Unanswered [1] | Urgent [0]
  

Posts by afwebb
Joined: Dec 28, 2010
Last Post: Jan 31, 2011
Threads: 6
Posts: 16  
From: US

Displayed posts: 22
sort: Oldest first   Latest first  | 
afwebb   
Dec 28, 2010
Essays / First vs Third person answers [5]

Yes, you should write in first person. Most essays are about something you have experienced so it makes sense they be from your perspective. Writing in third person is incredibly risky and I would personally advise against it.
afwebb   
Dec 28, 2010
Undergraduate / "I can't, I'm Mormon" - extracurricular activities [6]

Please briefly elaborate on one of your extracurricular activities or work experiences in the space below (150 words or fewer, 1000 character maximum).

Here's what I have come up with so far. I don't think I was able to provide enough details/examples, but it is currently 168 words.

I once read a t-shirt which read "I can't, I'm Mormon". I laughed as I read, thinking they couldn't be further from the truth. I may never see an r-rated movie and my Sundays and much of my free time may be consumed, but because of my being a Mormon I am now able to water-ski, speak in public, prepare a speech of the cuff, sing (well, to an extent), play the cello, and lead a group of my peers. Religion may not seem like an "extracurricular activity", but my church has allowed me to participate in more activities and volunteer work than if I were to join every club my high school has to offer. I doubt I would be able to do any of these things were it not for my church. Not only has being a Mormon expanded my opportunities to try new things and serve others, it has made me realize how much I can learn and do if I am willing to try.

Any suggestions would be greatly appreciated particularly regarding the topic and ways i can shorten it a little.
afwebb   
Dec 28, 2010
Undergraduate / "the High Mountain Institute; Spartan cabin" - CommonApp Personal [2]

Good essay and topic. The main problem I can see is the lack of voice. I think most readers would get bored during the first half so I would either shorten it or make it a little more "lively", people seem to eat that crap up. The other thing people seem to love is an "exciting introduction that draws you in", so I recommend trying to add something along those lines.

One last suggestion: the bulk of the essay seems to be the story of what happened, so you may want to expand the last part a bit or incorporate it into the story more. Particularly about how "He survived, not because of skill or preparedness, but because of luck", maybe try and draw some philosophical conclusion from it.
afwebb   
Dec 28, 2010
Undergraduate / "that real-world element" - why is stanford a good match for you [3]

I first read Adam's Smith Wealth of Nations when I was ten, and my subscription to The Economist began when I was twelve. However, at that timeIn retrospect , I had no idea what I was reading. I didn't know the difference between deflation and disinflation or between mutual funds and hedge funds. More importantly though, I it lacked any context for me behind it all (careful of the passive voice, adm people don't seem to like it) .

Good essay if you ask me. Not the most original, but i think its best you don't use the gimmicks you would for a general essay in this type. I think it's plenty entertaining and thoughtful, just a few minor fixes and you'll be good.
afwebb   
Dec 28, 2010
Undergraduate / UVA Essay Supp- "10 yr old business fail" What work of art, music, science, ... [3]

I'm not sure this essay quite fits the prompt to be honest. Are you saying the posters are the work of art?

if you want to stick to this topic I would recommend focusing more on what you learned from the experience or how it effected you rather than merely describing the experience. Talk about how you learned from your mistakes, and how learning from mistakes has helped you in your life.

You may want to edit the grammar more; i probably missed a few things.

Hope that was harsh enough for you. Good Luck
afwebb   
Dec 29, 2010
Undergraduate / "My biggest blunder; cutting down the wrong tree"- Common app essay [10]

Just finished a draft of my common app essay. I had a very hard time coming up with a topic and writing an essay; i'm no good at writing about myself. This is the best I could come up with. Not much of a topic but I did what I could with it.

I'm concerned it might not be serious enough or a little unclear. Please let me know what you think I could change to make it better.

Of course please be harsh and make any changes you feel necessary, be they big or small.
Thank you in advance for the help and I promise to return the favor for any advice.
p.s. it's only around 500 words because Yale wants it that way

Evaluate a significant experience, achievement, risk you have taken, or ethical dilemma you have faced and its impact on you

Here's an updated draft. I'm still undecided on a few things; I think i'll implement a few other revisions soon. It would be great if someone could let me know if anything is unclear about it still.

"Why did you cut down that tree?" my dad asked as he inspected what I then thought to be a completed assignment. I was about to refute the validity of his question, claiming that it was what he had asked me to do several hours and a gallon or two of sweat earlier (not sure about this last bit) . I then stared incredulously at another tree, still standing, just a few feet away, and realized all my work had been worthless. I had cut down the wrong tree.

My backyard used to consist of a meager patch of grass, a small garden, and a couple of grapefruit trees. My mom, wanting to expand our garden, was obstructed by the position of one of these trees. Seeing that this tree no longer produced any fruit she decided it was time to chop it down and uproot the stump of the offending plant. Shortly thereafter, despite my best reasons why my brother ought to be enlisted to the task instead, I was out hacking my way through a tree trunk. This was by no means a pleasant task, as anyone who has been in Arizona during the summer can attest. Strangely it never crossed my mind whether or not this was the correct tree. Motivated by a desire for an air-conditioned room and to move on to whatever apparently forgettable plans I had that night, I completed what I then thought to be the task at hand, thinking only of finishing as quickly as possible.

This motivation made learning that all my blisters and sore muscles had been for naught all the worse. My first instinct was to blame my blunder on someone else, or find a way around repeating the arduous task. There was no one else to blame and no other solution. I came to terms with what I had to do and, now knowing full well what lay ahead of me, I grudgingly began work on the correct tree.

This left me with an unwelcome amount of time to reflect on the mistake I had made. I was surprised to find that this time was considerably less than expected based on my previous experience. At first I thought maybe this tree was smaller, or the roots may not have been as deep. I then realized the difference was my own experience. After having done the same thing just moments before I knew exactly how I ought to swing the axe and just where around the stump I ought to dig.

It may not seem like a very significant experience, but it taught me not to fear failure, but learn from it as I make a second attempt. Rather than getting angry and frustrated over having done a math problem incorrectly or being reprimanded by my parents, I try and isolate what led me astray and refrain from repeating that mistake. From chopping down the wrong tree, I have learned not to avoid mistakes and their consequences, but to face them and learn from the experience.
afwebb   
Dec 29, 2010
Undergraduate / "A story with no conflict at all" - Stanford SOP [7]

"The best stories of time possibly have the worst situations to be dealt with." This was just a good story. I'm waiting for the best stories of my life.I'm anxious to see what others life has to throw at me.

Too be honest i'm not a fan of the topic. It seems a little petty and dull. You should try and shorten it quite a bit; i would just get rid of the whole beauty pageant thing and expand on how you were conflicted between your commitment to the project and your studies. I love your beginning and end, very unique and interesting way to begin an essay that is less unique in subject.

I would recommend making major changes to the length and content. Make it more interesting in the middle. Hope you could find something useful in all my harsh criticism.

Best of luck
afwebb   
Dec 29, 2010
Undergraduate / "My biggest blunder; cutting down the wrong tree"- Common app essay [10]

"The Wrong Tree"- common app essay

Just finished a draft of my common app essay. I had a very hard time coming up with a topic and writing an essay; i'm no good at writing about myself. This is the best I could come up with. Not much of a topic but I did what I could with it.

I'm concerned it might not be serious enough or a little unclear. Please let me know what you think I could change to make it better.

Of course please be harsh and make any changes you feel necessary, be they big or small.
Thank you in advance for the help and I promise to return the favor for any advice.
p.s. it's only around 500 words because Yale wants it that way.
afwebb   
Dec 29, 2010
Student Talk / Any list of essays to be prepared for exam? [5]

Well before you write the essay you may want to work on your grammar. Second, I have no idea what you're talking about.

What exam are you talking about and what is the essay on? try asking your question again, it makes no sense to me as is.
afwebb   
Dec 30, 2010
Undergraduate / Holden Caulfield, the protagonist in the novel, The Catcher in the Rye, COMMONAPP [5]

You answered the prompt adequately, but you run a bit of a risk using Mr. Caulfield as your topic. You do an adequate job, but I've seen several other essays using the same character and read on several sites to avoid Holden; he's been done to death. If you're set on that topic you may consider getting rid of the first part of your essay. Anyone reading your essay will be familiar with the book and will have read plenty of essays like yours, so there's no need to summarize the events of the book. Also try and be a little more specific about examples from your own life.

If you have the time you may want to consider really reworking your essay and even changing the topic. Their are going to be plenty of essays out there no different than yours; I don't think you're really helping yourself standout with this one.

Sorry to be so blunt, but simply telling you your essay is done well, while true, isn't helping your cause much.
afwebb   
Dec 30, 2010
Undergraduate / "parents were going through a custody and visitation battle" - (Princeton- Summers) [3]

I think you're writing is solid. I was going to go through and edit the whole thing, but I didn't see anything that needed correcting or rewording.

You may want to try and sound a little less whiny. Be careful you don't seem like you're just complaining about the situation with your parents.The last sentence might need some rewording, as well as several parts of the first paragraph. I think if you added a few subtle changes it would help change the tone of your essay a lot.

What I think I would do is be a little more clear about what you had hoped to accomplish over the summer, and how your actual summer differed from those expectations. A sentence about how despite the fact your summer wasn't what you had hoped, you learned this, this and this; or you found that life is full of disappointments, and that it's not about the obstacles you face, but what you can accomplish despite those obstacles.

I guess doing that makes it sound more like a normal essay, but I think if you are subtle about you can make it still sound like just an account of your summer.
afwebb   
Dec 30, 2010
Undergraduate / "my low grades" - Northwestern- would you send an essay like this to a school? [11]

You didn't answer the prompt. This isn't about why you would be good for northwestern, it's about what about Northwestern is good for you. I would rewrite your essay, and instead of saying why you would be a good candidate, tell them what about the school interests you and what you intend to do with the resources they provide.

Never try and make excuses for your bad grades; the person reading the essay will not appreciate it.
afwebb   
Dec 30, 2010
Undergraduate / "Chicago, the scientific community" - Why Northwestern? [NEW]

Just finished my Northwestern essay. It's not the best, nor the most original, but I'm fine with that. Any advice would be great on anything you see wrong with it; I would be glad to reciprocate the favor. It's not very long, and I'm not sure if thats a problem. Let me know if you think I should try and add more to it.

What are the unique qualities of Northwestern - and of the specific undergraduate school to which you are applying - that make you want to attend the University? In what ways do you hope to take advantage of the qualities you have identified?

Having lived in Naperville, Illinois as a child I can recall visiting the beaches of Northwestern's campus. Being only five years old at the time I doubt I even knew what the word "university" meant, but I remember seeing the campus and wanting to go there someday. Of course I had very few reasons why I wanted to go at that time, aside from Northwestern's proximity to my house at the time and its beautiful campus. Since then, I've developed a few better reasons why I know, as a seventeen year old, find attending Northwestern to be an ideal opportunity.

Topping the list is the integrated science program unique to Northwestern. My prospective field is physics, and it has become apparent to me that in order to anything with physics a solid background in mathematics is prerequisite. As such an undergraduate experience that not only has a solid physics department, but an effective means by which these two fields can be incorporated was one of the largest contributing factors in my college decision. Thus a "tailor-made honors curriculum that integrates mathematics with the sciences" is ideal for me to reach my goals not only in the next four years, but as I advance to graduate school and a career. I hope to be involved in research someday, and in order to make a contribution to the scientific community experience in all fields of science and as well as research is essential. The integrated science program offered by Northwestern meets any and all hopes I could have to give me the tools to be successful in the future.

Many of those I have told my career plans to have been surprised I hope to attend a liberal arts university, thinking a liberal arts focus detracts from the "hardcore" scientific curriculum. I don't find this to be the case with Northwestern. The fact Northwestern is a liberal arts university means to me that I can receive a multifaceted education in any field I have interest while pursuing my major, and infuse these other fields to my own interest of study. Not to mention the lack of reputation as a school for physics majors means I can get more hands-on attention and experience with less competition for lab space and smaller class sizes.

Since having lived near the Chicago area when I was younger I still remember the awe I experienced while in that city. I would revel in the opportunity to return to that area again in the pursuit of knowledge at a first-rate university and take in all the experience and knowledge that area has to offer.
afwebb   
Dec 30, 2010
Undergraduate / free afternoon + physics teacher compliment + the bing bang + questions - Yale [6]

Here are my answers... Let me know what you think of them, or ways I can improve.
Thank you in advance

Why Yale?
Still formulating a response...

What would you do with a free afternoon tomorrow?
I would use most of the time getting through a book off my list of things I haven't yet had time to read. The rest I would spend outside; either running or playing soccer.

Recall a compliment you have received. What was it? From whom did it come?
My physics teacher once called me a "freak"; a distinction earned by only a select few. This made me realize I didn't just enjoy physics, but have a chance to be good at it.

If you could witness one moment in history, what would it be and why?
Not sure this counts as history, but I would want to witness the moments just before and after the big bang because I want to understand how and why things are.

What do you wish you were better at being or doing?
I wish I was better at worthwhile questions. All the information in the world is useless to me without a question I want answered.

What other question would you ask that we have not?
What is the one thing you could not live without?
afwebb   
Dec 31, 2010
Undergraduate / (land of opportunities) + (diversity) + (M.L. King) cut down count for NYU [2]

If America is the land of opportunities, NYC is where dreams come true. I have always seen NYC and NYU as a distant dream, something that couldn't happen to an Ethiopian girl who lives in the suburbs of Virginia. And yet, I'm applying to NYUI see what you're trying to say, but i would try something different. Maybe like "now I hope to make that dream a reality". . I'm not sure what I specifically want to study; I can only say that I'm a learner and my excitement to know everything is what is makes me so indecisive. But I believe that if anywhere, the atmosphere of NYU would be the perfect place to cultivate a desirable area to study.Same as last time, you could say this a little better. Maybe "NYU would be the perfect place to cultivate this excitement/passion/interest to allow me to contribute to an area of study."

I get the impression you had a word limit, but i'm not sure. If your close to it I think you can leave it as is. If not, or you still have a lot of room, maybe talk about loving all the activities or classes you took in high school and learning so much from all of them made it difficult for you to choose one field. That way you can fulfill the "Mention any extracurricular or non-school-related activities or experiences that demonstrate your interest." part of the prompt
afwebb   
Dec 31, 2010
Undergraduate / "the books in Linsly-Chittenden hall and the walls of Paul-Rudolf" - MY WHY YALE? [7]

The first and last sentences are a little long. I would either shorten them or make each into two separate sentences. As is, I found it a little rough in terms of flow, particularly the first sentence.

As far as subject i'm not sure. Personally, I think this is meant as less of an essay and more of an "actually tell us what you want to do here". As such I feel you ought to try and pick something specific about the university that you like, rather than making too general of statements. Yours is pretty exclusive to you, but not Yale. You run a risk with the anecdote approach but at least its personal.

Not sure that made any sense to you, but I hope it helps.
afwebb   
Jan 1, 2011
Undergraduate / "the Arizona sun lifeguarding" - Princeton- My last two summers [3]

Here's my Princeton summer break essay. I can't believe I procrastinated this long, but its due today so i'm a little desperate for help. Any revisions, particularly near the end, or just general thoughts on what I can improve would be greatly appreciated.

Please tell us how you have spent the last two summers (or vacations between school years), including any jobs you have held, if not already detailed on the Common Application.

Because of my exceptionally white skin, many are surprised to learn that the bulk of my last two summers have been spent out in the Arizona sun lifeguarding. While I may have failed to get a tan I did ascertain considerable work and life experience. Motivated by my love of swimming and pressure from my mom, who had been a lifeguard as a teenager herself, I applied for a job as a lifeguard after my sophomore year. Having sacrificed my spring break to become a certified rescuer, I was rather nervous about whether or not I would be hired based on the economic situation of the time and the reports I had heard from friends of unsuccessful attempts to get a job. I was relieved when I was able to find work and make use of those hours of training.

During that first summer I was hesitant about my duties as a lifeguard; watching over a hundred people whom I was responsible for was a nerve-racking thought. The possibility of what could happen if I failed to do my job correctly haunted me originally. My training had given me some confidence, but it wasn't until I had spent some time guarding that I was able to feel comfortable with my responsibilities. Despite my experience, I still feel a combination of uneasiness and pride concerning the prospect of rescuing someone. I guess it's rather fortunate that I gained more experience cleaning toilets while at the pool than I did performing actual rescues. Over the last two summers I have performed three rescues, and though it may not seem like many I feel a sense of accomplishment when I think of them.

The time I spent outside the pool was used hanging out with friends, attending scout camp, and reading. One of my favorite things about summer is the fact I have plenty of time to read. Some of my favorites during that time were The Count of Monte Cristo, Atlas Shrugged and The Fountainhead, 1984, and of course, the final Harry Potter. It's a good thing the last Harry Potter came out during the summer, because otherwise I may have been tempted to ditch school for a day or two to when it came out. The rest of my time was mostly spent swimming, drawing, just watching television, and simply enjoying the time I had off.

oh, and i didn't underline book titles here, but I did in my actual essay
afwebb   
Jan 1, 2011
Undergraduate / "the robotics club" - JHU What extracurricular activities do you plan on joining? [2]

I can relate. I don't think you need to worry about it sounding like a list; the aren't looking for fancy artsy and literary crap here in my opinion. I'm not sure I like the first part to be honest.It sounds a bit like you don't care about education that much or its not a big priority for you. Also, try not to brag about your accomplishments. you stayed away from it mostly but be careful of your wording.
afwebb   
Jan 1, 2011
Undergraduate / "the Arizona sun lifeguarding" - Princeton- My last two summers [3]

Thanks for the advice. Not sure how to integrate it in effectively, but i'll do what I can. And Harry Potter was released in July 2007, so I guess that was three years ago. Oh, well, you're right, those parts didn't really add anything anyway.
afwebb   
Jan 31, 2011
Scholarship / "Physics: the understanding of mankind through research" - BYU - career goals [2]

Essay #2:
Please describe your educational, professional, and other goals. Describe how BYU
will help you achieve them. Limit your response to 300 words.

How can matter be both a wave and a particle simultaneously? I have no idea, but I would certainly like to find out. Questions like these, about the universe and the how the world works, have always fascinated me. It is in finding answers to complicated and interesting questions that has inspired me to pursue a career in science. Though I did not realize it at the time, my love of science began at BYU: At the age of two I remember standing in awe, at the enormous dinosaur in particular, in the Eyring Science Center with my parents while they were attending BYU and being fascinated by it. Because of this, from the very start of my life BYU has been associated in my mind with scientific intrigue. My interests have been refined over the years, but the desire to understand the natural world has led me to an interest in physics, and to BYU. As Albert Einstein once said "science without religion is lame; religion without science is blind". This is what makes BYU the ideal place to study physics: it possesses the unique synthesis of these two, science and religion, thereby providing the only holistic view of both. I intend to study physics and eventually earn a Ph.D. so as to be involved in researching and teaching in that field. Though this career I hope to increase my understanding of things as they are. But more importantly, I hope to give the knowledge that I find so valuable to others who can, with any luck, get some use out of what I hope to discover and teach. My ultimate goal is to make a difference in this world; by adding to the understanding of mankind through research, and assisting those whom I will teach, I intend to accomplish it.

This is my scholarship essay or BYU. It is due tomorrow, so any suggestions would be great. BYU is very much a religious university for those unfamiliar with it; and i'm actually considering trying to integrate more religious aspects in if i can.

its a few words over the limit, but I think the last two sentences can be combined into one. Also i'm a little unsure what to think of the intro...

Any specific suggestion or general suggestions on what I can improve would be greatly appreciated
Need Writing or Editing Help?
Fill out one of these forms:

Graduate Writing / Editing:
GraduateWriter form ◳

Best Essay Service:
CustomPapers form ◳

Excellence in Editing:
Rose Editing ◳

AI-Paper Rewriting:
Robot Rewrite ◳

Academic AI Writer:
Custom AI Writer ◳