Writing Feedback /
'The additional facility at Tusk University' - Gre argument [3]
Hi, I have some suggestions for your essay.
The argumentAt first glance, it may seem logical that a new recreational facility will attract new students to
enroll at Tusk University
and alsoas well as solve the inadequacy of current facilities.
may seem logical at first glance. The author makes a valid argument, one that would be correct
itif its premises were true. However, his conclusion relies on assumptions for which there is no clear evidence, and it uses terms that lack definition.
First, the writer assumes that building a new recreational facility will attract new student
s,andcausing enrollment to double over the years. However, this new recreational facility
mightcould be entirely
irrelevantineffective at improving enrollment.and might not help to improve the enrolment at all.Suppose,F or example,
if the new recreational facility that Tusk University plans on building is a
theater,then students who don't engage in filming might not find this new recreational facility fascinating. Additionally, this new theatre would not
necessarily serve its purpose of meeting the ever-increasing
needs of the students .
' needs.Besides, the writer also assumes that the expected growing number of students will make the existing facilities inadequate. But, the writer provides no evidence to see if a parallel exists between increasing number of students and the inadequacy of existing facilities. Hypothetically speaking, the existing facilities might look old and shabby. This appearance might not arouse students' desires to use those existing facilities.
Also,Thewritearticle implies
without citing specific evidence that students will be more inclined to use the on-campus facilities,
due to the risingas the cost of
the community health and recreational club membershi
p.has increased. In fact, the community health and recreational club might
be well equipped for certainoffer additional activities such as canoeing and mountaineerin
g, which the school facilities might lack. If so, these students would rather spend more money to
get access tojoin the community club. The argument's conclusion requires the support of evidence demonstrating that the school current facilities are fully equipped and advantageous to its students.
The notion that attractive new recreational center will attract more athletically gifted students to
enroll at Tusk University would be strengthened if the writer had provided evidence that this attractive recreational center is an athletic facility and not science laboratory.
(this sentence is far too long...) The author's argument would be strengthened considerably by additional evidence that shows some statistics and surveys that a large number of students are excited about the new recreational facility and a high percentage of these students will make use of it.
In conclusion, the writer would not necessarily be wrong to assert that new facility will potentially lead to some improvement in
enrollment at Tusk University. After all, the additional facility will certainly not adversely affect the school image. But to support the current conclusion that a new recreational facility will effectively double the
enrollmen t, the writer must submit more conclusive evidence that the new facility will, in fact, attract more prospective students.
(try to make this final paragraph less repetitive, strengthen this section as best you can. Continue to focus on your grammar)