Unanswered [17] | Urgent [0]
  

Posts by alicela
Joined: Dec 25, 2012
Last Post: Dec 30, 2012
Threads: -
Posts: 18  
Likes: 1
From: United States of America

Displayed posts: 18
sort: Latest first   Oldest first
alicela   
Dec 30, 2012
Undergraduate / Beautiful sounds of music; Common App - Extracurricular activity [7]

1) indoctrinate - Teach (a person or group) to accept a set of beliefs uncritically: "broadcasting was a vehicle for indoctrinating the masses". Are you sure this is what you mean to convey? The word has some negative connotations.

I think this is a large improvement from your last essay! Almost there. The two small anecdotes you slid in (Steve Vai and the underclassman) really add to the essay. I think you should elaborate and stay away from adding more 'telling.' Remember, the fact that you are even writing about music already implies how important it is to you.
alicela   
Dec 30, 2012
Undergraduate / Christianity, a part of my life; Common App - Person with significant influence [6]

AmoebaMan

You're welcome!

The Commonapp essay is uploaded, so it is actually alright to go over the 500 word limit by 1~2 sentences as long as it isn't cut off in the print-out version, or looks obviously long.

Maybe try rephrasing this sentence:
I realized that even though mainstream Christianity fails in many regards, logical atheism fails in many more, particularly concerning the concept of objective morality.
Into this?
I realized that even though mainstream Christianity fails in many regards, it succeeds in addressing the concept of objective morality by...insert something here. You could write anywhere between a phrase to a whole paragraph, morality is a huge argument for Christianity (not that I know what the 'objective morality' the book was referring to is, though).Logical atheism offers no insight/fails in this regard.
alicela   
Dec 30, 2012
Undergraduate / "You are Not Special" ; Cornell Sup /Economics [15]

Grammar and punctuation corrections are in green. Corrections in blue are suggestions and are up to your stylistic preferences.

I have a weakness for smart, funny, and inspirational YouTube videos. My favorite is the "You are Not Special" Commencement speech given by an English teacher named David McCullough. During his speech, Mr. McCullough urged his students that whatever they do in their lives, they do it "because you love it and believe in its importance." Ever since I heard that speech, I brushed aside all thoughts of majoring in biology or engineering, to focus on my most intense intellectual interest: economics.

My interest in economics started when I was a small boy living in a large apartment building in Brooklyn. While I was growing up, the predominately Irish and Italian neighborhood I lived in saw an influx of Arabic, Russian, and Chinese immigrants. I was amazed by the differences in culturedifferent cultures of my new friends and neighbors, but even more amazed by the incredible food inserved at the new falafel restaurant on the corner and sold at the Chinese grocery store across the street.(This sentence is a bit long. Consider breaking it up?) Living in that neighborhood made me feel like I was watching the world move in fast-forward by some sort of magic.

I realize now that the magic transforming my neighborhood was the unseen forces of economics. (Please elaborate. Just an example, even the most basic idea like coincidence of wants, etc will work) My love for economics stems from the fact that these forces have not only transformed my old neighborhood, but have also shaped human history. The world we live in is a result of a long story of economic development. Today globalization has put us in a particularly interesting chapter of the story, where emerging economies can triple their GDP in a decade and everything from the shirt on your back to the food on your plate traveled thousands of miles to get there. Studying economics helps us understand how this new globalized world works.

I believe economics is important because it ultimately boils down to people. After all, economics is the study of the production, distribution and consumption of goods and services that are used by people. We are all economic(Omit, implied) actors in a world where a slight increase in interest rates or the national debt affects the lives of millions. All economic(a new word would be nice. fiscal?) decisions, whether made by governments, businesses, or individuals affect the outside world. I want to study economics because I want(Works without it) to understand how my decisions both as a businessman and as a person impact others.

Studying at Cornell would put me in an intense intellectual environment, inhabited by inquisitive students and renowned professors. While the diverse range of classes that Cornell offers in its College of Arts and Sciences will allow me to become a well-rounded individual who'll be able to handle life's challenges and give back to his community. (This sentence needs to be rewritten. It's too long and is an incomplete thought since you began it with "while.") My personal goal is to gain a PhD in economics and become a professor. I know my goal(this ambition? another word) will be aided by the great faculty and immense research opportunities at Cornell; (Semi colon or period.) I just hope my weakness for YouTube videos won't get in the way.

For me, the strongest parts of your essay are the anecdote from your childhood and introduction. The part about economics tends to be slightly wordy and redundant. I'd add references to solid, real world examples, personal experience or theories to support your intellectual musings.

The rest has been commented on by everyone else, especially HarvardAccept (funny name, btw). Good luck on Cornell!
alicela   
Dec 30, 2012
Undergraduate / Beautiful sounds of music; Common App - Extracurricular activity [7]

Overall, I believe your essay could benefit with more concrete examples/small anecdotes. While the it generally flows very smoothly, the actual content is not that different from a list of lists of positive adjectives.
alicela   
Dec 30, 2012
Undergraduate / Christianity, a part of my life; Common App - Person with significant influence [6]

I like the topic of your essay a lot. It's very reflective and easy to read. The process which you describe is easy for the reader to relate to. The ending is triumphant.

Here are some issues:

The largest issue for me is that you do not go into detail or give any concrete example from C.S. Lewis' book. If you did, your beliefs, and in turn your reflection and essay will be much, much stronger. How does atheism fail in objective morality? What ideas did C.S. Lewis use to defend Christianity?

The second is a more general issue. As a fact, religion is a very touchy subject. Certain phrases you use such as "makes a lotmore sense than any other religion" or "room full of doubters" may make you appear unaccepting of other views or just simply turn off a reader faithful to their own respective religion. Of course, there is nothing wrong with defending your beliefs. You could rectify this by changing the former with "makesmuchmore sense thanmany other religions..." or rather than gaining the ability to "defend yourself," you can say you gained the ability to hold your ground in a debate.

Note that the 2nd issue will be far less of an issue if solve the first issue, since it will show exactly what rational lead you to adhering so strongly to your religion. This is your essay, however, so I will leave this choice to your own discretion.

Also, random, but if you'd like to read more about "air of pointlessness and hopelessness that I simply detested," I'd suggest researching existentialism.
alicela   
Dec 30, 2012
Undergraduate / "Silence," said the co-ordinator ; Common app- Challenge essay [3]

I think you need more of a reflection. I understand that this was a hard time for you, but I get little of what you were actually thinking, beyond fear, worry, or relief. Also, the conclusion doesn't quite close up the story well. Also, you keep using the word 'college.' Don't you mean 'high school?'
alicela   
Dec 29, 2012
Undergraduate / It's mine; Common App/ The creator of Pokemon & his influence [11]

I like your topic choice, especially since I have studied art and design c:

I am strongly against taking out your first paragraph. That one, and your second are the strongest. However, your third paragraph could have a stronger reflection. The ending to the third paragraph is perfect, as it shows that you have taken control of your artwork, your 'mind' - but I am left wondering "What is your mind?" Beyond you 'liking' it or being 'inspired,' what did you like about it, and what did it inspire you to do?

Your essay is already well on its way to be very engaging, but it could use more work. I'd be glad to review more should you present more questions, or another draft.
alicela   
Dec 29, 2012
Undergraduate / I am a "Cameron Crazy" at heart.; Duke Trinity College of A&S/ Good match? [5]

You're welcome ^__^

I forgot to mention this before, but another reason why your 1st and 2nd paragraph may need more logical flow is since the first paragraph seems to state that sports what mainly drew you to Duke, while in the second, it is academics. You can make the distinction by qualifying that sports initially drew your attention, but it was the academics was what made you stay. Then you could link back to the basketball you watched in your conclusion.
alicela   
Dec 29, 2012
Undergraduate / I am a "Cameron Crazy" at heart.; Duke Trinity College of A&S/ Good match? [5]

I think you should keep the first paragraph. It is an interesting introduction that catches the reader's interest. 'Over my high school career,' on the other hand, it a very typical beginning. However, you could try to integrate it better, so that the first paragraph flows more logically to the second. For example, you could omit or move the first sentence of the 2nd paragraph, and jump straight into the anecdote with 'In the summer after tenth grade...'. This would prevent an initial impression of typicality.

All alterations are suggestions affected by my stylistic preferences. How you choose to correct is up to you.

Overall, a strong essay, with few mistakes. Good luck!
alicela   
Dec 28, 2012
Undergraduate / "Choose your weapon"; JOHNS HOPKINS ESSAY/ UNDECIDED MAJOR [4]

Cute essay *__* haha. I love honest ones, even when they are dangerously so. You might not notice the commas I added, but there are a few where there were needed, as a heads up.

Great beginning! I absolutely loved the metaphor. Your conclusion was also strong. This essay can still be made even stronger, but your base is very good though. The essay flows extremely well and is easy to read.

The parts that can be improved are relatively minimal. Other than the parts I pointed out, you could for example, replace "The map I chose was John Hopkins..." with "The one I chose" to eliminate the repetition of "map." Or some other way. Vague words such as "everything" can be replaced by something more concrete such as "options," "freedom" etc

Another thing that could strengthen this is if you talk a little bit about your future direction, interests, etc, maybe just a hint.
alicela   
Dec 28, 2012
Undergraduate / Near train accident; University of Illinois/something more [4]

Since you are over the word limit, I'll focus on taking out unnecessary parts. Whether you keep them or omit them, is completely up to you however, unless I specifically state that it's better off not there.
alicela   
Dec 27, 2012
Undergraduate / Visual art and in business/ The cicada ; NYU App/ Program? What intrigues you? [8]

Overall, I find both of your essays to be very poetic and strong.

Yet, perhaps, the true value of the cicada is that people live vicariously through it.

This sentence is a bit unclear. Currently, the sentence states that 'the true value' of the cicada is that people 'live through it'. This is very vague, and I didn't understand. I strongly recommend revising it.

Good luck! Remember that all revisions are only suggestions! I'd gladly review your next draft if you would like ^__^
alicela   
Dec 27, 2012
Undergraduate / My father suffered from a stroke ; Johns Hopkins "Something about yourself?" [5]

The topic, your sentence structure and word choice, are good, but I believe that there must be more you can add to this. Many people are affected encounters with tragedies, and for understandable reasons. Death and danger of death is especially universal. However, this questions mentions that they want to know about you specifically. What personal development did you gain from this that only you could have gained? Your current essay is generally broad and unspecific currently, and does not say a lot about you as an individual.
alicela   
Dec 26, 2012
Undergraduate / Lego Cars; MIT App/ Pleasure activity [3]

luky0ne

Stack a lego piece on top of another and you getit becomes one structure; switch it around and you can getit becomes a completely different structure;T he endless possibilities that stem from simple pieces(the word 'individual components,' maybe?) is where my passion for building beganwhat began my passion for building (omit where. endless possibilities is not a place) . Every contraption I think up, I am able to build and tinker withI am able to build and tinker with every contraption I think up ; starting fF rom the basic Lego cars I built in my childhood(?), to working with VEX robotics in the present-day(?) , I have built a multitude of designs. For me building is a way to express my thoughts - a way to bring my ideas to life; it is what I love doing!

The fact I made a correction usually indicates an awkwardness, lack of flow, or grammatical mistake. The corrections I made are mostly suggestions, so feel free to alter your essay to suit your own voice! Feel free to repost your next draft, I'd be glad to critique it!
alicela   
Dec 26, 2012
Undergraduate / Business and Management/ NYU Supp/ Programs & Interests? [5]

How's my content though? Does it answer to the question effectively? Is my message clear?

And in answer to that question, I think your message is very clear. You want to become a successful businessman, and you decided the best way would to pursue NYU business. You admire and wish to have a interdisciplinary approach to your education. Your quote from Lee Kun Hee is an especially strong portion. It shows how you've been inspired by and admire an internationally successful businessman, and further supports your support for an interdisciplinary approach due to the comparison of a businessman to an artist. Finally, your last sentences show you have done your research. Your willingness to learn another foreign language (a fourth language, more impressively), shows your devotion to the global approach.

This is what I got from your essay. The only remark I'd make is that the ending is a bit typical.
alicela   
Dec 26, 2012
Undergraduate / Business and Management/ NYU Supp/ Programs & Interests? [5]

The tense in this part:

As I am preparing to grow myself prepare to grow as an international businessman, I am very excited to learn a fourth language in the Global Liberal Studies.

Honestly confuses me a bit. Rather than using present tense, maybe future tense? So it would look like this:

There, I can prepare myself to grow as an international businessman, and to learn a fourth language in through the Global Liberal Studies program.

If you want to correct it and have me critique it again, I'd be glad to ^__^ (I'm applying to NYU too, so good luck to both of us!! If you get in, I'd love to know). Remember that while I may point out errors and give suggestions, it is up to you on how to correct them!
alicela   
Dec 25, 2012
Undergraduate / I love to learn new and explore new things; Cornell sup [2]

Overall, the one thing that your essay would benefit most from would be showing instead of telling. The essay's is simply filled with telling. For example, instead of telling the reader that you run to your brother and play with him, you could describe how you felt while you played with him, and why that gave you joy. Another good idea would be to connect that to your core values.

Alternatively, you could further elaborate on why you are fascinated by the academic fields you mention (by adding depth, not broadness).
Writing
Editing Help?
Fill in one of the forms below to get professional help with your assignments:

Graduate Writing / Editing:
GraduateWriter form ◳

Best Essay Service:
CustomPapers form ◳

Excellence in Editing:
Rose Editing ◳

AI-Paper Rewriting:
Robot Rewrite ◳