RyanVi16
Oct 2, 2010
Undergraduate / Help/Suggestions for CA Prompt 1 - "I killed a Bird" [7]
Let me answer your second question first, I am not trying to accuse or making a random guess or anything but since you ask what I can tell about you from reading your essay. I think according to your religion (I assumed you follow a religion), killing a life (regardless of whatever it is) is a very serious sin. I can think of Buddhism (please do not take my words too seriously if its not Buddhism). Since not everybody follow the same religion, I think it is best to mention your beliefs in the essay to clarify the reason why the life of a pigeon can make such a big impact on you, or you can even say how much you love animals. Because to other, killing a pigeon is just a mistake that may shock the "killer"at that moment but they will soon forget so you have to make the reader share the feeling you had at that moment. I can see that you are also very sensitive to things around you and will try your best not to make the same mistake twice which is a very good thing when you writing to college, they want something positive.
To answer your first question, death is a sensitive subject, but as I said before, the gravity of the problem depend on the perspective that you have toward it. To some, even killing their pet will not make them shed a tear, so it is the writer responsibility to convey those feeling to the reader. Here is the BIGGEST thing, when you write college admission, does not matter whatever the topic they give you, include something in your essay to let them judge if you are the right person for that college. The major or goal in the future when you attend to that college. For example, this also talk about death (my words and i just write them at the spot so not that good): I witnessed the death of a complete stranger, he finally whispered the last words to his family members and friends then closed his eyes and waiting for eternity to consume his body. At that moment, to be able to help these people is the only goal i have in life, to give them more time to be with their family and friend. This actually talk about you want to be a doctor or medical of some sort. Your reaction to the problem is kind of generic compare to the drama that you put on for the death of the pigeon. Your reaction should also be something that the college will make an interesting note on you. It is hard to make the reader to feel bad for the bird compare to the lives of other bigger things: pet, humans, etc.
Your grammar is okay, but i feel the sentences lack the flow to it, kind of choppy. I think it is fine to stick to this topic but try to improve the conclusion (how you affected by it). Sorry it is long and sorry if I said something wrong. I hope it help at some sort. Good luck!
Let me answer your second question first, I am not trying to accuse or making a random guess or anything but since you ask what I can tell about you from reading your essay. I think according to your religion (I assumed you follow a religion), killing a life (regardless of whatever it is) is a very serious sin. I can think of Buddhism (please do not take my words too seriously if its not Buddhism). Since not everybody follow the same religion, I think it is best to mention your beliefs in the essay to clarify the reason why the life of a pigeon can make such a big impact on you, or you can even say how much you love animals. Because to other, killing a pigeon is just a mistake that may shock the "killer"at that moment but they will soon forget so you have to make the reader share the feeling you had at that moment. I can see that you are also very sensitive to things around you and will try your best not to make the same mistake twice which is a very good thing when you writing to college, they want something positive.
To answer your first question, death is a sensitive subject, but as I said before, the gravity of the problem depend on the perspective that you have toward it. To some, even killing their pet will not make them shed a tear, so it is the writer responsibility to convey those feeling to the reader. Here is the BIGGEST thing, when you write college admission, does not matter whatever the topic they give you, include something in your essay to let them judge if you are the right person for that college. The major or goal in the future when you attend to that college. For example, this also talk about death (my words and i just write them at the spot so not that good): I witnessed the death of a complete stranger, he finally whispered the last words to his family members and friends then closed his eyes and waiting for eternity to consume his body. At that moment, to be able to help these people is the only goal i have in life, to give them more time to be with their family and friend. This actually talk about you want to be a doctor or medical of some sort. Your reaction to the problem is kind of generic compare to the drama that you put on for the death of the pigeon. Your reaction should also be something that the college will make an interesting note on you. It is hard to make the reader to feel bad for the bird compare to the lives of other bigger things: pet, humans, etc.
Your grammar is okay, but i feel the sentences lack the flow to it, kind of choppy. I think it is fine to stick to this topic but try to improve the conclusion (how you affected by it). Sorry it is long and sorry if I said something wrong. I hope it help at some sort. Good luck!