Holt Educational Consultant
Dec 5, 2020
Writing Feedback / Ielts writing task 2: Many things can influence the development of students [3]
There are 2 errors in your presentation. The first, is that you changed the topic for discussion from "many things" to "many people". People are not the same as things. In this regard, you will appear to not have properly understood the original discussion topic due to the change from "things" to "people". You also did not give a proper response to the given question which asks you to pick one reason to defend in the essay. You cannot say both have a profound impact because the choices you are given for the reasoning discussion are specific. Either you:
- Agree that peers have more of an impact than teachers
- Disagree that peers have more impact than teachers
When you are given an "or" choice, that means there is an alternative decision that you can make. That does not mean you should defend both sides. That means you can only use one side, the other being an alternative response to the question. Since there are only 2 reasoning paragraphs, you need to give 2 individual, convincing reasons for the examiner to read. Convince him that your opinion is correct, based on the degree of your disagreement with the given statement.
This is not a comparison essay. I guess you are not familiar with the types of Task 2 essays yet. The A/D and comparison discussions are written using both sides of the discussion. All agree or disagree essays rely on a single opinion presentation in the reasoning paragraphs.
Never use words of uncertainty in these presentations. You must always have a strong statement in the presentation in support of a clear opinion. When you say you "suppose" that means you are not sure if the discussion presentation you presented is correct.
There are 2 errors in your presentation. The first, is that you changed the topic for discussion from "many things" to "many people". People are not the same as things. In this regard, you will appear to not have properly understood the original discussion topic due to the change from "things" to "people". You also did not give a proper response to the given question which asks you to pick one reason to defend in the essay. You cannot say both have a profound impact because the choices you are given for the reasoning discussion are specific. Either you:
- Agree that peers have more of an impact than teachers
- Disagree that peers have more impact than teachers
When you are given an "or" choice, that means there is an alternative decision that you can make. That does not mean you should defend both sides. That means you can only use one side, the other being an alternative response to the question. Since there are only 2 reasoning paragraphs, you need to give 2 individual, convincing reasons for the examiner to read. Convince him that your opinion is correct, based on the degree of your disagreement with the given statement.
This is not a comparison essay. I guess you are not familiar with the types of Task 2 essays yet. The A/D and comparison discussions are written using both sides of the discussion. All agree or disagree essays rely on a single opinion presentation in the reasoning paragraphs.
Never use words of uncertainty in these presentations. You must always have a strong statement in the presentation in support of a clear opinion. When you say you "suppose" that means you are not sure if the discussion presentation you presented is correct.
