amrosca
Oct 1, 2011
Letters / A Letter from Papa Bird to its Baby Birds [3]
Hei Anna! :D
First of all, welcome to EF! I'd give you a prize, but will you settle for a cyber-hug? >:D<
Now getting down to business: I liked your essay, I did. It's a cute story that makes me recall how I perceived the world when I was little.
However, and this will come out mean no matter how I'll say it, I don't find it to be impressive. It is not something truly special. First of all, birds do not feel the same emotions us humans do when it comes to family. For them, learning is about surviving. And the parents do not care about their futures after they can live on their own. I do get it that you meant everything in a metaphorical way, but you went over the top, so to say. If you look at fables and tales, all animals impersonating a certain character are simple and only roughly contoured.
My advise, choose one or few characteristics that actually exist in the bird world and try to bring the reader to empathize with your birdy story.
And what I would also do, I'd drop the names (Tweety, Chicky, Birdy). They sound too goofy and I personally was distracted from what you were trying to say because of that.
My last tip: a letter is still an essay. You need the structure. If every single line is loaded with information and meaning, you become boring. Focus on a good amount of description in the beginning to install a certain mood and then, gradually, work your way up to the conclusion.
That being said, your writing should reflect what you think. So perhaps you can wait for a while and then read this essay again. And maybe you will figure out where you can improve it or add a further thought yourself. :)
Good luck!
Hei Anna! :D
First of all, welcome to EF! I'd give you a prize, but will you settle for a cyber-hug? >:D<
Now getting down to business: I liked your essay, I did. It's a cute story that makes me recall how I perceived the world when I was little.
However, and this will come out mean no matter how I'll say it, I don't find it to be impressive. It is not something truly special. First of all, birds do not feel the same emotions us humans do when it comes to family. For them, learning is about surviving. And the parents do not care about their futures after they can live on their own. I do get it that you meant everything in a metaphorical way, but you went over the top, so to say. If you look at fables and tales, all animals impersonating a certain character are simple and only roughly contoured.
My advise, choose one or few characteristics that actually exist in the bird world and try to bring the reader to empathize with your birdy story.
And what I would also do, I'd drop the names (Tweety, Chicky, Birdy). They sound too goofy and I personally was distracted from what you were trying to say because of that.
My last tip: a letter is still an essay. You need the structure. If every single line is loaded with information and meaning, you become boring. Focus on a good amount of description in the beginning to install a certain mood and then, gradually, work your way up to the conclusion.
That being said, your writing should reflect what you think. So perhaps you can wait for a while and then read this essay again. And maybe you will figure out where you can improve it or add a further thought yourself. :)
Good luck!