pbhat
Dec 27, 2009
Undergraduate / Grandfather's Influence - Princeton Supplement [5]
I loved your introduction! I don't know about other people, but I started laughing.
With that said, there are a few things I would change/recommend to make this essay stellar.
My grandfather (ajoba), NAME, was born into a country on the verge of separation from the British Empire. Spending the majority of his years in a turbulent post-partition India, stories about his friends disappearing, daily riots in the streets, and terrifying commonplace crime found their ways into family discussions, inevitably reminding me of the richness of my family's history before their mass migration to COUNTRY. After settling in eastern CITY, he took up his true passion:
The above passage is a bit too lengthy. This isn't about your grandfather completely, it's about his profound influence. If I were you, I would condense the material into one or two lines and then directly address his garden. You will have more room to elaborate on your relationship with the garden- longer than the one sentence you have now.
Again, in a childish state of anger, I lividly asked my parents why my grandfather had given me a squash for my eleventh birthday.
The above statement is unnecessary because you mention afterward that you were the one who discovered its value- by yourself. No parents involved, thus the statement is extraneous.
I still look up to my grandfather very much to this day, and I hope that one day I will be able to sow my own garden, and give someone else a squash on their 11th birthday-it was the most meaningful and appreciated gift I have ever received.
If you can reword the conclusion and give the reader a gift then you will have a great essay. Right now, the essay ends weakly. You simply summarize your answer to the prompt. I like everything before the dash. Everything after the dash reduces the depth of your affection and understanding to a trite statement.
Other than that, I think your essay is great! It works well with the prompt and its about gardening (and Squash!)- now that's something unique.
I loved your introduction! I don't know about other people, but I started laughing.
With that said, there are a few things I would change/recommend to make this essay stellar.
My grandfather (ajoba), NAME, was born into a country on the verge of separation from the British Empire. Spending the majority of his years in a turbulent post-partition India, stories about his friends disappearing, daily riots in the streets, and terrifying commonplace crime found their ways into family discussions, inevitably reminding me of the richness of my family's history before their mass migration to COUNTRY. After settling in eastern CITY, he took up his true passion:
The above passage is a bit too lengthy. This isn't about your grandfather completely, it's about his profound influence. If I were you, I would condense the material into one or two lines and then directly address his garden. You will have more room to elaborate on your relationship with the garden- longer than the one sentence you have now.
Again, in a childish state of anger, I lividly asked my parents why my grandfather had given me a squash for my eleventh birthday.
The above statement is unnecessary because you mention afterward that you were the one who discovered its value- by yourself. No parents involved, thus the statement is extraneous.
I still look up to my grandfather very much to this day, and I hope that one day I will be able to sow my own garden, and give someone else a squash on their 11th birthday-it was the most meaningful and appreciated gift I have ever received.
If you can reword the conclusion and give the reader a gift then you will have a great essay. Right now, the essay ends weakly. You simply summarize your answer to the prompt. I like everything before the dash. Everything after the dash reduces the depth of your affection and understanding to a trite statement.
Other than that, I think your essay is great! It works well with the prompt and its about gardening (and Squash!)- now that's something unique.