vangiespen
Sep 18, 2015
Writing Feedback / Arts government funding - GRE Issue essay. Review, grade, point out mistake or suggest improvements. [4]
Hi Riyasat, now that you have mentioned it, there are some points where the grammar can be improved or corrected. I hope you won't mind if I go paragraph by paragraph for your reference. My comments will include suggestions and rewrites that will serve as samples for your future reference.
On one hand government funding of the arts ...
- Since you have not stated any previous facts or information, you should not use "On one hand" in this instance. "On one hand" connotes that previous statements have been made, that does not exist in this instance so don't use that term. Instead open immediately with "Government funding..."
- This is a second opinion that you are stating. "On the other hand" does not really fit the sentence. Rather, the best way to open the topic would be stating "However, the mere..." as the word "However" connotes a new idea being presented or in this case, a different side to the issue. This makes the presentation more formal and academic.
- - Remember, you need to present your stand on the matter because it is required in the prompt :
Therefore, you are required to clearly state, support, and discuss your position. I agree that there are some instances where being vague in your discussion is the best approach to take in discussing the topic unless, as in this case, the prompt clearly asks you to state and discuss your stand using other evidences to support your side.
Actually, your stand is not very clear in the essay because you never connoted ownership of any idea or side. Your essay comes across more as a well rounded discussion of the issue. In this case, not clearly stating or taking a position really hurt your discussion since it seems like you do not have a clear opinion regarding the matter.
If you would like to revise the essay and post it again in this thread, I'd be more than happy to help you develop your writing skill and work on the grammar issues with you :-)
Hi Riyasat, now that you have mentioned it, there are some points where the grammar can be improved or corrected. I hope you won't mind if I go paragraph by paragraph for your reference. My comments will include suggestions and rewrites that will serve as samples for your future reference.
- Since you have not stated any previous facts or information, you should not use "On one hand" in this instance. "On one hand" connotes that previous statements have been made, that does not exist in this instance so don't use that term. Instead open immediately with "Government funding..."
On the other hand, the mere idea of government ...
- This is a second opinion that you are stating. "On the other hand" does not really fit the sentence. Rather, the best way to open the topic would be stating "However, the mere..." as the word "However" connotes a new idea being presented or in this case, a different side to the issue. This makes the presentation more formal and academic.
I didn't take any concrete stand on either side, because ...
- - Remember, you need to present your stand on the matter because it is required in the prompt :
Write a response in which you discuss which view more closely aligns with your own position
Therefore, you are required to clearly state, support, and discuss your position. I agree that there are some instances where being vague in your discussion is the best approach to take in discussing the topic unless, as in this case, the prompt clearly asks you to state and discuss your stand using other evidences to support your side.
Actually, your stand is not very clear in the essay because you never connoted ownership of any idea or side. Your essay comes across more as a well rounded discussion of the issue. In this case, not clearly stating or taking a position really hurt your discussion since it seems like you do not have a clear opinion regarding the matter.
If you would like to revise the essay and post it again in this thread, I'd be more than happy to help you develop your writing skill and work on the grammar issues with you :-)