SilverKnight
Jan 1, 2014
Undergraduate / Columbia Essay: Superman and I, One and The Same [2]
Your essays seems to be fairly well-written and you chose something that very few people probably did. However, you use "we" much more often than you should. The prompt says to find something meaningful about the film as it applies to you and for the most part you do that. What need to do is point out that you and Cal-El/Superman have a connection of some sort, then go into a deep explanation of your own emotions and beliefs and how they eventually changed, as you no longer placed a limit on yourself.
This is a side note and has almost nothing to do with your essay. I have to question the merit of Man of Steel as a "cultural event." The movie made a lot more money than it should have because it really was a poor finished product. The stories ideas were pretty good and it was much needed new addition to the character of Superman. However, the directing, poor camera work, and an overuse of CGI in a prolonged battle scene really destroyed the story. If they had just smoothed these points out, then it would really would have been a good movie. As for now, I contend that a movie, even one about super heroes, needs to have a lot more than just explosions to be considered a good movie.
Anyway, I hope I was helpful.
Your essays seems to be fairly well-written and you chose something that very few people probably did. However, you use "we" much more often than you should. The prompt says to find something meaningful about the film as it applies to you and for the most part you do that. What need to do is point out that you and Cal-El/Superman have a connection of some sort, then go into a deep explanation of your own emotions and beliefs and how they eventually changed, as you no longer placed a limit on yourself.
This is a side note and has almost nothing to do with your essay. I have to question the merit of Man of Steel as a "cultural event." The movie made a lot more money than it should have because it really was a poor finished product. The stories ideas were pretty good and it was much needed new addition to the character of Superman. However, the directing, poor camera work, and an overuse of CGI in a prolonged battle scene really destroyed the story. If they had just smoothed these points out, then it would really would have been a good movie. As for now, I contend that a movie, even one about super heroes, needs to have a lot more than just explosions to be considered a good movie.
Anyway, I hope I was helpful.