Unanswered [17] | Urgent [0]
  

Posts by Katsch
Joined: Nov 23, 2009
Last Post: Dec 31, 2009
Threads: 4
Posts: 63  


Displayed posts: 67 / page 2 of 2
sort: Latest first   Oldest first  | 
Katsch   
Dec 20, 2009
Undergraduate / Michigan essay your favourite book [6]

I definitely agree, they way you characterize your friends makes you look bad also. Besides, if you say at the end that they didn't affect your choices, why talk about them at all? It's not like they were an obstacle to your learning, you chose to be friends with them.

The advice in this book is the same which every elder gives an adolescent but in this book it is done in such a way that touches the hearts of its readers.

This is overdoing it. Plus, you don't even tell us what was so great about this book, at least give examples. What did the book say?
Katsch   
Dec 19, 2009
Undergraduate / Quote relating to AP Physics C short essay [2]

Is that quote really from an essay or book? The prompt was kind of specific about it needing to be something you've read in the past three years.

I understand that you want to perhaps explain offhand why you didn't do so well initially, but it does seem a little bit like you're trying to make excuses.

I would instead focus on the extra work you did to keep up with the class, and perhaps contrast better scores at the end of the year with your initial failure? Explain for us how far perseverance ended up taking you. Colleges do like to see progress.

However... if you still weren't doing so well, maybe another topic might be a better choice. This is the Princeton essay, right? You definitely want to put yourself in the best light you can, considering the other candidates in their pool.

And yes, I would write more. When they ask for 500 words, I think it's safe if your word count is between 400 and 500. Expand more on specific examples that show your determination, and also evaluate yourself more at the end. Good luck!
Katsch   
Dec 19, 2009
Undergraduate / A European Experiment in Intolerance [9]

I do agree with Susan, it looks like it belongs in Time.
However, you do happen to be writing a college essay, and I'm sure the admissions officers would want to know why this means you should be accepted to their college?

"Write about an issue of personal, local, national or global concern and its importance to you."

I feel like you're lacking some personal connections of this issue to you. Why did you choose to write about this? What does your stance on this issue mean about you? You do analyze the issue well, but I'm sure colleges would rather see you analyze yourself. Why did you respond to this event the way you did? For example, one of my friends talked about the importance of public transportation, but in his essay he also talked about how he was working with local officials to improve buses, etc.

Remember the audience you're writing to, and convince admissions officers that you're more than just a reporter. You're an intellectually inquisitive student that should be accepted into their colleges, and if you shift some focus to yourself in this essay, I'm sure you'll be fine. You write very well.
Katsch   
Dec 18, 2009
Undergraduate / Rice Perspective Essay - elderly tennis stars. [6]

This prompt confused me a little, so I'd like to know if I'm answering the question fully. And I'd really appreciate constructive criticism on this, thank you for taking a look!

Prompt: The quality of Rice's academic life and the Residential College System are heavily influenced by the unique life experiences and cultural traditions each student brings. What perspective do you feel that you will contribute to life at Rice? (Most applicants are able to respond successfully in two to three double-spaced pages.)

---
I feel trapped in a state of hazy yellow this Sunday morning. As I trail bleary-eyed behind my mother onto the tennis court, I gaze up at the clouds lethargically drifting by. The sky has a soft lemon glow to it, one that provokes an escape back under the covers, not hours of athletic exertions and sweat. Through the drowsy veil over my eyes, I peer curiously at the strangers arranged against the chain-link fence and smile to myself. Perhaps I'll get rest after all; my mother's tennis friends would seem more at home indoors playing bingo than outside on the court. The buttery morning light diffuses across their hunched figures, highlights the wrinkles in their skin, and, if anything, only adds to their gentle elderly appearance.

As we arrange ourselves for a doubles match, I relax my muscles and prepare myself for a leisurely rally. My "opponents" will surely tire soon. I only hope they will have enough energy left for their afternoon naps. Nestling into the golden embrace of the morning, I let my eyelids droop halfway back into sweet repose, but a different yellow haze soon fills my vision. It appears to be... coming closer?

Suddenly, a serve rockets past my head at an impossible speed, leaving a stream of neon tennis-ball fuzz in its wake. Eyes jolted open, I stare blankly at the culprit, a man old enough to be my grandfather. His cheeky grin seems to tell me, no, this is not a game to take lightly. We're here to play.

Every Sunday since then, I've rolled out of bed and slapped myself awake for the challenge to come. Ron's killer serve clears the net only half of the time, but even without the advantage of surprise, it requires my undivided attention. I fear my arm bones may never stop wobbling from the impact, but there's no time to recuperate. Doris slices the ball across the court, while Barry continues glaring from the net through his polarized sunglasses. He says it unnerves people. And it does.

I suppose it is a little strange seeing us tear up the court. Our multi-generational group has the upper end of the spectrum well represented, but I am the only player under fifty. Although I do have a slight advantage with sprinting, they are the clear winners in dedication and passion, playing each week despite the fact that almost all wear knee or elbow braces. These seniors continue to destroy my preconceptions of senile sexagenarians, Sunday after Sunday, and though they have certainly given me many energizing games, they've also given me something else - a perspective unclouded by a haze of set expectations, one that is instead open to all possibilities.

Throughout my life, Sunday tennis being no exception, I've found that people tend to surpass the limits we set for them in our minds. First impressions are often wrong, as Ron, Barry, and Doris have shown me. With the random distribution in Rice's Residential College System, I fully expect to be surprised by my peers, as contradictory as that may sound. I don't know who I will meet in the future, but I'm ready to receive each new person with open arms. Instead of filing people under categories based on just one aspect of their identity, whether it be age or ethnicity or major, I plan on letting my fellow students show me who they are and what they can do. My new tennis friends sure did. After all, I do like a good surprise, as long as it's not zipping past my head at eighty miles an hour.
Katsch   
Dec 17, 2009
Undergraduate / Why biomedical engineer? Why Johns Hopkins? [8]

I'm sorry I don't have to time to give more detailed comments, but I would suggest that you vary your sentence length in the second paragraph you just posted? Perhaps try reading it aloud and combine a few sentences.
Katsch   
Dec 16, 2009
Undergraduate / "Whistler"- Common app main essay(Topic of your choice) [5]

I agree with Liebe. To me, you are only using whistling as a device through which you can explain all of the things that you think will look good to colleges, as harsh as that may sound.

I like your writing style, and I think this is a nice essay, but I feel like it would benefit you to either focus entirely on your whistling and how it makes you who you are, or choose one of the blurbs you have and expand on that.

Think about what are you passionate about, and try to keep your essay focused instead of all-compassing.
Katsch   
Dec 16, 2009
Undergraduate / Cornell's College of Arts and Sciences Supplement-- What Should I Fix? [3]

The description in your first paragraph is very nice! I can definitely see you cozying up with a book.

was enamored to a talk show-host's booming articulation

enamored by

I envisaged myself

envisioned myself

my appreciation for literature and communication has continued to heighten

either change "has continued" to just "continued", or make the verbs in the rest of the sentence present tense as well.

Interestingly enough, my fields of interest directly clash with those of my parents'. My father is a calculus professor and my mother is a microbiologist.

actually, their professions don't necessarily clash with your interest in words. Almost all professions require communication skills, whether through speaking or writing, and their jobs in math and science don't automatically mean they don't like language.

My lack of interest (and a correlating decline in performance, naturally)

ah, okay, this is a little iffy. You're trying to justify perhaps bad grades in math and science because you don't like the subject. However, to colleges, just because you're not as interested in something doesn't excuse a lack of hard work. I would take this out and simply focus on how you're passionate about other things, not how you aren't passionate about this.

Also, besides the possibility of a double major, how will Cornell benefit you? I think they'd want to see some mention of specific programs or aspects of their college.
Katsch   
Dec 16, 2009
Undergraduate / Princeton Supplemental Essay: Transforming Stones into Diamonds [8]

I'm actually a little confused by the motivational speaker's story.

The speaker was urging the sea of green shirts not to go through life as the first man did.

It seems the point of the story is that you should persevere and not give up, but the way the men are picking up the stones driven by only desires of greed, the diamonds, is probably not the message the story was supposed to convey.

Could you perhaps summarize what the story's moral was? I know you included the tale because you wanted to make that connection between the stones, but is there any greater connection between "if you pick up stones, good things will happen"? Your stones are questions, a search for knowledge, but the story's stones are not quite that.

Also, I think writing about your faith is fine, but again, I'm a little confused.

Some part of me didn't believe that those stones would ever become diamonds; that there were actually answers to defend Christ.

Other people are afraid to ask questions about their faith, but you asked questions so... you can defend your faith? Are you trying to find answers to defend Christ, and is finding answers turning the stones into diamonds? This sentence makes it seem like the stones won't be diamonds because there are answers in religion.

I like your style of writing, and I think this essay is well-written as well, but I think it is your flow of thoughts that has me more confused.
Katsch   
Dec 15, 2009
Undergraduate / "Life is like a box of chocolates" - COMMON APP Activities Short Essay [4]

I like how you integrate the quote, but it seems like you only want to emphasize that you've been active in school when the rest of the application will already do that.

Through Student Government, National Honor Society, National English Honor Society, and volunteering on my own time

For example, in this part you just list your activities when the extracurricular part of your app does the exact same thing.

Admissions officers will want to see what you're truly passionate about, so I would pick one activity and focus on that. I'd love to see what you could write then.
Katsch   
Dec 13, 2009
Undergraduate / Cornell University -- Why Engineering? [6]

Make sure you touch on some specific aspects of Cornell's engineering program. Specifically, how will Cornell help you?

You write a beautiful narrative, but you'll probably need to cut out a paragraph's worth of description in order to answer the second part of the question.
Katsch   
Dec 13, 2009
Undergraduate / "Convey to the Reader a Sense of Who You Are" - Columbia and Common App Essay [3]

You have a very powerful writing style.
As much as I like the introduction, it doesn't tie in as well to the rest of the essay to me. It feels as if you would talk about those different moments in your life after that, but you focus on your love for history and music instead, so it becomes more unnecessary.

there is a connection I feel to the music

"I feel a connection to the music" [avoid passive tense, right?]

I love the chance every Friday to drive out to Victoria's house

"I love the chance I get every Friday to drive out to my teacher Victoria's house"

I definitely like it though.
Katsch   
Dec 13, 2009
Undergraduate / Hopkins essay, a shopping addiction [6]

Very nice, I think it definitely brings us into your mind and thought process! You do have some grammatical errors, I wish I had time to more throughly edit your paper. Try to get someone to proofread it for you.

Although the first change would be to take out one of the lines at the end of your third paragraph.
"Thus, I decided to major psychology as my first choice. This is why I chose psychology as my first choice." < It's redundant, pick one sentence or the other. (:
Katsch   
Dec 13, 2009
Undergraduate / "I had a crush on Jennifer" - Essay Prompt [8]

I'm not sure, but you might want to avoid topics about dating/relationships? My English teacher said it might seem a bit insignificant, that admissions officers wouldn't be as interested by teenage romance.

For your third paragraph, is there any way you could be more specific about this girl? How did she show you "it was okay to be yourself," especially if you only asked her out after you lost weight? It seems a little contradictory.

After you started dating, did you just gain confidence from dating a pretty girl? I don't quite understand.
Katsch   
Dec 12, 2009
Undergraduate / My family, The world I come from. MIT essay. [17]

I think you could leave out the parts where you only describe your surroundings and not how they influence you, such as when you talk about your parents and city.

I would focus on the parts where you talk about having a smaller school, being familiar with your teachers, and how they gave you opportunities to compete in math. That would make for a much nicer, focused essay. (:
Katsch   
Dec 12, 2009
Undergraduate / Common Application Essay - Topic of your Choice - Importance work ethic [5]

Some may work voraciously to accomplish them while others may do so with disregard.halfheartedly.

Throughout society, there are those who work just enough to keep their job, and there are those who simply sit at home without initiative.

Living with this mentality will not allow for advancement in one's life, which can lead to feeling unimportant.a feeling of unimportance.

On top of disappointment in oneself,

No matter in whatRegardless of the application, personal work ethics can either propel one to success or leave one behind.

I'm not sure about using this for a college essay. It's nicely written, but the overall tone feels more like a blunt English paper, which I realize it is, than an essay showing the admissions officers some of your personality and thought process. For example, the part about you working to get good grades. They receive your transcripts, so by seeing you did well in school, they can assume you worked hard. So do many other students.

If possible, it would benefit you to write about something more unique about yourself. You want to stand out among the candidates, and I think most colleges expect applicants to work hard in school, considering the transcript is the most important part of the process.
Katsch   
Dec 12, 2009
Undergraduate / Common Application essay + short answer: [ a spelling bee and artistry.] [5]

[ common app essay prompt. ] -- ah, so I really don't know what other people would think about this. I was a little concerned after reading that you should avoid writing about events too far back. I'd really appreciate any opinions!

250 word minimum: Evaluate a significant experience, achievement, risk you have taken, or ethical dilemma you have faced and its impact on you.

There was wordlust in my eyes. Driven by a hunger for new and exotic vocabulary, I pestered my family to feed me word after word, and I tore each apart letter by letter with an unbridled voracity. In the weeks before the Delaware state spelling bee, I planned to bulk up on words as much as humanly possible.

Spelling bees are extreme examples of Darwin's "survival of the fittest" theory. In order to make the cut, a contestant must have extraordinary dedication and stamina. Dedication comes first, the sheer devotion to a skill made nearly obsolete by technology; stamina comes later, the ability to continue poring down spelling lists even after exhaustion sways the letters to and fro in one's vision. I thought I possessed both qualities, and even one more - an innate love of words. I have always been fascinated by words, ever since the day I learned to spell "chrysanthemum" in second grade.

Four grades later, I still harbored a special fondness for sesquipedalian words, enraptured by the lull of their many syllables. They were the life of the etymological party, so to say, and I needed their excitement in my hours of studying. I feasted heartily on words like "connoisseur" and "chauffeur," noting the double letters, the bane of my spelling existence. At the age of eleven, I could boast that I knew not only what a klipspringer was, but how to spell it too. On the other hand, I nonchalantly tossed away the scraps, the mundane words of everyday language. "Believe" and "neighbor?" Please. The English language contains more words than any single person could learn in a lifetime; there was simply no time for run of the mill, sixth-grade vocabulary.

Finally, my time had come. The morning of the bee, I felt well rested, catching sunbeams in my open mouth with a drowsy yawn. Fifteen minutes before the start of the bee, my head was still tilted regally in self-assurance as I filed onto the stage with the others and took my seat. Only a few minutes later, however, I was trembling, and it seemed inexplicable to me. My mother, father, and little sister sat in the dim auditorium, confident they had prepared me well. I had devoured scores upon scores of luscious words, so why did my stomach feel so queasy?

I walked into the lights.

"Your word is 'permanent,'" said the announcer.

"Permanent." I traced the letters out on the podium. I hadn't studied this, but it was an easy enough word, a mere appetizer for what would come.

"P-e-r-m-a-n... a-n-t. Permanent."

"Is that a-n-t?" clarified the announcer. I nodded.

My sister buried her head in the nook of my mom's arm. Did the lights on the stage suddenly seem brighter, harsher? I barely heard the announcer speak, but I sensed the sympathy in his words. In a daze, I watched as the rest of the participants took their turn, subsequently taking their seats permanently just as I had-all but the winner. The embarrassment and shock of my mistake didn't hit hard until later. My family offered words of consolation, but rings of red still encircled my sister's eyes. I had messed up on the most basic word, one I had pretentiously overlooked. It's almost ironic that this single word has had such a lasting impact on me. Challenging myself with the hardest of subjects or the longest of words has its place, but it means nothing without a grasp of the fundamentals. An unbalanced diet of knowledge only leads to future stomach aches. I would know; it's written on my brain in Sharpie.

[ 602 words ]
-----

[ common app short answer. ] -- I had a lot of trouble with this one. It feels dry to me... I think part of that is because I like telling narratives, and I used up my word limit only to explain things. I'm still over by 15 words, so I'd love some harsh critique on this.

150 words or less: In the space provided below, please elaborate on one of your activities (extracurricular, personal activities, or work experience).

When I discovered that I could sell my digital artwork online, what started as a passion evolved into a passionate side job. My freelancing business perfectly married my artistic desires for improvement and my hopes to earn some money.

As with any marriage, commitment was key. With an expectant buyer at the other end of the transaction, not only was a timely delivery essential, but a dedication to quality was also. Fine-tuning my Photoshop skills took hours of practice, supplemented by both self-reflection and critique from fellow artists.

Still, thriving in an online market required an entirely new skill set. A need for ardent self-promotion conflicted with my humble, even self-deprecating, tendencies, but interacting with appreciative customers gave me a renewed sense of pride in my work. Each piece was as much for the buyer as it was for me, and now when I look back at that art, I don't think of the price I was paid. I only see the progress I've made.

[165 words]

Thank you for looking! (:
Katsch   
Dec 7, 2009
Undergraduate / "I now understand the value family" - Michigan Setback [5]

I would perhaps combine some of the sentences in your first paragraph. Too many short lines makes it sound a little choppy.

"The screaming, the glasses breaking, the tears shedding" --> The screaming, the breaking of glasses, the shedding of tears [parallel structure requires them to all be nouns]

"As much as I wanted to be thirteen year old about to start his adolescence, I was forced into becoming the man of the house. " --> At the age of thirteen, I was excited to enter my adolescence; instead, I was forced into becoming the man of the house. [may or may not sound better, just another option]

I'm sorry I didn't quite have time to check the last three paragraphs for grammar, but I think you answer the prompt quite well.
Katsch   
Dec 7, 2009
Undergraduate / Common App Essay "Shower Dreams" [10]

Forgive me if I'm just being ignorant, but what exactly is the impression you are trying to make about yourself in this essay? And what is the significance behind using the shower imagery? Is it just a place you can dream?

After reading this, I get the idea that you're trying to show your diversity of interests, but it feels a bit disjointed to me combining them into a single essay as you mind skips from future career to future career.

It may be just my opinion, but I think an essay should focus more on a single aspect of you and cover it thoroughly than try to cover all points more vaguely. I really enjoy your descriptive language though, and this is a very nicely written essay. I'd definitely get some more thoughts from other people on this one, as I'm not sure what an admissions officer would want to see.
Katsch   
Dec 3, 2009
Undergraduate / Engineering, an Artist - Critique my UVA Supplement essays? [7]

Thanks again, yang and izlong!

I absolutely gutted the first paragraph so I think I have a breathing space of about 50 words to be more specific about the program. And in all seriousness, I do appreciate the bluntness, yang. It definitely helps.

On their website they seemed to stress, "ABET recently cited BME's true dual culture in engineering and medicine, which is almost unique to UVa, as one of our particular program strengths" but perhaps I interpreted it wrong.

Will be editing some more tonight.
Katsch   
Dec 2, 2009
Undergraduate / UC Prompt #1 - How We Reason [3]

It was fall 2005, not long after I moved to the U.S. On a stormy, rainy day, I had just gotten out of school and was walking home when I suddenly saw that there was a car driving into a slough, passing right next to me at a very high speed. Realizing it was all rain and dirt, and could not avoid it; [I don't really understand what you're saying there?] I tried my best to stay away from the curb and prayed that the driver would slow down. Right whenAs I was praying, the driver stepped on the gas pedal and passed me inat a greater speed. The driver did not even have any intention of slowing down or stopping. I was upset and started to wonder why the driver did not slow down while he was passing pedestrian or why he was even speeding up and does not have any sign of stopping to see if the pedestrian were fine.the driver would speed up as he was passing a pedestrian without any regard to the person walking. This event brought up my interest in how humans reason and decide as they are being called, the study of Philosophy.

--
I'm sorry, I only had time to edit the first paragraph, but it would help a lot if you had someone else also edit the rest for grammar and spelling as well!

I like how you give different examples, but I think you could make this more interesting and personal if you went over your thoughts about each situation as well as describing it. Perhaps try to illustrate what was going through your mind, maybe your ideas on why those people acted differently?
Katsch   
Dec 2, 2009
Undergraduate / Engineering, an Artist - Critique my UVA Supplement essays? [7]

@yang: I can't thank you enough! I definitely agree with both of those suggestions for my first prompt.

I tried to be more specific in this draft and tie it into the school more, but I'm still not sure if it's enough. I think I need to cut down my first two paragraphs somehow, but a way to do that is sort of eluding me. I may just end up submitting as is.
Katsch   
Dec 1, 2009
Undergraduate / Engineering, an Artist - Critique my UVA Supplement essays? [7]

Ah, so I just finished two essays for the University of Virginia, and I've love some fine-tuning or even general comments on ideas I should add/remove. I really want to know if they make sense, and if they would tell the admissions officer enough about me!

[ prompt 1 ]
We are looking for passionate students to join our diverse community of scholars, researchers, and artists. Answer the question that corresponds to the school you selected above. Limit your answer to a half page or roughly 250 words.

Engineering: Discuss experiences that led you to choose an engineering education at U.Va. and the role that scientific curiosity plays in your life.

Splitting up Ampere's Law into four separate integrals to determine the magnetic field around a solenoid - easy, right? Each new problem my physics teacher introduces seems like an unsurpassable monolith to me, but they are nothing to him. With masterful strokes, he chips away at them with logic and basic equations until a solution presents itself from the rubble. I am always thoroughly intrigued by how the simple concepts he uses can solve such seemingly complex problems. Sitting at home, I struggle to figure out the same types of questions my teacher so elegantly solves in class, even armed with the same standard arsenal of equations.

But that's the beauty of a eureka moment. After long attempts at a problem, when it feels as if vectors of frustration are jabbing my gray matter into submission, I close my eyes. With time, the throbbing in my mind invariably subsides to clarity, and I wake up from my physics-induced coma with a start. Upon discovering a new angle to the problem, a rush of adrenaline courses through my body, and I quickly scribble down my thoughts. Suddenly, all of the elements fall into place. Eureka!

It is the sheer nerdy ecstasy of finding solutions that draws me to engineering. Presented with any problem, whether a textbook question or a real-world situation, I feel a relentless urge to find the answer. Even if I fail, each failure brings a new opportunity to learn. The University of Virginia's biomedical engineering program drew me in through its sheer dedication to integrating undergraduate research and design in both engineering and medicine, but after I chanced upon a collection of posters about discoveries made by the department, I knew I had to be part of a future team. The name of this series of posters?

"Eureka!"

(299 words)

(276 words)

[ prompt 2 ]
Answer one of the following questions in a half page or roughly 250 words:
Discuss something you secretly like but pretend not to, or vice versa.

My mother pulls up into the Home Depot parking lot, and I shudder at the disproportionate number of heavy-duty trucks in the spaces around me. I feel as if I'm entering an alternate dimension reeking of elbow grease, whereas my natural universe revolves around dainty watercolor brushes.

Trudging past the automatic doors, I drag my shoes on the slate-gray concrete floors while my mother urges me to walk faster. As a proud member of the female gender, I should turn up my nose at the endless rows of hardware, gag at the atmosphere of unfettered virility, and run screaming in the opposite direction, but something about Home Depot fascinates me.

It's beautiful.

Even out of my comfort zone, I tend to view the world around me as an artist. Home Depot serves as an unlikely muse, stocked with vast arrays of forms and surfaces. As we pass doorknobs and two-by-fours, I consider how to capture textures of metal and wood in graphite on paper. Walking past a display of paint cards, I quickly slip a few swatches of color into my pocket to paste in my sketchbook later for inspiration. I may not show any love for Home Depot's wares, but I still secretly appreciate the everyday beauty hidden behind its rugged veneer.

(213 words)

I'd be happy to read over your essays in return, although I'll be leaving my computer now for a bit. Thank you!

Writing
Editing Help?
Fill in one of the forms below to get professional help with your assignments:

Graduate Writing / Editing:
GraduateWriter form ◳

Best Essay Service:
CustomPapers form ◳

Excellence in Editing:
Rose Editing ◳

AI-Paper Rewriting:
Robot Rewrite ◳