitly. Otherwise, you need to tone down the introduction and significantly reduce the tone of grievance that runs through the recitation of your struggles with the graduation requirement.

You say that you want to cut length. I can tell that this experience is still very sore for you and, as people do when they are still very anguished by something, you go on and on, giving far too many details and losing the reader's interest in the process. That's a shame, because your commitment to children's rights law is sincere and unique. Don't let it get lost in the shuffle.

Similarly, you need to be more concise in describing the special circumstances. In cutting down, stay with the facts and keep your tone even. You do not want to inadvertently sound like someone the school has to worry will complain or even sue the moment things don't go her way. What I'm talking about here is tone: You can pitch this as a victory for people with disabilities about which you feel proud or you can pitch it as one more in a series of endless grievances that will undoubtedly continue wherever you go.

In summary, you've experienced difficulties in both high school and college. Instead of stressing those difficulties in a tone of complaint, stress your successful resolution of them in a tone of confident pride. And, again, if there was some identifiable reason for the differential treatment you received in high school, say so. Otherwise, tone down the language in which you introduce those difficulties.
EF_Simone   
Jul 16, 2009
Undergraduate / The place we come from determines the person - UC admission essay [9]

i think u should have main sentence in first line of each paragraph which show ur argument.

This is called a topic sentence. Composition teachers often instruct their students to begin each paragraph with such a sentence when writing basic essays. However, it is not required for more advanced writing. There does need to be, somewhere in each paragraph, a sentence that clarifies its point, but this need not be at the beginning and is often -- when building to a point with a series of images or examples -- at the end.
EF_Simone   
Jul 16, 2009
Undergraduate / About my environment - admission essay topic [7]

Losing a brother to gunfire doesn't sound like a "very calm and peaceful environment." Even if the fatal event occurred elsewhere, it must have punctured the tranquility of the household. If so, that would be an appropriate theme: your experience with that and how it affected you.

Challenges can be big or small and need not be traumatic. The key is for you to show that you have some capacity for self-reflection, that you are able to look at your family history and environment (including any challenges you have faced) and say how this influenced you. We can help you with the writing, but you have to do the reflection yourself.
EF_Simone   
Jul 15, 2009
Essays / Pro Con Analysis (Immigrants to Learn English) [19]

Well, there are two ways you can approach this. To write the most intelligent paper on the topic, you need to address the subject more thoughtfully than it is usually addressed in the media, asking first and most specifically: What would be the purpose of such a policy? Then you can argue (a) for and against the purpose, as well as (b) for and against this particular policy as a means of achieving that purpose.

Or, you could take the somewhat easier journalistic approach and simply report the reasons that people support or oppose the policy, whether or not these are logical or make policy sense.

In between, you could both report and assess the common reasons people give for proposing or opposing this policy.
EF_Simone   
Jul 15, 2009
Undergraduate / "We the People" - Undergrad Admissions Essay for Ivies? Critique =) [29]

For the first one, is the "eternal flame" metaphor too hackneyed?

Yes!

For the second, does the word "confirmed" seem like the best diction? I want to portray that my experience solidified my intent to pursue that specific career path.

Well, it didn't confirm your passion. It did confirm your sense that this is the work for you and, as you just said, solidified your intent to pursue that path.
EF_Simone   
Jul 15, 2009
Writing Feedback / health and personal fitness, interview three people and back ur thesis up! [3]

Do people "receive" exercise?

Does your interview really "prove" or simply "support" your theory?

In your conclusion, can you state any other factors associated with level of exercise? You've done a good job of showing that more responsibilities equal less time to work out, but surely there are other factors. Can you think of any?

Here's a hint: I know someone who is a full time college professor (in English -- lots of grading) with a four year old child and a heavy load of writing and volunteer work on top of her job. She goes to the gym, often taking her daughter, much more often than a mutual friend who is unemployed and childless (although also does a lot of community work). The one who goes to the gym feels restless and agitated when she doesn't get the chance to work out. The one who doesn't prefers other recreational activities.
EF_Simone   
Jul 15, 2009
Scholarship / MBA Scholarship Short Personal Statement [12]

The information does show diversity. You could delete unnecessary phrases such as "I have to say" and "I will share." Don't say what you're going to say; just say it.
EF_Simone   
Jul 15, 2009
Undergraduate / "We the People" - Undergrad Admissions Essay for Ivies? Critique =) [29]

Could you comment on my questions please or help me rewrite those couple of sentences? Or do they seem fine they way they are?

What questions? We can't help you rewrite those sentences because only you know what civic activities you can include in them. Once you've drafted the revised sentences, we can help you correct or improve them.
EF_Simone   
Jul 15, 2009
Undergraduate / My Heritage - in my own country I feel the most foreign. Common App. Essay [10]

Simone, what do you think? Is this an overused topic, do I come off as a pretentious ABCD who doesn't know what she's talking about?

I do not know what Simone is going to say, but I think when you are applying to highly selective universities, you want your essay to stand out, and my opinion is that a hackneyed topic

What an interesting dialogue. Too bad you can't turn this in, to show yourself as an authentic and constantly questioning writer.

For whatever it's worth, here's what I think: Adolescents from similar backgrounds struggle with similar questions. Writing about one of those questions is not necessarily hackneyed as long as the writing itself is vivid, authentic, and expressive. Your writing is vivid and often authentic -- as when you admit to negative perceptions of people in India -- but is sometimes so stylized as to sound superficial -- e.g., the "sugar-spun dreams." Moreover, even though you are describing what must have been an emotionally agonizing process, the way that you write about it is all from the head, not the heart.

So I say: Stick with the topic; it's what you really want to say and it's always best to stay with what you are compelled to express. In revising the essay, provide more vivid descriptions of (a) people and scenes, and (b) your own feelings -- not just your thoughts. Avoid high-flown prose in favor of direct sentences in which the unique images do the work.

Make sense?
EF_Simone   
Jul 15, 2009
Writing Feedback / Narrative Essay (Warning: slightly depressing)! [11]

If you're worried about length, go through sentence by sentence striking unnecessary words and phrases.

You know,T hey say that hospitals have an unbearable smell to them , but the truth is, on the last day of June of 2009, the only thing I could smell as I was sitting in room 208 of the ICU department was nothing.

I went outside to the hospital's garden and seated myselfsat on the most secluded bench. For the first time in my life, I noticedSuddenly, everything seemed so fake: from the two women gossiping in the garden's distant corner to the whitened smile that the outside café waitress gave to each customerof his new customers .
EF_Simone   
Jul 15, 2009
Essays / Pro Con Analysis (Immigrants to Learn English) [19]

~People who don't speak English must be illegal.

Huh???

~Other countries require immigrants to learn their national language, so should we.

You'll need a citation here, remembering that there's a difference between having a national language and forcing people to learn it. Also, you'll need to show not just that this policy exists but also, since it is quite rare, explain why we should follow the lead of these few countries rather than the preponderance of nations.

~By losing control of the language we will lose political control.

Who's "we"?

Your "cons" seem weak and all focus on the difficulty of learning English for some immigrants rather than the justice or utility of the policy itself. So, here are a few more:

~ Languages that are native to this region include Navaho, Hopi, Illini, Creek, Cree and scores of others... but not English
~ Spanish and Native language speaking immigrants from Mexico include descendants of Native Americans who were here first, and thus arguably have more right to be in the region than the English-speaking descendants of immigrants from Europe

~ The trend, globally, is not toward single-language countries but, rather, recognition of several languages as official languages of a country; countries such as Brazil find that this fosters rather than inhibits democracy and economic growth

~ The policy is unfeasible -- What would be the mechanism by which, for example, a refugee fleeing genocide who, for whatever reason, was unable to become fluent in English would be punished for her failure? Jail? Deportation?
EF_Simone   
Jul 15, 2009
Undergraduate / My Heritage - in my own country I feel the most foreign. Common App. Essay [10]

It is a paradox that in my own country I feel the most foreign.

This is a strong opening but would be stronger if it were actively phrased. You don't need to tell us it's a paradox; we can see that. Also, the sentence will be stronger if it doesn't start with a prepositional phrase. I'd suggest: "I feel most foreign in my own country" or, even better, "I feel least at home in my own country"

ⓘ Need academic writing help? 100% custom and human!
Fill out one of these forms for professional help:

Best Writing Service:
CustomPapers form ◳

Graduate Writing / Editing:
GraduateWriter form ◳

Excellence in Editing:
Rose Editing ◳

AI-Paper Rewriting:
Robot Rewrite ◳