Unanswered [14] | Urgent [0]
  

Posts by CrimeanGurl
Joined: Nov 21, 2010
Last Post: Jan 4, 2011
Threads: 1
Posts: 17  

From: United States of America

Displayed posts: 18
sort: Latest first   Oldest first  | 
CrimeanGurl   
Jan 4, 2011
Undergraduate / "becoming licensed as a Registered Dietician" - Texas-Statment of Purpose [6]

You're a good writer, but this essay is way too scattered. In my opinion, you should get rid of the first paragraph - I do not see how it relates to the story. Its sole purpose seems to be to grab readers' attention, but in a way that would make them feel that they was cheated into reading. Maybe try to begin by describing very vividly your disorder. You have a very good reason to go into Nutritional Sciences and a solid first draft. Now add add a little more drama and imagery!
CrimeanGurl   
Jan 3, 2011
Undergraduate / "X is unknown" - University of Chicago Supplement, Find X [3]

I think you're a good writer, but this topic is way too weird, no wonder you had troubles with it. To be honest, even though well-written, I felt that this essay was little more than a bunch of facts thrown together. Maybe you should pick a different topic?
CrimeanGurl   
Jan 3, 2011
Undergraduate / "DREAM Act; reach a logical stance" - CommonApp Issues of importance [5]

Thanks for reviewing my essay, Van

I absolutely loved this! It is extremely well written, and I could not spot a single error. What makes this essay particularly great, in my opinion, is that you are able to draw on your own experience, which makes it more powerful than if it was just argumentative.

Very well done
CrimeanGurl   
Jan 3, 2011
Undergraduate / "a vigorous cultural appetite" - why I'm interested in the University of Chicago [3]

"The University of Chicago soonimmediately caught my attention during my college selection process " Or something else - I simply don't like the way "soon" sounds here

"The prestigious political science program at the University of Chicago also played a significant role in my application decision. " to provide a transition

"I love the way that the program offers an overview of the politics of various regions... "

"The opportunities for internship, the collection of historic sites and cultural institutions, and the vivid life of a big city maketurn Chicago into a fascinating place to live my college experience."

You might want to work on it a little more, but overall, I find it very decent.

Please take a look at mine as well
CrimeanGurl   
Jan 3, 2011
Undergraduate / "the start of something new, exhilarating, and not experienced" - Why U Chicago essay [14]

"I wanted the personal learning experience the university is known for, with the flexibility the quarter system provides." This sentence sounds kind of strange to me: Do you want "personal learning experience" and "the flexibility" or does "personal learning" take place due to "the flexibility"?

"Whether I spend the day studying for a huge psychology test or rummaging the campus for Scav hunt, four years at UC would help shape me into a successful adult." I believe the second part should have "will" instead of "would" since it is the first conditional.

Overall, awesome essay: It is very detailed and definitely shows your knowledge about the University and enthusiasm to attend it. Well Done!

Can you please take a sec to look at mine?
CrimeanGurl   
Jan 3, 2011
Undergraduate / "My mom is no different": Describe a significant influence a person has had on you [9]

You are trying to say way too much! This essay is supposed to be about your mother, and yet, you hardly focus on her at all. To be honest, I lost interest shortly after the first paragraph and until the very end kept wondering what any of this had to do with the prompt. You were asked to describe a person who has influenced you, not the life circumstances! I understand the need to tell the admission committee about things you had to overcome (I also struggled with how to fit all of them into a single essay), but you should try to do it in a much less obvious manner!
CrimeanGurl   
Jan 1, 2011
Undergraduate / Brown - global community, practice makes perfect, a competitive gymnast [4]

I think the first essay needs some polishing: Your reasons seem good enough but the language in which you explain them seems not very sophisticated.

I think this would sound better:
In addition, Volunteering in a rehab facility combined with my education and experiences has also made me interested in the field of sports medicine which I hope to pursue.

The last sentence of your second essay seems completely unrelated to the rest of the paragraph - you need some transition.

The last one is pretty good! I like it the best.
CrimeanGurl   
Jan 1, 2011
Undergraduate / "returning to my life of academia" - Rochester curriculum 150 words [26]

I really don't see much you can improve about it. It does not sound as enthusiastic as the one about NU, but, I guess, this is due to the fact that they don't give applicants enough room to bring enthusiasm across.

I agree with the previous poster that you should get rid of the comma after "subjects" in the first sentence and that you should use "the world is my playing field..." as the last sentence. Maybe just break the last sentence into two: "I look forward to learning, envisioning and exploring all subjects of academia. The world is my playing field at Rochester." or "At Rochester, the world is my playing field."
CrimeanGurl   
Jan 1, 2011
Undergraduate / "I want to be a Wildcat; I want to go to Northwestern." - Why Northwestern [14]

And, Northwestern is not just about being a member of the Weinberg college community;-- it is about being a member of the exceedingly larger Northwestern family.

Dash is more appropriate, in my opinion, since you have a sudden change of thought here.

There will be times when I will feel homesick, and times when I appreciate the distance from Evanston to Atlanta.

Should you be really using a comma here? Also "times when I will feel homesick" and "times when I appreciate" lack parallelism.

As to the content, I don't know much about Northwestern, but I can really feel that you're truly interested in attending it, which is probably the most important thing one can learn from this type of essay.
CrimeanGurl   
Dec 31, 2010
Undergraduate / "Learning with Purpose" - Commonapp essay [4]

It written well and answers the question. I like the conclusion "Anything I learned became common ground for me to communicate with others" - it definitely adds value to your experience.
CrimeanGurl   
Dec 29, 2010
Undergraduate / "Difficulty need not foreshadow despair: how I defeated my mother" AMHERST SUPPLEMENT [6]

I know that this is way too long (590 words instead of 300), but I simply can't shorten this essay without ruining it completely. Do you think it is good enough to compensate for going over the limit or should I scrap the whole thing entirely and just try something completely different? I am looking for constrictive criticism, not grammar correction. Thanks!

I went into that conversation prepared better than ever: my research was extensive, my arguments compelling, my logic unbreakable. The idea I was about to bring to the table seemed to be among the best to ever grace my mind, my enthusiasm for the matter making it twice as compelling. I was absolutely certain that any reasonable person would support my decision and expected nothing less than tearful embraces and praises for my ingenuity. Imagine my surprise then, when only a few minutes into a very passionate speech of mine, I was cut short by my mom's uncompromising "Only across my dead body!"

At the moment, her reaction struck me as unreasonable, unfair, and painfully over-dramatic. But now that I think, one can hardly blame a woman who has just been informed about her only teenage daughter's desire to move across the ocean for being too dramatic. In retrospect, I don't even know where my surprise came from: I had a great many opportunities to learn about my mom's extraordinary ability to see a myriad of threats to my well-being in every imaginable thing. After all, wasn't she the one who wouldn't let me stay out until after dark well into my late teens and try to cause a large-scale panic every time I was an hour late from school?

The idea towards which my parent showed so much resentment was that of me becoming an au-pair in the United States. Up until I raised the subject, she had never heard about the program that brought American families and young women from around the world together thus helping both parties to experience different cultures. In fact, the only "cultural exchange" that involved young Ukrainian girls my mother was aware of was the one that often ended in police busts and loud newspaper headlines. She was not - and I quote - "about to send her only child into slavery." None of my tearful arguments about groundlessness of her concerns worked: she would not give me her blessing no matter what.

After that first unpleasant conversation, I had no choice but to retreat. It did not mean, however, that I surrendered: For the first time in my life I knew exactly what I wanted, and even though I had no idea where this decision would eventually bring me, I was absolutely sure that I was standing on a threshold of an incredible adventure that I could not afford to miss. I realized from the start, however, that our conflict would not end with just a few skirmishes - it had to be a long war fare that would require a lot of creativity and patience on my part. So I dug my trenches deep, fortified them well, and prepared to defeat my parent's resentment whatever it took.

Needless to say, the total lack of support that came from my mother during what turned into a yearlong confrontation caused much frustration on my part. In retrospect, however, I realize that it was her decline to see the matter through my eyes that ultimately prepared me for what was to come next. Unintentionally, by refusing to play any part in what she viewed as her daughter's insane scheme, she encouraged me to take charge of my own fortune for the first time in my life, which led me to uncover drive and determination I never realized I possessed in such a great quantities. Saying my goodbyes in the airport on December 7th, 2007, I knew that I was well-prepared for everything life could possibly throw at me.
CrimeanGurl   
Dec 29, 2010
Undergraduate / obtaining a higher degree - "Why do you want to transfer" smith & others [15]

By no means was I comparing the substance of the aforementioned books with that of your essay or was I trying to flaunt my knowledge - I was talking about the style of writing. Being familiar with these works, I think you would agree that the way in which they are written differs greatly from that of contemporary prose or classical fiction. Such style does make it more difficult to comprehend what exactly the author is trying to say as certain ideas get entangled in the intricacies of the language. To my knowledge, very few people read Darwin or Machiavelli for pleasure - undoubtedly meaningful, their works are hardly a delightful read. So my point, which Lightning55 has summed up very nicely, is that you should lighten up the style of your writing and make admission officers feel like they are reading an exciting and enjoyable short story, not a scientific treatise required by the curriculum. Sorry, if you found my opinion unnecessary critical.
CrimeanGurl   
Dec 28, 2010
Undergraduate / obtaining a higher degree - "Why do you want to transfer" smith & others [15]

I think you should lay off the thesaurus. Kudos to you if, in fact, your vocabulary is as versatile as this essay attempts to demonstrate, but all the pompous words you're using make the whole thing sound pretentious. In all honesty, I have had more difficult time processing this essay than "The Republic", "The Prince", and "The Origin of Species" combined. You have great ambitions, so show the admission officers how enthusiastic you're about them, rather than how capable you're of perusing the dictionary.
Do You Need
Writing
or Editing Help?
Fill in one of the forms below to get professional help with your assignments:

Graduate Writing / Editing:
GraduateWriter form ◳

Best Essay Service:
CustomPapers form ◳

Excellence in Editing:
Rose Editing ◳

AI-Paper Rewriting:
Robot Rewrite ◳