EF_Sean
Apr 17, 2009
Letters / Response to Dr. Kings Letter to Clergymen Essay [3]
Are you supposed to write a response to Dr. King from a modern perspective, or as if you were someone living at the time he wrote it? The instructions, and the way you begin your essay, seem like the latter, but then at the end you sound more like the former, that is, someone writing fifty years later. It makes a difference, because America is a very different place now that it was then. You might want to revise the ending of your essay so that the entire thing sounds like a response written by someone living at that time. If you do, you might want to role-play a bit and consider who exactly you are supposed to be -- a white moderate, a black activist, or perhaps even one of the clergymen. For that matter, that last would make a lot of sense, because he wrote the letter to them in response to a letter they wrote to him. So, you could write as if you were one of the clergymen writing back to him, continuing the exchange. Of course, to do that, you would have to disagree with him, because that's what the clergymen would have done. That might actually be a really interesting exercise, because you would have to put yourself in the shoes of someone you presumably disagree with vehemently, which is always a good learning experience.
Are you supposed to write a response to Dr. King from a modern perspective, or as if you were someone living at the time he wrote it? The instructions, and the way you begin your essay, seem like the latter, but then at the end you sound more like the former, that is, someone writing fifty years later. It makes a difference, because America is a very different place now that it was then. You might want to revise the ending of your essay so that the entire thing sounds like a response written by someone living at that time. If you do, you might want to role-play a bit and consider who exactly you are supposed to be -- a white moderate, a black activist, or perhaps even one of the clergymen. For that matter, that last would make a lot of sense, because he wrote the letter to them in response to a letter they wrote to him. So, you could write as if you were one of the clergymen writing back to him, continuing the exchange. Of course, to do that, you would have to disagree with him, because that's what the clergymen would have done. That might actually be a really interesting exercise, because you would have to put yourself in the shoes of someone you presumably disagree with vehemently, which is always a good learning experience.
