lightfox
Jul 14, 2015
Writing Feedback / "Does the success of a community depends on limiting personal Interest" SAT May 2006 [4]
Much better. I cannot think of any obvious mistakes in grammar or syntax that I can point out right away.
My only problem of course, is your conclusion. Yeah, now that I think about it, you really did introduce it as a metaphor to the human body early in the sentence rather than later. However, it's the way you introduced it that made it sound awkward. You said "I ponder that a community is best assimilated to a human body..." I don't think that's a very apt way of delivering the comparison, which was why I probably did not recognize it as a simile the first time I read it. From my experience, people don't say it like that when they want to compare two things. In this case, simple is best: "To cap it all, a community is like a human body, with all of its components foregoing individuality in order to better serve a specific task each aspect is a part of." Something like this. And just add one more sentence stating how it's a good thing community forgets their egocentrism or self-interest in order to better serve society.
I would give your essay a 5. It's not perfect, which is why I'm not giving a 6, but you gave an excellent and a diverse set of examples that prove your point and it was tons better than your previous essay.
Much better. I cannot think of any obvious mistakes in grammar or syntax that I can point out right away.
My only problem of course, is your conclusion. Yeah, now that I think about it, you really did introduce it as a metaphor to the human body early in the sentence rather than later. However, it's the way you introduced it that made it sound awkward. You said "I ponder that a community is best assimilated to a human body..." I don't think that's a very apt way of delivering the comparison, which was why I probably did not recognize it as a simile the first time I read it. From my experience, people don't say it like that when they want to compare two things. In this case, simple is best: "To cap it all, a community is like a human body, with all of its components foregoing individuality in order to better serve a specific task each aspect is a part of." Something like this. And just add one more sentence stating how it's a good thing community forgets their egocentrism or self-interest in order to better serve society.
I would give your essay a 5. It's not perfect, which is why I'm not giving a 6, but you gave an excellent and a diverse set of examples that prove your point and it was tons better than your previous essay.