Writing Feedback /
Philosophy: Is Aristotle right in his definition of happiness ? [2]
Oh, there are a few counter-arguments!
Theists: You can cite religious arguments that hold the highest good to be service to god.
Utilitarians: Other people would say that the highest good is to make a great contribution to society -- which would be contributing to the happiness of others.
Buddhists and Taoists: More interesting is the argument for enlightenment, as in the Buddhist and Taoist traditions! Enlightenment is a way to transcend duality altogether, so that you have gone beyond happy vs. unhappy.
So, read a book or article about each of those things, and cit what you read as part of a counter-argument.
Incidentally, if one is a theist, or a utilitarian, or a Buddhist or Taoist, it is still true that you seek happiness. Whether you find happiness in pleasing God, or helping others, or achieving enlightenment, it is still all pursuit of happiness.