Unanswered [26] | Urgent [0]
  

Posts by tal105
Joined: Jul 27, 2009
Last Post: Feb 20, 2011
Threads: 7
Posts: 130  

From: United States of America

Displayed posts: 137 / page 4 of 4
sort: Oldest first   Latest first  | 
tal105   
Sep 7, 2009
Undergraduate / "swim coach" - Person of influence. Common App [7]

in a nut shell, your essay talks too much about your coach. im proabably sounding like a broekn record or a hacker on this forum saying the same thing, but o wells; im gonna say it again. colleges do want to hear about your coach, but remmeber, it does no good if you just write a killer essay about your coach and write NOTHING about you. if i was adimissions ple,id automatically put you to the no pile, or the maybe pile. if you didnt care enough to tell me about yourself, i shouldnt care enough to consider you, no matter how good your grades are.

it just loses focus in that you dont tell practically anything about yourself and. in fact, i stopped reading b.c. i realized this essay said nothing about YOU lol. fix that then repost.

good luck!
tal105   
Sep 7, 2009
Undergraduate / "an all girls Catholic school" - Diversity [2]

This experience instilled in me a respect for individuals of all backgrounds and the knowledge to throw away prejudgments.

did you not have this before? or did this experience only help you reinforce this or waht? i think this just needs some work.

i love the realness of your essay. you know how you say "white" then you get a little bit more proper then say "african american" later (idk thats the stuff i notice).

you do have a passive/active voice thing here:
The children that I worked with were African-American...

change this too
I worked with African-American children, some on welfare, and many who came from dysfunctional homes.

do u see the difference with the bold part? thats difference between the active and passive voice. plus itll save you a few words.

also, you didnt tackle the religion part of the african american children, but you did say they came from dysfunctional homes. i think you should leave out the christian part in the beginning and say something like "close knit families" (something wayyy less cliche though). you also say their world was VASTLY different. if you want to show how vastly different, i think you needd more than just skin color, money, and religion to show that. (in other words, consider taking out that word vastly. remember, you were supposed to have learned a "lesson" from this. not feel sorry for the "poor black kids" get it?)

i cant say anything else. i really like it. it answers the prompt. you link yourself to it professionally (by saying the anecdote about your brother) its sorta perfect in a way. gj!

good luck!
tal105   
Sep 7, 2009
Undergraduate / "swim coach" - Person of influence. Common App [7]

NOPE! dont ever feel like you write too much about yourself. the only time you can write too much about yourself if in an essay about why you want to attend a school. then you have to write 1/3 -50% about the school. you can always post on this forum b.c. there are members like liebe, simone, and noto and llama, that are GREATT. esp. since you may want more than one opinion than just your school counselor and stuff.

but as for this essay, i really do feel its not enough about you. it really is almost like a waaste of an essay. you give it all to you coach you know? lol. use this as an oppourtunity to tell about like one of your competititions! thats a good idea! use each essay to showcase something different. that is a lot of essays :(
tal105   
Sep 7, 2009
Undergraduate / Another one for Roomies... (So many people are applying to Standford !) [22]

i knoww how hard it is to have to keep on trying. i had to on my u of chicago essay, but you have to understand, people are going to go to standford with some SUPER CREATIVE roomie essays that are going to be like WOW and may get them in on their essay alone, or may not.

my suggestion: you stoppp overthinking this and just write. i really think what you should do too is write down some things about you that cant be found else where in your application. like for me, i know that in my application it would never be found that i LOVE scary/gory movies and not a lot of ple can take those, so i would play that up in my standford roomie essay if i was applying. like i lovee the 'saw' series, so i would start off like "I want to play a game" or somehting silly like that. you have to think out of the box, without forgetting that your NOT writing to a roomie so you have to keep it professional.

wahts not found in your application essay that you can write about? do you like poetry? if so write a poem as your app essay about being clean and bubbly and stuff. do u like board games? then you can make that the main focus and sprinkle some other things. remember they didnt tell you to write about a lot of things either. you can just write about ONE thing you want them to know about. THINK OUTSIDE OF YOUR BOX.

good luck!
tal105   
Sep 7, 2009
Undergraduate / Another one for Roomies... (So many people are applying to Standford !) [22]

honestly, its just a list to me. it seems like its not creative b.c. you took the easy way out and listed stuff.

but its only my opinion. like i said, dont overthink it, you can do a really good one.

i think you should do something funky with that paradox thing you say you are! that could be interesting. make an essay full of paradoxes about yourself or somehting. then at the end say, your a paradox who does one thing but thinks the other.

(thats what i meant by thinking out of the box)
tal105   
Sep 9, 2009
Undergraduate / UF app essay two, I decided to write a completely different essay [6]

i do like the way your paragraphs are broken up. it plays tricks on the eyes of the reader and then it makes it all seem like not a lot to read. kudos!

besides that, i would like to see the connection of marshalls in the first paragraph a bit more. as of now its just...there. the rest of the story seems to flow and connect but the first paragraph doesnt seem to go with the rest of your essay for some reason. like you say you liked to shop there b.c. of getting cheap clothes? but i mean then you say your mom told u something horrific there. you dont even say "i didnt realize that my favorite store would turn out to be filled with not so favorite memories" or some transiton like that. (not that cheesy though LMAO!)

other than that it'll work.

good luck!
tal105   
Sep 9, 2009
Undergraduate / "faculty ratio and more" - UCF Admissions Essay [10]

while your first essay answers the prompt, its like this:

WHY I WANT TO GO TO UCF:
-nice campus
-friends attend
-staff to student ratio...
you just seem to list and dont add any creativity. i mean this is fine as the 1st essay is def. an okay essay, it just lacks creativity in my opinion.

the 2nd essay i like the personal approach u decided to take, only it seems like the timeline and the entire story is being rushed along. try to slow it down somehow by maybe explaining what tole the death of your father had on you (only breifly though) and tel how it made you a stronger person (this is good as it can be a quality that makes you good for the school as well) and then expand a little bit more on the 2nd paragraph, and waht i mean by that is you jump from 'holding down a job and school is hard' to 'i had a 3.7 gpa' relativly fast. (quick time frame once again)

other than that, its all good ;)

-edit
i dont know the word limit, but it seems pretty short. i know its prety tight, but witht that being said, i think you can still add in some detail (aka toss around some ideas) and then when your all done and its VERY specific,both essays, then you look back and you CUT OUT. then youll realize some stuff you originally had, wasnt relevant, or necessary, or what ever word you want to use-

good luck!
tal105   
Sep 10, 2009
Undergraduate / "faculty ratio and more" - UCF Admissions Essay [10]

i read ur revision and my opinion is starting an essay saying that the school is recognized as such prestige is not the best thing.

for example, im applying to columbia. tell me what you think this is like:
columbia is noted as one of the best schools in the country, which is why it is ivy league, which is a big reason why i want to attend!

this sounds like you want to go for the prestige. i would consider revising that out. but to really wrap it up, i think id rather you pick a few reasons and expand on them rather tell a whole laundry list of reasons you want to apply. some of them arent even important whereas some of them i feel you can really elaborat on, making for a good essay. for example, you dont have to mention the culture thing b.c. this day in time diversity and culture is a "hot topic" whereas if you elaborate on how your going to develope yourself a little bit more, thats good. elaborate on the small student to teacher ratio, etc.

but thats the way i would do it. im not sure whats really better. if its better to say ALL of the reasons, or if its better to say less and expand more.

the next essay:

I believe that if somebody asks the people who know me best,....

i sorta dont know what to say. i personally think your 1st esasy with some TWEAKS, is okay, but deep down i feel ur 2nd needs some work. idk, maybe the other members should comment. if they dont, repost it maybe if you can according to the forum rules.

good luck!
tal105   
Sep 24, 2009
Undergraduate / Diversity Essay (AIDS Patient) - U of Michigan App [4]

you should say 'i had never knowingly touched someone with aids' b.c. im sure u may have before u just didnt know it. u dont wanna come off ignorant :)

other than that, its good. consider cutting out somee detail to make it shorter. idk, if that makes sense.
tal105   
Oct 26, 2009
Undergraduate / track! ("I am able to do more") [3]

comments plze :)

I inhale. I exhale. For twenty minutes those are the only two things that I concentrate on. My heart beat races. The air around me is hot and heavy. Below me, I can feel the pieces of wood against the soles of my feet. I start to slow down as I approach the wall that I'm dreading. I inhale. I exhale. I ignore the soreness on my ankles, the tightness in my legs. I take a deep breath and pick myself up the hill. I begin to feel pushes and shoves. As girls run ahead of me, my determination replaces my fear. Before I know it, I'm on the other side of the hill. My arms grow quicker and my strides, longer. I spot the waving red, orange, green and blue flags. I increase my pace as I approach them. They greet me, with my face sweating, my legs aching, and my heart pumping. Despite everything, I still manage to smile, with a small medal in my hand. An anonymous writer once said, "Every accomplishment starts with the decision to try."

Getting the confidence to try, came to me at a late age. As an only child, I always liked to spend my time alone. To me, loneliness came with shyness. In Elementary School, while all the other kids lined up for their turn to hit the ball in a game of whiffle ball, I stood in the back of the line. As they came to the back of the line, I took a step back, letting them take a step forward. I would continue that. My turn would never come. Even in Junior High School, my turn never came. By then, I was always picked last in my gym class. In class, when my teacher stepped out of the room, all the other kids began talking to their friends. I didn't. I had no one to talk to. I never had the courage to do so. Instead I just sat there and continued to do my work. I knew that I wanted to be surrounded by many friends. I wanted to talk about the new show on T.V, the gross cafeteria lunches, our new alien math teacher. It didn't matter what, as long as I had them.

When I got to high school I knew that I wanted to change. But getting the confidence to do that took some time as well. I decided that I wanted to join a sports team. But after many years of standing in the back of the line, I didn't know how to play anything. After hearing that Tech's Track Team did not have any tryouts, I decided that I would try that sport.

My first day of practice was a Wednesday. Wednesday was the day when the girls were racing in Prospect Park. Wednesday was the day that I ran a short distance of about 1.5 miles, for the first time. I ran from Tech to Prospect Park with girls that had been in the team for one, two, or even three years. After one block of running, my face was already red. I was gasping for air. My feet hurt inside my blue, flat, puma sneakers. With every step I took, I could feel the pain going from my toes to my thighs. It felt as if I had been running for hours, when in reality, it had only been minutes. My first day of practice was horrible. But even so, I was back the next day.

As I run day after day, week after week, I am able to do more. I have something in common with all the girls in team: we are all runners. Running teaches me that I need to be strong when approaching that hill. I need to try my hardest when things are most difficult. I also need to be confident when racing, knowing that I am trying my hardest. The ground below me, and the sky above me: both are still. Only I am moving. Only I can push myself forward. As Helen Keller once stated, "Nothing can be done without hope and confidence."
tal105   
Nov 6, 2009
Undergraduate / U of Michigan, gained respect for intellectual, social, or cultural differences. [9]

in my opinion, i think its necessary that you mention your korean. you sorta just leave the reader to assume that from this essay. i think its importatn for you to say "being korean growing up in traditional korean society..." or w.e. you wrote i think will help the flow.

o answer 'no', especially in Korean society where strict formalities exist; students would bow to teachers rather than saying 'hello' and use the terms of respect.

see! you just say in korean society. u assume the reader knows your korean! lol.

besides that and grammar stuff, this is very nice.

My old friend of a different culture

good luck!
tal105   
Feb 14, 2011
Research Papers / "don't shoot the messenger" - essay for my intro to latin american study class [3]

hey guys:) id like if you can help me with this. now, this essay was supposed to be written based off of two essays/papers we read in class and i didnt post them, but i know you guys are smart and can still help me.

now, im a freshman in college, and i havent written papers for college yet, so please tell me i guess if its up to par. its due tomorrow, so i dont have a lot of time, but id like some feedback. just even if its grammar mistakes. im really worried about it.

i go to johns hopkins btw.

and here it is... (its non fiction writing btw)
and she didnt really give us a topic to write on, but it is somethign liek "compare the european gaze with the indiginous perspective" or something like that. shes RLY not that great at telling us essay topics or organization.

thanks;)

The 15th century conquest has left both the indigenous people of the Americas and the Europeans disputing on what occurred. Both parties attempt to justify their reasoning for the situation, and it is up to readers to interpret and decide what they believe. Who was to blame for the conflicting indigenous prospective, and European gaze? The messengers of both sides played an important role in relaying exaggerated information to their leaders, causing perhaps the taking over of the indigenous people.

When the conquistadores arrived in the 16th centuries, they discovered this new place of spices, opportunity, and hope. Men like Christopher Columbus were sent to report back to Spain about the land and, give his opinion on what it was like and all the other Europeans took his word. Columbus arrived, saw the beautiful fauna of the Americas, and the lands' potential, and embellished a little bit in his report.

Columbus, didn't so much discover America, since there were already indigenous people living there, as much as he painted the picture of what the America's were like to the Spaniards. In his letter to Luis de Sant Angel, he writes "...varied forms, accessible, and full of trees of endless varieties, so high that they seem to touch the sky..." and "...covered with blossoms, some with fruit, and some in other conditions...". Columbus told the Spaniards the land had resources that were not found in Spain, and this would appeal to the king. Columbus' report was the first step in the European's idea for take over.

Even worse than how special he makes the land out to be is how he portrays the people that inhabit it. Since he already makes the land out to be an area they have to be in control of, the people are the only thing getting in the way; they were these specs that weren't as beautiful as the land. Since the people are just a tiny problem to take care of, he tells the King things like "...they appear extraordinarily timid" and they have weapons they are afraid to use. While these characteristics will make it easier for the Spaniards to take over, he doesn't dispute the native's intelligence. He mentions they can understand each other, which seems to surprise him since they live in the wild. They navigate the sea, which is useful to him and his people, and they can be easily manipulated [to Catholicism] since they don't follow any religion. Looking closely at what Columbus does, he paints a pictures to the Spaniards that this land is the perfect new world, the Natives are the perfect people-both intelligent and easy to overpower, making it easier for the Spaniards to get what they want.

While some of these exaggerations are refuted in Broken Spears, messengers are again put to use by the ruler, (in this case chief). When the Spaniards arrived, the natives didn't see them as strangers, but welcomed them as gods; so unbeknownst to the Spaniards they did in fact believe in a higher power. In Columbus's letter to Luis he writes "...I gave them some of everything I had, without receiving anything in return..." while in Broken Spears, the Natives recount giving to their "Gods" (Spaniards) "...quetzal feathers, its ornaments of gold and mother-of-pearl." Columbus depicted them as helpless, and needy. The message he painted to the Spaniards was a false one that showed the Natives as people who would, in fact benefit from the European's taking over. The idea of manifest destiny is best showed here; that it is the job of the Europeans to help the poor less fortunate countries. Really those "poor, less fortunate countries" had a system that worked for them.

The natives, however told a different story. When they came in contact with the Spaniards they showered them with gifts because they thought they were these gods. This is the antithesis of what Columbus wrote back in his letter because they were not these selfish people that were living in these difficult conditions that they needed saving as he described. They in face were able to provide for themselves by making nature work for them although they did not have eastern luxuries. They even had things to share with the Spaniards, and from in Broken Spears the Natives described the Spaniards as the selfish ones. When the natives tried to give them gifts, the response: "The Captain asked them: 'And this is all?' "

But the Spaniards were not the only ones responsible for sending skewed messages; the Natives were responsible of it as well. For example, when Motecuhzoma sent his messengers to scope out the situation (the Spaniards arrival), instead of giving Motecuhzoma the strength to take action, there report made him more fearful. When the messengers came back to report, they told their chief about the weapons. The messengers described the cannons as "...is aimed against a mountain, the mountain splits and cracks open...Most unnatural sight, as if the tree had exploded from within." The messengers had also done what Columbus had done in his letter, and exaggerated to their chief, making it seem as if their entire civilization could not do anything to save themselves.

Both sides show a heavy reliance on messengers for the sole reason of the chief or king not wanting to explore the land themselves. However, this is not always a great idea because these messengers do exaggerate as did Columbus and the messengers of Motecuhzoma. The Spaniards in return, were painted a picture of this great place that has such potential, and also has these timid people that could be easily overpowered, so the king felt it necessary to send in knights. Motecuhzoma was painted a picture by his messengers of these people (the Spaniards) with these "stags" horses, that were larger than life, and a type of vicious animal, these European gods they could not satisfy and they had these weapons they could not compare to. This gave Motecuhzoma fear, and made him a worse leader for his people and allowed him the Europeans to easily come in and take over.

So the common phrase of "don't shoot the messenger" is not always accurate, and is not pertinent to this situation. While the chief of the natives and the King of the Spain thought, at the moment it would be more convenient to send messengers, they would have been much more successful if they had went themselves. Instead they both got exaggerated versions of the truth, like a game of telephone, from the people they sent that put either put them in fear, or made them take extreme action, respectively. Both the indigenous perspective and the European gaze, are thus not entirely accurate since they were ideas planted by just a few people-mere messengers reporting-rather than ideas seen first hand by the entire group of people.

Do You Need
Academic Writing
or Editing Help?
Fill in one of the forms below to get professional help with your assignments:

Graduate Writing / Editing:
GraduateWriter form ◳

Best Essay Service:
CustomPapers form ◳

Excellence in Editing:
Rose Editing ◳

AI-Paper Rewriting:
Robot Rewrite ◳