Unanswered [12] | Urgent [0]
  

Posts by ershad193
Joined: May 25, 2010
Last Post: Nov 12, 2014
Threads: 14
Posts: 333  
Likes: 5
From: India

Displayed posts: 347 / page 3 of 9
sort: Latest first   Oldest first  | 
ershad193   
Sep 17, 2010
Graduate / "Part of the Fenway Family"--Peace Corps Application Essay #2 [18]

I didn't mean a "safe space" in the literal sense

Okay, if that's jargon then you don't have to change anything. I was thinking of it in the literal sense, and yes, I wasn't aware of "safe space" in relation to resource and outreach environments. I'll look it up pronto :)

I was wondering if you had any specific suggestions for a final sentence

You know it's a lot more difficult to write, than to read or edit something...hehe... :D

Anyway, I would've removed the "As a Peace..." sentence and ended the essay with the following sentences:
Now I am ready for a fresh challenge -- a challenge more challenging than moving to Boston; a challenge only Peace Corps can provide. However, this will be different. Even though, I will be stepping into unfamiliar territory again, I know that this will be a familiar unfamiliarity.

^^Does that sound cheesy? Sorry, I'm not very good with words...haha :P

So do your necessary brainstorming and come up with a good one. I'm sure you can do that. :)
ershad193   
Sep 17, 2010
Graduate / "Part of the Fenway Family"--Peace Corps Application Essay #2 [18]

Cut out unnecessary words. Also condense some sentences. It will give you room to include more ideas, or elaborate the existing ones. Even though your word count is below the limit, it's always better to have some extra free space.

You write well, Kayla. This is a good essay.
You don't have to agree with all of my suggestions :)
ershad193   
Sep 16, 2010
Writing Feedback / Digital textbooks vs Textbook [12]

Respond

Response

Missing word(s) here
There is no doubt that schools are always adding new (???) and providing learning materials to students

Starting from the first day of school, students are supposed to work immediately, and they are assigned homework and reading right away.

Unfortunately, some of them are unable to complete the project on time because they do not have textbooks ready for them to check out. It is quick and convenient for students when they do not have to spend hours at a library or bookstore to check out books.

I'm not sure if I understood correctly. Do you mean to say that books are not available immediately after classes start, and consequently, students need to spend most of their time in libraries?

Anyway, I'm correct, then it would be better if you expound on the idea. Otherwise, rephrase the sentences to improve clarity.

We can access to a library or other information with a touch of a button.
or
We can gain access to a library or other information with a touch of a button.

The idea of having digital textbooks would

The word idea doesn't sound right. I'd make a change to that sentence.
The idea of having Digital textbooks would give students the opportunity to learn new techniques to prepare students with certain computer skills when they are going to a higher grade.

It maximizes students' time, improves their computer skills, and makes the world better

You should change the wording of this sentence. It looks very similar to the last sentence of the first para.
ershad193   
Sep 16, 2010
Writing Feedback / Writing about Heuristics that relates to your life [3]

Consider this example:

My peers and teachers all thought that I would go to college, become a doctor and save lives.

You've just described the opinions of all those people in a single sentence. What I mean is you should develop these examples. Tell us why did they think so. Were you very good in your studies? Did you have exceptional insight in the concepts of biology? Give some background information on those people.

Am I being clear?
ershad193   
Sep 15, 2010
Graduate / 'Physical Therapy more competitive' - : PTCAS Admission Essay for DPT Program [3]

All across the country, physical therapy programs are becoming more and more competitive, and the most qualified and dedicated individuals are being selected to enter.

Admissions essays are not the place for making obvious statements. This sentence doesn't give any new information to the reader, and hence, is a waste of space. Sorry for being so blunt. Try to make every sentence count.

Your second sentence also suffers from the same problem.

For me your essay actually starts from the third sentence.

I quickly learned the importance of being humble, forgiving, self-disciplined, honest, and the hard work needed to achieve excellence.

This is all fine, but it would be better if you can highlight those with the help of some personal experiences or examples. Do you know what I mean? Anyone can say they have those qualities. It's up to you to distinguish yourself from others.
ershad193   
Sep 14, 2010
Faq, Help / Love to be here on EssayForum [14]

So, it means deep inside you know that you are like what sort of a writer? :)

Lol
That's a strange sort of interpretation.
I think people are never tortured by hearing their own singing because they get used to their voice, whether it's good or bad.
So deep inside they don't care what they sound like. Using that analogy I can safely say that I don't care whether my writing is good or bad; I just write whenever there is a requirement, or if something crazy is going on in my mind.

By the way, it seems that I won't be writing the GRE experience essay after all. They made me sign a bond or something which prevents me from divulging any details, and I'm not sure as to what qualify as "details."

Anyway, I'll give a brief and general description.

My exam was in the city of Kolkata which is about a thousand kilometers from my hometown. I landed there the day before the exam, and since my plan was to stay there for only two nights, I checked into a relatively cheap hotel. That was a mistake. The room smelled like a strange mixture of cigarette smoke and dentist's gloves. Moreover, I found that the mosquitoes of that place had a particular affinity for my blood. Consequently, I didn't get any sleep. The food wasn't great either. Anyway, I arrived at the examination center, completely disgruntled and pissed at everything in the damned city.

So it was a surprise, albeit of the pleasant variety, when I found how helpful the staff were. They assisted me with everything, and properly explained the procedures. The check-in process was smooth. The testing environment was good, and the test went uninterrupted. The invigilators were always there if any test taker had any problems.

I just encountered one problem. The "s" key of my keyboard was slightly faulty. It didn't work when I pressed it like any other key. I had to smack it real hard to make it obey my command. While doing that I unintentionally started smacking the other keys also. By the time I was in full flow with my essays, I must have looked like someone who was intent on destroying the keyboard. I assure you I had no such intentions.

When I left the center, I had a big smile on my face, because I had scored way more than I expected. Of course, I have not got the officially verified scores yet, but the unofficial scores were good. The essay scores will be out only after a few days. Before taking the flight home, I treated myself to a sumptuous meal which also was an extension of my Eid celebrations.

Hence, the moral of the story is that there is no moral. Just trust your instincts, except while choosing hotels (of course, not everyone has lousy instincts like mine). Take all the identification documents required to avoid unnecessary hassles. Stay in a good place if your center is not in your hometown. Practice from the GRE Test Prep available on the GRE website.

That's all I guess.
ershad193   
Sep 14, 2010
Undergraduate / Statement of Purpose UT TRANSFER CHEMICAL ENGINEERING [3]

able to answer the question: "Where are you from?" -- put the question in quotes

The longest I have ever stayed anywhere has beenwas 5 years. -- I'm not sure about this suggestion. By the way, spell out small numbers like "five."

I couldn't stand saying goodbyes -- plural

preserving it long enough for them to live their lives or maybe even their children

Chemistry can be applied in many different fields such as water treatment, energy efficiency, renewable resources, preventing contamination and many others.

Don't make obvious statements. Give a unique insight into the applications of the subject.

The truth is I am extremely interested in all these fields.

Really?...that's fine, but to an AO that may seem like you don't have a lot of knowledge about your chosen field. A lack of knowledge is often one of the reasons for the generic choices. I don't mean to offend you, and I'm not implying that you have any lack of knowledge in chemical engineering. I just want to point out the different impressions your statement can make.

Moreover, you have not included even a single sentence which is specific to the field of chemical engineering.
Use your research, and say some unique and specific things about chemical engineering. What is it that really attracted you towards this branch? What do you want to become after you graduate?

Read this thread: Engineers can turn ideas into reality.
ershad193   
Sep 14, 2010
Writing Feedback / Why did Kimveer Gill murder? - Paragraph for Psychology class [3]

Kimveer Gill was led to commit acts of violence due to various events which caused him to plunge him into a state of depression and hate

He described the main character of one of his favorite...

I think this is very well written.
ershad193   
Sep 14, 2010
Undergraduate / "major in Engineering" - UIUC Essay, motivation to transfer and professional goals [3]

was not qualified for the School of Engineering

was not enough to qualify for the School of Engineering

As a Chinese student, the contrast in Industrial Engineering in China between prospective implications and start-up stage also stimulated me to share professional and ethical responsibilities as an engineer, making contributions to our community.

This long sentence didn't make a whole lot of sense to me. My suggestion would be to break it up into two sentences and rephrase slightly, so that the clarity is not lost.

Utilizing skills learned in class, I will embark on a career where I can help manufacturers improve efficiency in productivity and optimize the integrated systems of various factors.

This is all very good, but there is room for you to be more specific. Can you name a profession where you can utilize those skills?

I say this because optimization and improvement in efficiency are the basic principles of engineering. In other words, each and every type of engineer has to work keeping those principles in mind. It is up to you to make that distinction between industrial engineering and other branches of engineering.

Do you understand my point?
ershad193   
Sep 11, 2010
Faq, Help / Love to be here on EssayForum [14]

I thought you are a writer

Haha...I am the writing equivalent of a bathroom singer.

It would be great if you write an essay about it, that would be a fun read :)

It will be fun to write too. :)
ershad193   
Sep 11, 2010
Undergraduate / Favorite Plays: Importance of Being Earnest & Rosencrantz and Guildenstern are Dead [3]

Bunburying

haha...I love that word.

Wilde-ly

good stuff

If people were more honest about reality and themselves, then the world might consist of less social ills through the deterioration of illusions and more meaningful relationships between individuals through the fostering of personas that reflect a person's true being.

Is there a simpler version of this one? ;)
Anyway, this could be more personal.

now I value the importance of being earnest about decision-making. For instance, a choice I am particularly earnest about is applying to the University of Chicago and, hopefully, attending it.

A suggestion
Can you rearrange that into a single sentence? I mean, the "for instance" part makes the reader pause slightly, and I think it would be better if that didn't happen.

Something like this -- now I value the importance of being earnest about decision making, like the decision of applying to University of Chicago.
ershad193   
Sep 11, 2010
Faq, Help / Love to be here on EssayForum [14]

I intend to do an MS, and then maybe a PhD, in Biomedical Engineering. I'll apply to UCLA too, but my first preference is Purdue. I'll probably apply to 4-5 universities.

And please do give me an account of your GRE experience, it'll give me an insight.

Sure :)
Do you have a Facebook account? You can find me there. My profile pic is the same as the one given in the contributor page.

Otherwise, I can describe the experience here itself.
ershad193   
Sep 11, 2010
Research Papers / Ghana Soccer culture. [3]

The sport of football, or soccer as it is widely known in the United States, is the most celebrated and played sport in the world

As the British Empire colonized one-third of the world, they bringintroduced the modern day sport

Federation of International Football Association (FIFA)

FIFA is the acronym for "Fédération Internationale de Football Association (in French)," or "International Federation of Association Football (in English)."

Even though the sport of football (soccer) is not popular in the United States as in the rest of the world, it has a great effect on people's lives.

Football has its own culture in Ghana and can be traced back to the hegemonic culture

The level of enthusiasm for the game,and especially when their home teams win,areis so great that it can promote nationalism and multicultural existence.

In Ghana the sport of football is promoting the hegemonic masculinity for it only supports the male gender and it objectify female players as the subject of the male gaze and not their athletic values. The sport of football is been used as a source of culture hegemony, nationalism and hegemonic masculinity in Ghana.

I don't think you should talk about this aspect in this paragraph. Talk about the positive aspects in one paragraph, and then introduce the negative ones in a different paragraph.

Football

Don't capitalize football unless it's at the start of a sentence.

The sport become a favorite pass time for all ages on the street and the field.

I think this one should come after the sentence that goes like: "The game became an instant favorite..."

I have to go now. I'll come back as soon as I can.
ershad193   
Sep 10, 2010
Graduate / 'Research project and industrial' - Personal Statement for MSc Energy and Environment [6]

and my goal is to contribute to bettering the technologies of developing countries.

This is not specific enough. What type of technology do you want to improve? Green technology/engineering/chemistry are very broad fields. The concept of sustainable development can be applied to a lot of situations. Those situations may or may not be scientific.

So, you should specify the field where you want to work. Like Kevin said, read some articles from professional journals. You probably know the 12 principles of Green Chemistry and the 12 principles of Green Engineering. Read where those are applied. In short, research more about your chosen field. If you have already done that, include some of it to highlight your objectives.
ershad193   
Sep 10, 2010
Faq, Help / Love to be here on EssayForum [14]

I'm planning to do MS in molecular and medicinal pharmacolgy from USA

Oh cool. Have you decided on which universities you plan to apply to?
ershad193   
Sep 9, 2010
Faq, Help / Love to be here on EssayForum [14]

Hello Mariam!

I'm Ershad, and I'm from India. You're right, EF is great.
Initially, I found it quite addictive. Lately, I haven't been able to spend as much time here as I'd like, but I still make it a point to visit at least once daily.

Anyway, I saw your GRE essays. So what do you intend to study and where?
ershad193   
Sep 9, 2010
Writing Feedback / 'It was a crisp October morning'; Innovation needs one thought, one person. [3]

Hi again, Mariam!

We are Pharmacists not Artists, how can we pull it off?

Don't capitalize pharmacists and artists. If you want emphasis, you can put them in quotes, though I'm not sure whether that is permitted :)

be a more stylish way then to send them in a sports car with the slogan that says

It should be "than."

"Your off to bumpy road, so best of luck"

You are/ You're.

don't you think?", a few nods in the crowd

Here you need a full stop instead of the comma.

spiritedly," and think

When you start a quote, you shouldn't leave any space between the inverted commas and the first word. Like this -- spiritedly, "And think..."

Moreover, I think the comma should be a dash (not sure again), and "and" should be capitalized.

Through out

Throughout is one word.

great multitude, in 1906 he offered

Comma splice.

the car evolve

evolved

But the acclaim of revolutionizing the mode of transportation can not be awarded exclusively to Ford, but coming up with such an innovative concept which brought about this revolution can, most certainly, be credited to his name

Two "buts" in this sentence.
My version would be: While the acclaim of revolutionizing the mode of transportation can not be awarded exclusively to Ford, the act of coming up with such an innovative concept which brought about this revolution can, most certainly, be credited to his name.

mother, although

A full stop in place of the comma. You won't have any grammar problems once you sort out your punctuation.

Your job is to locate a punctuation error in the concluding paragraph, and correct it.

Okay, so you write really well. You have given some good points and developed them well. I just think you used too many words describing that stage-designing experience. After all, it's not a personal essay. A more concise paragraph would have given you some space and time for another example.

Otherwise, a job well done.

P.S. My GRE is on the 13th of this month. Don't know what am I gonna do :(
ershad193   
Sep 7, 2010
Undergraduate / "my trip to India and China" - I will be applying early decision to Dartmouth. [4]

Your first paragraph looked very rushed to me. It also seemed as if you are trying to say a lot of things in a limited space.

My suggestion would be to break it down into two paragraphs, and slowly develop the theme.

Keep in mind, I had first traveled alone across America at the age of five to visit my family, but this summer was bound to be an entirely different experience

This sentence is unnecessary.

We began to plan our trip several months

Use fewer words wherever possible -- "We planned our trip several..."

This also seems useless.

I truly felt as though I had lived there my whole life

I like this!

Hmm...I don't think you did a good job with the conclusion. It's hard to see how that experience helped you understand all that you say in the concluding para.

I think the problem with your essay is that it lacks a distinct theme. I couldn't see where you were going with this, except describing your tour experience.
ershad193   
Sep 7, 2010
Undergraduate / Enigma of Success (interested in learning more about you) [4]

But what is success? They both lovingly drilled my talents in math and science and encouraged me to become a successful person, but I did not understand what they meant.

I'd put the question after the highlighted sentence.

Since then, I disallowed anyone to dissuade me from pursuing academic excellence.

Well, this sentence looks out of context. In that paragraph, you don't say anything about those taunts hampering your studies. It would be better if you add a sentence to illustrate that point. Otherwise, change that sentence into something else relating to the paragraph. Something like a more mature person who is not bothered by trivialities, like the taunts of ignorants --- I don't know if I'm making sense.

However, I had been cursed me with paranoia:

After considering the adversities I had overcome, I discovered the remarkable truth in the adage.

For some weird reason I like this sentence a lot.

Good stuff Eugene! Pretty impressive I'd say. One thing -- I don't like too many rhetorical questions. However, that's just a personal opinion.
ershad193   
Sep 5, 2010
Undergraduate / "Spanish was my motivation to begin my scholastic career", Statement of Purpose UT [4]

So I was pretty confident about my ability to communicate when I boarded a plane to Honduras five years ago. Overly confident.

I love the way you have written this.

and I may be interested in the Language Teaching program as well.

Don't say "I maybe." It portrays a negative image -- one that shows a lack of a plan.
My version would be -- "I am mostly interested in the concentration of Hispanic Linguistics, but I find the Language Teaching program intriguing as well"

Peace Core

Is that Peace Corps?

This is good!! I'm impressed!!!
ershad193   
Sep 4, 2010
Undergraduate / Caltech Engineering Essay, my ideas to come to fruition [5]

You have a cool start to the essay. However, your second paragraph is too cliched for my liking. It would be better if you leave out the second para and link the first with the third.

I think the fourth para would be even better if you add a sentence or two on how you made the hair collector. Adding some aspects of the actual construction procedure would show the AOs that you really know your stuff.

This is a good essay. Add the part on Caltech and post the revision.
ershad193   
Sep 1, 2010
Writing Feedback / Influence of past achievements is necessary for making a significant contribution [3]

I think my poor vocabulary is highlighted in this essay.

"In any field of endeavor, it is impossible to make a significant contribution without first being strongly influenced by past achievements within that field." (Time limit: 45 mins)

A scientist, a leader, a doctor - these are examples of people who leave lasting impressions in their respective fields. Most of them pursue their fields after being motivated by others who had taken the same paths before them. They are propelled towards their goals by others who had already reached those goals. However, to assume that others, who are not inspired by past achievements in their chosen fields, cannot make noteworthy contributions would be wrong. Such an assumption would disregard the cases which, amongst others, include contributions which were firsts in their fields, fortuitous discoveries, or those that are made indirectly.

First of all, the statement downgrades the meaning of the word "pioneer." A pioneer is someone who proposes something that has never been thought of before. Therefore, pioneers are not influenced by the past achievements, but rather influence others who will work after them in their pioneered field. When Newton and Leibnitz invented calculus, they were not influenced by the work of others. Similarly, before Einstein, no one had given any thought to the reality that is known as relativity. Such examples are scattered over history which disprove the given statement.

In scientific fields, we also encounter something known as a serendipitous discovery or invention. A serendipitous discovery is an unintentional discovery. It is something which takes place by chance. One of the most famous examples is the discovery of the drug penicillin. We all know how significant penicillin has been for the human race. A serendipitous discovery may not take place in the intended field, but it may still be significant.

The quote also ignores people who make valuable contributions in an indirect way. Let us consider the case of philanthropists who make donations or take part in charity. Usually, the donated money goes to some sort of organization like a cancer research center, children's home, etc. Now, the people donating the money may not have any idea how cancer research is done or how to run a children's home, but they are still making a significant contribution, although not directly.

It is clear from the above examples that a contribution in a field can be significant even if the contributor has not been affected by history of that field. While usually, people are more determined to do something significant when they are inspired by the feats of others in that field; it is not the necessary criterion. As explained above, for a significant change to occur, all that is necessary may be as simple as pure luck.
ershad193   
Sep 1, 2010
Graduate / writing layers of software over Video/Image decoders, SOP for M.S in computer science [7]

When I was a kid I was curious about how ants followed a path without getting lost.

It was during my Undergraduate final year project when I came across this interesting 'Ant colony algorithm' I realized that, there exists highly creative new technological design

Except the word "ant" I can't see how your childhood experience relates to whatever you have written afterward.
...it was only after this event didthat my desire to explore greater...

During my bachelors, the courses which held my interest the most were Design and Analysis of Algorithms, Compiler construction, and Operating Systems .

It would be better if you add a phrase or two on why you liked those courses.

overall first class along with a campus placement at Infosys Technologies

I won't be able to do work on technology of my liking in a service based company.
^^Avoid contractions.

So instead I joined a start-up (a hyphen is needed) where along with ("along with" are two words) with working on small projects

I prepared for GRE alongwith my tight work schedule and without taking any extra preparatory leaves.

This is not a very impressive thing to say.
ershad193   
Sep 1, 2010
Undergraduate / Subsonic Delight, something that you find fun or humorous (Caltech) [8]

I agree with Kevin, although not completely.

I think you can write about anything, even if it involves your family. It should be recent though. I'm sure there are many such incidents. If you were so evil in your childhood, I seriously doubt that you have mended your ways :P
ershad193   
Sep 1, 2010
Undergraduate / Monitoring clinical research trials is'nt what I want for rest of my life; PA - PS [4]

Monitoring clinical research trials is not what I want to do for the rest of my life,

I've

Always use complete words in formal writing -- I have

3rd world

Third world -- technically this term has becoming obsolete.

Being a PA, is being the patient advocate, that bedside friend who has a firm understanding

I'm not sure, but I think there should be a colon after the word "advocate" instead of the comma.

in multiple courses in my young career as a Biomedical Engineering

Biomedical Engineer

The last sentence looks a bit awkward. What is the point of including the part -- "Problems based...ailments?"
ershad193   
Aug 31, 2010
Poetry / critique for my "5 senses of your favorite color" poem [10]

Hey, that connection between purring and orange is kind of flimsy!!

I know, but that's what it reminded me. Actually, I love cats (even in cartoons), so I notice anything remotely related to them.

By the way, the Garfield strip on my newspaper is in black-and-white...thus the confusion.
ershad193   
Aug 31, 2010
Scholarship / Centers, infinity, absurdity--they're exciting [12]

Of course this is comparing two unlike things, but that is the beauty of creativity. Why have I seemingly arbitrarily decided that absurdity is the center of infinity?

The question comes abruptly.

This is definitely better.

However, the value lies not in your ability to spontaneously make a point, but in the thought that investigates it =DI'm not sure if I am clear yet XD

You're perfectly clear.
I made that statement thinking about theoretical physics. Anyway, I've understood what you meant.
ershad193   
Aug 31, 2010
Scholarship / Microsoft & Apple: Differences, Similarities & Best Interest of Users in Mind [3]

Back in the 1940's and '50s, after one buys a car, fridge, house, and microwave, what more did one need?

I couldn't find a way of linking this sentence with the rest of the paragraph. Honestly, to me, the paragraph looks better without it.

One may argue that Microsoft also uses the planned obsolescence tactic, pushing out operating systems only to be replaced by better ones.

This sentence is redundant. The first two sentences of the para make the same point.

can't

I'd advise against using contractions.

The "performance" of the software depends on the hardware inside the computer such as the processor speed and the random-access memory (RAM) -- the "processor" is a hardware, not "processor speed."

Otherwise, you can remove the word "hardware," and write the sentence like -- "The "performance" of the software depends on the processor speed and the random-access memory (RAM)"

A really fast processor will allow you to load Windows pretty fast and the user will be happy, however with a slow processor Windows will take ages to load and the user will complain.

Why did you suddenly use the second person?

manufacturers'

Misplaced apostrophe -- "manufacturer's"

Microsoft has been so successful because mainly because they haveit has licensed out the Windows OS, allowing multiple manufacturers such as Dell, Sony, and HP to use Windows and build their own computers.

Apple, being one of the largest technology companies, also exercises more control over what its consumer can and can't do than does Microsoft.

You need a semi-colon in this sentence: "Software developers will keep developing for the most popular operating systems; thus many programs will not work on Linux"

Hello, Parth!
You write well. I hope I was of some help. Since your essay is due, so I restrained from criticizing the content. I just wish I had seen this essay a few days earlier.
ershad193   
Aug 31, 2010
Undergraduate / Why Reed? Rhythm and High Hands [3]

When I enjoy a person, place, or experience I...
^^Here the word "like" looks better.

At other colleges I have visited the students seem more intent on getting drunk than engaging in the subject matter.

I don't know if this is a good reason. It would be better if you make comparisons based only on the positive aspects of various colleges, like, the course structure, faculty, etc.

For this, I was named names.

I'd use "called" in place of the highlighted word.

Brownose, knowitall, etc. I'm sure you have heard many of these as well.

This is redundant. The preceding sentence makes that point clear.

I like your first four sentences. They reminded me of the movie "August Rush."
However, I'm not sure if the reasons you have given for attending Reed are compelling enough. For instance, if you replace Reed with the name of any other college, the essay will still sound coherent -- and that is a problem.

Which discipline are you going to take up at Reed? Talk about that; explain how it is different that other colleges.
What profession would you like to join after you graduate? Will studying at Reed give you a better platform to pursue your goals?
ershad193   
Aug 30, 2010
Writing Feedback / Does the end justify the means? - GRE issue essay. [6]

Thanks Eugene!

I don't know if losing on purpose is illegal, but it is definitely immoral.

Err...right. Note taken :)

I think you should add a smoother transition between the second and third paragraph.

I knew that would come up. The third paragraph comes with jolt, doesn't it? I knew that from the start. I didn't get the time to write a proper transition.

Anyway, did I defend my stand properly?

but you're pretty good at it. (I was never good at the SAT essays ><)

Haha...thanks. By the way, this is a GRE essay.
ershad193   
Aug 30, 2010
Writing Feedback / Does the end justify the means? - GRE issue essay. [6]

I had a really hard time composing this within the stupid 45 min time limit. I hate time limits. Anyway, I'd appreciate some feedback.

"If a goal is worthy, then any means taken to attain it is justifiable."

Whether the end justifies the means, is a debate we all have taken part in some point of our lives. In my opinion, we can only justify the means when they are morally, ethically, and socially upright.

People who go in pursuit of their dreams, more often than not, have to take the path which has more obstacles than others. When someone drops out of college to start a small business, we generally consider it as an act of lunacy. However, when that someone becomes a Bill Gates, we laud the decision. It just proves that it is not necessary to take the usual paths towards success. When success comes knocking, even the awkward decisions look coherent. But in this case, the goals are achieved through hard work or innovation, so the means can be easily defended.

For many people, the goal in life is to earn money at any cost. The match fixing scandals in cricket and football that have surfaced recently point out this phenomenon. Here we see sportsmen losing on purpose to earn some extra money. Thus, the goal is to earn money, but the method is illegal. Moreover, it brings disrepute to the sport, and the fans and spectators find it hard to trust the players in any future games.

Likewise, if a student cheats in the entrance examination to get a seat in a medical college, we cannot condone it. In this case, that particular student will attain her goal, but she may not become a competent doctor. She may put the lives of her future patients at risk. The greater good is more important than the goals of a particular person.

The most blatant example of such indiscretion is the attitude of the terrorists. Their goal of waging jihad does not justify their acts of killing innocent people or violating human rights. Similarly, we cannot rationalize the declaration of war on a country to rid it of an oppressive regime without any regard to the collateral damage it can cause.

In conclusion, the methods which violate our sense of righteousness and morals, cannot validate the goal, however worthy it may be. After all, our values are what make us humans.
ershad193   
Aug 30, 2010
Poetry / critique for my "5 senses of your favorite color" poem [10]

I have never heard the word tosh used in a sentence...

The Brits use it mostly. If you spend half of your weekends watching soccer, then you're bound to remember some of the commentary.

I think the mention of Cheetos takes care of that. :-)

Yeah that's a clear indication. Moreover, the word "purring" reminds me of Garfield, and he is orange...wait, is he orange?
ershad193   
Aug 30, 2010
Writing Feedback / New idea always faces contradiction desipte its reasonalbilty [4]

I think your thesis misses the point being asked in the prompt. You probably made a mistake distinguishing between an "important truth" and an "important idea."

For example, do we call a religious idea a truth? The example of the heliocentric model is a "truth." It is accepted universally. However, religion cannot be considered a truth because everyone can have different interpretations of a particular religion, whether they take into account the faith, preachings, or even the existence of God. I, as a Muslim, don't believe in the teachings of other religions. So will those teachings qualify as truths? For me, they are not. The same can be said for Christians who may think Islam is blasphemous.

Do you understand what I am saying?

"Rehabilitation" and "caretaker" are single words.

Again, the example of Elizabeth Blackwell doesn't qualify as a truth. It was something that brought a paradigm shift.

In the fifth and sixth paragraphs you explicitly talk about new ideas and not truths.

You write very well. If the prompt was on "important ideas," I think this essay would have been a very astute response. You defended your thesis with good examples and gave some significant observations.

Do You Need
Academic Writing
or Editing Help?
Fill in one of the forms below to get professional help with your assignments:

Graduate Writing / Editing:
GraduateWriter form ◳

Best Essay Service:
CustomPapers form ◳

Excellence in Editing:
Rose Editing ◳

AI-Paper Rewriting:
Robot Rewrite ◳