EF_Kevin
Aug 17, 2010
Undergraduate / Common App. - Inspiring person to run for Governor [7]
This is a very good question! I'll answer it with an example related to another of your questions...
er, actually, I canot find any spot where you are guilty of telling instead of showing. You told a story that demonstrates something about your character: you are willing to learn, you are humble, you are serious about accomplishment.. it makes the reader like you! It makes the reader know that you are a serious student. The fact that you were selected for Girls State is enough to show seriousness, but in fact you went miles beyond that by telling this story...
So, what you did here really showed the reader what you are about. TELLING would be like this:
"I have always had high standards for myself, and I feel proud of my accomplishments, but I also am willing to listen to the advice of others." This makes a reader say, "Well that is nice, but words are cheap."
About the Dr. Seuss thing... it would be nice if you had a reference to the good doctor in the beginning of the essay, too, so that this would wrap it up by coming full circle back to Seuss... but actually, the abrupt reference to him works, I think. You said he was "right" and that was enough to make me understand that you were ending with a relevant quote. I think it works!
About the cliches... yes,they are cliches. But not bad ones! Change them if you come up with clever alternatives.
:-)
I was really worried on the "showing" rather than "telling" because I'm telling this as a story to the reader.
This is a very good question! I'll answer it with an example related to another of your questions...
er, actually, I canot find any spot where you are guilty of telling instead of showing. You told a story that demonstrates something about your character: you are willing to learn, you are humble, you are serious about accomplishment.. it makes the reader like you! It makes the reader know that you are a serious student. The fact that you were selected for Girls State is enough to show seriousness, but in fact you went miles beyond that by telling this story...
So, what you did here really showed the reader what you are about. TELLING would be like this:
"I have always had high standards for myself, and I feel proud of my accomplishments, but I also am willing to listen to the advice of others." This makes a reader say, "Well that is nice, but words are cheap."
About the Dr. Seuss thing... it would be nice if you had a reference to the good doctor in the beginning of the essay, too, so that this would wrap it up by coming full circle back to Seuss... but actually, the abrupt reference to him works, I think. You said he was "right" and that was enough to make me understand that you were ending with a relevant quote. I think it works!
About the cliches... yes,they are cliches. But not bad ones! Change them if you come up with clever alternatives.
:-)
