Unanswered [8] | Urgent [0]
  

Posts by Wanderer_x
Joined: Dec 19, 2009
Last Post: Mar 5, 2010
Threads: 5
Posts: 88  


Displayed posts: 93 / page 1 of 3
sort: Oldest first   Latest first  | 
Wanderer_x   
Dec 19, 2009
Undergraduate / Any environment that is particularly significant to you my Willliams supplement! [17]

Below is my essay. Please comment on it, whether it should work or not. Also you may edit it if you wish to. Your help will be immensely appreciated!

Imagine looking thrugh a wiindow at any environment that is particularly significant to you. Reflect on the scene, paying close attention to the relation between what you are seeing and why it is meaningful to you. Please limit your statement to around 300 words.

I do not need to imagine one; its already there on the left of my bed, big enough for me to see the world outside.

Right next to my home is a house where a dozen devils live, all children of course! They have become a part of my everyday life, courtesy to my dear window. Even the tiniest children out there wrestle along with older ones and shout at the top of their voices. All together, they represent chaos at its best.

Everyday after their school, they first argue on which game to play. Then, after an hour or two, with their clothes drenched in sweat and stained with mud, they disperse momentarily just to gather again after an hour. Then begins their usual chatting session, I being their permanent audience.

Unlike adults, they never lack interesting topics. And yes, they even talk about politics! A nine year old once stood up and shouted "I am the Superman. So better obey my orders!". Another boy refuted "I am Obama, more powerful than you and maybe even richer. Go back to your Krypton!". "How can you be Obama? Your live in a yellow house, not white!", interrupted someone from the group. Another then said in a pretentious manner "If you don't know anything about Obama or White House, better not discuss about it kids!".

At another time, the eldest of the girls whispered something to another girl who giggled in response. Slowly, all of the elder ones started to giggle and laugh. With my ear stuck to the window, I was trying to figure out what it was all about when I heard a boy reply in a preachy tone: "Sex is no big deal guys!"

To me, their conversations make perfect sense. They share among each other the wierdest or ideas. They giggle, laugh, shout, wrestle and all the time, grow together. A friend of mine said that I have become crazier these days. Another even called me abrupt and blunt. Maybe I should keep my random thoughts to myself. I try so, but every time I see those children live life without inhibitions, I become one of them. Maybe I have always been like them.

(Also please let me know if my essay sounds off-topic)
Wanderer_x   
Dec 19, 2009
Undergraduate / 'Fresh start revelation' - Stanford's intellect engaging prompt. [5]

The best thing about your essay is its simplicity. It flows elegantly enough not to make you stumble any where.
At first, I thought you were taking the convenient route since I have read similar essays that try to be clever with the question. However, your essay takes a different approach later which I admire. The last line is really impactful and sums up your piece beautifully.

I hope your commonapp essay on trip to Laos I suppose is also well-written.

Please help me with mine...
Wanderer_x   
Dec 22, 2009
Undergraduate / "dance my worries away" - stanford supplement: letter to roommate [8]

A really interesting piece!!!

Few suggestions: "Make sure that breakables are out of sight while we are dancing"...make sure sounds like an order...Make it "We ought to make sure...or We should make sure..."

"and protect me from the predators that are the real world"...does not sound right. maybe "predators out there in the real world" would sound better.

Ending sounds a bit abrupt. What you can still add at last: "Dont worry if you hate dancing. I will make you fall in love with it!" Or "Dont worry if you hate dancing. I will dance all along without ever troubling you. Both way, we will surely have some fun together." ...

That was just my opinion.
Cheers!!

If you'd like to help me with mine:
Wanderer_x   
Dec 23, 2009
Undergraduate / "MY OWN CURIOUS CASE " Feedbacks on my admission essay... [13]

This is my first draft. So, errors are bound to happen. I want to know whether the concept clicks to the reader or not. Here, I tell a story through which I try to reflect myself. Feel free to comment on it. Suggestions and criticisms are welcomed. Also tell me the parts that I can dispose off. I dont want to make it long and boring.

My own curious case

Almost eleven years back, my mom gifted me with a table-clock. With a pink and white body and arms that fluoresced at night, the clock looked perfect. Its beauty was my source of pride and its rhythmic ticking, my inspiration. Only once in a while, when the battery would be completely used up, would it bother me. We were happy together for two years till one day it stopped breathing. I bought a fresh pair of battery but still it did not come back to life. In desperation, I asked my dad to get it fixed but he replied annoyingly,

"Can't you see I am busy? Here, take mine. I will get you a new one tomorrow."

Get a new one? I was infuriated. I decided to mend it myself. Stealing my dad's tool box, I managed to open up the clock. To my dismay, inside of it was even more complicated than a human body! I started to inspect it carefully, like a cell under a microscope. Then, I tried to forcibly move its second-hand. It still did not work. I pressed the spring of the clock just to create even more trouble. Next day, I again tried different techniques. I checked the metal plates connecting the battery and moved the oscillating wheels. Nothing worked at all. Next, I borrowed my dad's table-clock and opened it up as well. I compared its inside with that of my clock. Just like a corpse alongside a living body, they looked exactly identical, except for the sound one made and the haunting silence the other possessed. Third day, in absolute despair, I took off the wheels and all the hands from their places. I then fixed them back to their positions. Without much expectation, I still connected the battery. To my surprise, I heard an abrupt sound "Tick". Then, in a perfect rhythm, the sound started to repeat "Tick, tick, tick". My clock was working!

But something weird was happening. The second-hand was moving in the opposite direction. What had I done? After five minutes, the minute-hand shifted from six to five. I thought of dismantling the whole thing again. "But what will I do if it stops working altogether?" I put on its cover and kept it gently in its precise position on my tiny table. I thought God must have had played a trick on me. In naïve revenge, I planned to trick God instead. I took my permanent marker and marked '6' in big font above '12'. Similarly, '9' of the clock became my '3' and '3' my '9'. My darling clock looked different from its peers, yet as efficient as any other of its kind in the world.

Few months before, while I was watching "The Curious Case of Benjamin Button", I saw a clock in that movie which functioned exactly like mine. While that giant clock was deliberately designed to work in the reverse direction, mine was by chance. For seven years, it had served me without ever complaining. When I think of my clock, I realize that we do not just share an emotional bond, but a huge part of our identity itself. We do not give up that easily. When my clock was not working, I did not just go out and buy another one. Instead, I tried in every way to fix it. When I succeeded, it went on to live for five more years, in reverse direction, defying its very basic rule. In a way, we look quite stubborn; determined I would say. We are not the ones who perpetually freak out. No wonder why my friends and family got more worried than I when I did not enroll in any college last year.

We two share a common take on life- things may go reverse, still we move forward.
Wanderer_x   
Dec 23, 2009
Undergraduate / The store as a reflection of the world - Williams essay - looking through a window... [10]

Every Williams esssay I have read till now seems to be good, this being no exception.
You make you point clear throughout. Good Work!
Last para : "where consumerism takes center-stage while problems like poverty become increasingly pressing"...it should either be "problem like poverty" or "problems like poverty and ..."

"I ll always think back..". Make it I often think of ...Dont you think of it now?

these global issues impact the lives of those around me
Cut this part...it makes you sound as if you are trying too hard.

PS: I am also a Williams candidate...my essays are out here as well
Wanderer_x   
Dec 23, 2009
Undergraduate / COMMON APP ESSAY FOR DARTMOUTH, UPENN, NORTHWESTERN AND OTHER SCHOOLS [37]

REturning the favor :)

Well, I am confused. I could not exactly follow your essay even though I read it very slowly and carefully. Being a student of Biology, I still stumbled upon some technical words. Your essay lacks cohesion and a good singled-out idea. Its risky as it gets more philosophical. A Upenn admission officer advised us once "Dont use an abstract essay unless you are damn sure of it. MOst of the times, they just tend to confuse us and lead us nowhere. We rather like to read stories told simply. We wont have time to ponder upon a single essay trying to figure out what the writer must have meant."

Sorry. I had to honest :(
Wanderer_x   
Dec 23, 2009
Undergraduate / Common App essay - significant experience (immigration and different cultures) [6]

Awesome piece. I love the flow of your essay. Its like a river commencing its journey from an ocean, taking different routes, and finally returning back to the ocean.

Diversity is a favorite topic among intls. But your essay stands out since it does not try hard. Told simply, yet in a very effective way.

If you have time, please provide feedback on mine. :)
Wanderer_x   
Dec 23, 2009
Undergraduate / Brown Supplement - how a book influenced you (le petit prince) [3]

its good.
"Because of this book, I now take time to appreciate the little things in my life. "
Dint you appreciate little things in life before? Make your transition subtle.

An yes, I also love that tiny book. I remember the hat being interpreted as Elephant inside a snake. haha

Would you like to comment on mine?
Wanderer_x   
Dec 23, 2009
Undergraduate / "MY OWN CURIOUS CASE " Feedbacks on my admission essay... [13]

anne..thanks a lot. I will add a line or two at last. Also, like you said, since I am present alongside my clock througout the essay, I dont feel the need to talk about myself directly.

No other comments? I thought I'd decide on whether to use this or not keeping in mind various comments. HElp please!
Wanderer_x   
Dec 24, 2009
Undergraduate / "We are almost there!" - Williams essay [4]

Well, I did not get what you are trying to say. Why is that event significant to you? Just mentioning that the camp was the last one does not make it significant enough. You ought to be creative and reflect more on the scene. It sounds more like a page of your journal.
Wanderer_x   
Dec 24, 2009
Undergraduate / "to light the way for my students" - Take a look at my "Why Northwestern?" [17]

Personally, I like your approach. Adcom at Northwestern must get bored of reading volumes of pretentious praises; your essay might provide them little air to breathe.

On the other side, try to make your dialouges more casual and quirky. Though your response is definitely above the ordinay ones, it still does not stand out. If you work on it, it will be good for sure.

If you'd like to help me further:
Wanderer_x   
Dec 24, 2009
Undergraduate / my career in the medical field - Common Application Essay [8]

I wish I had a tooth like yours to write about :)

But then, I still dont get one thing. At two, you had your baby tooth broken. And how come your tooth becomes crooked since you baby tooth is supposed to be replaced?

Ignoring that point( though it shouldn't be ignored at all!), your essay is really interesting.
Wanderer_x   
Dec 24, 2009
Undergraduate / my career in the medical field - Common Application Essay [8]

Well, you ought to mention that thing. Else how are we supposed to know which "the tooth" you are talking about?
Maybe mention something like "I played with my broken tooth so often that it was later replaced by a crooked tooth, like that of a vampire( to add a little humor) ."

I had noticed many people I met staring at my tooth, so I found it necessary to tell them the story behind it, and this ended up being the way I met many new friends.

Long and clumsy. My suggestion: "People often stared at my tooth. So, I could not stop myself from telling them the story behind it; and this ended up being the way I made many new friends."

During the first days of school, I was very reserved; until someone asked me about my tooth. As I told the story more often, it became more vivid in my mind and I got better at telling the tale

During the initial days of my new(I suppose) school, I remained reserved, until someone asked me....As I ....mind and I got better at narrating the little tale of my own.

Having moved to so many different schools I have become accustomed to meeting new people and introducing myself. My tooth has liberated my initial timidity

so many different!!!...make it just " having switched to many schools".Comma after schools...liberated me from my intial timidity.

Many comma splices throughout.
In school comma my communication...

and now I am not afraid to stand behind my beliefs as a result of past experiences

rephrase it.

Being exposed to many different people and having lived in many different areas has allowed me to become very adaptable and very at ease with people.

again many different!....that too twice in the same line!!..avoid it. very adaptive and very at ease...You quite frequently abuse "many" and very".

I have enjoyed joining the Heart and Stroke Foundation and also functioned as the publicity person, coordinating all the details for special events. For this club, I helped raise money through various sports tournaments including basketball, volleyball, and badminton. I ensured that there was ample participation and that rules were followed during the tournaments. We raised approximately $2,500 dollars for cancer research from a Hoops-for-Heart basketball tournament. This was one of the most successful events I helped orchestrate.

This does not flow with the rest of your essay. Stress on how your communication skills helped you in the club.

I enjoyed your essay :)

HElp me with mine
Wanderer_x   
Dec 24, 2009
Undergraduate / World beyond my village; "Memorable experience in high school" [4]

Its long.
Also your essay is not cohesive enough. It will work better if you single out an idea and talk about it only. For instance, you may revolve your essay just around Free-Tibet Movement. How your stay in a heterogenous society has helped you embrace others' cultures and understand their concerns.
Wanderer_x   
Dec 24, 2009
Undergraduate / "being a trilingual Egyptian and Palestinian" - Michigan diversity essay [6]

something the French system does not teach.

It sounds exaggerated (regardless of your intention). Change it to" something the French system emphasizes less upon."

As per me, your response is not appropriate enough.
Neither do you mention how you gained "respect" for the difference you talk about, nor do you answer the second part: "how your personal experiences and achievements would contribute to the diversity of the University of Michigan"
Wanderer_x   
Dec 24, 2009
Undergraduate / "Mathematician With Love of Arts" -- Common Application Main Essay [5]

Creativity and imagination are what I give ballet

akwardly phrased.

Piano is similar to ballet because it can inspire new creativity and imagination as well.

\
omit "new"...how can creativity be new or old?

I interpret "Pathétique Ppy.iano Sonata" by Beethoven as full of strongly pathetic and dark emotion.

I find the use of "pathetic" somewhat inappropriate.

I feel that after you talk so much about arts, you ought to give Maths a little more space in your essay. Transition from arts to Maths is a bit abrupt.

First paragraph is exceptional! You need to work on the rest. Overall it's impressive indeed!

Would you take a look into mine? (hover on my username)
Wanderer_x   
Dec 25, 2009
Undergraduate / Tufts required essay- describe the environment in which you were raised. [4]

I understand your genuine intentions. But every student from a third world country capitalizes on his/her country's misery. Who would not like to see their country and countrymen progress?

"let your life speak"
Describe a significant event that made you determined to help others. I dont think one would be so moved by a begger in the street. Even if you were, many applicants would have already written the same thing.
Wanderer_x   
Dec 25, 2009
Undergraduate / "Aitizaz Ahsan inspired me" - significant person, Common application essay [3]

Well, its long!! By the time I finished reading it, I completely forgot what you had written in the first few paragraphs.
Your language is fine. HOwever, your content is not strong enough for a personal statement. Most of the times, it sounds more like a personal news report for a magazine. You need to add more personal touch to your essay rather than just describe the man and his political issue. Since the event was well-known throughout the world, you can cut off the basic parts.
Wanderer_x   
Dec 25, 2009
Undergraduate / idiosyncrasies or peculiarities about ourselves, UChicago essay [23]

What color is your essay?
To me, it's definitely GOLDEN!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

U Chicago people will miss a really interesting personality if they dont accept you!

PS: Does your username got to do something with your condition Synesthesia? Plain curious.

Also I'd love if you'd review my Williams supplement as well.
Wanderer_x   
Dec 25, 2009
Undergraduate / "to join clubs and befriend a new community" - Why Northwestern [16]

I dont think you need to worry about your Northwestern supplement. You should easily get into U Chicago with your wonderful essay!

...anyone else want to help me fix my common app essay?

Where is your commonapp essay?
Wanderer_x   
Dec 25, 2009
Undergraduate / "to join clubs and befriend a new community" - Why Northwestern [16]

I just love the way you write. The flow esp.

As I grew older, I looked to expand my boundaries. To satisfy my desire for a new frontier, I journeyed far inland along a stream that runs parallel to an alternate trail. Wise as it would have been to carry a GPS system, I continued to walk along the road carrying nothing but curiosity.

This line is lovely.

Its good. But I'd suggest you change your UChicago essay into your commonapp essay for other colleges. It will definitely make you stand out.

Just add a bit more of your perspectives in that essay. For instance, you can end up with few lines like "With the help of my disorder, a gift in disguise, I develop thoughts and perspectives that are uniquely my own.

I always add a bit of my color to things which otherwise look black and white. And that makes me different."
Wanderer_x   
Dec 25, 2009
Undergraduate / Any environment that is particularly significant to you my Willliams supplement! [17]

Guys, thanks for all the comment.
I have another response to this prompt that I used last year. I am confused to what I should do. Whether use the new one or use this one below. Please comment and suggest.

There was no window as such. Still, I would love to imagine a big frame in front
of my eyes through which I would have captured the scene that would remain etched
in my memory forever. A house stood there with its height as high as the sky. No
need to peek through the window for I could see everything from the outside itself. Each brick of that house seemed to have a unique shape and appeared as if each was coloured wih a purpose, one as black as coal while another as deep as blood. Near the door sat a boy wearing a multi-colored coat piling up one brick after another to build a castle of his own. To complement the entire picture, a beautiful creature sat just above the door basking in the sun, with its eyes twinkling and body shining. No, not a dove, it was a crow. The whole scene looked so still yet it had a pace of its own. Now I would not like to spoil the beauty of that scene by telling the truth; yet I must confess that it was the site of a bomb blast.

Few months back, I had gone to Dang, a remote district of Nepal which was one of the major combat zones during the decade long Maoist insurgency in which thousands of people were killed and millions injured and displaced. Everyone gets horrified by the terror of a bomb blast and in the place I was talking about, at least a dozen were killed in the explosion and all the houses had entirely collapsed. Only one house was erect, that too without its ceiling and a large part of its front wall intact.

That house was special for it was the only one that could resist all the forces, be it the power of an explosion or the force of nature. In a place where no dove loves to hover around, a crow picked that house to sit and contemplate about its future. The poor child chose the fallen bricks of the same ruined house to build his tiny castle. In the midst of despair, that house stood like a glimmer of hope to the crow, the boy and to me. Indeed, this is what I call the real beauty, one that has the power to inspire hope in our soul and spirit. In that site of terror, I found hope for the days ahead.
Wanderer_x   
Dec 25, 2009
Undergraduate / "to join clubs and befriend a new community" - Why Northwestern [16]

I remember that during every practice of every recital.
remove the first every.
"When I considered the joy and enthusiasm on the faces of those who weren't fortunate enough to hear music on a daily basis, I wanted to give back to the world in a different way."

considered is not an appropriate word to use out here. Maybe "noticed". Dont know exactly.
May be rephrase the whole sentence. "I wanted to give back.." seems out of place.
Each tune I played brought in their faces the joy and ethusiasm for life. And every time I realized this, I felt like playing my violin forever, for my music was making a difference in their lives.

Sounds solid. Tells us about your passion for violin, team ability and compassion for others. Good!

Well I have another supplement for Williams that I used last year. I like it myself. So, I am kinda confused about which one I should send. Would you check that one out and compare the two?

I ll post that in my Williams Supp thread.
Wanderer_x   
Dec 25, 2009
Undergraduate / Supplement for Trinity--''free the mind from parochialism and prejudice" [2]

Your essay is nice.

"moment I witnessed the glistening tears in the eyes of children from both city and country, I knew I had freed their minds. "

I doubt if they really cried!! Even if they did, its hard to believe that all of them cried just because they listened to a touching story. USe something believable like "As I told them the story of Hiu, I sensed a feeling of discomfort among them. My story made an imapct upon their minds. I indeed freed their minds to an extent."

rest, its good.
God bless!
Wanderer_x   
Dec 25, 2009
Undergraduate / "to join clubs and befriend a new community" - Why Northwestern [16]

Playing together required musical ability, respect, and flexibility; I remember that during practice of every recital.

Playing together requires not just ability, but also respect and flexibility;....

Howz that? Since abilility is a basic thing, I think you should emphasize more on the remaining two.

I need to start writing all my supplements from tomorrow :( I will look forward to your comments on my essays I post in future. Also feel free to ask for any help :)

Good Luck with your application!
Wanderer_x   
Dec 25, 2009
Undergraduate / How horses transformed a science-phobe (revamped!) Cornell CALS Supplement [6]

I liked it.

Then, one day, it dawned on me. As I sat on my bed, sketching out Punnett squares in an attempt to determine the color of a newly-conceived foal, I realized I loved science. Rote memorization from a textbook hadn't installed that passion - using practical knowledge to help animals had. I may never go to vet school, but I hope to work with off-the-track Thoroughbreds, rehabilitating and retraining them as riding horses

"I loved science" part sounds contrieved and dramatic. ALso "I may never go to a vet school" make it look like you actually want to go to a vet school, not Cornell.

Rest, thumpz up!

WOuld you take a loook at my Grinnell supplement?
Wanderer_x   
Dec 25, 2009
Undergraduate / Basketball is not only for killing time - it's part of my life, it's in my blood [6]

Some moments in life, I can memorize by heart-that is, some things I can remember with such brilliant clarity that it repeats and replicates ceaselessly, and naturally. Such moments are precious not because they occur only rarely once in an eternity, but because they can be always be revived time and again with surprising precision and authenticity:

How about delelting this entire portion? Actually I think they just bore the reader. Your vivid description of the scene is good enough for us to know how passionate you are about basketball.

Help me with my short supplement if you have time:
Wanderer_x   
Dec 27, 2009
Undergraduate / "cooked pig intestines" - Common App Essay [5]

Your story telling part is pretty amazing. HOwever, the essay still needs some improvements.

But I knew that I would never be able to "acquire" that awful taste, because I promised myself that I would never eat chitlins again.

Doesn't it contradict with what you say later in the essay? Maybe just say "I doubt if I will ever "aquire" that awful taste."

and boy was it gross!

isn't IT TOO MUCH OF A SLANG???? Though I find its use quite cool, but seriously doubt if it is wise enough to risk an otherwise slang-free statement.

The story describes an instance where I was willing to try something new and take a chance.

While the rest of your essay is interesting, this one line is dull!

Link between your story and the rest of the essay should be more apparent. Maybe add lines like "For me, chitin still smells repulsive and tastes horrible. Yet, I don't mind eating them because I learn to better connect with my tradition through chitins.
Wanderer_x   
Dec 27, 2009
Undergraduate / Princeton Quote Essay---Engaging a troublesome child [3]

FAB!
Very well written, short but adequate. a 100% winning essay! One of the best essays I ve read in EF.

I can get a very clear pictue of you through this essay.

I'd love if you'd take a look into my commonapp essay.
Wanderer_x   
Dec 27, 2009
Undergraduate / Colby Supplemental Essay - "The ultimate measure of man" [4]

I did not read your propmt at first. So, I read your essay like I d read a random story. And I really liked it!

But after I read your prompt, I am not sure if your essay is what they are looking for as a response to their "serious" sounding prompt.

Is your "waking up issue" really a "challenge and controversy" they expect to read about?
I ve read three Colby accepted students' essays on this topic: 1 was about AIDS, another about third gender issue, and the last one was about fighting the stereotype.

I still love your essay the way it is.
It will for sure serve as an interesting commonapp essay though!
Wanderer_x   
Dec 27, 2009
Undergraduate / idiosyncrasies or peculiarities about ourselves, UChicago essay [23]

Well...I was about to comment on your why UChicago essay but the thread got deleted by the moderators :( So, i ll comment here itself.

overall, it was fine.

I know the importance of learning for the sake of learning

Its quite cliched, isn't it?

The numerous choices of academics and activities offered by the University of Chicago excite me. Apart from its extensive list of majors, the university hosts over three hundred student organizations and clubs

I think your final paragraph can do well without these two lines. What's the use of telling things they already know?

What more could I want at a university aimed at providing ample opportunities for its students to learn? I know now that the University of Chicago will provide me with a nurturing and stimulating environment so that I may excel

Do something with these lines. Its not quite impactful.

Writing
Editing Help?
Fill in one of the forms below to get professional help with your assignments:

Graduate Writing / Editing:
GraduateWriter form ◳

Best Essay Service:
CustomPapers form ◳

Excellence in Editing:
Rose Editing ◳

AI-Paper Rewriting:
Robot Rewrite ◳